Channel Conflict and Coordination in the E‐Commerce Age
Tóm tắt
A number of factors, including developments in Internet‐based commerce and third‐party logistics, have led many companies to consider engaging in direct sales. Such a company may at once be both a supplier to and a direct competitor of any existing reseller partners (e.g., land‐based retailers), which can result in “channel conflict.” This can have momentous implications for distribution strategy.
To generate managerial insights into this important issue, we develop a model that captures key attributes of such a setting, including various sources of inefficiency. We examine these in detail and identify a number of counterintuitive structural properties. For instance, the addition of a direct channel alongside a reseller channel is not necessarily detrimental to the reseller, given the associated adjustment in the manufacturer's pricing. In fact, both parties can benefit.
Finally, we examine ways to adjust the manufacturer‐reseller relationship that have been observed in industry. These include changes in wholesale pricing, paying the reseller a commission for diverting customers toward the direct channel, or conceding the demand fulfillment function entirely to the reseller. The latter two schemes could be mutually beneficial in that they achieve a division of labor according to each channel's competitive advantage.
Từ khóa
Tài liệu tham khảo
Ahn H., 2002, Price competition between retailers and manufacturer‐owned stores
Axsater S., 1993, Handbooks in operations re search and management science, vol. 4 (Logistics of production and inventory), 175
Bannon L. 2000. Selling Barbie online may pit Mattel vs. stores. The Wall Street Journal, November 17 B1.
Bell D. R., 2002, An explanation for partial forward integration: Why manufacturers become marketers
Boyaci T., 2001, Manufacturer‐retailer competition and coordination in a dual distribution system
Brooker K., 1999, Fortune, 140, 28
Bucklin C. B., 1997, The McKinsey Quarterly
Chiang W. K., 2002, Direct marketing, indirect profits: A strategic analysis of dual‐channel supply chain design
Cohen M. A., 1999, Inter faces, 29, 1
Collinger T., 1998, Advertising Age
Federgruen A., 1993, Handbooks in operations re search and management science, vol. 4 (Logistics of production and inventory), 133
Garner R. 1999. Mad as hell. Sales & Marketing Management June 1 54.
Ghosh S., 1998, Harvard Business Review, 76, 126
Girishankar S. 1998. IBM to sell product line over Web. CMP TechWeb February 19.
Goldman A. 1999. Battle for Web customers pits retailer against manufacturer; Internet: now that product makers can open virtual shops accessible to every online customer, traditional merchants are beginning to show their displeasure. Los Angeles Times August 8 C‐1.
Hamel G., 1998, Fortune, 138, 88
Hendershott T., 2001, A model of direct and intermedi ated sales
Janah M. 1999. Tech firms slow to use direct web sales. San Jose Mercury News February 24 C1.
Kravetz S. 1999. Mattel's new retail plan aims to boost direct sales. The Wall Street Journal Europe February 18.
Machlis S. 1998a. Channel conflicts stall web sales. Computerworld February 16 2.
Machlis S., 1998, Com puterworld
Machlis S., 1998, Com puterworld
Margretta J., 1998, Harvard Business Review, 76, 73
McAfee R., 1994, The American Economic Review, 84, 210
McGuire T. W., 1986, Research in marketing, 8, 181
McIntyre S. J., 1997, Direct marketing
McWilliams G., 1998, The Wall Street Journal
Moorthy K. S., 1993, Handbooks in operations research and management science, vol. 5, 143
Muckstadt J. A., 1993, Handbooks in operations research and management science, vol. 4 (Logistics of production and inventory), 59
Naert P. A., 1971, Manage ment Science, 18, 90
Nasireti R., 1998, The Wall Street Journal
Peleg B., 2002, Secondary markets for product diversion with potential manufacturer's intervention
Reinhardt G., 2001, Virtual versus bricks‐and‐mortar retailing
Rhee B., 2001, A hybrid channel system in competition with net‐only direct marketers
Rhee B., 2000, Online stores as a new direct channel and emerging hybrid channel system
Schmid J., 1999, Catalog Age
Schonfeld E., 1998, Fortune, 138, 114
Stern L. W., 1996, Marketing channels, 5th edition
Tirole J., 1988, The theory of industrial organization
Tsay A. A., 2002, Supply chain analysis in the eBusiness era
Yamey B. S., 1954, The economics of resale price maintenance