Pushing poverty off limits: quality improvement and the architecture of healthcare values
Tóm tắt
Poverty and social deprivation have adverse effects on health outcomes and place a significant burden on healthcare systems. There are some actions that can be taken to tackle them from within healthcare institutions, but clinicians who seek to make frontline services more responsive to the social determinants of health and the social context of people’s lives can face a range of ethical challenges. We summarise and consider a case in which clinicians introduced a poverty screening initiative (PSI) into paediatric practice using the discourse and methodology of healthcare quality improvement (QI). Whilst suggesting that interventions like the PSI are a potentially valuable extension of clinical roles, which take advantage of the unique affordances of clinical settings, we argue that there is a tendency for such settings to continuously reproduce a narrower set of norms. We illustrate how the framing of an initiative as QI can help legitimate and secure funding for practical efforts to help address social ends from within clinical service, but also how it can constrain and disguise the value of this work. A combination of methodological emphases within QI and managerialism within healthcare institutions leads to the prioritisation, often implicitly, of a limited set of aims and governing values for healthcare. This can act as an obstacle to a genuine broadening of the clinical agenda, reinforcing norms of clinical practice that effectively push poverty ‘off limits.’ We set out the ethical dilemmas facing clinicians who seek to navigate this landscape in order to address poverty and the social determinants of health. We suggest that reclaiming QI as a more deliberative tool that is sensitive to these ethical dilemmas can enable managers, clinicians and patients to pursue health-related values and ends, broadly conceived, as part of an expansive range of social and personal goods.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Marmot MG, Smith GD, Stansfeld S, Patel C, North F, Head J, et al. Health inequalities among British civil servants: the Whitehall II study. Lancet. 1991;337:1387–93.
Wilkinson R, Pickett K. The spirit level: why more equal societies almost always do better. London: Penguin; 2009.
Leeser R. Poverty in London 2018/19. 2020. https://data.london.gov.uk/blog/poverty-in-london-2018-19/. Accessed 19 Oct 2020.
Singh G, Zhu H. Poverty in practice: using quality improvement (QI) in paediatrics to improve identification and support of families living in poverty. Arch Dis Child Educ Prac Ed. 2020. https://doi.org/10.1136/archdischild-2019-318259.
Andermann A. Taking action on the social determinants of health in clinical practice: a framework for health professionals. CMAJ. 2016;188(17–18):E474–83.
Andermann A. Screening for social determinants of health in clinical care: moving from the margins to the mainstream. Public Health Rev. 2018;39:19–35.
Fierman AH, Beck AF, Chung EK, Tschudy MM, Coker TR, Mistry KB, et al. Redesigning health care practices to address childhood poverty. Acad Pediatr. 2016;16(3):S136–46.
Garg A, Boynton-Jarrett R, Dworkin PH. Avoiding the unintended consequences of screening for social determinants of health. JAMA. 2016;316(8):813–4.
Garg A, Toy S, Tripodis Y, Silverstein M, Freeman E. Addressing social determinants of health at well child care visits: a cluster RCT. Pediatrics. 2015;135(2):e296-304.
Grant C, Goodenough T, Harvey I, Hine C. A randomised controlled trial and economic evaluation of a referrals facilitator between primary care and the voluntary sector. BMJ. 2000;320:419.
Kaufman A. Theory vs practice: should primary care practice take on social determinants of health now? Yes. Ann Fam Med. 2016;14(2):100–1.
Swain GR, Grande KM, Hood CM, Inzeo PT. Health care professionals: opportunities to address social determinants of health. Wis Med J. 2014;113(6):218–22.
Asaria M, Doran T, Cookson R. The costs of inequality: whole-population modelling study of lifetime inpatient hospital costs in the English National Health Service by level of neighbourhood deprivation. J Epidemiol Community Health. 2016;70:990–6.
McCartney G, Hart C, Watt G. How can socioeconomic inequalities in hospital admissions be explained? A cohort study. BMJ Open. 2013;3:e002433.
Weissman JS, Stern RS, Epstein AM. The impact of patient socioeconomic status and other social factors on readmission: a prospective study in Four Massachusetts Hospitals. Inquiry. 1994;31(2):163–72.
Institute for Healthcare Improvement. Plan-Do-Study-Act (PDSA) Worksheet. No date. http://www.ihi.org/resources/Pages/Tools/PlanDoStudyActWorksheet.aspx. Accessed 19 Oct 2020.
Singh G. Health is much bigger than the NHS: Using improvement methods to address the wider determinants of health. Presentation at UK-wide Q Community Event, Health Foundation; 2019; London.
NHS. The NHS long term plan. 2019. https://www.longtermplan.nhs.uk/. Accessed 24 Apr 2021.
NHS. About Quality Accounts. https://www.nhs.uk/using-the-nhs/about-the-nhs/quality-accounts/about-quality-accounts/. Accessed 18 Apr 2021.
NHS. 2020/21 National Tariff Payment System. Annex D: Guidance on best practice tariffs. NHS. 2020. https://www.england.nhs.uk/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/20-21NT_Annex_D_Best_practice_tariffs.pdf. Accessed 18 Apr 2021.
NHS England Sustainable Improvement Team. The Change Model Guide. 2018. https://www.england.nhs.uk/wp-content/uploads/2018/04/change-model-guide-v5.pdf. Accessed 18 Apr 2021.
Wiig S, Aase K, von Plessen C, Burnett S, Nunes F, Weggelaar AM, et al. Talking about quality: exploring how ‘quality’ is conceptualized in European hospitals and healthcare systems. BMC Health Serv Res. 2014;14:478.
Exworthy M, Hunter DJ. The challenge of joined-up government in tackling health inequalities. Int J Public Adm. 2011;34(4):201–12.
Goddard M, Smith P. Equity of access to health care services: theory and evidence from the UK. Soc Sci Med. 2001;53(9):1149–62.
Chivu CM, Reidpath DD. Social deprivation and exposure to health promotion. A study of the distribution of health promotion resources to schools in England. BMC Public Health. 2010;10(473):1–6.
Wyatt R, Laderman M, Botwinick L, Mate K, Whittington J. Achieving health equity: a guide for health care organizations. IHI White Paper. Institute for Healthcare Improvement, Cambridge; 2016.
Institute of Medicine. Crossing the quality chasm: a new health system for the 21st century. Washington, DC: National Academy Press; 2001.
Mitchell P, Cribb A, Entwistle VA. Defining what is good: pluralism and healthcare quality. Kennedy Inst Ethics J. 2019;29(4):367–88.
Bharmal N, Derose KP, Felician M, Weden MM. Understanding the upstream social determinants of health. Santa Monica: RAND Corporation; 2015.
Altman MR, Oseguera T, McLemore MR, Kantrowitz-Gordon I, Franck LS, Lyndon A. Information and power: Women of color’s experiences interacting with health care providers in pregnancy and birth. Soc Sci Med. 2019;65(4):466–73.
Easton P, Entwistle VA, Williams B. How the stigma of low literacy can impair patient-professional spoken interactions and affect health: insights from a qualitative investigation. BMC Health Serv Res. 2013;13:319.
Edwards ST, Marino M, Balasubramanian BA, Solberg LI, Valenzuela S, Springer R, et al. Burnout among physicians, advanced practice clinicians and staff in smaller primary care practices. J Gen Intern Med. 2018;33:2138–46.
Tak HJ, Curlin FA, Yoon JD. Association of intrinsic motivating factors and markers of physician well-being: a national physician survey. J Gen Intern Med. 2017;32:739–46.
Tung YC, Chou YY, Chang YH, Chung KP. Association of intrinsic and extrinsic motivating factors with physician burnout and job satisfaction: a nationwide cross-sectional survey in Taiwan. BMJ Open. 2020;10:e035948.
Cribb A. Healthcare in transition: understanding key ideas and tensions in contemporary health policy. Bristol: Bristol Policy Press; 2017.
NHS Digital. Quality and Outcomes Framework, 2019–20. Indicator definitions. 2020. https://digital.nhs.uk/data-and-information/publications/statistical/quality-and-outcomes-framework-achievement-prevalence-and-exceptions-data/2019-20#resources. Accessed 19 Oct 2020.
Public Health System Group for England. Quality in public health: a shared responsibility. 2019. https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/809305/Quality_in_public_health_shared_responsibility_2019.pdf. Accessed 19 Oct 2020.
Fereday S. A guide to quality improvement methods. London: Healthcare Quality Improvement Partnership; 2015.
Toma M, Dreischulte T, Gray NM, Campbell D, Guthrie B. Balancing measures or a balanced accounting of improvement impact: a qualitative analysis of individual and focus group interviews with improvement experts in Scotland. BMJ Qual Saf. 2018;27:547–56.
Batalden M, Batalden P, Margolis P, Seid M, Armstrong G, Opipari-Arrigan L, Hartung H. Coproduction of healthcare service. BMJ Qual Saf. 2016;25:509–17.
Vennik FD, van de Bovenkamp HM, Putters K, Grit KJ. Co-production in healthcare: rhetoric and practice. Int Rev Adm Sci. 2016;82(1):150–68.
Martin GP, McKee L, Dixon-Woods M. Beyond metrics? Utilizing ‘soft intelligence’ for healthcare quality and safety. Soc Sci Med. 2015;142:19–26.
Junghans T. “Don’t Mind the Gap!” reflections on improvement science as a paradigm. Health Care Anal. 2018;26:124–39.
Pflueger D. Accounting for quality: on the relationship between accounting and quality improvement in healthcare. BMC Health Serv Res. 2015;15:178.
Cribb A, Entwistle V, Mitchell P. What does “quality” add? Towards an ethics of healthcare improvement. J Med Ethics. 2020;46(2):118–22.
McCalman J, Bailie R, Bainbridge R, McPhail-Bell K, Percival N, Askew D, et al. Continuous quality improvement and comprehensive primary health care: a systems framework to improve service quality and health outcomes. Front Public Health. 2018;6:76.
Gottlieb K. The Nuka system of care: improving health through ownership and relationships. Int J of Circumpolar Health. 2013;72:1.
Hayward MN, Pace R, Zaran H, Dyck R, Hanley AJ, Green ME, et al. Closing the indigenous health gap in Canada: results from the TransFORmation of IndiGEnous PrimAry HEAlthcare delivery (FORGE AHEAD) program. Diabetes Res Clin Pract. 2020;162:108066.
Glendinning C. Breaking down barriers: integrating health and care services for older people in England. Health Policy. 2003;65(2):139–51.
Kurunmäki L, Miller P. Regulatory hybrids: Partnerships, budgeting and modernising government. Manag Account Res. 2011;22(4):220–41.