Lewis and Quine in context

Springer Science and Business Media LLC - Tập 2 Số 2
Sander Verhaegh1
1TiLPS, Department of Philosophy, Tilburg University, Tilburg, Warandelaan 2, 5032AB, The Netherlands

Tóm tắt

AbstractRobert Sinclair’s Quine, Conceptual Pragmatism, and the Analytic-Synthetic Distinction persuasively argues that Quine’s epistemology was deeply influenced by C. I. Lewis’s pragmatism. Sinclair’s account raises the question why Quine himself frequently downplayed Lewis’s influence. Looking back, Quine has always said that Rudolf Carnap was his “greatest teacher” and that his 1933 meeting with the German philosopher was his “first experience of sustained intellectual engagement with anyone of an older generation” (1970, 41; 1985, 97-8, my emphasis). Quine’s autobiographies contain only a handful of biographical references to Lewis and he regularly soft-pedaled the latter’s influence in private correspondence. In this note, I discuss some archival evidence that helps us better understand Quine’s reluctance to acknowledge Lewis’s influence. I contextualize the relation between Lewis and Quine and argue that the latter viewed his teacher as a retrograde force in modern epistemology, impeding the more rigorous approach that Carnap had been developing in Europe. Next, I briefly discuss Lewis’s contribution to the development of scientific philosophy in the United States and argue that Quine underestimated his teacher’s role in this process. In doing so, I argue that Quine’s zealous commitment to Carnap’s approach negatively affected his assessment of Lewis’s influence, thereby supplementing Sinclair’s praiseworthy reconstruction with an explanation of why Quine himself underestimated Lewis’s role.

Từ khóa


Tài liệu tham khảo

Carnap, R. (1928). Der Logische Aufbau der Welt. Weltkreis-Verlag.

Carnap, R. (1934). Logische Syntax der Sprache. Springer.

Carnap, R. (1936). Testability and meaning. Philosophy of Science, 3(4), 419–471.

Carnap, R. (1937). Testability and meaning—Continued. Philosophy of Science, 4(1), 1–40.

Davidson, D. (2004). Problems of rationality. Clarendon Press.

Feigl, H. (1968). The Wiener Kreis in America. In: Feigl (1981). Inquiries and provocations: Selected writings, 1929–1974 (pp. 57-94). Reidel.

Floyd, J. (2021). Sheffer, Lewis, and the ‘Logocentric predicament’. In Q. Kammer, J. Narboux and H. Wagner. C. I. Lewis: The a priori and the given (pp. 27-103). Routledge.

Langer, S. K. (1964). Henry M. Sheffer 1883–1964. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, 25(2), 305–307.

Lewis, C. I. (1918). A survey of symbolic logic. University of California Press.

Lewis, C. I. (1925). Review of scientific thought by C. D. Broad. The Philosophical Review, 34(4), 406-11.

Lewis, C. I. (1929). Mind and the World-Order. Charles Scribner’s Sons.

Lewis, C. I. (1934). Experience and meaning. The Philosophical Review, 43(2), 125–146.

Lewis, C. I. (1946). An analysis of knowledge and valuation. Open Court.

Lewis, C. I., & Langford, C. H. (1932). Symbolic logic. The Century Co.

Murphey, M. G. (2005). C. I. Lewis: The last great pragmatist. State University of New York Press.

Palmer, G. H. and Perry, R. B. (1930). Philosophy, 1870-1929. In S. E. Morison (ed.). The development of Harvard University since the inauguration of President Eliot, 1869-1929 (pp. 3-32). Harvard University Press.

Quine, W. V. (1933). A theorem in the calculus of classes. Journal of the London Mathematical Society, 8(30), 89–95.

Quine, W. V. (1943). The United States and the revival of logic. In W. Carnielli, F. Janssen-Lauret, and W. Pickering (2020, eds.). The significance of the new logic (pp. 145-57). Cambridge University Press.

Quine, W. V. (1951). Two dogmas of empiricism. Philosophical Review, 60(1), 20–43.

Quine, W. V. (1970). Homage to Rudolf Carnap. In Quine (1976). The ways of paradox and other essays (pp. 40-3). Revised Edition. Harvard University Press.

Quine, W. V. (1985). The time of my life: An autobiography. MIT Press.

Quine, W. V. (1986). Autobiography of W. V. Quine. In Hahn & Schilpp (eds). The philosophy of W. V. Quine. Library of living philosophers (pp. 1-46). Open Court.

Quine, W. V. (2001). Confessions of a confirmed extensionalist. In D. Føllesdal & D. B. Quine (Eds.), Confessions of a confirmed extensionalist and other essays (pp. 498–506). Harvard University Press.

Sellars, R. W. (1927). Current realism in Great Britain and United States. The Monist, 37(4), 503–520.

Sinclair, R. (2022). Quine, conceptual pragmatism, and the analytic-synthetic distinction. Rowman & Littlefield.

Verhaegh, S. (2020a). The American reception of logical positivism: First encounters, 1929-1932. HOPOS: The Journal of the International Society for the History of Philosophy of Science, 10(1), 106–142.

Verhaegh, S. (2020b). Coming to America: Carnap, Reichenbach and the great intellectual migration. Part I: Rudolf Carnap. Journal for the History of Analytical Philosophy, 8(11), 1–23.

Verhaegh, S. (2023). Carnap and Quine: First encounters (1932-1936). In S. Morris (Ed.), The philosophical project of Carnap and Quine (pp. 11–31). Cambridge University Press.

White, M. (1999). A philosophers’ story. Pennsylvania State University Press.

Whitehead, A. N. and Russell, B. (1910-2). Principia Mathematica. Vols. I-III. Cambridge University Press.

Thông tin
Thông tin xuất bản

Springer Science and Business Media LLC

Tập 2 Số 2

Thông tin tác giả