Optimal investments in volatility
Tóm tắt
Volatility has evolved as an attractive new asset class of its own. The most common instruments for trading volatility are variance swaps. Mean returns of DAX and ESX variance swaps over the time period of 1995 to 2004 are strongly negative, and only part of the negative premium can be explained by the negative correlation of variance swap returns with stock market indices. We analyze the implications of this observation for optimal portfolio composition. Mean-variance efficient portfolios are characterized by sizable short positions in variance swaps. Typically, the stock index is also sold short to achieve a better portfolio diversification. To capture heterogeneous preferences for higher moments, we use a variant of the polynomial goal programming method. We assume that investors strive for a high Sharpe ratio, high skewness, and low kurtosis. Our analysis reveals that it is often not possible to achieve a balanced tradeoff between Sharpe ratio and skewness. Investors are advised to hold the extreme portfolios (Sharpe ratio driven, skewness driven, or kurtosis driven) and avoid the middle ground. This “all-or-nothing” characteristic is reflected in jumps of asset weights when certain thresholds of preference parameters are crossed. These empirical findings can explain why many investors are so reluctant to implement option-based short-selling strategies.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Bakshi, G., Kapadia, N.: Volatility risk premiums embedded in individual equity options: Some new insights. J. Derivativ. 11(1), 45–55 (2003)
Bessler, W., Drobetz, W., Pensa, P.: Do managers adjust the capital structure to market value changes? Evidence from Europe. Zeitschrift für Betriebswirtschaft 78 (2008, forthcoming)
Black, F.: The pricing of commodity contracts. J. Financ. Econ. 3, 167–179 (1976)
Bliss, R., Panigirtzoglou, N.: Option-implied risk aversion estimates. J. Finance 59, 407–446 (2004)
Bollen, N., Whaley, R.: Does net buying pressure affect the shape of implied volatility functions? J. Finance 59, 711–754 (2004)
Bollerslev, T., Gibson, M., Zhou, H.: Dynamic estimation of volatility risk premia and investor risk aversion from option-implied and realized volatilities. Working Paper (2005)
Bondarenko, O.: Market price of variance risk and performance of hedge funds. Working paper, University of Illinois (2004)
Canela, M., Colla, E.: Portfolio selection with skewness in emerging markets. Technical report IESE Business School Barcelona (2004)
Carr, P., Wu, L.: Variance risk premia. Working paper, Courant Institute and Baruch College, July 2003 (2005)
Chernov, M., Ghysels, E.: A study towards a unified approach to the joint estimation of objective and risk neutral measures for the purpose of options valuation. J. Financ. Econ. 56, 407–458 (2000)
Chunhachinda, P., Dandapani, K., Hamid, S., Prakash, A.: Portfolio selection and skewness: Evidence from international stock markets. J. Bank. Finance 21(2), 143–167 (1997)
Coval, J., Shumway, T.: Expected option returns. J. Finance 56, 983–1009 (2001)
Davies, R., Kat, H., Lu, S.: Fund of Hedge funds portfolio selection: a multiple-objective approach. Working paper ISMA Centre, University of Reading (2004)
Demeterfi, K., Derman, E., Kamal, M., Zou, J.: A guide to volatility and variance swaps. J. Deriv. 6(4), 9–35 (1999)
Dittmar, R.: Nonlinear pricing kernels, kurtosis preference, and evidence from the cross section of equity returns. J. Finance 57, 369–403 (2002)
Doran, J., Ronn, E.: The bias in black-scholes/black implied volatility. Working Paper Florida State University (2004a)
Doran, J., Ronn, E.: On the market price of volatility risk. Working paper Florida State University (2004b)
Driessen, J., Maenhout, P.: The world price of jump and volatility risk. Working Paper University of Amsterdam (2003)
Eraker, B., Johannes, M., Polson, N.: The impact of jumps in volatility and returns. J. Finance 58, 1269–1300 (2003)
Figlewski, S., Wang, X.: Is the ‘Leverage Effect’ a leverage effect? Working Paper Stern School of Business, New York (2000)
Füss, R., Kaiser, D.: The tactical and strategic value of hedge fund strategies: A cointegration approach. Financ. Mark. Portfolio Manag. 21(4), 425–444 (2007)
Hafner, R.: Stochastic Implied Volatility. Lecture Notes in Economics and Mathematical Systems, vol. 545, Springer, Berlin (2004)
Hafner, R., Wallmeier, M.: The dynamics of Dax implied volatilities. Int. Q. J. Finance 1, 1–27 (2001)
Hafner, R., Wallmeier, M.: Volatility as an asset class: European evidence. Eur. J. Finance 13(7), 621–644 (2007)
Harvey, C., Liechty, J., Liechty, M., Müller, P.: Portfolio selection with higher moments. Working Paper Duke University (2004)
Illmer, S., Marty, W.: Return decomposition of absolute-performance multi-asset class portfolios. Financ. Mark. Portfolio Manag. 21(1), 121–134 (2007)
Jackwerth, J., Rubinstein, M.: Recovering probability distributions from option prices. J. Finance 51, 1611–1631 (1996)
Jiang, G., Tian, Y.: The model-free implied volatility and its information content. Rev. Financ. Studies 18, 1305–1342 (2005)
Lai, T.-Y.: Portfolio selection with skewness: A multiple-objective approach. Rev. Q. Finance Account. 1(3), 293–305 (1991)
Le Moigne, C., Savaria, P.: Relative importance of hedge fund characteristics. Financ. Mark. Portfolio Manag. 20(4), 419–441 (2006)
Lowenstein, R.: When Genius Failed. Random House, New York (2000)
Moise, C.: Is market volatility priced? Working Paper University of Chicago (2004)
Neuberger, A.: The log contract. J. Portfolio Manag. 20(Winter), 74–80 (1994)
Pan, J.: The jump-risk premia implicit in option prices: Evidence from an integrated time-series study. J. Financ. Econ. 63, 3–50 (2002)
Prakash, A., Chang, C.-H., Pactwa, T.: Selecting a portfolio with skewness: Recent evidence from US, european, and Latin American equity markets. J. Bank. Finance 27(7), 1375–1390 (2003)
Santa-Clara, P., Yan, S.: Jump and volatility risk and risk premia: a new model and lessons from S+P 500 options. NBER Working Paper 10912 (2004)
Sun, Q., Yuxing, Y.: Skewness persistence with optimal portfolio selection. J. Bank. Finance 27(6), 1111–1121 (2003)
Welsh, I.: Capital structure and stock returns. J. Political Econ. 112, 106–132 (2004)
Wilmott, P.: Derivatives: the theory and practice of financial engineering. New York et al. (1998)