China and biofuels: legal and policy issues in the framework of the WTO system
Tóm tắt
The aim of this article is to provide an overview of policy and legislative measures adopted by China in the field of biofuel production and to assess them in the light of WTO law and recent jurisprudence relating to renewable energy. The article first provides a short overview of biofuels development in China, starting from the initial enthusiasm for fossil fuel substitution up to current concerns about the impact of biofuel production on food security. It then focusses on the legal discipline applying to biofuel production, taking into account, in particular, the existence of fiscal measures, subsidies, technical requirements, investment regulations and tariff measures. In the second part, these measures are analyzed in the light of WTO legal categories, in order to understand China’s position, both as a complainant and as a defendant, in actual and potential disputes regarding renewable energy. In order to provide a more complete picture of the legal issues concerning biofuels, similar measures adopted by other countries (especially the EU) will also be examined.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Bigdeli SZ (2010) Incentive schemes to promote renewables and the WTO law of subsidies. In: Cottier T, Nartova O, Bigdeli SZ (eds) International trade regulation and the mitigation of climate change. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 155–192
Bouët A, Laborde Debuquet D (2010) The economics of export taxes in the context of food security. In: The economic impact of export restrictions on raw materials. OECD, Paris, pp 59–78
Burrell A, Gay S, Kavallari H (2002) The compatibility of EU biofuel policies with global sustainability and the WTO. World Econ 35:784–798
Chiavari J, Withana S (2009) The impacts of EU policies for the development and use of biofuels on sustainable development in developing countries. Studia Diplomatica 62:61–83
Cloots AS (2011) Biofuels and the right to food: an uneasy partnership. In: De Schutter O, Cordes KY (eds) Accounting for hunger: the right to food in the era of globalisation. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 95–134
Cosbey A, Mavroidis P (2014) A turquoise mess: green subsidies, blue industrial policy and renewable energy: the case for redrafting the subsidies agreement of the WTO. J Int Econ Law 17:11–47
Douma W (2010) Legal aspects of the European Union’s biofuels policy: protection or protectionism. Ger Yearb Int Law 53:371–420
Feehan J, Petersen JA (2003) A framework for evaluating the environmental impact of biofuel use. In: Biomass and agriculture. OECD, Paris, pp 151–167
Frederick H, Tuan F, Wang X, Cao Z (2009) China is using more corn for industrial products. http://www.ers.usda.gov/media/153522/fds09k01.pdf
Howse R, van Bork P, Hebebrand C (2009) WTO Disciplines and biofuels: opportunities and constraints in the creation of a global marketplace. http://www.globalbioenergy.org/uploads/media/0610_Rob_Howse_-_WTO_Disciplines_and_Biofuels.pdf
Josling TE, Blandford D (2009) Biofuels subsidies and the green box. In: Cottier T, Nartova O, Bigdeli SZ (eds) International trade regulation and the mitigation of climate change. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 530–568
Kulovesi K, Morgera E, Muñoz M (2011) Environmental integration and multi-faceted international dimensions of EU law: unpacking the EU’s 2009 climate and energy package. Common Market Law Rev 48:829–891
Lydgate EB (2012) Biofuels, sustainability, and trade-related regulatory chill. J Int Econ Law 15:157–180
Qiu H et al (2012) Liquid biofuels in China: current status, government policies, and future opportunities and challenges. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 16:3095–3104
Rubini L (2012) Ain’t Wastin’ time no more: subsidies for renewable energy, the SCM agreement, policy space, and law reform. J Int Econ Law 15:525–579
Shiyan C, Lili Z, Timilsina GR, Xiliang Z (2009) Development of biofuels in China. http://elibrary.worldbank.org/doi/book/10.1596/1813-9450-6243
Sindico F (2008) The EU and carbon leakage: how to reconcile border adjustments with the WTO? Eur Energy Environ Law Rev 17:328–340
Swinbank A, Daugbjerg C (2013) Improving EU biofuels policy? Greenhouse gas emissions, policy efficiency, and WTO compatibility. J World Trade 47:813–834
Vergano PR, Laurenza E (2010) Subsidies to renewable energy sources and international trade: issues and tools to reconcile trade rules and environmental policies. Glob Trade Cust J 5:223–236
Vergano PR, Laurenza E (2012) Fossil fuel ‘grading and sustainability criteria for biofuels and bioliquids under the EU fuel and renewable energy directive: implications for international trade. Glob Trade Cust J 7:92–102
Wang H (2011) Building a regulatory framework for biofuels governance in China: legislation as the starting point. Nat Resour Forum 35:201–212
Wilke M (2009) Feed-in tariffs for renewable energy and WTO subsidy rules—an initial legal review. http://www.ictsd.org/downloads/2011/11/feed-in-tariffs-for-renewable-energy-and-wto-subsidy-rules.pdf
Zhao J (2013) Developed countries’ cap-and-trade border measures: China’s possible reactions. Chin J Int Law 12:809–842