Glass circulation in late Iron Age Southeast Asia: New Compositional and Isotopic Data of Beads found at Non Ban Jak in Northeast Thailand

Laure Dussubieux1, Charles F. W. Higham2, T. O. Pryce3
1Field Museum, Chicago, USA
2Archaeology Programme, University of Otago, Dunedin, New Zealand
3Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, LAPA-IRAMAT, NIMBE, CEA, CNRS, Université Paris-Saclay, CEA Saclay, Gif-sur-Yvette, France

Tóm tắt

With this study we expand the glass data available for northeast Thailand through the analysis of elemental and isotopic (Sr-Nd-Pb) compositions of glass beads from Non Ban Jak. This site, located in Nakhon Ratchasima Province, Northeast Thailand, yielded more than 3000 glass artifacts dating from the mid-late Iron Age (CE 200-850). A representative selection of sixty-five glass beads was analyzed for elemental compositions, and Sr-Nd-Pb isotopic data were obtained for 10 of these beads. Most of the beads belong to the mineral soda – high alumina (m-Na-Al) 1 glass group, which originated from either Sri Lanka or southern India. Three color-specific sub-groups were identified: m-Na-Al 1.1, m-Na-Al 1.2 and m-Na-Al 1.3. Two glass samples with an orange color have a mixed-alkali composition also associated with India. Two glass beads have a potash composition usually associated with the Early Iron Age period and the South China Sea exchange network. Translucent dark blue beads have a soda-lime composition suggesting import from the west (the Mediterranean area or the Middle East). Results for Non Ban Jak show strong similarities with results from the neighboring sites of Ban Non Wat and Noen-U Loke and seem to share a strong connection during the Late Iron Age with South India/Sri Lanka.

Từ khóa


Tài liệu tham khảo

Ahmed AA, Ashour GM (1981) Effect of heat treatment on the crystallisation of cuprous oxide in glass. Glass Technol 22(1):24–33 Ahmed AA, Ashour GM (1977) Effect of melting conditions on the crystallization of copper and cuprous oxide in glass. Proc XIth Int Congress Glass, Prague 2:177–187 Barfod GH, Freestone IC, Lesher CE, Lichtenberger A, Raja R (2020) ‘Alexandrian’ glass confirmed by hafnium isotopes. Scientific Rep 10, Article number: 11322 Bellina B, Favereau A, Dussubieux L (2019) Southeast Asian early Maritime Silk Road trading polities’ hinterland and the sea-nomads of the Isthmus of Kra. J Anthropolog Archaeolog 54:102–120 Brems D, Ganio M, Degryse P (2014) The Sr-Nd isotopic fingerprint of sand raw materials. In: Degryse P (ed) Glass Making in the Greco-Roman World - Results of the ARCHGLASS Project, Leuven University Press, pp 51–68 Brill RH (2003) The glassmakers of Firozabad and the glassmakers of Kapadwanj: Two pilot video projects. Annales du 15e Congrès de l’Association Internationale pour l’Histoire du Verre, Corning New York, 2001, Nottingham, UK: AIHV. 267–268 Brill RH (1987) Chemical analyses of some early Indian glasses. In: Bhardwaj HC (ed) Archaeometry of Glass - Proceedings of the Archaeometry Session of the XIV International Congress on Glass – 1986 (part I), New Delhi. Calcutta, India: Indian Ceramic Society. 1–25 Brill RH, Cahill ND (1988) A red opaque glass from Sardis and some thoughts on red opaque in general. J Glass Studies 30:16–27 Carter AK (2015) Beads, exchange networks and emerging complexity: a case study from Cambodia and Thailand (500 BCE-CE 500). Cambridge J Archaeol 25(4):733–757 Carter AK (2013) Trade, exchange, and socio-political development in Iron Age (500 BCE - AD 500) mainland Southeast Asia: An examination of stone and glass beads from Cambodia and Thailand. Unpublished PhD Dissertation, University of Wisconsin-Madison Carter AK, Dussubieux L, Fenn TR, Lertcharnrit T, Pryce TO (2022) The exchange of beads in Central Thailand in the protohistoric period: Glass objects from Phromthin Tai. In: Dussubieux L, Walder H (eds) The Elemental Analysis of Glass Beads: Technology, Chronology and Exchange, Studies in Archaeological Sciences 8. University of Leuven Press, Leuven, pp 161–176 Carter AK, Dussubieux L, Stark MT, Gilg HA (2021) Angkor Borei and Protohistoric trade networks: a view from the glass and stone bead assemblage. Asian Perspect 60(1):32–70 Carter AK, Lankton JW (2012) Analysis and comparison of glass beads from Ban Non Wat and Noen U-Loke. In: Higham C, Kijngam A (eds) The Origins of Angkor, vol 6. The Iron Age: Summary and Conclusions. Fine Arts Department of Thailand, Bangkok, pp 91–114 Dussubieux, L (2022) Annex A: Glass analysis with LA-ICP-MS at the EAF. In Dussubieux L and Walder H (eds) The Elemental Analysis of Glass Beads: Technology, Chronology and Exchange. Studies in Archaeological Sciences 8, Leuven: University of Leuven Press. https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/2395/9517/files/Annex_A_HW_final.pdf?v=1664281532 Dussubieux L (2009) Compositional analysis of ancient glass fragments from North Sumatra, Indonesia. In: Perret, D. and Surachman, H. (ed) Histoire de Barus III: Regards sur une place marchande de l'océan Indien (XIIe-milieu du XVIIe s.). Paris: Association Archipel/EFEO. 385–417 Dussubieux L (2001) L’Apport de l’ablation laser couplée à l’ICP-MS à l’étude du verre archéologique de l’Océan Indien, PhD Dissertation. Université d’Orléans, France Dussubieux L (2016) Potash glass: a view from South and Southeast Asia. In: Gan F, Henderson J and Li Q (eds) Recent progress of scientific research On ancient glass and glaze, series on archaeology and history of science in China (Book 2), World Scientific Publishing Company, pp 95–111 Dussubieux L, Allen J (2014) Compositions of glass artifacts from Malaysia: new data from the sites of Pengkalan Bujang and Sungai Mas. In: Perret D, Zulkifli B Jaafar (eds) Ancient Gassware in Malaysia: the Pengkalan Bujang collection. Department of Museums Malaysia: Kuala Lumpur. pp 119–161 Dussubieux L, Bellina B (2018) Glass ornament production and trade polities in the Upper-Thai Peninsula during the Early Iron Age. Archaeolog Res Asia 13:25–36 Dussubieux L, Bellina B (2017) Glass from an early Southeast Asian producing and trading centre. In: Bellina B (ed) Khao Sam Kaeo: a late prehistoric early port-city between the Indian Ocean and the South China Sea. Ecole française d’Extrême-Orient: Paris. 549–585 Dussubieux L, Bellina B, Win Hsan Oo, U Maung Sun Win, Htet Myet Tut, Kalayar Myat Myat Htwe, Khinsandar Kyaw (2020) First elemental analysis of glass from Southern Myanmar: replacing the region in the early Maritime Silk Road. Archaeological and Anthropological Sciences 12, article number, 139 Dussubieux L, Cloquet C, Pryce TO (2021) Isotope analysis and its applications to the study of ancient Indian glass. In: Kanungo AK and Dussubieux L (eds) Ancient Glass of South Asia - Archaeology, Ethnography and Global Connections. Singapore: Springer Nature and Gandhinagar: IIT Gandhinagar. 175–202 Dussubieux L, Fenn TR, Abraham SA, Kanungo AK (2022) Tracking ancient glass production in India: elemental and isotopic analysis of raw materials. Archaeolog Anthropolog Sci 14:226 Dussubieux L, Gratuze B (2010) Glass in Southeast Asia. In: Bellina B, Bacus EA, Pryce TO and Wisseman CJ (eds) 50 years of Archaeology in Southeast Asia: Essays in honour of Ian Glover. River Books, 247–259 Dussubieux L, Gratuze B, Blet-Lemarquand M (2010) Mineral soda alumina glass: occurrence and meaning. J Archaeolog Sci 37:1645–1655 Dussubieux L, Kanungo A (2013) Trace Element Analysis of Glass from Kopia. In: Kanungo A (ed) Glass in Ancient India: Excavations at Kopia. KCHR, Triruvananthapuram. 360–366 Dussubieux L, Kusimba CM, Gogte V, Kusimba SB, Gratuze B, Oka R (2008) The trading of ancient glass beads: new analytical data from South Asian and East African soda-alumina glass beads. Archaeometry 50(5):797–821 Dussubieux L, Lankton JW, Bellina-Pryce B, Chaisuwan B (2012) Early Glass Trade in South and Southeast Asia: New insights from two coastal sites, Phu Khao Thong in Thailand and Arikamedu in South India. In: Crossing Borders in Southeast Asian Archaeology. Selected papers from the 13th International Conference of the European Association of Southeast Asian Archaeologists, Berlin, 2010. 2 vol. Singapore, NUS Press. 307–328 Dussubieux L, Pryce TO (2016) Myanmar’s role in Iron Age interaction networks linking Southeast Asia and India: Recent glass and copper-base metal exchange research from the Mission Archéologique Française au Myanmar. J Archaeolog Sci: Rep 5:598–614 Dussubieux L, Robertshaw P, Glascock MD (2009) LA-ICP-MS analysis of African glass beads: laboratory inter-comparison with an emphasis on the impact of corrosion on data interpretation. Int J Mass Spectrom 284:152–161 Dussubieux L, Wood M (2021) Indian glass: chronology and distribution in Eastern Africa. In: Kanungo AK and Dussubieux L (eds) Ancient Glass of South Asia - Archaeology, Ethnography and Global Connections. Singapore: Springer Nature and Gandhinagar: IIT Gandhinagar. 511–532 Francis P Jr (2001) Asia’s Maritime Bead Trade from ca. 300 BCE to the Present, Honolulu. University of Hawai’i Press. Gill MS (2017) A single Ingredient for primary glass production: Reassessing traditional glass manufacture in Northern India. J Glass Stud 59:249–259 Gratuze B (2016) Glass Characterization Using Laser Ablation-Inductively Coupled Plasma-Mass Spectrometry Methods. In: Dussubieux L, Golitko M, Gratuze B (eds) Recent Advances in Laser Ablation ICP-MS for Archaeology. Springer Verlag, pp 179–196 Gratuze B, Dussubieux L, Bopearachchi O (2000) Etude de perles de verre trouvées au Sri Lanka, IIIe s. av. - IIe s. ap. JC. Annales du 14e congrès de l'AIHV, Italia\Venezia-Milano 1998. 46–50 Gratuze B, Pactat I, Schibille N (2018) Changes in the signature of cobalt colorants in Late Antique and Early Islamic glass production. Minerals 8(6):225 Higham CFW, Kijngam A, eds. (2020) The Origins of of the Civilization of Angkor volume VII. The Excavation of Non Ban Jak. Bangkok: the Fine Arts Department. Hirao Y, Ro J-H (2013) Chemical composition and lead isotope ratios of bronze artifacts excavated in Cambodia and Thailand. In: Yasuda Y (ed) Water Civilisation: From Yangtze to Khmer Civilisations. Springer, Tokyo, pp 247–312 Kanungo AK (2016) Mapping the Indo-Pacific Beads vis-à-vis Papanaidupet. Aryan Books International and International Commission on Glass, New Delhi and Madrid Kock J, Sode T (1995) Glass, glass beads and glassmakers in Northern India, Vanlose, Danmark: THOT Print Lankton JW, Dussubieux L (2013) Ancient glass from Southeast Asia. In: Janssens K (ed) Modern Methods for Analysing Archaeological and Historical Glass. John Wiley & Sons, pp 413–441 Lankton JW, Dussubieux L (2006) Early Glass in Asian Maritime Trade: A Review and an Interpretation of Compositional Analyses. Journal of Glass Studies 48:121–144 Lankton JW, Dussubieux L, Gratuze B (2008) Glass from Khao Sam Kaeo: Transferred technology for an early Southeast Asian exchange network. In: Recent Advances in the Archaeology of Exchange in the Upper Thai-Malay Peninsula. Bulletin de l’Ecole Française d’Extrême-Orient 2006 93:317–351. Li F (1999) Elemental and isotopic analysis of ancient Chinese glass. Master Dissertation. University of Hong Kong Lin Yi-Xian, Rerhen Th, Wang Hui, Ren Xiao-Yan, Ma Jian (2019) The beginning of faience in China: A review and new evidence. J Archaeolog Sci 105:97–115 Lü Q-Q, Chen Y-X, Henderson J, Bayon G (2023) A large-scale Sr and Nd isotope baseline for archaeological provenance in Silk Road regions and its application to plant-ash glass. J Archaeolog Sci 149:105695 Nguyen Kim Dung (2001) Jewelry from Late Prehistoric sites recently excavated in South Vietnam. Indo-Pacific Prehistory Assoc Bull 21(5):107–113 Pautreau JP, Aung Aung Kyaw, Coupey, A-S eds (2010) Excavations in the Samon Valley : Iron Age burials in Myanmar. Mission archéologique française au Myanmar Pryce TO, Baron S, Bellina B, Bellwood PS, Chang N, Chattopadhyay P, Dizon E, Glover IC, Hamilton E, Higham CFW, Kyaw Aung Aung, Laychour V, Natapintu S, Nguyen Viet, Pautreau J-P, Pernicka E, Pigott VC, Pollard M, Pottier C, Reinecke A, Sayavongkhamdy T, Souksavatdy V, White J (2014) More questions than answers: the Southeast Asian Lead Isotope Project 2009–2012. J Archaeolog Sci 42:273–294 Salisbury A, Glover I (1997) New analyses of early glass from Thailand and Vietnam. Bead Study Trust Newslett 30:7–14 Schibille N (2022) Islamic glass in the making, Chronological and geographical dimension, Studies in Archaeological Sciences 7. Leuven University Press, Leuven Schibille N, Degryse P, Corremans M, Specht CG (2012) Chemical characterization of glass mosaic tesserae from sixth-century Sagalassos (south-west Turkey): chronology and production techniques. J Archaeolog Sci 39:1480–1492 Schlick-Nolte B, Werthmann R (2003) Glass Vessels from the Burial of Nesikhons. J Glass Stud 45:11–34 Schreurs JWH, Brill RH (1984) Iron and sulphur related colors in ancient glasses. Archaeometry 26(2):199–209 Shortland AJ, Schachner L, Freestone IC, Tite M (2006) Natron as a flux in the early vitreous materials industry: sources, beginnings and reasons for decline. J Archaeolog Sci 33:521–30 Turner WES, Rooksby HP (1959) A study of the opalising agents in ancient opal glass throughout three thousand four hundred years. Glastechnische Berichte 32K, VIII(17):20–28 Walder H, Petrus JA, Dussubieux L, Hancock RGV, Hawkins AL (2021) Comparing chemistries: inter-laboratory evaluation of glass bead compositional research in the Great Lakes. Archaeom 63(6):1236–1254