Community Governance and Pastorship in Shanghai: A Case Study of Luwan District
Tóm tắt
The current literature on Chinese urban studies and governmentality undertheorises the reform of local governance with regard to the activation and empowerment of community in China. Inspired by Dean’s and Sigley’s discussions of non-liberal or ‘Chinese governmentality’, this paper seeks to understand and conceptualise one of China’s most noted examples of community development, the so-called Shanghai model, using the Foucauldian concept of pastorship. Understood here as distinct from the notion of ‘advanced liberal’ governmentality, it is argued that Shanghai’s community governance depends on the governing concepts and technologies associated with the socio-political construction of the ‘pastoral’ relationship between local Party leaders and citizens. By focusing on the case study of Luwan district and one of its grass-roots community organisations (Wuliqiao Street Office), this paper will demonstrate the characteristics, institutionalisation and limitations of, pastoral governance.
Từ khóa
Tài liệu tham khảo
Beck U., 1999, World Risk Society
Chen Y. F., 2003, Strategy and Management, 6, 87
Dean M., 1999, Governmentality: Power and Rule in Modern Society: Foucault, Power and Social Structure
Delanty G., 2003, Community
DuoJi C. R., 2003, The Reader of Urban Community Construction
Foucault M., 2002, Michel Foucault: The Essential Works: Power, 298
Gu J., 2000, The community mediation and social stability: a research report of Shanghai Luwan District WuLiQiao Street Office
Habermas J., 1975, Legitimation Crisis
Howell J., 2004, Governance in China
Hu J. T., 2003, The Yearbook of Community Development in China
Hu J. T., 2009, The President’s Order Number 16 (27th/June/2009)
Imrie R., 2004, New Horizons in British Urban Policy: Perspectives on New Labour’s Urban Renaissance, 129
LCPC (Luwan Communist Party Committee), 2002, The internal institutions of WSO
LDG (Luwan District Government), 2005, Luwan eleventh five-year national economy and social development plan
Lin S. L., 2003, Community Democracy and Governance: Case Studies
Lin W. I., 2010, Chinese Administration, 82, 23
Organisation Department of SCPC (Shanghai Communist Party Committee), 2008, Shanghai’s two initiatives (Shunag Chuang Huo Dong) of expanding and strengthening the party construction of community
Ren Y., 2006, Globalisation and the Chinese City, 292
Robinson J., 2006, Ordinary City: Between Modernity and Development
Rose N., 2006, The Anthropology of the State: A Reader, 144
SCAB (Shanghai Civil Affairs Bureau), 2000, Community Development Report of Shanghai 1996–2000
SCPC (Shanghai Communist Party Committee), 1996, Community Development Report of Shanghai 1996–2000, 527
Walker R., 2007, New Left Review, 46, 39
WSO (WuLiQiao Street Office), 2000, The research and principle of community development in WuLiQiao Street Office, Luwan District, Shanghai
WSO, 2006, Annual review of WSO (2003–2005)
Wu Z. H., 2002, Government’s Research of Legal System (Shanghai), 5, 1
Xu D. M., 2005, Civilisation and Civilised City: A Research of National Framework for Assessing Civilised Cities
Zhang J. S., 2004, Chinese Social Sciences, 2
Zhao M., 2003, Community Development Planning: Theory and Practice
Zhu J. G., 1997, Strategy and Administration, 4