Feminist Lesbians as Anti-Trans Villains: A Comment on Worthen and Elaboration
Tóm tắt
In her recent article published in Sexuality & Culture, “This is my TERF! Lesbian Feminists and the Stigmatization of Trans Women,” Worthen focuses on feminist lesbians and their alleged “anti-trans” and “trans-exclusionary” beliefs. Analyzing a subsample of ‘cis women’ from a larger online survey, Worthen examines whether feminist lesbians “express greater levels of negativity” toward transwomen than other women and whether there is “a relationship between feminist identity among lesbian cis women and the stigmatization of trans women”. Although Worthen reports finding a positive association between being a feminist lesbian and holding negative views towards transwomen, which she interprets as indicating that lesbian feminists hold more negative sentiments toward transwomen than other women, that is not what her results show. Notably, while this misinterpretation of findings is particularly egregious, mischaracterizations pervade Worthen’s article. Here, I correct these misrepresentations. I address Worthen’s use of ad hominem in lieu of logic and evidence. I also discuss differences between gender-critical feminism and what I call trans-activist feminism, drawing attention to the latter’s explicit prioritization of male inclusion in women’s provisions over female safety and psychological well-being. I show that, contrary to her interpretations, Worthen’s findings indicate that lesbians have significantly less ‘anti-trans [woman] sentiment’ than most other women and their non-lesbian feminist counterparts. I conclude by considering how we arrived at this socio-cultural situation, where feminists who believe that sex is biologically real and matters in some contexts are derided, their concerns are denounced as hateful, and flawed articles purporting to demonstrate feminist lesbians’ uniquely ‘anti-trans’ sentiment are published despite factual inaccuracies.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Allen, S. R., Finneron-Burns, E., Leng, M., Lawford-Smith, H., Jones, J. C., Reilly-Cooper, R., & Simpson, R. (2019). On an alleged case of propaganda: Reply to McKinnon.
Barry, K. (1979). Female sexual slavery. NYU Press.
Bettcher, T. M. (2017). Trans feminism: Recent philosophical developments. Philosophy Compass, 12(11), e12438.
Blair, K. L., & Hoskin, R. A. (2019). Transgender exclusion from the world of dating: Patterns of acceptance and rejection of hypothetical trans dating partners as a function of sexual and gender identity. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 36(7), 2074–2095.
Browne, K. (2009). Womyn’s separatist spaces: Rethinking spaces of difference and exclusion. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 34(4), 541–556.
Browne, K. (2010). Lesbian separatist feminism at Michigan Womyn’s music festival. Feminism & Psychology, 21(2), 248–256.
Burt, C. H. (2022c). Sex, gender, and the US Equality Act: Confusion, conflict, and consequences. In A. Sullivan & S. Todd (Eds.), Sex and gender identity: A reader. Under Review.
Burt, C. H. (2020). Scrutinizing the U.S. Equality Act 2019: A feminist examination of definitional changes and sociolegal ramifications. Feminist Criminology, 15(4), 363–409. https://doi.org/10.1177/1557085120918667
Burt, C. H. (2022a). Discounting females, denying sex, and disregarding dangers from self-ID: A reply and a defense of open debate. Journal of Controversial Ideas. https://doi.org/10.35995/jci02010015
Burt, C. H. (2022b). Irreducibly social: Why biocriminology’s ontoepistemology is incompatible with the social reality of crime. Theoretical Criminology. https://doi.org/10.1177/13624806211073695
Cameron, D. (2016). What makes a word a slur? Retrieved from https://debuk.wordpress.com/2016/11/06/what-makes-a-word-a-slur/
Frye, M. (1993). Some reflections on separatism and power. In H. Abelove, M. A. Barale, & D. M. Halperin (Eds.), The lesbian and gay studies reader (pp. 91–98).
Head, M. L., Holman, L., Lanfear, R., Kahn, A. T., & Jennions, M. D. (2015). The extent and consequences of p-hacking in science. PLoS Biology, 13(3), e1002106. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.1002106
Hester, M. (1992). Lewd women and wicked witches: A study of the dynamics of male domination. Routledge.
Heyes, C. J. (2003). Feminist solidarity after queer theory: The case of transgender. Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society, 28(4), 1093–1120.
Jeffreys, S. (1990). Anticlimax. The Women’s Press.
Jeffreys, S. (1997). Transgender activism: A lesbian feminist perspective. Journal of Lesbian Studies, 1(3–4), 55–74.
Jeffreys, S. (2003). Unpacking queer politics: A Lesbian feminist perspective. Polity Press.
Jeffreys, S. (2014). Gender hurts: A feminist analysis of the politics of transgenderism. Routledge.
Johnston, J. (1993). Lesbian nation: The feminist solution. Simon and Schuster.
Lawford-Smith, H. (2022a). Gender-critical feminism. Oxford University Press.
Lawford-Smith, H. (2022b). Trashing and tribalism in the gender wars. In N. Birondo (Ed.), The moral psychology of hate. Rowman & Littlefield.
Leeds Revolutionary Feminist Group. (1981). Political lesbianism: The case against heterosexuality. In Onlywomen (Ed.), Love your enemy? Onlywomen Press.
Leon, B. (1978). Separate to integrate. In Redstockings of the Women's Liberation Movement (Ed.), Feminist revolution: An abridged edition with additional writings. Random House.
Lorber, J. (2001). Gender inequality. Roxbury.
Manne, K. (2017). Down girl: The logic of misogyny. Oxford University Press.
Millett, K. (1970). Sexual politics. Columbia University Press.
Morris, B. J. (2003). At the Michigan Womyn’s music fest. The Gay & Lesbian Review Worldwide, 10(5), 16–19.
Morris, B. J. (2005). Commentary: Valuing woman-only spaces. Feminist Studies, 31(3), 618.
Morris, B. J. (2016). The disappearing L: Erasure of lesbian spaces and culture. SUNY Press.
Nunberg, G. (2018). The social life of slurs. New work on speech acts, pp. 237–295.
Raymond, J. G. (1979). The transsexual empire: The making of a she-male. Beacon Press.
Rich, A. (1980). Compulsory heterosexuality and lesbian existence. Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society, 5(4), 631–660.
Searle, J. R. (1995). The construction of social reality. Simon and Schuster.
Simmons, J. P., Nelson, L. D., & Simonsohn, U. (2011). False-positive psychology: Undisclosed flexibility in data collection and analysis allows presenting anything as significant. Psychological Science, 22(11), 1359–1366.
Stock, K. (2021). Material girls: Why reality matters for feminism. Hachette.
Stock, K. (2022). The importance of referring to human sex in language. Law and Contemporary Problems, 85(1), 25–45.
Worthen, M. G. (2022). This is my TERF! Lesbian feminists and the stigmatization of trans women. Sexuality & Culture. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12119-022-09970-w