Gap-accepteance parameters for roundabouts: a systematic review
Tóm tắt
The critical and follow-up headways are the two gap-acceptance parameters which explain the traffic interaction of a minor street vehicle when enters the roundabout, merging into or crossing one or more circulating (major) streams. Several studies and researches provide measurements of critical and follow-up headways from real data at roundabouts. The objective of our research is to synthesize the data from the series of selected studies to interpret variation across the studies. In order to match the research goal, a systematic literature review on estimations of critical and follow-up headways at roundabouts was undertaken. Since several studies and researches developed worldwide were examined, we were able to note that the effect size varied from study to study. Thus the meta-analysis of effect sizes was performed as part of the literature review through the random-effects model. After discussing the assumptions of this model, the dispersion in effects across studies was assessed and the summary effect for each of the parameters under examination was computed. Calculations were made both for single-lane roundabouts and double-lane roundabouts, as well as for turbo roundabouts. Compared to the results of individual studies, the single (quantitative) meta-analytic estimate provides an accurate and reliable synthesis on the specific issue here addressed, and gives, with greater power of the individual reviewed studies, a comprehensive measure for the parameters of interest.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Luoma J, Sivak M (2012) Interactions of environmental and safety measures for sustainable road transportation. European Transport Research Review 4:189–199. doi:10.1007/s12544-012-0078-5
Rodegerdts L, Bansen J, Tiesler C, Knudsen J, Myers E, Johnson M, Moule M, Persaud B, Lyon C, Hallmark S, Isebrands H, Crown RB, Guichet B, O’Brien A (2010) National Cooperative Highway Research Program Report 672: Roundabouts: An Informational Guide, 2nd edn. Transportation Research Board of the National Academic. Washington. D.C, US
Moya-Gómez B, García- Palomares J C (2015) Working with the daily variation in infrastructure performance on territorial accessibility. The cases of Madrid and Barcelona. European Transport Research Review 7: 20. doi: 10.1007/s12544-015-0168-2
Gitelman V, Carmel R, Pesahov F (2014) The evaluation of safety efficiency of non-urban infrastructure improvements; a case-study. European Transport Research Review 6:477–491. doi:10.1007/s12544-014-0145-1
Robinson B W, Rodegerdts L, Scarbrough W, Kittelson W, Troutbeck R, Brilon W, Bondzio L, Courage K, Kyte M, Mason J, Flannery A, Myers E, Bunker J, Jacquemart G (2000) Roundabouts: An Informational Guide. Report Federal Highway Administration - FHWA-RD-00-067. US Department of Transportation
Tollazzi T (2015) Alternative Types of Roundabouts: An Informational Guide. Springer Tracts on Transportation and Traffic 6. Springer-Verlag. Springer International Publishing, Switzerland
Fortuijn LGH, Harte VF (1997) Meerstrooksrotondes: verkenning can nieuwe vormen - Turbo-roundabouts: A well-tried concept in a new guise. Verkeerskundige werkdagen 1997. CROW Ede, The Netherlands
Mauro R (2010) Calculation of Roundabouts. Springer-Verlag, Berlin Heidelberg
Brilon W, Wu N, Bondzio L (1997) Unsignalized intersections in Germany—a State of the Art. 3rd International Symposium on Intersections Without Traffic Signals, Portland, Oregon, USA, July 21–23, 1997
Bovy H, Dietrich K, Harmann A (1991) Guide Suisse des Giatoires. Lausanne, Switzerland
Kimber R M (1980) The traffic capacity of roundabouts. TRRL Laboratory Report 942, Berkshire, UK
GIRABASE (2008) Calculation of roundabout capacity. http://www.certu.fr
Brilon W, Wu N (2001) Capacity at unsignalized intersections derived by conflict technique. Transportation Research Record 1776:82–90
Highway Capacity Manual (2000) Transportation Research Board Special Report 209, 3th edition
Al-Madani HMN (2013) Capacity of large dual and triple-lanes roundabouts during heavy demand conditions. Arabian Journal for Science and Engineering 38(3):491–505. doi:10.1007/s13369-012-0330-2
Giuffrè O, Granà A, Marino S (2012) Comparing performances of turbo-roundabouts and double-lane roundabouts. Modern Applied Science 6(10):70–79. doi:10.5539/mas.v6n10p70
Zheng D, Chitturi M, Bill A, Noyce D A (2011) Comprehensive evaluation of Wisconsin roundabouts Volume 1: Traffic Operations. Wisconsin Traffic Operations and Safety Laboratory, Wisconsin, US, Available at http://wwwtopslabwiscedu/projects/4-10html Accessed 28 March 2013
Tian Z, Troutbeck R J, Kyte M, Brilon W, Vandehey M, Kittelson W, Robinson B (2000) A further investigation on critical gap and follow-up time. 4th International Symposium on Highway Capacity, Transportation Research Circular E-C018. Maui, Hawaii, June 27–July 1
Tian Z, Kyte W, Vandehey M, Robinson B, Kittelson W, Troutbeck RW, Brilon W (1999) Implementing the maximum likelihood methodology to measure driver’s critical gap. Transportation Research Part A 33:187–197
Troutbeck R J (1992) Estimating the critical acceptance gap from traffic movements. Queensland University of Technology
Highway Capacity Manual (2010) Transportation Research Board. Special Report 209. 5th edition
Khatib Z, Kyte M (2000) Framework to consider the effect of uncertainty in forecasting the level of service of signalized and unsignalized intersections. 4th International Symposium on Highway Capacity, Transportation Research Circular E-C018. Maui, Hawaii, June 27–July 1
Kyte M, Tian Z, Mir Z, Hameedmansoor Z, Kittelson W, Vandehey M, Robinson B, Brilon W, Bondzio L, Wu N, Troutbeck R J (1996) NCHRP Web Document 5: Capacity and level of service at unsignalized intersections: Final Report Vol. 1: Two-Way Stop Controlled Intersections. TRB. National Research Council. Washington. DC
Troutbeck RJ (1986) Average delay at an unsignalized intersection with two major streams each having a dichotomized headway distribution. Transportation Science 20(4):272–286. doi:10.1287/trsc.20.4.272
Troutbeck R J (1991) Recent Australian unsignalized intersection research and practices. Intersections without Traffic Signals II. Springer-Verlag (Werner Brilon. ed.): 238–257
Chalumuri RS, Yasuo A (2014) Modelling travel time distribution under various uncertainties on Hanshin expressway of Japan. European Transport Research Review 6:85–92. doi:10.1007/s12544-013-0111-3
Grayman WM (2005) Incorporating uncertainty and variability in engineering analysis. Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management 131(3):158–160
Galvan JL (2012) Writing literature reviews, 5th edn. Pyrczak Publishing, Glendale, CA
Borenstein M, Hedges LV, Higgins JPT, Rothstein HR (2009) Introduction to meta-analysis. Wiley, Chichester, UK
Singh V, Sharma SK (2015) Fuel consumption optimization in air transport: a review, classification, critique, simple meta-analysis, and future research implications. European Transport Research Review 7:12. doi:10.1007/s12544-015-0160-x
Brilon W (2011) Studies on roundabouts in Germany: Lessons Learned. 3rd International TRB-roundabout Conference, Carmel, Indiana, May 2011
FGSV: Handbuch fuer die bemessung von Straβen (HBS: German Highway Capacity Manual). Forschungsgesellschaft für Straßen- und Verkehrswesen (FGSV). (www.fgsv.de). Cologne, edition 2001
Tanner JC (1967) The capacity of an uncontrolled intersection. Biometrica 54(3/4):657–658
Brilon W, Koenig R, Troutbeck RJ (1999) Useful Estimation Procedures for Critical Gaps. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice 33(3–4):161–186. doi:10.1016/S0965-8564(98)00048-2
BPS: Manual for the program KREISEL version 7, (www. bps-verkehr.de), 2011
Brilon W (2014) Roundabouts: a state of the art in Germany. 4th International TRB-roundabout Conference, Conference, Seattle, Washington, April 2014
Wu N (1997) An universal formula for calculating capacity at roundabouts. Research report of Institute for Traffic Engineering No.13, Ruhr-University Bochum, March 1997
Wu N (2012) Estimating distribution function of critical gaps at unsignalized intersections based on equilibrium of probabilities. Transportation Research Record 2286:49–55. doi:10.3141/2286-06
Brilon W, Bondzio L, Weiser (2014) Experiences with Turbo-Roundabouts in Germany. 5th Rural Roads Design meeting, Copenhagen. http://nmfv.dk/wp-content/uploads/2014/04/Experiences-with-Turbo-Roundabouts-in-Germany-Brilon-Bondzio-Weiser.pdf Accessed April 3–4, 2014
Leemann N, Santel G (2009) Two-lane roundabouts. 9th Swiss Transport Research Conference, Ascona, Sept 9–11, 2009
Brilon W (1988) Recent development in calculation methods for unsignalized intersections in West Germany. In: Brilon W (ed) Intersections without Traffic Signals. Springer-Verlag, Berlin Heidelberg, pp. 111–153
Hagring O, Rouphail N M, Sørensen H A (2003) Comparison of capacity models for two-lane roundabouts. 82nd TRB Annual Meeting, Washington, DC, USA, January 2003
Greibe P, La Cour Lund B (2010) Capacity of 2-lane roundabouts. 4th International Symposium on Highway Geometric Design, June 2nd-5th 2010 Valencia, Spain
Fortuijn LGH (2009) Turbo roundabout. Estimation of capacity. Transportation Research Record 2130(2009):83–92. doi:10.3141/2130-11
Gazzarri A, Martello MT, Pratelli A, Souleyrette R (2013) Gap acceptance parameters for HCM 2010 roundabout capacity model applications in Italy. Wit serifes on Transport systems & traffic engineering 1:1–6
Ferrari P, Giannini F (1994) Ingegneria stradale: geometria e progetto di strade [Road engineering: geometry and road geometric design]. ISEDI, pp 228–230
Raff MS, Hart JW (1950) A volume warrant for urban stop signs. The Eno Foundation for Highway Traffic Control. Saugatuck, Conn, USA
Romano E (2004) Driver behaviour at the roundabouts: analysis and simulation. 2nd International SIIV Congress: New technologies and modeling tools for roads, Florence, Italy, October 2004
Nicolosi V, Crisalli U, D’Apuzzo M (2008) Le intersezioni a rotatoria: analisi teorico-sperimentale e modelli teorici per la stima della capacità [Roundabouts: theoretical and experimental analysis and models for capacity estimation]. 17° Convegno Nazionale SIIV [17th National SIIV Conference], Enna, Italy, September 2008
Dawson R F (1969) The hypererlang probability distribution – a generalized traffic headway model. International Symposium on the Theory of Traffic Flow and Transportatio, Karlsruhe, Series Strassenbau und Strassenverkehrstechik 86
Siegloch W (1973) Die Leistungsermittlung an Knotenpunkten ohne Lichtsignalsteuerung (Capacity Calculations for Unsignalized Intersections), Series Strassenbau und Strassenverkehrstechnik 154, Bundesminister für Verkehr
De Luca M, Grossi R, Petitto S (2002) Studio del funzionamento delle rotatorie mediante la tecnica della simulazione: modello e verifiche sperimentali [Study of roundabout performances by simulation: model and experimental validation]. 1th International SIIV Conference, Parma, Italy, October 2002
Vasconcelos L, Bastos Silva A, Seco Á, Rouxinol G (2012) Estimation of critical headways at unsignalized intersections - a microscopic approach. Advances in Transportation Studies Special Issue 1:59–72
Polus A, Shiftan Y, Shmueli-Lazar S (2005) Evaluation of the waiting-time effect on critical gaps at roundabouts by a logit model. European Journal of Transport and Infrastructure Research 5(1):1–12
Vasconcelos L, Seco Á, Bastos Silva A (2013) Comparison of procedures to estimate critical headways at roundabouts. Promet – Traffic & Transportation 25(1):43–53. doi:10.7307/ptt.v25i1.1246
Troutbeck RJ (1993) Capacity and design of traffic circles in Australia. Transportation Research Record 1398:68–74
Troutbeck R J (1990) Traffic interactions at roundabouts. 15th ARRB Conference, Vol. 15-Part 5, Australia, 1990
Troutbeck RJ (1984) Capacity and Delays at Roundabouts-A Literature Review. Australian Road Research Board 14(4):205–216
Troutbeck R J (1985) Does gap acceptance theory adequately predict the capacity of a roundabout? 12th ARRB Conference, Australia, Vol. 12-Part 4: 62–75
Troutbeck R J (1992) Changes to Analysis and Design of Roundabouts Initiated in the Austroads Guide. 16th ARRB Conference, Vol. 16-Part 5, Australia, 1992
Rodegerdts L, Blogg M, Wemple E, Myers E, Kyte M, Dixon M, List G, Flannery A, Troutbeck R, Brilon W, Wu N, Persaud B, Lyon C, Harkey D, Carter D (2007) Roundabouts in the United States. National Cooperative Highway Research Program Report 572. Transportation Research Board of the National Academic. Washington. D.C., USA
Akcelik R (2007) A review of gap acceptance capacity models. 29th Conference of Australian Institute of Transport Research, Adelaide, Australia 5–7 December 2007, Revised 14 July 2011
Akcelik R (2008) Roundabouts in Australia. 2nd International TRB-Roundabouts Conference. Kansas City, MO, USA, 18–21 May 2008
Akçelik R, Chung E, Besley M (1998) Roundabouts: Capacity and Performance Analysis, Research Report ARR No 321, 2nd edn. ARRB Transport Research Ltd, Australias
Troutbeck RJ (1989) Evaluating the performances of a roundabouts. Special report SR 45 ARRB, Transport Research Ltd, Vermouth South, Australia
AUSTROROADS (1993) Roundabouts. Guide to traffic engineering practice Part 6. Association of State Australian state road and transport authorities, Sidney, Australia
Akcelik R (2011) An Assessment of the Highway Capacity Manual 2010 Roundabout Capacity Model. International TRB Roundabout Conference, Carmel, Indiana, USA, May 2011
Akcelik R (2011) Roundabout design and capacity analysis in Australia and New Zealand. International Roundabout Design and Capacity Seminar. 6th International Symposium on Highway Capacity and quality of service, Stockholm, Sweden, 1st July, 2011
Qu X, Zhang IJ, Wang S, Liu Z (2014) Modelling follow up time at a single-lane roundabout. Journal of Traffic and Transportation Engineering 1(2):97–102
Troutbeck RJ (1998) Background for HCM Section on Analysis of Performance of Roundabouts. Transportation Research Record 1646(1998):54–62
Li Z, De Amico M, Chitturi M V, Bill A R (2013) Calibrating Vissim roundabout model using a critical gap and follow-up headway approach. 16th Road Safety on Four Continents Conference, Beijing, China, 15–17 May 2013
Xu F, Tian Z (2008) Driver behavior and gap-acceptance characteristics at roundabouts in California. Transportation Research Record 2071(2008):117–124. doi:10.3141/2071-14
Abrams D S, Fitzpatrick C D, Tang Y, Knodler M A (2013) A spatial and temporal analysis of driver gap acceptance behavior at modern roundabouts. 92nd Annual Meeting of the Transportation Research Board, Washington, D.C. January, 2013
Mensah S, Eshragh S, Faghri A (2009) A critical Gap Analysis for Modern Roundabouts. 89th Annual Meeting of the Transportation Research Board, Washington, D.C. January, 2010
Dahl J, Lee C (2012) Empirical estimation of capacity for roundabouts using adjusted gap-acceptance parameters for trucks. Transportation Research Record 2312:34–45. doi:10.3141/2312-04
Qu Z, Duan Y, Song X, Hu H, Liu H, Guan K (2014) Capacity prediction model based on limited priority gap-acceptance theory at multilane roundabouts. Mathematical Problems in Engineering 2014:1–12(Article ID 490280)
Guo R (2010) Estimating critical gap of roundabouts by different methods. 6th Advanced Forum on Transportation of China, IET publisher, Beijing, October 2010: 84:89. doi:10.1049/cp.2010.1107
Ashworth R (1970) The analysis and interpretation of gap acceptance data. Transportation Science 4(3):270–280. doi:10.1287/trsc.4.3.270
Manage S, Suzuki K, Nakamura H (2003) Performance analysis of roundabouts as an alternative for intersection control in Japan. Journal of the Eastern Asia Society for Transportation Studies 5:871–883
Cochran WG (1950) The comparison of percentages in matched samples. Biometrika 37(3/4):256–266. doi:10.1093/biomet/37.3-4.256
Higgins J, Thompson SG, Deeks JJ, Altman DG (2003) Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses. BMJ 327:557–560