Impact of trade liberalisation on formal–informal interlinkages in India: does sectoral labour mobility matter?
Tóm tắt
Existing study argues that labour market flexibility accompanied by trade liberalisation helped in building complementary relationship between formal and informal sectors in India. However, no direct relation is established between the labour market flexibility and trade liberalisation with respect to inter- and intra-sectoral movement of labour. The present study enquires whether the extent of labour mobility between and within formal–informal sectors affects the formal–informal growth linkages due to the tariff cut on traded goods, as a part of trade liberalisation in India. The findings based on static CGE analysis indicate that in absence of labour market segmentation (i.e. in absence of both wage rigidity and skill specificity) with full mobility of labour, formal sector growth is higher vis-à-vis the growth of those activities under segmented labour market with full mobility of labour. Amongst growing informal sector activities, output growth is lower in absence of segmented labour market with full mobility of labour. Finally, restricted labour mobility leads to largest expansion of formal activities, but further exacerbates the growth of informal activities. The study reveals that improvement in functional income distribution is mixed across households, depending on the degree of labour mobility, which implies labour market adjustment is costly due to structural reforms, that pitches for government intervention.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Agenor PR, Aizenman J (1994) Macroeconomic adjustment with segmented labor markets. NBER Working Paper No. 4769
Ahluwalia MS (2002) Economic reforms in India since 1991: has gradualism worked? J Econ Perspect 16:67–88
Banga R, Das A (2012a) Twenty years of india’s liberalization: experiences and lessons. UNCTAD Publication, Geneva
Banga R, Das A (2012b) Role of trade policies in growth of Indian manufacturing sector (chapter 2). In: Banga R, Das A (eds) Twenty years of india’s liberalization: experiences and lessons. UNCTAD Publication, Geneva
Boeters, S and Savard L (2011) The labour market in CGE models. CPB Discussion Paper No. 201
Chakrabarti S (2016) Inclusive growth and social change: formal–informal-agrarian relations in India. Oxford University Press, New Delhi
Chaudhuri S, Banerjee D (2007) Economic liberalisation, capital mobility and informal wage in a small open economy: a theoretical analysis. Econ Model 24:924–940
Corneliβen T, Hubler O (2005) Downward wage rigidity and labour mobility. IZA Discussion Paper No. 1523
Decaluwé B, Lemelin A, Maisonnave H, Robichaud V (2009) “The PEP standard computable general equilibrium model single-country, static version. PEP-1-1”. Poverty and Economic Policy (PEP) Research Network, Second Revised Edition, October 2009
Dehejia R, Panagariya A (2014) Trade liberalization in manufacturing and accelerated growth in Services in India. NBER Working Paper No. 19923
Goldar B, Pradhan BK, Sharma AK (2013) Elasticity of Substitution between capital and labour inputs in manufacturing industries of the Indian economy. J Ind Stat 2:169–194
Harrison AE, Martin LA, Nataraj S (2011) Learning versus stealing: how important are market-share reallocations to India’s productivity growth. NBER WorkingPaper 16733
ILO (2018) Indian Wage Report: Wage policies for decent work and inclusive growth. ILO, Geneva
India Labour and Employment Report (2014) India labour and employment report 2014—workers in the era of globalization. Academic Foundation and Institute for Human Development, New Delhi
Kar S, Marjit S (2001) Informal sector in general equilibrium: welfare effects of trade policy reforms. Int Rev Econ Finance 10:289–300
Kotwal A, Ramaswami B, Wadhwa W (2011) Economic liberalization and Indian economic growth: what’s the evidence? J Econ Lit 11:1152–1199
Krishna P, Mitra D (1998) Trade liberalization, market discipline and productivity growth: new evidence from India. J Dev Econ 56:447–462
Marjit S (2003) Economic reform and informal wage—a general equilibrium analysis. J Dev Econ 71:371–378
Marjit S, Kar S (2009) A contemporary perspective on the informal labour Market: theory, policy and the Indian experience. Economic and Political Weekly XLIV, No. 14
Marjit S, Kar S (2011a) The outsiders: economic reform and informal labour in a developing economy, 1st edn. Oxford University Press, New Delhi
Marjit S, Kar S (2011b) The extended heckscher-ohlin framework with the informal sector’ (chapter 7). In: Marjit S, Kar S (eds) The outsiders economic reform and informal labour in a developing economy, 1st edn. Oxford University Press, New Delhi
Marjit S, Maiti DS (2005) Globalization, reform and the informal sector. WIDER Working Paper Series 012, World Institute for Development Economic Research (UNU-WIDER)
Marjit S, Kar S, Acharyya R (2007) Agricultural prospects and informal wage in general equilibrium. Econ Model 24:380–385
Marjit S, Kar S, Beladi H (2007) Trade reform and informal wages. Rev Dev Econ 11:313–320
Mazumder D, Sarkar S (2008) Globalization, Labour markets and inequality in India. International Development Research Centre, Routledge, London/New York
Meagher K (2013) Unlocking the informal economy: a literature review on linkages between formal and informal economies in developing countries. WIEGO Working Paper No. 27
Murgai R, Ravallion M (2005) Employment guarantee in rural India: what would it cost and how much would it reduce poverty? Econ Political Weekly 40:3450–3455
Nataraj S (2011) The impact of trade liberalization on productivity: evidence from India’s formal and informal manufacturing sectors. J Int Econ 85:292–301
Nayyar G (2013) Inside the Black box of Services: evidence from India. Camb J Econ 37:143–170
NCEUS (2007) Report on conditions of work and promotion of livelihoods in the unorganized sector. National Commission for Enterprises in Unorganized Sector, Government of India
NCEUS (2009) The Challenge of Employment in India:An Informal Economy Perspective. Volume-I, Main Report, National Commission for Enterprises in Unorganized Sector, Government of India
NSSO (2003) Unorganised Service Sector in India 20011–02: salient features, National Sample Survey Organisation Report No. 482(57/2.345/1), Government of India
NSSO (2007) Operational characteristics of unorganised manufacturing enterprises in India, National Sample Survey Organisation Report No. 524 (62/2.2/1), Government of India
NSSO (2009): Service sector in India, 2006–07: economic characteristics of enterprises, National Sample Survey Organisation Report No. 529 (63/2.345/2), Government of India
Pradhan BK, Sahoo A (2008) The impact of trade liberalization on household welfare and poverty in India. In: Cockburn J, Decaluwé B, Robichaud V, editors. Trade liberalization and poverty: a CGE analysis of the 1990s experience in Africa and Asia. Poverty and Economic Policy (PEP) Research Network
Pushpangadan K, Babu MS, Balakrishnan P (2000) Trade liberalisation and productivity growth in manufacturing. Econ Political Weekly 35:41
Rada C, von Arnim R (2014) India’s structural transformation and role in the world economy. J Policy Model 36:1–23
Ramaswamy KV (1999) The search for flexibility in Indian manufacturing: new evidence on outsourcing activities. Econ Political Weekly 34:363–368
Robinson S (1989) Multi Sectoral Model. In: Chennery H, Srinivasan TN editors. Handbook of development economics, vol 2. North-Holand, pp 885–947
Sen K, Saha B, Maiti D (2010) Trade openness, labour institutions and flexibilisation: theory and evidence from India, Brooks World Poverty Institute Working Paper No.123, The University of Manchester, UK
Siggel E (2010) The Indian informal sector: the impact of globalization and reform. Int Labour Rev 149:93–105
Sundaram A, Ahsan RN, Mitra D (2012) Complementarity between Formal and Informal Manufacturing in India: the role of policies and institutions. SIPA Working Paper No. 2012-1
Taiwo O (2013) Employment choice and mobility in multi-sector labour markets: theoretical model and evidence from Ghana. Int Labour Rev 152:469–492
Topalova P, Khandelwal A (2011) Trade liberalization and firm productivity. Rev Econ Stat 93:995–1003
Wingender AM (2015) Skill complementarity and the dual economy. Eur Econ Rev 74:269–284
Wong S (2012) Short-term macroeconomic and poverty impacts of the global economic crisis on the ecuadorian economy. http://ecomod.net/system/files/Wong_EcoMod_March2012.pdf. Accessed 21st February 2017