Two Faces of Power

American Political Science Review - Tập 56 Số 4 - Trang 947-952 - 1962
Peter Bachrach1, Morton S. Baratz1
1Bryn Mawr College

Tóm tắt

The concept of power remains elusive despite the recent and prolific outpourings of case studies on community power. Its elusiveness is dramatically demonstrated by the regularity of disagreement as to the locus of community power between the sociologists and the political scientists. Sociologically oriented researchers have consistently found that power is highly centralized, while scholars trained in political science have just as regularly concluded that in “their” communities power is widely diffused. Presumably, this explains why the latter group styles itself “pluralist,” its counterpart “elitist.”There seems no room for doubt that the sharply divergent findings of the two groups are the product, not of sheer coincidence, but of fundamental differences in both their underlying assumptions and research methodology. The political scientists have contended that these differences in findings can be explained by the faulty approach and presuppositions of the sociologists. We contend in this paper that the pluralists themselves have not grasped the whole truth of the matter; that while their criticisms of the elitists are sound, they, like the elitists, utilize an approach and assumptions which predetermine their conclusions. Our argument is cast within the frame of our central thesis: that there are two faces of power, neither of which the sociologists see and only one of which the political scientists see.

Từ khóa


Tài liệu tham khảo

Dahl, 1961, Who Governs?

Long, 1956, A Research Program on Leadership and Decision-Making in Metropolitan Areas

10.1086/221799

Dahl, 1958, A Critique of the Ruling-Elite Model, Review, 52, 463

Vidich, 1958, Small Town in Mass Society

10.2307/972597

Dahl, 1961, Who Governs?

Herson, 1961, In the Footsteps of Community Power, Review, 55, 817

Hunter, 1953, Community Power Structure

Bentley, 1908, The Process of Government, 202

10.2307/2088617

Sayre, 1960, Governing New York City

Lasswell, 1950, Power and Society, 75

10.2307/2126892

Schattschneider, 1960, The Semi-Sovereign People, 71

Thông tin
Thông tin xuất bản

American Political Science Review

Tập 56 Số 4

947-952

Thông tin tác giả