Rationality, Imagination and Advocacy in Educational Research

Journal of Educational Administration - Tập 28 Số 3 - 1990
William S.Simpkins

Tóm tắt

Enterprising projects require a mixture of the imaginative and rational, not the rejection of one in favour of the other. Where a clear distinction is made, the imaginative and rational may support different doctrines on how knowledge and understanding should be acquired. Where attempts are made to draw on both as analytic and creative resources, e.g. as in the qualitative treatment of new social data, researchers may have the task of developing a complementary approach to social enquiry which combines objectivity with intuition and detachment with feelings of rapport. The data obtained often require an advocacy approach to argument, one where a persuasive line of argument is designed to establish the relative strength of a case in what may well be an adversarial context of claims and counter‐claims. Where research deals with various kinds of evidence, e.g. objective and subjective, research methods must be argued as compatible with a research problem and its context, and not dictated arbitrarily by research doctrine. An example is given of what is claimed to be a rational, linear approach to developing the internal logic of a research report; the claim is discussed that rationality and imagination may be complementary in speculative research; and an advocacy approach to presenting a research case is discussed.

Từ khóa


Tài liệu tham khảo

Davidson R., 1989, The Australian

Macpherson R.J.S., 1989, National Conference of Educational Administration

Connell R.W., 1985, The Australian Universities' Review, 28, 38

Simpkins W.S., 1987, The Journal ofEducational Administration, 25

Harre R., 1972, The Philosophies of Science

Hospers J., 1984, An Introduction to Philosophical Analysis, Routledge and Kegan Paul

Bullock A., 1988, Modern Thought

Chalmers A.F., 1982, What is the Thing Called Science?

10.1007/BF01557719

Theroux P., 1985, Hamish Hamilton

Allen C, 1989, Art

Hughes R., 1980, BBC

Irmscher W.F., 1975, Holt

Seymour-Smith M., 1979, Fifty European Novels

Raban J., 1987, Collins

Hyman S.M., 1970, Appleton-Century-Crofts

George W.H., 1936, The Scientist in Action, Williams and Norgate

Merton R.K., 1966, Readings on Modern Sociology, 23

Redfield R., 1966, Readings on Modern Sociology, 36

Thông tin
Thông tin xuất bản

Journal of Educational Administration

Tập 28 Số 3

Thông tin tác giả