Competition as a means of procuring public services

Judith D.Smyth1
1Management Consultant, Visiting Research Fellow and Part‐time Lecturer, Southampton Institute, UK

Tóm tắt

Competition is now widely used as the means of choosing the providers of essential public services in the USA and the UK. Many different approaches are found in the USA and there are useful lessons for the UK. With particular reference to mental health and substance abuse services, describes the effects of using competitive tendering on users, providers, purchasers and citizens and examines the problems of specification, transaction costs, the use of consultants, supply, the level playing field, trust, innovation, local accessibility and accountability. Ends with discussion of co‐operation and collaboration and the emergence of monopolies and integrated delivery systems in the USA and concludes by finding politics and political decision making of overriding importance.

Từ khóa


Tài liệu tham khảo

1.Bennett, C. and Ferlie, E., “Management by contract rhetoric or reality?”, unpublished paper to the ERU conference Cardiff, 1994.

2.Donahue, J.D., The Privatization Decision ‐ Public Ends, Private Means, Basic Books Inc., New York, NY, 1989.

3.Doremus, H., “Managing competition in the health care industry”, Health Care Strategic Management, December 1992, pp. 22‐3.

4.HCIA study, Health Care Strategic Management, April 1993, p. 5.

5.Melnick, G.A. and Zwanziger, J., “Hospital behavior under competition and cost containment policies ‐ the California experience, 1980 to 1985”, Journal of American Medical Association, Vol. 260 No. 18, 1988, pp. 2669‐75.

6.Higgins, C.W., “Myths of competitive reform”, Health Care Management Review, Vol. 16 No. 1, 1991, pp. 65‐72.

7.Robinson, J.C. and Luft, H.S., “Competition and the cost of health care, 1972‐1982”, Journal of Health Economics, Vol. 4, 1987, pp. 333‐56.

8.Milward, H.B., Provan, K. and Smith, L.J., “Human service contracting and coordination”, Research in Public Administration, Vol. 3, 1994, pp. 231‐79.

9.Osborne, D. and Gaebler, T., Reinventing Government, Plume, New York, NY, 1993.

10.Light, D.W., “Homo economicus: escaping the traps of managed competition”, unpublished lecture, 1995.

11.Clark, R.E. and Dorwart, R.A., “Competition and community mental health agencies”, Journal of Health Politics, Policies and Law, Vol. 17 No. 3, 1992, pp. 517‐40.

12.Smith, S.R. and Ingram, H. (Eds), Public Policy for Democracy, The Brookings Institute, Washington, DC, 1993.

13.Smith, S.R. and Lipsky, M., Nonprofits for Hire: The Welfare State in the Age of Contracting, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, 1993.

14.Smyth, J.D., “An analysis of the strategic implications of increasing competition for a not for profit organization”, unpublished thesis, Portsmouth University, 1992.

15.Deakin, N., “Evolving relations between government and the third sector in Britain: the case of community care”, unpublished paper for Conference of International Society for Third Sector Research, Pecs, Hungary, 4‐7 July 1994.

16.Le Grand, J., “Quasi markets and community care”, Studies in Decentralization and Quasi Markets, No. 17, School for Advanced Urban Studies, Bristol.

17.Chambers, D., Learning from Markets, Office for Public Management, London, June 1989.

18.March, J., Summarising the Public Service Ethos in Local Government, Lawrence Pratchett and Melvin Wingfield, ICSA/Commission for Local Democracy, London, 1995.

19.Kettl, D.F., Sharing Power, The Brookings Institute, Washington, DC, 1993.

20.Schlesinger, M., Dortwart, R.A. and Pulice, R.A., “Competitive bidding and states, purchase of services: the case of mental health in Massachusetts”, Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, Vol. 5, Winter 1986, pp. 251‐2.

21.Milward, H.B. and Provan, K., “Integration of community‐based services for the severely mentally ill and the structure of public funding: a comparison of four states”, Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, Vol. 19 No. 4, Winter 1994.

22.Hoogland Dehoog, R., Contracting out for Human Services: Economic, Political and Organisational Perspectives, State University of New York Press, NY, 1984.

23.Higgins, C.W., “Competitive reform and nonprice competition: implications for the hospital industry”, Health Management Review, Vol. 14 No. 4, 1989, pp. 57‐66.

24.Smith, S.R. and Smyth, J.D., “Contracting for services in a decentralized system”, unpublished paper, 1995.

25.Charlesworth, J., Clark, J. and Cochrane, A., “Tangled webs? Managing local mixed economies of care”, unpublished paper for ERU conference Cardiff, 1994.

26.Barzelay, M., Breaking through Bureaucracy, University of California Press, Berkeley and Los Angeles CA, 1992.

27.Smith, S.R., “Innovation in the nonprofit sector”, unpublished paper, 1995.

28.Osborne, S.P., Unpublished paper given at the 1995 Independent Sector Spring Research Forum, Alexandria, Virginia, 22/24 March, 1995.

29.Anton, J.J. and Gertler, P.J., “Regulation, local monopolies and spatial competition”, unpublished paper, 1994.

30.Carswell L. and Connolly, M., “The contract state and the voluntary sector”, unpublished paper, Department of Public Administration, University of Ulster, 1994.

31.Murray, D.et al., “Managed care 1995”, Medical Economics, 13 March 1995, pp. 44‐57.

32.Ham, C., “Managing the NHS market”, Health Director, February 1995, p. 4.

33.Lynn, L.E. Jr, “Government Lite”, The American Prospect, Winter 1994, pp. 135‐44.

Anton, J.J. and Yao, D.A. (1989, “Split awards, procurement, and innovation”, RAND Journal of Economics, Vol. 20 No. 4, Winter, pp. 538‐52.

Appleby, J., Smith, P., Ranade, W., Little, V. and Robinson, R. (1994, “Monitoring managed competition”, in Robinson, R. and Le Grand, J. (Eds), Evaluating the NHS Reforms, Policy Journals, Newbury.

Carbone, C.P (1992‐93., Associate Director, Arizona Department of Health Services, Division of Health Services, nnual Report FY.

Barr, N. (1987, The Economics of the Welfare State, Weidenfield and Nicholson, London.

Brenton, M. (1990, The Voluntary Sector and the Social Services, Longman, London/Essex.

Common, R., Flynn, N. and Mellon, E. (1992, Managing Public Services ‐ Competition and Decentralisation, Butterworth‐Heinemann, Oxford and Stoneham, MA.

Culyer, A.J., Maynard, A.K. and Posnett, J. (Ed.) (1990, Competition in Health Care ‐ Reforming the NHS, Macmillan, Basingstoke.

Enthoven, A.C. (1988, Theory and Practice of Managed Competition in Health Care Finance, Elsevier Science, Amsterdam.

Enthoven, A.C. (1993, “The history and principles of managed competition”, Health Affairs Supplement, Vol. 12, pp. 24‐48.

Deakin, N. (1987, The Politics of Welfare, Methuen, London.

Doremus, H. (1992, “Managing competition in the health care industry”, Health Care Strategic Management, December, pp. 22‐3.

Dunleavy, P. (1991, Democracy, Bureaucracy and Public Choice, Harvester‐Wheatsheaf, Brighton.

Farnham, D. and Horton, S. (Eds) (1993, Managing the New Public Services, Macmillan, Basingstoke.

Ferris, J. and Graddy, E. (1986, “Contracting out: for what? with whom?”, Public Administration Review, Vol. 46 No. 4, July/August, pp. 332‐44.

Ferris, J.M. and Graddy, E. (1995, “Hospital industry dynamics and the non‐profit role in health care”, unpublished paper prepared for the 1995 Independent Spring Research Forum, 23‐24 March.

Flynn, N. (1990, Public Sector Management, Harvester‐Wheatsheaf, London.

Gore, A. (1993, Creating a Government that Works Better and Costs Less, Penguin, New York, NY.

Gutch, R., Kunz, C. and Spencer, K. (1990, Partners or Agents?, NCVO, London.

Gyford, J. (1990, Citizens, Consumers and Councils. Local Government and the Public, GBC Macmillan, Basingstoke.

Ham, C. and Hill, M. (1993, The Policy Process in the Modern Capitalist State, Harvester‐Wheatsheaf, Brighton.

Hambleton, R. and Taylor, M. (1993, People in Cities: a Transatlantic Policy Exchange, School of Advanced Urban Studies, Bristol University, Bristol.

Hirschman, A.O. (1982, “Rival interpretations of market society: civilizing, destructive or feeble?”, Journal of Economic Literature, Vol. 20, pp. 1463‐84.

James, E. (1987, “The non‐profit sector in comparative perspective”, in Powell, W.W. (Ed.), The Nonprofit sector, A Research Handbook, Yale University Press, New Haven, CT.

James, E. (1992, “How nonprofits grow: a model”, Journal of Public Policy Analysis and Management, Vol. 2 No. 3, pp. 350‐65.

Le Grand, J. and Bartlett, W. (1993, Quasi‐Markets and Social Policy, Macmillan, Basingstoke.

Levitt, D (1995., “Expensive prize”, oluntary Housing, April, p. 7.

Light, D.W. (1994, “Health care systems and their financing”, in Walton, Lord, Owen, G. and Rhodes, P. (Eds), The New Oxford Medical Companion, Oxford University, Oxford Press.

Lish, M. (1993, Contracting: The Impact on Small or Rural Nonprofit Organizations, National Council of Voluntary Organizations, London.

Melnick, G.A., Zwanziger, J. and Verity‐Guerra, A. (1989, “The growth and effects of hospital selective contracting”, Health Care Management Review, Vol. 14 No. 3, pp. 57‐64.

Mintzberg, H., Quinn, J.B. and James, R.M. (1991, The Strategy Process: Concepts, Context and Case, 2nd ed., Prentice‐Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ.

Moss Kanter, R. (1989, When Giants Learn to Dance, Unwin, Hyman, London.

Morone, J.A (1990., he Democratic Wish: Popular Participation and the Limits of American Government, Basic, New York, NY.

Oster, S.M. (1995, Strategic Management for Nonprofit Organizations, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

Paton, C. (1991, “Myths of competition”, The Health Service Journal, 30 May, pp. 22‐3.

Paton, C. (1992, Competition and Planning in the NHS ‐ The Danger of Unplanned Markets, Chapman & Hall, London.

Prohl, M. (1993, Carl Bertlesman Prize 1993, Bertlesman Foundation, Gutersloh.

Robinson, R. (1991, “Who’s playing monopoly?”, The Health Service Journal, 8 July, p. 25.

Robinson, R. and Le Grand, J. (Eds) (1994, Evaluating the NHS Reforms, Policy Journals, Newbury.

Smith, S.R. and Lipsky, M. (1992, “Privatization in health and human services: a critique”, Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, Vol. 17 No. 2, pp. 233‐53.

Taylor‐Goodby, P. (1991, Social Change, Social Welfare and Social Science, Harvester‐Wheatsheaf, Brighton.

Taylor‐Goodby, P. and Lawson, R. (Ed.) (1993, Markets and Managers, Open University Press, Milton Keynes.

Williamson, O.E. (1975, Markets and Hierarchies, Analysis and Antitrust Implications, The Free Press, New York, NY.

Williamson, O.E. (Ed.) (1990, Industrial Organization, Edward Elgar, Aldershot.

Wistow, G., Hardy, B., Knapp, M. and Allen, C. (1994, Social Care in a Mixed Economy, Open University Press, Milton Keynes.