Does piracy lead to product abandonment or stimulate new product development?: Evidence from mobile platform‐based developer firms
Tóm tắt
With the growth of digital platforms, understanding the role of property rights on those platforms has become increasingly important. Digital piracy, the unauthorized copying and distribution of digital products, is therefore an important strategic issue, both because of lost revenues and because it is thought to decrease innovation. Yet, while the latter effect is often argued, empirical evidence is limited. We study whether piracy affects innovation and whether it leads firms to shift to different types of innovations. By studying a large piracy event in a mobile app marketplace, we find that piracy leads to a decrease in the release of incremental innovations, such as bug fixes, but does not decrease more substantial revisions. Additionally, it is associated with subsequent new product development.
For many platform companies, a critical issue is understanding how piracy and imitation should be regulated, motivated in part by a common narrative that piracy will eliminate innovation on these platforms. The present article suggests that these effects are slightly more nuanced. We find that piracy does lead to a decline in incremental innovations, such as bug fixes or appearance tweaks, but no discernible decline in more major innovations, such as feature updates or entirely new versions. This implies that piracy can shape the type of innovation, potentially leading to products that are less polished and refined but not affecting the overall level of innovation.
Từ khóa
Tài liệu tham khảo
Belleflamme P., 2012, The Oxford handbook of the digital economy
Bloom N., 2005, Competition and innovation: An inverted‐U relationship, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 120, 701
Bradley W. A. &Kolev J.(2019).Can piracy increase innovation? The software industry's response to online file sharing. Working paper.
BSA, 2016, BSA global software survey
Buccafuso C., 2013, Do bad things happen when works enter the public domain?: Empirical tests of copyright term extension, Berkeley Technology Law Journal, 28, 1
Danaher B., 2017, Digital piracy, film quality and social welfare, George Mason Law Review, 23, 923
Giorcelli M., 2017, Copyrights and creativity—Evidence from Italian operas
Godinho de Matos M., 2017, The effect of subscription Videoon‐demand on piracy: Evidence from a household‐level randomized experiment, Management Science, 64, 5461
Goldfarb A., 2014, Economics of digitization, 13
Graham S. J. H., 2009, High technology entrepreneurs and the patent system: Results of the 2008 Berkeley patent survey, Berkeley Technology Law Journal, 24, 1255
Koetsier J., 2018, The mobile economy has a $17.5B leak: App piracy
Sakakibara M., 2001, Do stronger patents induce more innovation? Evidence from the 1998 Japanese patent law reforms, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 32, 77
Schumpeter J. A., 1939, Capitalism, socialism and democracy
Shapiro C., 1998, Information rules: A strategic guide to the network economy
SIIA, 2018, Internet anti‐piracy program