Educational (Mis)match and skill utilization in Germany: Assessing the role of worker and job characteristics

Daniela Rohrbach-Schmidt1, Michael Tiemann1
1Department of Sociology and Economics of Vocational Education and Training, Federal Institute for Vocational Education and Training, Robert-Schuman Platz 3, 53175, Bonn, Germany

Tóm tắt

Abstract This paper provides precise figures on the incidence and wage penalties of mismatching in Germany. We use the BIBB/BAuA Employment Survey 2006 to compute two different measures of person-to-job matching. A first measure indicates an educational (mis)match, i.e., whether a worker’s attained level of education corresponds to the qualificational requirements of his or her job. Second, — and different from most other studies—we observe a skill (mis)match that reflects the correspondence between the skills of the job holder and the skill requirements of the job. We explore whether and the extent to which results on mismatch differ between these measures and explain the probability of being (mis)matched by different sets of worker and job characteristics. We also examine wage penalties for mismatching in Germany, considering a large number of controls for workers and, in addition to most earlier studies, job heterogeneity; we use random intercept models with workers nested in occupations. Our results indicate that large shares of over- or under-educated workers in Germany have skills that correspond to the skill requirements of their jobs. Furthermore, there are workers perfectly matched with respect to their education who, nevertheless, feel under- or over-challenged by their jobs’ skill requirements. Random intercept models reveal that beyond worker characteristics, i.e., human capital compensation (heterogeneous ability) and career mobility rationalities, job characteristics play a role in the mismatching variance and its real or apparent wage penalties.

Từ khóa


Tài liệu tham khảo

Acemoglu, D.: Technical change, inequality, and the labor market. J. Econ. Lit. 40(1), 7–72 (2002)

Alda, H., Rohrbach-Schmidt, D.: “Imputation fehlender Werte für die Einkommensvariable in der BIBB/BAuA-Erwerbstätigenbefragung 2006”. BIBB-FDZ Daten- und Methodenberichte, 1/2011. BIBB, Bonn (2011)

Allen, J., and van der Velden, Rolf: Educational mismatches versus skill mismatches. Effects on wages, job satisfaction, and on-the-job search. Oxford Econ. Pap. 53(3), 434–452 (2001)

Antonczyk, D., DeLeire, T., Fitzenberger, B.: “Polarization and Rising Wage Inequality: Comparing the U.S. and Germany” IZA Discussion Paper Series, No. 4842, Bonn (2010)

Autor, D., Dorn, D.: This job is “getting old”: measuring changes in job opportunities using occupational age structure. American Economic Review, 99(2): 45–51 (2009)

Autor, D.H., Handel, M.J.: Putting tasks to the test. Human capital, job tasks and wages. Journal of Labor Economics 31(2), 59–96 (2013)

Autor, D.H., Levy, F., Murnane, R.J.: The skill content of recent technological change: An empirical exploration. Quart. J. Econ. 3(4), 1279–1333 (2003)

Autor, D.H., Katz, L.F., Kearney, M.S.: “The polarization of the US labor market”, American Economic Review, 96(2), 189–194 (2006)

Autor, D.H., Katz, L.F., Kearney, M.S.: Trends in U. S. wage inequality. Revising the revisionists. Rev. Econ. Stat. 90(2), 300–323 (2008)

Bauer, T.K.: Educational mismatch and wages. A panel analysis. Econ. Educ. Rev. 21(3), 221–229 (2002)

Büchel, F., Battu, H.: The theory of differential overqualification. Does it work? Scott. J. Political Econ. 50(1), 1–16 (2003)

Büchel, F., Mertens, A.: Overeducation, undereducation, and the theory of career mobility. Appl. Econ. 36(8), 803–816 (2004)

Büchel, F., van Ham, M.: Overeducation, regional labour markets and spatial flexibility. J. Urban Econ. 424(53), 482–493 (2003)

Büchel, F., Witte, J.C.: “The incidence and consequences of overeducation among young workers in the United States and Germany. A comparative panel analysis”, Proceedings of the 1996s International Conference of the German Socio-Economic Panel Study Users, 66(1), 32–40 (1997)

Card, D., DiNardo, J.E.: “Skill biased technological change and rising wage inequality. Some problems and puzzles”, Journal of Labor Economics 20(4), 733–783 (2002)

Carnoy, M.: “Vocational Education: Is There a “Best” Model in the New Global Economy?” Unpublished Keynote Speech. EHB Switzerland, Interdisciplinary Congress on Research in Vocational Education and Training (2009)

Chevalier, A.: Measuring over-education. Economica. 70(279), 509–531 (2003)

Daly, M.C., Büchel, F., Duncan, G.J.: Premiums and penalties for surplus and deficit education. Evidence from the United States and Germany. Econ. Educ. Rev. 19(2), 169–178 (2000)

Dolton, P., Vignoles, A.: The incidence and effects of overeducation in the UK graduate labour market. Econ. Educ. Rev. 19(2), 179–198 (2000)

Duncan, G.J., Hoffman, S.D.: The incidence and wage effects of overeducation. Econ. Educ. Rev. 1(1), 75–86 (1981)

Dustmann, C., Schoenberg, U.: Why does the German apprenticeship system work? Skill formation. 2008, 85–108 (2008)

Dustmann, C., Ludsteck, J., Schoenberg, U.: Revisiting the German Wage structure. Quart. J. Econ. 114(2), 843–882 (2009)

Frenette, M.: The overqualified Canadian graduate: the role of academic program in the incidence, persistence, and economic returns to overqualification. Econ. Educ. Rev. 23, 29–45 (2004)

Frey, C., Osborne, M.A.: The Future of Employment: How Susceptible are Jobs to Computerization? University of Oxford (2013)

Goos, M., Manning, A.: Lousy and lovely jobs. The rising polarization of work in Britain. Rev. Econ. Stat. 89(1), 118–133 (2007)

Goos, M., Manning, A., Salomons, A.: “Recent changes in the European employment structure: the roles of technology and globalization”, Open Access publications from Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven (2009)

Green, F.: Demanding Work. The Paradox of Job Quality in the Affluent Economy. Princeton University Press, Princeton (2006)

Green, F.: “Employee Involvement, Technology and Evolution in Job Skills: A Task-Based Analysis.” Industrial & Labor Relations Review 65. pp. 35–66 (2012)

Green, F., McIntosh, S.: Is there a genuine under-utilization of skills amongst the overeducated? Appl. Aconomics. 39, 427–439 (2007)

Green, F., Zhu, Y.: Overqualification, job dissatisfaction, and increasing dispersion in the returns to graduate education. Oxford Econ. Pap. 62(2), 740–763 (2010)

Groot, W. and Maassen van den Brink, Henriette: Overeducation in the labor market. A meta-analysis. Econ. Educ. Rev. 19(2), 149–158 (2000)

Hadjar, A., Becker, R. (eds.): Expected and Unexpected Consequences of the Educational Expansion in Europe and the US. Haupt, Bern (2009)

Hall, A., Siefer, A., Tiemann, M.: BIBB/BAuA Employment Survey of the Working Population on Qualification and Working Conditions in Germany 2012. suf_4.0; Research Data Center at BIBB (ed.); GESIS Cologne (data access); Bonn: Federal Institute for Vocational Education and Training. doi:10.7803/501.12.1.1.40 (2015)

Hall, A., Tiemann, M.: BIBB/BAuA Employment Survey of the Working Population on Qualification and Working Conditions in Germany 2006: suf_1.0; Research Data Center at BIBB (ed.); GESIS Cologne (data access). Federal Institute for Vocational Education and Training, Bonn (2006). doi:10.4232/1.11072 (2009)

Handel, M.J.: “Skills Mismatch in the Labour Market”, Annual Review of Sociology, 29 (2003)

Handel, M.J.: “Measuring Job Content: Skills, Technology, and Management Practices”. Institute for Research on Poverty. Discussion paper 1357–08 (2008)

Hartog, J.: Over-education and earnings. where are we, where should we go? Econ. Educ. Rev. 19(2), 131–147 (2000)

Hillmert, S.: When traditions change and virtues become obstacles. Skill formation in Britain and Germany. Skill formation. 2008, 50–81 (2008)

Hox, J.: Multilevel analysis. Techniques and applications. Erlbaum, Mahwah (2002)

Kalleberg, A.L. (ed.): Organizations in America. Analyzing their structures and human resource practices. Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks (1996)

Konsortium Bildungsberichterstattung: Bildung in Deutschland. Ein indikatorengestützter Bericht mit einer Analyse zu Bildung und Migration. W. Bertelsmann Verlag, Bielefeld (2006)

Korpi, T., Tåhlin, M.: Educational mismatch, wages, and wage growth. Overeducation in Sweden; 1974–2000. Lab. Econ. 16(2), 183–193 (2009)

Lazear, E.P.: A jobs-based analysis of labor markets. Am. Econ. Rev. 85(2), 260–265 (1995)

Leuven, E., Oosterbeek, H.: Overeducation and Mismatch in the Labor Market. Handbook of the Economics of Education 4 (2011): 283–326.

Lutz, B., Grünert, H.: Beruflichkeit, das Risiko von Arbeitsmarkt-Mismatch und offene Fragen. In: Der gesellschaftliche Umgang mit Ungewissheit - Berufe und Professionen als Beispiel. Mitteilungen des SFB 580 Nr. 13, S. 59–69 (2003)

McGuinness, S.: Overeducation in the labour market. J. Econ. Surveys. 20(3), 387–418 (2006)

Morris, M., Western, B.: Inequality in Earnings at the Close of the Twentieth Century. Annu. Rev. Sociol. 25, 623–657 (1999)

Müller, W., Brauns, H., Steinmann, S.: Expansion und Erträge tertiärer Bildung in Deutschland, Frankreich und Vereinigten Königreich. Berl. J. Soziol. 12(1), 37–62 (2002)

OECD (ed.): Education at a Glance. OECD, Paris (2007)

Oesch, D., Rodriguez, J.: Upgrading or polarization? Occupational change in Britain, Germany, Spain and Switzerland, 1990–2008, Socio-Economic Review 9(3), 503–531 (2011)

Quintini, G.: Over-Qualified or Under-Skilled. A review of existing literature. OECD Social, Employment and Migration Papers No. 121 (2011)

Rabe-Hesketh, S., Skrondal, A.: Multilevel and longitudinal modeling using stata (2. ed. ed.). Stata Press, College Station (2008)

Raudenbush, S.W., Bryk, A.S.: Hierarchical linear models. Applications and data analysis methods (2nd ed ed.). Sage Publ, Thousand Oaks (2002)

Rohrbach-Schmidt, D.: The BIBB/IAB- and BIBB-BAuA Surveys of the Working Population on Qualification and Working Conditions in Germany. BIBB-FDZ Daten- und Methodenberichte Nr. 1/2009. Bonn: BIBB. ISSN 2190-300X (2009)

Rohrbach-Schmidt, D., Tiemann, M.: Mismatching and job tasks in Germany - rising over-qualification through polarization? Empir. Res. Vocat. Educ. Train. 1(3), 39–53 (2011)

Rubb, S.: Overeducation in the labor market. A comment and re-analysis of a meta-analysis. Econ. Educ. Rev. 22(6), 621–629 (2003a)

Rubb, S.: Overeducation: a short or long run phenomenon for individuals? Econ. Educ. Rev. 22(4), 389–394 (2003b)

Sattinger, M.: Assignment models of the distribution of earnings. J. Econ. Lit. 31(2), 831–880 (1993)

Schneider, S.L. (ed.): Applying the ISCED-97 to the German educational qualifications. S. 76–102 in: The International Standard Classification of Education (ISCED-97). An Evaluation of Content and Criterion Validity for 15 European Countries. Mannheimer Zentrum für Euorpäische Sozialforschung (MZES), Mannheim (2008)

Sichermann, N., Galor, O.: A theory of career mobility. J. Polit. Economy. 98(1), 169–192 (1990)

Sørensen, A.B., Kalleberg, A.L.: An outline of a theory of the matching of persons to jobs, pp. 49–74 in: I. E. Berg, Sociological perspectives on labor markets. Academic Press, New York (1981)

Spence, M.A.: Job market signaling. Quart. J. Econ. 87(3), 355–374 (1973)

Spitz-Oener, A.: Technical change, job tasks, and rising educational demands: Looking outside the wage structure. J. Lab. Econ. 24(2), 235–270 (2006)

Statistisches Bundesamt: Bildung und Kultur. Nichtmonetäre hochschulstatistische Kennzahlen 1980–2008 (Reihe 4.3.1 (ed.)). Wiesbaden: Statisches Bundesamt (2009)

Thurow, L.C.: Generating inequality. Basic Books, New York (1975)

Tiemann, M.: Actual changes in the world of work. Development of the division of labor in Germany since 1979. Paper presented at 17th ILERA World Congress 2015, “The Changing World of Work: Implications for Labour and Employment Relations and Social Protection”, Cape Town, ZA (2015)

Verhaest, D., Van der Velden, R.: Cross-country differences in graduate overeducation. Eur. Sociol. Rev. 29(3), 642–653 (2013)