Media views of the Stromboli 2002–2003 eruption and evacuation: a content analysis to understand framing of risk communication during a volcanic crisis
Tóm tắt
The 2002–2003 eruption of Stromboli (Aeolian Islands, Italy) was one of Stromboli’s most important effusive events of the last two centuries and began on 28 December 2002. On 30 December 2002, two days after the beginning of the eruption, a landslide entered the sea and caused a tsunami that struck Stromboli’s coastal areas. The events of 30 December led to a “voluntary evacuation” by Stromboli’s inhabitants. To understand the role of the media in framing risk and the evacuation, we analyzed the content of five newspapers, including two national newspapers (Il Corriere della Sera and La Repubblica) and three regional newspapers (La Gazzetta del Sud, La Sicilia and Il Giornale di Sicilia), published during the period covering the onset of the eruption, the tsunami and the voluntary evacuation (28 December 2002–18 January 2003). Our aim was to assess the type of hazard information given, how it was delivered, and how this may have helped (or not) with the population’s resilience, especially in regard to viewing a potential need to evacuate in a favorable light. News regarding the eruption covered a total area of 12,000 cm2 for the national newspapers (~ 6000 cm2/paper) against 41,700 cm2 for the regionals (14,000 cm2/paper); making the regional newspapers the more important sources by quantity. For both newspaper categories, most of this area was occupied by interviews with experts, followed by quotes from residents and tourists, and, finally, those involved in the response (i.e., hazard managers, including civil protection and local government). Out of a total of 9286 words analyzed, the most popular was “tsunami” (426 cases), with the word “volcano” being repeated 315 times (the 6th most popular word); so it would have been difficult for the population not to have known there was a potential risk of tsunami associated with the volcano. In texturally framing the eruptive crisis, negative words, such as “fear”, “terror” and “apocalypse”, were much more frequent than positive words, which were rare and even not present in some newspapers. The reporting focused on the tsunami threat with little link back to the eruption and other hazards, and contrasted with imagery (that took up 41% of the reporting space) which comprised relaxing pictures of a tranquil island surrounded by a calm blue sea. This, coupled with a confused message through selection of quoted expert sources, may have led to an exaggerated and alarmist frame for the eruption and attendant hazards. This was in spite of widespread use of scientific sources, as well as pleas from the population itself, to the journalists and published in the newspapers themselves, to tone the reporting down. The newspaper agenda was, thus, plainly not compatible with effective communication in support of disaster management.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Abbruzzese D (1935) Attività dello Stromboli dal 1930 al 1934. Boll Soc Sismol XXIII:3–4
Barberi F, Rosi M, Sodi A (1993) Volcanic hazard assessment at Stromboli based on review of historical data. Acta Vulcanol 3:173–187
Barclay J, Haynes K, Mitchell T, Solana C, Teeuw R, Darnell A, Crosweller HS, Cole P, Pyle D, Lowe C, Fearnley C, Kelman I (2008) Framing Volcanic Risk communication within Disaster Risk Reduction: Finding Ways for the Social and Physical Sciences to Work Together: Fig. 1. Geol Soc Lond, Spec Publ 305(1):163–177. https://doi.org/10.1144/SP305.14
Bertolaso G, Bonaccorso A, Boschi E (2008b) Scientific community and civil protection synergy during the Stromboli 2002–2003 eruption. In: The Stromboli Volcano: An integrated study of the 2002–2003 eruption, AGU Monograph, vol 182, pp 387–397
Bertolaso G, De Bernardinis B, Bosi V, Cardaci C, Ciolli S, Colozza R, Cristiani C, Mangione D, Ricciaedi A, Rosi M, Scalzo A, Soddu P (2009) Civil protection preparedness and respose to the 2007 eruptive crisis of Stromboli volcano. Italy J Volcanol Geotherm Res 182:269–277
Bertolaso G, De Bernardinis B, Cardaci C, Scalzo A (2008a) Stromboli ( 2002–2003 ) Crisis Management and Risk Mitigation Actions. In: The Stromboli Volcano: An integrated study of the 2002–2003 eruption, AGU Monograp, vol 182, pp 373–385
Block L.G., Keller P.A. When to accentuate the negative: the effects of perceived efficacy and message framing on intentions to perform a health-related behavior. J Mark Res 1995. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.2307/3152047
Bonaccorso A., Calvari S., Garfi G., Lodato L., Patanè D. Dynamics of the December 2002 flank failure and tsunami at Stromboli Volcano inferred by Volcanological and geophysical observations. Geophys Res Lett 2003; 30 (18): 28–31. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1029/2003GL017702
Boykoff M.T. Flogging a Dead Norm? Newspaper Coverage of Anthropogenic Climate Change in the United States and United Kingdom from 2003 to 2006.” Area. 2007; https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1475-4762.2007.00769.x
Bretton R.J., Gottsmann J., Aspinall W.P., Christie R. Hazard communication by volcanologists: part 1 - framing the case for contextualisation and related quality standards in volcanic hazard assessments. J Appl Volcanol 2018; 7:9 https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1186/s13617-018-0077-x
Burton M, Calvari S, Spampinato L, Lodato L, Pino N. A., Marchetti E., Muré F. Dynamics of Strombolian activity. In the Stromboli Volcano: an integrated study of the 2002-2003 eruption, AGU Monograph 2008; 182, 93–104
Capaldi G, Guerra I, Lo BA, Luongo G, Pece R, Rapolla A, Scarpa R, Del Pezzo E, Martini M, Ghiara MR, Lirer L, Munno R, La Volpe L (1978) Stromboli and its 1975 eruption. Bull Volcanol 41-3:259–285
Cavallaro C., Cincotta R. Stromboli. Sagep editrice (Genova). 1991. p. 165
Chua L. A Nonlinear Dynamics Perspective of Wolfram's New Kind of Science :(Volume VI) (World Scientific Series on Nonlinear Science Series A Book 85). Ed. Società editrice Affinità Elettice; 2013. p. 112,121,122,124
Clark G., Bonetto C. Sicilia. Ed. Lonely Planet; 2017
De Fino M, La Volpe L, Falsaperla S, Frazzetta G, Neri G, Francalanci L, Rosi M, Sbrana A (1988) The Stromboli eruption of December 6, 1985–April 25, 1986: volcanological, petrological and seismological data. Rend Soc Ital Mineral Petrol 43:1021–1038
Di Benedetto M (2017) Il vulcano in mezzo al mare. Ed Strombolibri
Doyle E.E.H., McClure J., Paton D., Johnston D.M. Uncertainty and decision making: volcanic crisis scenarios. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction. 2014; 10: 75–101. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijdrr.2014.07.006
Elo S., Kyngäs H. The Qualitative Content Analysis Process.” J Adv Nurs 2008; 62 (1): 107–15. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2648.2007.04569.x
Fearnley C. J, Bird D.K., Mcguire W.J. Advances in Volcanology Observing the Volcano World. 2018. https://doi.org/ISSN 2364–3285
Fiske R. Volcanologists, journalists, and concerned local public: a tale of two crises in the Eastern Caribbean, in: Explosive Volcanism: Inception, Evolution, and Hazards. Studies in Geophysics, ed. F. Boyd, National Academy Press, Washington DC. 1984; p. 170–176
Gaillard J.C., Dibben C.J.L. Volcanic risk perception and beyond. J Volcanol Geotherm Res2008; 172 (3–4): 163–169. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jvolgeores.2007.12.015
GAO - Program Evaluation and Methodology division. In Content Analysis: A Methodology for Structuring and Analyzing Written Material, edited by Brian P. Crowley and Joseph F. Delfico. Illinois state University.1996
Harcup T. Journalism: principles and practice (second edition). Sage, Los Angeles; 2009. p. 244
Harris A.J.L. Forecast communication through the newspaper part 1: framing the forecaster. Bull Volcanol 2015; 77:29. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1007/s00445-015-0899-x
Harris A.J.L., Gurioli L., Hughes E.E., Lagreulet S. Impact of the Eyjafjallajökull Ash Cloud: A Newspaper Perspective. Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth. 2012;117(3). https://doi.org/10.1029/2011JB008735.
Harris A.J.L., Villeneuve N. Newspaper Reporting of the April 2007 Eruption of Piton de La Fournaise, Part 2: Framing the Hazard. Journal of Applied Volcanology. 2018a; 7 (1). https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1186/s13617-018-0072-2
Harris A.J.L., Villeneuve N. Newspaper reporting of the April 2007 eruption of piton de La Fournaise part 1: useful information or tabloid sensationalism? J Appl Volcanol 2018b; 7 (1): 4. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1186/s13617-018-0073-1
Haynes K., Barclay J., Pidgeon N. Whose reality counts? Factors affecting the perception of volcanic risk. J Volcanol Geotherm Res 2008; 172 (3–4): 259–272. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jvolgeores.2007.12.012
Hicks A., Armijos M.T., Barclay J., Stone J., Robertson R., Cortés G.P. Risk Communication Films: Process, Product and Potential for Improving Preparedness and Behaviour Change.” International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction 2017 Jan 23: 138–51. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijdrr.2017.04.015
Hincks T.K., Komorowski J.C., Sparks S. R, Aspinall W.P. Retrospective Analysis of Uncertain Eruption Precursors at La Soufrière Volcano, Guadeloupe, 1975–77: Volcanic Hazard Assessment Using a Bayesian Belief Network Approach. Journal of Applied Volcanology. 2014; 3 (1). https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1186/2191-5040-3-3
IAVCEI Subcommittee for Crisis Protocols. Professional conduct of scientists during volcanic crises. Bulletin of Volcanology. 1999; 60:323–334
Joseph J.K., Karunakaran Akhil Dev, Pradeepkumar A.P., Mohan M. Big Data Analytics and Social Media in Disaster Management. Integrating Disaster Science and Management: Global Case Studies in Mitigation and Recovery. 2018 Apr; 287–94. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-812056-9.00016-6
Katzman N (1972) Television soap operas: what’s been going on anyway? Public Opinion Quarterly 36(2):200–212
Kitzinger J. Researching risk and the media. Health, Risk and Society 1999; 1 (1): 55–69. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1080/13698579908407007
Kitzinger J., Reilly J. The rise and fall of risk reporting: media coverage of human genetics research, ‘false memory syndrome’ and ‘mad cow disease’. Eur J Commun 1997; 12 (3): 319–350. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1177/0267323197012003002
Krippendorff K. Validity in Content Analysis.” Computerstrategien Für Die Kommunikationsanalyse 1980
La Colla V. L'eruzione dello Stromboli nel 1930. [cited 2010 Feb 13]. Available from: http://www.archiviostoricoeoliano.it/sites/www.archiviostoricoeoliano.it/files/La%20Colla.pdf
Leiss W. Three phases in the evolution of risk communication practice. The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 1996; 545 (1): 85–94. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1177/0002716296545001009
Leonard G.S., Stewart C., Wilson T.M., Procter J.N., Scott B. J, Keys H. J, Jolly G. E, Wardman J. B, Cronin S.J., McBride S.K. Integrating multidisciplinary science, Modelling and impact data into evolving, Syn-event volcanic Hazard mapping and communication: a case study from the 2012 Tongariro eruption crisis, New Zealand Journal of Volcanology and Geothermal Research 2014. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jvolgeores.2014.08.018
Linville P.W., Fischer G. W, Fischhoff B. AIDS risk perceptions and decision biases. In The Social Psychology of HIV Infection 2015. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315722924
Lippmann W. Public opinion. BN Publications. 2008. p. 319
Loughlin S.C., Sparks S., Brown S.K., Jenkins S.F. Vye-Brown C. Global volcanic hazards and risk. Cambrige U 2015
Maramai A, Graziani L, Tinti S (2005a) Tsunamis on the Aeolian Islands (southern Italy): a review. Mar Geol 215:11–21
Maramai A, Graziani L, Tinti S (2005b) Near- and far-field survey report of the 30 December 2002 Stromboli (southern Italy) tsunami. Mar Geol 215:93–106
Marca M. Sicilie. Le Guide Vert, Michelin. Frence: Boulogne Billancourt. 2019. p. 4.
Mathien M (1986) La presse quotidienne régionale. Presses Universitaires de France, Paris, p 127
McClure J., Sibley C.G. Framing effects on disaster preparation: is negative framing more effective? Australas J Disaster Trauma Stud 2011 (1)
McCombs M (2014) Setting the agenda, (2nd ed). Polity Press, Cambridge, p 209
McCombs M, Shaw DL (1972) Agenda-setting function of mass media. Publ Opin Q 36(2):176–187
Naccarato JL, Neuendorf KA (1998) Content analysis as a predictive methodology: recall, readership, and Evauations of business-to-business print advertising. J Advertising Res 38(3):19–33
Neuendorf K.A. The content analysis guidebook. Thousand Oak Sage. 2002. p. 301
P MC–DPC. Benvenuti sul vulcano attivo piu bello del mondo. Dipartimento della Protezione Civile (Romas). 2008. p. 17
Pino NA, Ripepe M, Cimini GB (2002) The Stromboli volcano landslides of December 2002: a seismological desription. Geophys Res Lett 31:L02605. https://doi.org/10.1029/2003GL018385
Rachelli G. L'isola di Stromboli. Ed: Oreste Ragusi (Milazzo). 1998. p. 63
Reese S.D., Gandy O.H., Grant A.E. Framing public life: perspectives on media and our understanding of the social world. Focus. 2001. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.4324/9781410605689
Ripepe M, Delle DD, Harris AJL, Marchetti E, Ulivieri G (2008) Dynamics of Strombolian activity. In the Stromboli Volcano: an integrated study of the 2002-2003 eruption. AGU Monograph 182:39–48
Rowe G., Frewer L. Sjöberg L. Newspaper reporting of hazards in the UK and Sweden. Public Underst Sci 2000; 9 (1): 59–78. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1088/0963-6625/9/1/304
Sigurdsson H., Houghton B., McNutt S. R., Rymer H. Stix J. eds. Encyclopedia of Volcanoes (2nd ed.) Vol. 91. London: Academia Press. 2015. p. 915–1283
Stieglitz S., Mirbabaie M., Ross B., Neuberger C. Social Media Analytics – Challenges in Topic Discovery, Data Collection, and Data Preparation. International Journal of Information Management 39. 2018; 156–68. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijinfomgt.2017.12.002
Struck A. Volcano tourism and its influence on the territory of Mount Etna (Italy) - Explored with disgressions to Stromboli (Italy). In Erfurt-Cooper P, Cooper M. Volcano and geothermal tourism: sustainable geo-resources for leisure and recreation. 2010. Chapter 15, p. 221–232
Tinti S., Armigliato A., Manucci A., Pagnoni G., Tonini R., Zaniboni F., Maramai A., Graziani L. The double lanslide-induced tsunami. In The Stromboli Volcano: An integrated study of the 2002–2003 eruption, AGU Monograph. 2008; 182, 147–157
Tinti S, Maramai A, Armigliato A, Graziani L, Manucci A, Pagnoni G, Zaniboni F (2006a) Observations of physical effects from tsunami's of December 30, 2002 at Stromboli volcano, southern Italy. Bull Volcanol 68:450–461
Tinti S, Pagnoni G, Zaniboni F (2006b) The landslides and tsunamis of the 30th December 2002 in Stromboli analysed through numerical simulations. Bull Volcanol 68:462–479
Vu H.T., Guo L., McCombs M.E. 2014. Exploring “the world outside and the pictures in our heads”: a network agenda-setting study. J Mass Commun Q 91:669–686. doi:https://doi.org/10.1177/1077699014550090
Williams R., Krippner J. The use of social media in volcano science communication: challenges and opportunities. Volcanica. 2018; 1.2: i-viii
Wilson K (1995) Mass media as sources of global warming knowledge. Mass Comm Review 22:75–89