Joint ownership by farmers and investors in the agri-food industry: an exploratory study of the limited cooperative association
Tóm tắt
Since the 1990s, producers of farm commodities have been attempting to enter value-added agri-food sectors by means of joint ownership of hybrid cooperatives. New generation cooperatives, characterized by substantial supply and equity requirements, inspired much farm producer optimism before revealing weaknesses and limitations in the early 2000s. In response, recent innovations in US cooperative state law introduced the limited cooperative association (LCA), a new legal entity allowing joint ownership by member patrons and member investors to facilitate large-scale equity acquisition. However, business registration data indicate few such organizations have been formed in the agri-food industry. The LCA is adopted by several small-scale operations in niche markets such as lamb, elderberry, and non-GMO seed, but there is not much interest among business organizations in the commodity sector. This paper raises possible explanations for the limited adoption of the LCA, including the competing objectives of farmers and investors, the ambiguous legal interpretation of investor objectives, the superiority of other legal structures, and the lack of strategic advantages. The conclusion facilitates an invitation to further study the challenging future of farmer cooperatives in the agri-food industry.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Baarda J (2006) Current issues in cooperative finance and governance. In: Cooperative programs, rural development. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Washington, D.C.
Benos T, Kalogeras N, Verhees FJ, Sergaki P, Pennings JM (2016) Cooperatives’ organizational restructuring, strategic attributes, and performance: the case of agribusiness cooperatives in Greece. Agribusiness 32(1):127–150
Beverland M (2007) Can cooperatives brand? Exploring the interplay between cooperative structure and sustained brand marketing success. Food Policy 32(4):480–495
Brown L (2006) Innovations in co-operative marketing and communications. Centre for the Study of Co-operatives, University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon
Brown RB, Merrett CD (2000) The limited liability company versus the new generation cooperative: alternative business forms for rural economic development. In: ) (ed) Illinois Institute for Rural Affairs, Rural Research Report 11. Illinois Institute for Rural Affairs, Macomb
Burress MJ, Cook ML, Klein PG (2008) The clustering of organizational innovation: developing governance models for vertical integration. Int Food Agribusiness Manage Rev 11(4):49–75
Chaddad FR, Cook ML (2004) Understanding New Cooperative Models: An Ownership-Control Rights Typology. Rev Agric Econ 26(3):348–360
Cook ML (1995) The future of US agricultural cooperatives: a neo-institutional approach. Am J Agric Econ 77(5):1153–1159
Cook ML, Iliopoulos C (1999) Beginning to inform the theory of the cooperative firm: emergence of the new generation cooperative. Finn J Bus Econ 4(99):525–535
Dean JB, Geu TE (2008) The uniform limited cooperative association act: an introduction. Drake J Agric Law 13:63–113
Dempsey JJ, Kumar AA, Loyd B, Merkel LS (2002) A value culture for agriculture: to become high-performing businesses, agricultural co-ops must move away from their traditional role as service providers. McKinsey Q(Summer):64–76. https://go.galegroup.com/ps/i.do?p=AONE&sw=w&u=googlescholar&v=2.1&it=r&id=GALE%7CA90192563&sid=classroomWidget&asid=00032fdb
Deng W, Hendrikse GW (2015) Managerial vision bias and cooperative governance. Eur Rev Agric Econ 42(5):797–828
Drnevich PL, Croson DC (2013) Information technology and business-level strategy: toward an integrated theoretical perspective. MIS Q 37(2):483–509
Eversull E (2008) Co-ops ring up additional $14 billion in sales via other ownership structures. Rural Coop 75(6):18–19
Ferrell SL (2002) New generation cooperatives and the capper-Volstead act: playing a new game by the old rules. Okla City UL Rev 27:737–771
Frederick DA (1998) The impact of LLCs on cooperatives: bane, boon, or non-event? J Coop 13:44–52
Geu TE, Dean JB (2009a) The new uniform limited cooperative association act: a capital idea for principled self-help value added firms, community-based economic development, and low-profit joint ventures. Real Property Trust Estate Law J 44(1):55–205
Geu TE, Dean JB (2009b) The uniform limited cooperative act: comparative leverage points and principles. Coop Account 62(1):3–12
Grashuis J (2017) Branding by farmer cooperatives: an empirical study of trademark ownership. J Coop Organ Manag 5(2):57–64
Grashuis J (2018) An exploratory study of cooperative survival: strategic adaptation to external developments. Sustainability 10(3):652
Grashuis J, Cook M (2018) An examination of new generation cooperatives in the upper midwest: successes, failures, and limitations. Ann Public Coop Econ 89(4):623-644
Grashuis J, Su Y (2018) A review of the empirical literature on farmer cooperatives: performance, ownership and governance, finance, and member attitude. Ann Public Coop Econ. https://doi.org/10.1111/apce.12205
Hanson M (2001) A new cooperative structure for the 21st century: the Wyoming processing cooperative law. Coop Account Fall 2001:3–9
Hardesty SD (2005) Cooperatives as marketers of branded products. J Food Distrib Res 36(1):237–242
Harris A, Stefanson B, Fulton M (1996) New generation cooperatives and cooperative theory. J Coop 11(6):15–28
Hendrikse GW, Veerman CP (2001) Marketing co-operatives: an incomplete contracting perspective. J Agric Econ 52(1):53–64
Höhler J, Kühl R (2017) Dimensions of member heterogeneity in cooperatives and their impact on organization - a literature review. In: Annals of public and cooperative economics. https://doi.org/10.1111/apce.12177
Hovelaque V, Duvaleix-Tréguer S, Cordier J (2009) Effects of constrained supply and price contracts on agricultural cooperatives. Eur J Oper Res 199(3):769–780
Kelley CR (2001) New generation farmer cooperatives: the problem of the just investing farmer. NDL Rev 77:185–246
Kenkel P, Park J (2007) Business models and producer-owned ventures: choices, challenges, and changes. J Agric Appl Econ 39(2):381–387
Kontogeorgos A (2012) Brands, quality badges and agricultural cooperatives: how can they co-exist? TQM J 24(1):72–82
Liang Q, Hendrikse GW (2013) Cooperative CEO identity and efficient governance: member or outside CEO? Agribusiness 29(1):23–38
Lushin L (2010) A Trojan horse in our midst: ten faults of the limited cooperative association act. Coop Grocer 151:28–29
McCorriston S (2002) Why should imperfect competition matter to agricultural economists? Eur Rev Agric Econ 29(3):349–371
Mérel PR, Saitone TL, Sexton RJ (2009) Cooperatives and quality-differentiated markets: strengths, weaknesses, and modeling approaches. J Rural Coop 37(2):201–224
Merlo C (2017) Crossing the merger finish line. In: Rural Cooperatives, September/October 2017. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Washington, D.C.
Pasour EC, Rucker RR (2005) Plowshares and pork barrels: the political economy of agriculture. The Independent Institute, Oakland
Patrie W (1998) Creating co-op fever: a rural developer’s guide to forming cooperatives. In: Rural Business-Cooperative Service, Service report 54. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Washington, D.C.
Porter PK, Scully GW (1987) Economic efficiency in cooperatives. J Law Econ 30(2):489–512
Reynolds B (2012) Joint ventures and subsidiaries of agricultural cooperatives. In: Rural Business and Cooperative Programs, research report 226. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Washington, D.C.
Saitone TL, Sexton RJ (2017) Concentration and consolidation in the U.S. food supply chain: the latest evidence and implications for consumers, farmers, and policymakers. Econ Rev 102:25–59 Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City
Senechal D (2007) Value-added business success factors—the role of investor attitudes and expectations. Ag Decision Maker 2007:5–6
Sexton RJ (1990) Imperfect competition in agricultural markets and the role of cooperatives: a spatial analysis. Am J Agric Econ 72(3):709–720
Sexton RJ (2013) Market power, misconceptions, and modern agricultural markets. Am J Agric Econ 95(2):209–219
Soboh RAME, Lansink AO, Giesen G, van Dijk G (2009) Performance Measurement of the Agricultural Marketing Cooperatives: The Gap between Theory and Practice. Rev Agric Econ 31(3):446–469
Spear R (2000) The co-operative advantage. Ann Public Coop Econ 71(4):507–523