Comment on “History, Origins and Prediction of Elastohydrodynamic Friction” by Spikes and Jie
Tóm tắt
Progress in the classical field of EHL has for decades been paralyzed by the assumption that shear thinning should be indistinguishable from the shear dependence of the viscosity of a liquid heated by viscous dissipation and that the parameters of this simple shear dependence can be obtained from the shape of a friction curve. In the last few years, by abandoning this assumption and employing real viscosity measured with viscometers, there has been revolutionary progress in predicting film thickness and friction. Now, Spikes and Jie conclude that the previous assumption has as much merit as the use of viscosity measured in viscometers. This suggestion may be popular among those who wish to ignore viscometer measurements in favor of extracting properties from friction curves. However, within the subject article, there are numerous misstatements of fact and misrepresentations by omission, and the recent progress using real viscosity is not acknowledged. The debate has degenerated into a friction curve fitting competition which is not helpful. The great progress of the last few years would not have been possible using the concepts and methods espoused in this article.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Liu, Y., Wang, Q.J., Bair, S., Vergne, P.: A quantitative solution for the full shear-thinning EHL point contact problem including traction. Tribol. Lett. 28(2), 171–181 (2007)
Jang, J.Y., Khonsari, M.M., Bair, S.: On the elastohydrodynamic analysis of shear-thinning fluids. Proc. R. Soc. A 463(2088), 3271–3290 (2007)
Liu, Y., Wang, Q.J., Krupka, I., Hartl, M., Bair, S.: The shear-thinning elastohydrodynamic film thickness of a two-component mixture. J. Tribol. 130(2), 021502 (2008)
Krupka, I., Bair, S., Kumar, P., Khonsari, M.M., Hartl, M.: An experimental validation of the recently discovered scale effect in generalized Newtonian EHL. Tribol. Lett. 33(2), 127–135 (2009)
Martini, A., Bair, S.: The role of fragility in EHL entrapment. Tribol. Int. 43(1), 277–282 (2010)
Krupka, I., Kumar, P., Bair, S., Khonsari, M.M., Hartl, M.: The effect of load (pressure) for quantitative EHL film thickness. Tribol. Lett. 37(3), 613–622 (2010)
Habchi, W., Vergne, P., Bair, S., Andersson, O., Eyheramendy, D., Morales-Espejel, G.E.: Influence of pressure and temperature dependence of thermal properties of a lubricant on the behaviour of circular TEHD contacts. Tribol. Int. 43(10), 1842–1850 (2010)
Habchi, W., Bair, S., Vergne, P.: On friction regimes in quantitative elastohydrodynamics. Tribol. Int. 58, 107–117 (2013)
Habchi, W., Bair, S., Qureshi, F., Covitch, M.: A film thickness correction formula for double-Newtonian shear-thinning in rolling EHL circular contacts. Tribol. Lett. 50(1), 59–66 (2013)
Björling, M., Habchi, W., Bair, S., Larsson, R., Marklund, P.: Towards the true prediction of ehl friction. Tribol. Int. 66, 19–26 (2013)
Björling, M., Habchi, W., Bair, S., Larsson, R., Marklund, P.: Friction reduction in elastohydrodynamic contacts by thin-layer thermal insulation. Tribol. Lett. 53(2), 477–486 (2014)
Spikes, H., Jie, Z.: History, origins and prediction of elastohydrodynamic friction. Tribol. Lett. (2014). doi:10.1007/s11249-014-0396-y
Kleinschmidt, R.V., Bradbury, D., Mark, M.: Viscosity and density of over forty lubricating fluids of known composition at pressures to 150,000 psi and temperatures to 425 F. ASME, New York (1953)
Bair, S.: Roelands’ missing data. Proc. Inst. Mech. Eng Part J. 218(1), 57–60 (2004)
Bair, S.: A critical assessment of the role of viscometers in quantitative elastohydrodynamics. Tribol. Trans. 55(3), 394–399 (2012)
Mooney, M.: A theory of the viscosity of a Maxwellian elastic liquid. Trans. Soc. Rheol. 1(1), 63–94 (1957)
Alfrey, T.A.: Mechanical Behavior of High Polymers, p. 87. Interscience, New York (1948)
Greenwood, J. A.: Non-Newtonian lubrication. Elsevier Tribology Series, 39, Proceedings of the 27th Leeds/Lyon Symposium, 2000, Tribology Research from Model Experiment to Industrial Problem. 723–732 (2001)
Bair, S., Winer, W. O. A rheological basis for concentrated contact friction. Elsevier Tribology Series, 27, Proceedings of the 20th Leeds/Lyon Symposium, 1993, Dissapative Processes in Tribology. 37–44 (1994)
Champion, J.V., Meeten, G.H.: Flow birefringence in simple liquids. Trans. Faraday Soc. 64, 238–247 (1968)
Bair, S.: Normal stress difference in liquid lubricants sheared under high pressure. Rheol. Acta 35(1), 13–23 (1996)
Bair, S., McCabe, C.: A study of mechanical shear bands in liquids at high pressure. Tribol. Int. 37(10), 783–789 (2004)
Berg, R.F.: Fluids near a critical point obey a generalized Cox–Merz rule. J. Rheol. 48(6), 1365–1373 (2004)
Gerrard, J.E., Steidler, F.E., Appledoorn, J.K.: Viscous heating in capillaries. Adiabatic case. Ind. Eng. Chem. Fundam. 4(3), 332–339 (1965)
Hahn, S.J., Eyring, H., Higuchi, I., Ree, T.: Flow properties of lubricating oils under pressure. NLGI Spokesm. 21(3), 123–128 (1958)
Norton, A.E., Knott, M.J., Muenger, J.R.: Flow properties of lubricants under high pressure. Trans. ASME. 63(7), 631–643 (1941)
Bair, S., Winer, W.O.: A new high-pressure, high-shear stress viscometer and results for lubricants. Tribol. Trans. 36(4), 721–725 (1993)
Bair, S.: Recent developments in high-pressure rheology of lubricants. Elsevier Tribology Series, 30, Proceedings of the 21st Leeds-Lyon Symposium on Tribology, 1994, Lubricants and Lubrication. 169–187 (1995)
Spikes, H.: Basics of EHL for practical application. Lubr. Sci. (2014). doi:10.1002/ls.1271
Cook, R.L., King Jr, H.E., Herbst, C.A., Herschbach, D.R.: Pressure and temperature dependent viscosity of two glass forming liquids: glycerol and dibutyl phthalate. J. Chem. Phys. 100(7), 5178–5189 (1994)
Bair, S., Winer, W. O.: The pressure-viscosity coefficient at Hertz pressure and its relation to concentrated contact traction. Elsevier Tribology Series, 38, Proceedings of the 26th Leeds-Lyon Symposium, Thinning Films and Tribological Interfaces. 433–443 (2000)
Poll, G.W.G., Wang, D.: Fluid rheology, traction/creep relationships and friction in machine elements with rolling contacts. Proc. Inst. Mech. Eng. Part J 226(6), 481–500 (2012)
Carter, F.J.: On the action of a locomotive driving wheel. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. Ser. A. 112, 151–157 (1926)
Bair, S.: The nature of the logarithmic traction gradient. Tribol. Int. 35(9), 591–597 (2002)
Bair, S.: High pressure rheology for quantitative elastohydrodynamics (Tribology Series 54), pp. 12–13. Elsevier, Amsterdam (2007)
Bair, S., Winer, W.O.: The high shear stress rheology of liquid lubricants at pressures of 2 to 200 MPa. J. Tribol. 112(2), 246–253 (1990)
Bair, S., Roland, C.M., Casalini, R.: Fragility and the dynamic crossover in lubricants. Proc. Inst. Mech. Eng. Part J 221(7), 801–811 (2007)
Bair, S.: A Critical evaluation of film-thickness-derived pressure-viscosity coefficients. Lubr. Sci. (2014). doi:10.1002/ls.1284
Bair, S., Vergne, P., Marchetti, M.: The effect of shear-thinning on film thickness for space lubricants. Tribol. Trans. 45(3), 330–333 (2002)
Bair, S.: Actual Eyring models for thixotropy and shear-thinning: experimental validation and application to EHD. J. Tribol. 126(4), 728–732 (2004)
Bair, S., Qureshi, F.: Ordinary shear thinning behavior and its effect upon EHL film thickness. Elsevier Tribology Series, 41, Proceedings of the 29th Leeds-Lyon Symposium, Tribological Research and Design for Engineering Systems. 693-699 (2003)
Kumar, P., Bair, S., Khonsari, M.: Full EHL simulations using the actual Ree–Eyring model for shear-thinning lubricants. J. Tribol. 131(1), 011802 (2009)