Physical proximity as pleasure or pain? A critical review of employee–customer proximity in sales and services settings
Tóm tắt
This paper presents a critical review of published findings pertaining to the physical proximity between employees and customers in various sales and service settings. Following an overview of this stream of research, reflections are then offered on how the concepts of personal space and physical proximity may have changed in terms of their financial and well-being-related effects as a function of the COVID-19 pandemic. Due to the risk of infection in interpersonal interactions, and despite the affiliative aspects associated with physical proximity, recent recipes for success—as advocated by academics—may eventually have a negative impact on multiple crucial metrics in a post-pandemic world, such that employees’ physical proximity to customers may soon come with a wide array of costly consequences. The article concludes with a set of future research directions.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Albert, S., & Dabbs, J. M., Jr. (1970). Physical distance and persuasion. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 15(3), 265–270
Andersson, P., E. Wästlund, and P. Kristensson. 2016. The effect of gaze on consumers’ encounter evaluation. International Journal of Retail & Distribution Management 44(4): 372–396.
Argo, J.J., D.W. Dahl, and R.V. Manchanda. 2005. The influence of a mere social presence in a retail context. Journal of Consumer Research 32(2): 207–212.
Avdiu, B., and G. Nayyar. 2020. When face-to-face interactions become an occupational hazard: Jobs in the time of COVID-19. Economics Letters 197: 109648.
Back, M.D., S.C. Schmukle, and B. Egloff. 2008. Becoming friends by chance. Psychological Science 19(5): 439–440.
Belk, R.W. 1988. Possessions and the extended self. Journal of Consumer Research 15(2): 139–168.
Berger, J., and C. Heath. 2007. Where consumers diverge from others: Identity signaling and product domains. Journal of Consumer Research 34(2): 121–134.
Blanchard, S.J., T.L. Dyachenko, and K.L. Kettle. 2020. Locational choices: Modeling consumer preferences for proximity to others in reserved seating venues. Journal of Marketing Research 57(5): 878–899.
Blut, M., and G.R. Iyer. 2020. Consequences of perceived crowding: A meta-analytical perspective. Journal of Retailing 96(3): 362–382.
Brehm, J.W. 1966. A theory of psychological reactance. Academic Press.
Brehm, S.S., and J.W. Brehm. 2013. Psychological reactance: A theory of freedom and control. Academic Press.
Brown, S.P., and R.A. Peterson. 1994. The effect of effort on sales performance and job satisfaction. Journal of Marketing 58(2): 70–80.
Chi, C.G., and D. Gursoy. 2009. Employee satisfaction, customer satisfaction, and financial performance: An empirical examination. International Journal of Hospitality Management 28(2): 245–253.
Clee, M.A., and R.A. Wicklund. 1980. Consumer behavior and psychological reactance. Journal of Consumer Research 6(4): 389–405.
Eguren, J., L. Antúnez, T. Otterbring, M.R. Curutchet, and G. Ares. 2021. Health gains through loss frames: Testing the effectiveness of message framing on citizens’ use of nutritional warnings. Appetite 166: 105469.
Ernest, R.C., and R.E. Cooper. 1974. “Hey mister, do you have any change?”: Two real world studies of proxemic effects on compliance with a mundane request. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 1(1): 58–59.
Esmark, C.L., and S.M. Noble. 2018. Retail space invaders: When employees’ invasion of customer space increases purchase intentions. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science 46(3): 477–496.
Esmark Jones, C.L., J.L. Stevens, S.M. Noble, and M.J. Breazeale. 2020. Panic attack: How illegitimate invasions of privacy cause consumer anxiety and dissatisfaction. Journal of Public Policy & Marketing 39(3): 334–352.
Fay, A.J., and J.K. Maner. 2012. Warmth, spatial proximity, and social attachment: The embodied perception of a social metaphor. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 48(6): 1369–1372.
Gidlöf, K., E.S. Lahm, A. Wallin, and T. Otterbring. 2021. Eco depletion: The impact of hunger on prosociality by means of environmentally friendly attitudes and behavior. Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services 62: 102654.
Gillani, A., S. Kutaula, L.C. Leonidou, and P. Christodoulides. 2021. The impact of proximity on consumer fair trade engagement and purchasing behavior: The moderating role of empathic concern and hypocrisy. Journal of Business Ethics 169(3): 557–577.
Gneezy, A. 2017. Field experimentation in marketing research. Journal of Marketing Research 54(1): 140–143.
Gómez-Corona, C., V.R. Rakotosamimanana, M.P. Sáenz-Navajas, H. Rodrigues, E. Franco-Luesma, E. Saldaña, and D. Valentin. 2021. To fear the unknown: Covid-19 confinement, fear, and food choice. Food Quality and Preference 92: 104251.
Hall, E.T. 1966. The hidden dimension. New York, NY: Doubleday.
IJzerman, H., and G.R. Semin. 2009. The thermometer of social relations: Mapping social proximity on temperature. Psychological Science 20(10): 1214–1220.
IJzerman, H., and G.R. Semin. 2010. Temperature perceptions as a ground for social proximity. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 46(6): 867–873.
Jacob, C., and N. Guéguen. 2012. The effect of physical distance between patrons and servers on tipping. Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Research 36(1): 25–31.
Karjaluoto, H., M. Mattila, and T. Pento. 2002. Electronic banking in Finland: Consumer beliefs and reactions to a new delivery channel. Journal of Financial Services Marketing 6(4): 346–361.
Kleijnen, M., M. Wetzels, and K. De Ruyter. 2004. Consumer acceptance of wireless finance. Journal of Financial Services Marketing 8(3): 206–217.
Levav, J., and R. Zhu. 2009. Seeking freedom through variety. Journal of Consumer Research 36(4): 600–610.
Li, J.Q., P. Rusmevichientong, D. Simester, J.N. Tsitsiklis, and S.I. Zoumpoulis. 2015. The value of field experiments. Management Science 61(7): 1722–1740.
Luangrath, A.W., J. Peck, and A. Gustafsson. 2020. Should I touch the customer? Rethinking interpersonal touch effects from the perspective of the touch initiator. Journal of Consumer Research 47(4): 588–607.
Luck, M., and M. Benkenstein. 2015. Consumers between supermarket shelves: The influence of inter-personal distance on consumer behavior. Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services 26: 104–114.
Machín, L., M.R. Curutchet, V. Gugliucci, A. Vitola, T. Otterbring, M. de Alcantara, and G. Ares. 2020. The habitual nature of food purchases at the supermarket: Implications for policy making. Appetite 155: 104844.
McElroy, J.C., P.C. Morrow, and S. Eroglu. 1990. The atmospherics of personal selling. Journal of Personal Selling & Sales Management 10(4): 31–41.
Mehta, R. 2013. Understanding perceived retail crowding: A critical review and research agenda. Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services 20(6): 642–649.
Mencl, J., and D.R. May. 2009. The effects of proximity and empathy on ethical decision-making: An exploratory investigation. Journal of Business Ethics 85(2): 201–226.
Mongey, S., L. Pilossoph, and A. Weinberg. 2021. Which workers bear the burden of social distancing? The Journal of Economic Inequality 19: 1–18.
Nowak, B., P. Brzóska, J. Piotrowski, C. Sedikides, M. Żemojtel-Piotrowska, and P.K. Jonason. 2020. Adaptive and maladaptive behavior during the COVID-19 pandemic: The roles of dark triad traits, collective narcissism, and health beliefs. Personality and Individual Differences 167: 110232.
Otterbring, T. 2016. Touch forbidden, consumption allowed: Counter-intuitive effects of touch restrictions on customers’ purchase behavior. Food Quality and Preference 50: 1–6.
Otterbring, T. 2017. Smile for a while: The effect of employee-displayed smiling on customer affect and satisfaction. Journal of Service Management 28(2): 284–304.
Otterbring, T. 2021a. Evolutionary psychology in marketing: Deep, debated, but fancier with fieldwork. Psychology & Marketing 38(2): 229–238.
Otterbring, T. 2021b. Peer presence promotes popular choices: A “Spicy” field study on social influence and brand choice. Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services 61: 102594.
Otterbring, T., Bhatnagar, R. (2021). Touch, threats, and transactions: Pandemic influences on consumer responses and the mediating role of touch likelihood when shopping for fruits and vegetables. Food Quality and Preference, 104461
Otterbring, T., and C. Lu. 2018. Clothes, condoms, and customer satisfaction: The effect of employee mere presence on customer satisfaction depends on the shopping situation. Psychology & Marketing 35(6): 454–462.
Otterbring, T., and K. Rolschau. 2021. Beauty is in the eye of the beer holder but rarely because of the beer. Personality and Individual Differences 179: 110921.
Otterbring, T., J. Pareigis, E. Wästlund, A. Makrygiannis, and A. Lindström. 2018a. The relationship between office type and job satisfaction: Testing a multiple mediation model through ease of interaction and well-being. Scandinavian Journal of Work, Environment & Health 44(3): 330–334.
Otterbring, T., C. Ringler, N.J. Sirianni, and A. Gustafsson. 2018b. The Abercrombie & Fitch effect: The impact of physical dominance on male customers’ status-signaling consumption. Journal of Marketing Research 55(1): 69–79.
Otterbring, T., Danielsson, C. B., Pareigis, J. 2020a. Office types and workers' cognitive vs affective evaluations from a noise perspective. Journal of Managerial Psychology 36(4): 415–431.
Otterbring, T., J. Sundie, Y.J. Li, and S. Hill. 2020b. Evolutionary psychological consumer research: Bold, bright, but better with behavior. Journal of Business Research 120: 473–484.
Otterbring, T., R. Bhatnagar, P. Samuelsson, and S. Borau. 2021a. Positive gender congruency effects on shopper responses: Field evidence from a gender egalitarian culture. Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services 63: 102738.
Otterbring, T., A. Festila, and M. Folwarczny. 2021b. Replication and extension of framing effects to compliance with health behaviors during pandemics. Safety Science 134: 105065.
Otterbring, T., A. Festila, and M. Folwarczny. 2021c. Self-isolation for the self-centered: Negative framing increases narcissists’ willingness to self-isolate during COVID-19 through higher response efficacy. Personality and Individual Differences 174: 110688.
Otterbring, T., F. Wu, and P. Kristensson. 2021d. Too close for comfort? The impact of salesperson-customer proximity on consumers’ purchase behavior. Psychology & Marketing 38(9): 1576–1590.
Otterbring, T., Festila, A., & Folwarczny, M. (2021). Selfless or Selfish? The Impact of Message Framing and Egoistic Motivation on Narcissists’ Compliance with Preventive Health Behaviors during COVID-19. Current Research in Ecological and Social Psychology, 100023
Ozdemir, A. 2008. Shopping malls: Measuring interpersonal distance under changing conditions and across cultures. Field Methods 20(3): 226–248.
Patterson, M.L., and L.B. Sechrest. 1970. Interpersonal distance and impression formation. Journal of Personality 38(2): 161–166.
Patterson, M.L., C.E. Kelly, B.A. Kondracki, and L.J. Wulf. 1979. Effects of seating arrangement on small-group behavior. Social Psychology Quarterly 42: 180–185.
Pfattheicher, S., L. Nockur, R. Böhm, C. Sassenrath, and M.B. Petersen. 2020. The emotional path to action: Empathy promotes physical distancing during the COVID-19 pandemic. Psychological Science 31: 1363.
Pham, M.T. 2013. The seven sins of consumer psychology. Journal of Consumer Psychology 23(4): 411–423.
Preciado, P., T. Snijders, W.J. Burk, H. Stattin, and M. Kerr. 2011. Does proximity matter? Distance dependence of adolescent friendships. Social Networks 34(1): 18–31.
Priest, R.F., and J. Sawyer. 1967. Proximity and peership: Bases of balance in interpersonal attraction. American Journal of Sociology 72(6): 633–649.
Rodrigues, H., D. Valentin, E. Franco-Luesma, V.R. Rakotosamimanana, C. Gomez-Corona, E. Saldana-Villa, and M.P. Sáenz-Navajas. 2021. How has COVID-19, lockdown and social distancing changed alcohol drinking patterns? A cross-cultural perspective between britons and spaniards. Food Quality and Preference 95: 104344.
Schlesinger, L.A., and J. Zornitsky. 1991. Job satisfaction, service capability, and customer satisfaction: An examination of linkages and management implications. Human Resource Planning 14(2): 141–149.
Simmons, J.P., L.D. Nelson, and U. Simonsohn. 2018. False-positive citations. Perspectives on Psychological Science 13(2): 255–259.
Smith, T.S., and B.D. Seymour. 2014. Bulletproof salesman: A lively guide to enhance your sales techniques. Toronto, ON: Productive Publications.
Söderlund, M. 2016. Employee mere presence and its impact on customer satisfaction. Psychology & Marketing 33(6): 449–464.
Söderlund, M., and S. Rosengren. 2008. Revisiting the smiling service worker and customer satisfaction. International Journal of Service Industry Management 19(5): 552–574.
Sorokowska, A., P. Sorokowski, P. Hilpert, K. Cantarero, T. Frackowiak, K. Ahmadi, A.M. Alghraibeh, R. Aryeetey, A. Bertoni, K. Bettache, and S. Blumen. 2017. Preferred interpersonal distances: A global comparison. Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology 48(4): 577–592.
Suoranta, M., and M. Mattila. 2004. Mobile banking and consumer behaviour: New insights into the diffusion pattern. Journal of Financial Services Marketing 8(4): 354–366.
Sussman, N.M., and H.M. Rosenfeld. 1982. Influence of culture, language, and sex on conversational distance. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 42(1): 66–74.
Van Bavel, J.J., P. Mende-Siedlecki, W.J. Brady, and D.A. Reinero. 2016. Contextual sensitivity in scientific reproducibility. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 113(23): 6454–6459.
Wang, C., R. Pan, X. Wan, Y. Tan, L. Xu, R.S. McIntyre, F.N. Choo, B. Tran, R. Ho, V.K. Sharma, and C. Ho. 2020. A longitudinal study on the mental health of general population during the COVID-19 epidemic in China. Brain, Behavior, and Immunity 87: 40–48.
Webb, A., and J. Peck. 2015. Individual differences in interpersonal touch: On the development, validation, and use of the “comfort with interpersonal touch” (CIT) scale. Journal of Consumer Psychology 25(1): 60–77.
Xu, J., H. Shen, and R.S. Wyer. 2012. Does the distance between us matter? Influences of physical proximity to others on consumer choice. Journal of Consumer Psychology 22(3): 418–423.
Jia, Y., Y. Huang, R.S. Wyer Jr., and H. Shen. 2017. Physical proximity increases persuasive effectiveness through visual imagery. Journal of Consumer Psychology 27(4): 435–447.
Zitek, E.M., and R.J. Schlund. 2020. Psychological entitlement predicts noncompliance with the health guidelines of the COVID-19 pandemic. Personality and Individual Differences 171: 110491.