Transaction cost economics and mutual legal uncertainty to build commitment

Journal of Organization Design - Tập 12 - Trang 141-156 - 2023
Joseph McManus1
1Leon Hess Business School, Monmouth University, West Long Branch, USA

Tóm tắt

The central premise of transaction cost economics (TCE) is that parties select governance mechanisms to mitigate the hazards of opportunism (or “behavioral uncertainty”) while also economizing on the costs of more complex forms of governance. However, boundedly rational actors face meaningful limitations on their foresight which constrains their ability to negotiate complete contractual terms. TCE largely treats contractual incompleteness as a problem that parties eliminate whenever cost considerations allow. The theory developed here argues that under certain conditions, mutual legal uncertainty serves as a commitment strategy that enables contracting parties to ensure shared dependence and forbearance within their transactional relationship. Parties that employ this commitment strategy mutually accept the risk of an unfavorable outcome based upon an interpretation of the incomplete language imposed through the judicial enforcement mechanism. Thus, contractual incompleteness constitutes a shared commitment to both avoid judicial enforcement and adapt the relationship to unforeseen or unlikely future events.

Tài liệu tham khảo

Adams KA (2004) A legal-usage analysis of material adverse change provisions. Fordham J Corp & Fin l 10(1):9–53 Al-Najjar NI (1995) Incomplete contracts and the governance of complex contractual relationships. Am Econ Rev 85(2):432–436 Anderson E, Weitz B (1992) The use of pledges to build and sustain commitment in distribution channels. J Mark Res 29(1):18–34 Argyres NS, Mayer KJ (2007) Contract design as firm capability: an integration of learning and transaction cost perspectives. Acad Manag Rev 32(4):1060–1077 Argyres NS, Bercovitz J, Mayer KJ (2007) Complementarity and evolution of contractual provisions: an empirical study of IT services contracts. Organ Sci 18(1):3–19 Ariño A, Reuer JJ (2004) Designing and renegotiating strategic alliance contracts. Acad Manag Perspect 18(3):37–48 Arrow K (1962) Economic welfare and the allocation of resources for invention. In: Arrow K, Nelson R (eds) The rate and direction of inventive activity: economic and social factors. Princeton University Press, Princeton, pp 609–626 Arter & Hadden (1996) D&O insurance case law: recent Developments. Arter & Hadden, Columbus Atiyah PS (1988) An introduction to the law of contract. Clarendon Press, Oxford Bailey DA (1995) Directors and officers—The ACE report. ACE Bermuda News, Bermuda Bailey D (2002) Size of D&O settlements exploding. http://library.findlaw.com/2002/Nov/1/130753.html Accessed 10 January 2010 Baker S, Krawiec KD (2005) Incomplete contracts in a complete contract world. Florida St University Law Review 33:725–756 Balakrishnan S, Wernerfelt B (1986) Technical change, competition, and vertical integration. Strateg Manag J 7(4):347–359 Barnard CI (1938: 1962) The functions of the executive. 15th ed, Harvard University Press, Cambridge Barney JB (1990) The debate between traditional management theory and organizational economics: substantial differences or intergroup conflict? Acad Manag Rev 15(3):382–393 Bernheim BD, Whinston MD (1998) Incomplete contracts and strategic ambiguity. Am Econ Rev 88(4):902–932 Brander JA, Spencer BJ (1983) Strategic commitments with R&D: the symmetric case. Bell J Econ 14(1):225–235 Buckley P, Casson M (1988) A theory of cooperation in international business. In: Contractor F, Lorange P (eds) Cooperative strategies in international business: joint ventures and technology transfers between firms. Lexington Books, New York, pp 31–53 Cao Z, Lumineau F (2015) Revisiting the interplay between contractual and relational governance: a qualitative and meta-analytic investigation. J Oper Manag 33–34:15–42 Choi A, Triantis G (2010) Strategic vagueness in contract design: the case of corporate acquisitions. Yale Law J 119:848–924 Coase RH (1937) The nature of the firm. Economica 4:386–405 Cornerstone Research (2010) Securities class action filings 2009: a year in review. Cornerstone Research, Menlo Park Crocker KJ, Reynolds KJ (1993) The efficiency of incomplete contracts: an empirical analysis of Air Force engine procurement. RAND J Econ 126–146 Cuypers IR, Hennart JF, Silverman BS, Ertug G (2021) Transaction cost theory: past progress, current challenges, and suggestions for the future. Acad Manag Ann 15(1):111–150 Das TK, Teng BS (1998) Between trust and control: developing confidence in partner cooperation in alliances. Acad Manag Rev 23(3):491–512 Dye RA (1985) Costly contract contingencies. Int Econ Rev 26(1):233–250 Fehr E, Gachter S (2000) Fairness and retaliation: the economics of reciprocity. J Econ Perspect 14(3):159–181 Feinman JM (2009) Insurance relationship as relational contract and the fairly debateable rule for first-party bad faith. San Diego L Rev 46(1):553–573 Frank RH (2004) What price the moral high ground? Ethical dilemmas in competitive environments. Princeton University Press, Princeton Geyskens I, Steenkamp JEM, Kumar N (2006) Make, buy, or ally: a transaction cost theory meta-analysis. Acad Manag J 49(3):519–543 Ghoshal S, Moran P (1996) Bad for practice: a critique of transaction cost theory. Acad Manag Rev 21:13–47 Gilson RJ, Sabel CF, Scott RE (2010) Braiding: the interaction of formal and informal contracting in theory, practice, and doctrine. Columbia Law Rev 110(6):1377–1447 Gladstone S (2010) The future of D&O insurance. Risk and Insurance Management Society, Risk Management Magazine, New York Goffman E (1986) Frame analysis: an essay on the organization of experience, 2nd edn. Northeastern University Press, Boston Handley SM, Angst CM (2015) The impact of culture on the relationship between governance and opportunism in outsourcing relationships. Strateg Manag J 36(9):1412–1434 Hart OD (1988) Incomplete contracts and the theory of the firm. J Law Econ Organ 4:119–140 Hart OD, Moore J (1999) Foundations of incomplete contracts. Rev Econ Stud 66(1):115–138 Hay BL, Spier KE (1997) Burdens of proof in civil litigation: an economic perspective. J Leg Stud 26(2):413–431 Hayek F (1945) The use of knowledge in society. Am Econ Rev 35:519–530 Ingram P (1996) Organizational form as a solution to the problem of credible commitment: the evolution of naming strategies among U.S. hotel chains, 1896–1980. Strateg Manag J 17:85–98 Kahneman D, Tversky A (1979) Prospect theory: an analysis of decision under risk. Econometrica 47(2):263–292 Kahneman D, Knetsch JL, Thaler RH (1991) Anomalies: the endowment effect, loss aversion, and status quo bias. J Econ Perspect 5(1):193–206 Kale P, Puranam P (2013) The design of equity ownership structure in inter-firm relationships: do managers choose according to theory? J Organ Des 2(2):15–30 Kaplan S (2008) Framing contests: strategy making under uncertainty. Organ Sci 19(5):729–752 Keller A, Lumineau F, Mellewigt T, Ariño A (2021) Alliance governance mechanisms in the face of disruption. Organ Sci 32(6):1542–1570 Ketokivi M, Mahoney JT (2016) Transaction cost economics as a constructive stakeholder theory. Acad Manag Learn Educ 15(1):123–138 Klein BA (2002) The role of incomplete contracts in self-enforcing relationships. In: Brousseau E, Glachant J (eds) The economics of contracts. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 549–571 Klein BA, Crawford A, Alchain A (1978) Vertical integration, appropriable rents, and the competitive contracting process. J Law Econ Organ 7:972–991 Koopmans T (1957) Three essays on the state of economic science. McGraw Hill, New York Lapan HE, Sandler T (1988) To bargain or not to bargain: that is the question. Am Econ Rev 78(2):16–26 Li JJ, Poppo L, Zhou KZ (2010) Relational mechanisms, formal contracts, and local knowledge acquisition by international subsidiaries. Strateg Manag J 31(4):349–370 Liu SS, Ngo HY (2004) An action pattern model of inter-firm cooperation. J Manage Stud 42(6):1123–1153 Llewellyn KN (1931) What price contract? An essay in perspective. Yale Law J 40:704–751 Lumineau F (2017) How contracts influence trust and distrust. J Manag 43(5):1553–1577 Lumineau F, Malhotra D (2011) Shadow of the contract: how contract structure shapes interfirm dispute resolution. Strateg Manag J 32(5):532–555 Lumineau F, Wang W, Schilke O (2020) Blockchain governance—a new way of organizing collaborations? Organ Sci 32(2):500–521 Macaulay S (1963) The use and non-use of contracts in the manufacturing industry. Prac Law 9:13 Macneil IR (1974) The many futures of contracts. S Cal L Rev 47:691–816 Macneil IR (1978) Contracts: adjustments of long-term economic relations under classical, neoclassical and relational contract law. Nw UL Rev 72:854–906 Malhotra D (2009) When contracts destroy trust. Harv Bus Rev 87(5):25 Malhotra D, Murningham JK (2002) The effects of contracts on interpersonal trust. Adm Sci Q 47(3):534–559 March JG (1995) A primer on decision making. Free Press, New York Mayer KJ, Argyres NS (2004) Learning to contract: evidence from the personal computer industry. Organ Sci 15(4):394–410 Messick DM (1999) Alternative logics for decision making in social settings. J Econ Behav Organ 38:11–28 Messick DM, Tenbrunsel AE (1999) Sanctioning systems, decision frames and cooperation. Adm Sci Q 44(4):684–707 Monteverde K, Teece DJ (1982) Supplier switching costs and vertical integration in the automobile industry. Bell J Econ 13:206–213 Naim MM, Gosling J (2011) On leanness, agility and leagile supply chains. Int J Prod Econ 131(1):342–354 Oxley JE (1999) Institutional environment and the mechanisms of governance: the impact of intellectual property protection on the structure of inter-firm alliances. J Econ Behav Organ 38(3):283–309 Parkhe A (1993) Strategic alliance structuring: a game theoretic and transaction cost examination of interfirm cooperation. Acad Manag J 36(4):794–829 Perrin T (2006) Directors’ and officers’ liability: 2005 survey executive summary. Towers Perrin, Chicago, IL Pisano G (1989) Using equity to support exchange: evidence from the biotechnology industry. J Law Econ Organ 5:109–126 Poppo L, Zenger T (2002) Do formal contracts and relational governance function as substitutes or complements? Strateg Manag J 23(8):707–725 Rice MD, Shappell S (2009) 2008 year-in-review legal news and developments in executive liability. Aon Global Corporate Marketing and Communications, Chicago, IL Rindfleisch A, Heide JB (1997) Transaction cost analysis: past, present, and future applications. J Mark 61:30–54 Ring PS, Van de Ven AH (1994) Developmental processes of cooperative interorganizational relationships. Acad Manag Rev 19(1):90–118 Sadovnikova A, Pujari A, Mikhailitchenko A (2016) Radical innovation in strategic partnerships: a framework for analysis. J Bus Res 69(5):1829–1833 Sampson R (2007) R&D alliances and firm performance: the impact of technological diversity and alliance organization on innovation. Acad Manag J 50(2):364–386 Saussier S (2000) Transaction costs and contractual incompleteness: the case of Electricite de France. J Econ Behav Organ 42:189–206 Schelling TC (1956) An essay on bargaining. Am Econ Rev 46(3):281–306 Schelling TC (1960: 1980) The strategy of conflict. 2nd ed, Harvard University Press, Cambridge Schepker DJ, Oh W, Martynov A, Poppo L (2014) The many futures of contracts: moving beyond structure and safeguarding to coordination and adaptation. J Manag 40(1):193–225 Scott RE, Triantis GG (2005) Incomplete contracts and the theory of contract design. Case W Res L Rev 56:187–201 Scott RE, Triantis GG (2006) Anticipating litigation in contract design. Yale L J 115:814–879 Shelanski HA, Klein PG (1995) Empirical research in transaction cost economics: a review and assessment. J Law Econ Organ 11(2):335–361 Simon HA (1947:1976) Administrative behavior. 3rd ed. The Free Press, New York Simon HA (1978) Rationality as a process and as product of thought. Am Econ Rev 68:1–16 Spence AM (1977) Entry, capacity, investment and oligopolistic pricing. Bell J Econ 8(2):534–544 Spence M (1978) Job market signaling. In: Uncertainty in economics, Academic Press, pp 281–306. Srinivasan R, Brush TH (2006a) Supplier performance in vertical alliances: the effects of self-enforcing agreements and enforceable contracts. Organ Sci 17(4):436–452 Srinivasan R, Brush TH (2006b) Supplier performance in vertical alliances: the effects of self-enforcing agreements and enforceable contracts. Organ Sci 17:436–452 Taffae PR (2002) Navigating rough seas. Best Company Inc, A.M Telser LG (1980) A theory of self-enforcing agreements. J Bus 53(1):27–44 Triole J (1999) Incomplete contracts: where do we stand? Econometrica 67(4):741–781 Tsang EW (2006) Behavioral assumptions and theory development: the case of transaction cost economics. Strateg Manag J 27(11):999–1011 Tushman M, Lakhani K R, Lifshitz-Assaf H (2012) Open innovation and organization design. J Organ Design 1(1) Tversky A, Kahneman D (1991) Loss aversion in riskless choice: a reference-dependent model. Q J Econ 106(4):1039–1061 Vanneste BS, Puranam P (2010) Repeated interactions and contractual detail: identifying the learning effect. Organ Sci 21(1):186–201 Verbeke A, Greidanus N (2009) The end of the opportunism versus trust debate: bounded reliability as a new envelope concept in research on MNE governance. Int J Bus Stud 40:1472–1495 Weber L, Mayer KJ, Macher JT (2011) An analysis of extendibility and early termination provisions: the importance of framing duration safeguards. Acad Manag J 54(1):182–202 Williamson OE (1981) The economics of organization: the transaction cost approach. Am J Sociol 87(3):548–577 Williamson OE (1983) Credible commitments: using hostages to support exchange. Am Econ Rev 73(4):519–540 Williamson OE (1985) The economic institutions of capitalism. The Free Press, New York, NY Williamson OE (1988) Corporate finance and corporate governance. J Finance 43(3):567–591 Williamson OE (1991a) Comparative economic organizing: the analysis of discrete structural alternatives. Adm Sci Q 36:269–296 Williamson OE (1991b) Strategizing, economizing, and economic organization. Strateg Manag J 12:75–94 Williamson OE (1993) Calculativeness, trust, and economic organization. J Law Econ 36:453–486 Young-Ybarra C, Wiersema M (1999) Strategic flexibility in information technology alliances: the influence of transaction cost economics and social exchange theory. Organ Sci 10(4):439–459 Zaheer A, Venkatraman N (1995) Relational governance as an interorganizational strategy: an empirical test of the role of trust in economic exchange. Strateg Manag J 16:373–392 Zamir E, Ritov I (2012) Loss aversion, omission bias, and the burden of proof in civil litigation. J Leg Stud 41(1):165–207 Zhang J, Jiang H, Wu R, Li J (2019) Reconciling the dilemma of knowledge sharing: a network pluralism framework of firms’ R&D alliance network and innovation performance. J Manag 45(7):2635–2665