Animal bones in old graves: a zooarchaeological and contextual study on faunal remains and new dated evidence for the ritual re-use of old cemetery sites in Southern and Western Finland

Archaeological and Anthropological Sciences - Tập 12 - Trang 1-15 - 2020
Auli Bläuer1,2
1Production Systems, Natural Resources Institute Finland, Turku, Finland
2Archaeology, University of Turku, Turku, Finland

Tóm tắt

Animal remains from twelve Iron Age (ca. 500 BC–1200/1300AD) sites from Southern and Western Finland, showing a mixture of finds and features typical of both settlement sites and cemeteries, were investigated using a zooarchaeological, taphonomic and contextual approach. Rarefaction analysis of the species richness and anatomical distribution indicates that the samples included both general domestic waste type and species and element-selective deposits of cattle and horse skulls, mandibles and limb bones. According to radiocarbon dating results, there seems to be a gap between the dates of burials and those of other ritual activities, indicating that the context of such deposits is a disused cemetery. The faunal deposits could represent remembrance rituals or relate to votive offerings intended to ensure healthy or productive livestock, a practice described in later ethnographic sources. These deposits seem to be in use within a large geographical area over a long period, and some aspects of this belief system may even have survived into the Christianisation of society in the historical period.

Tài liệu tham khảo

Äikäs T, Puputti AK, Núñez M, Aspi J, Okkonen J (2009) Sacred and profane livelihood: animal bones from Sieidi sites in northern Finland. Nor Archaeol Rev 42(2):109–122 Andors AV (1977) An Iron Age fauna from Retulansaari, Southern Finland. Osteological report. Archives of NBA, Finland Asplund H (2008) Kymittæ. Sites, centrality and long-term settlement change in the Kemiönsaari region in SW Finland. Turun yliopiston julkaisuja series B, part 312. University of Turku, Turku Asplund H (2011) Early Bronze Age cairn dates from burned bone. In: Harjula J, Helamaa M, Haarala J (eds) Times, things and places. 36 essays for Jussi-Pekka Taavitsainen. Juhlatoimikunta, Turku, pp 42–59 Asplund H, Moisio J, Salomaa S, Bläuer A (2019) Digging deeper into an Iron Age cairn – rethinking Roismala Ristimäki in Sastamala. Finland Fennosc Archaeol XXXVI:83–104 Bell C (1992) Ritual theory, ritual practice. Oxford University Press, New York Bläuer A (2017) Myöhäisrautakauden ja keskiajan koti- ja riistaeläimet sekä maatiaisrodut. In: Lesell K, Meriluoto M, Raninen S (eds) Tursiannotko. Tutkimuksia hämäläiskylästä viikinkiajalta keskiajalle. Tampereen museoiden julkaisuja 148. Tampereen museot, Tampere pp 93-103 Bläuer A, Kantanen J (2013) Transition from hunting to animal husbandry in Southern, Western and Eastern Finland: new dated osteological evidence. J Archaeol Sci 40:1646–1666 Bläuer A, Korkeakoski-Väisänen K, Arppe L, Kantanen J (2013) Bronze Age cattle teeth and cremations from a monumental burial cairn in Selkäkangas, Finland: new radiocarbon-dates and isotopic analysis. Estonian J Archaeol 17(1):3–23 Bläuer A, Harjula J, Helamaa M, Lehto H, Uotila K (2019) Zooarchaeological evidence of large-scale cattle metapodial processing in the 18th century in the small town of Rauma. Finland Post Medieval Archaeol 53:172–185. https://doi.org/10.1080/00794236.2019.1654737 Broderick LG (2012) Ritualisation (or the four fully articulated ungulates of the apocalypse). In: Pluskowski A (ed) The ritual killing and burial of animals. European Perspectives. Oxbow books, Oxford, pp 22–32 Bull G, Payne S (1982) Tooth eruption and epiphysial fusion in pigs and wild boar. In: Wilson B, Grigson C, Payne S (eds) Ageing and sexing animal bones from archaeological sites. BAR British Series 109. BAR publishing, Oxford, pp 55–71 Carlie A (2004) Forntida byggnadskult. Tradition och regionalitet i södra Skandinavien. Arkeologiska undersökningar, Skrifter No. 57. Riksantikvarieämbetet, Stockholm Deckwirth V (2008) Tutkimuksia Suomen rannikon kulttuuripiirin varhaismetallikauden karjataloudesta eräiden asuinpaikkojen arkeo-osteologisen aineiston ja vertailualueiden tietojen valossa. Master’s thesis, Department of Archaeology, University of Helsinki Fischer R, Luoto J (1983) Paimio Spurila. Koekaivausraportti. Rautakautinen polttokenttäkalmisto15.7.-15.8. 1982. Excavation report, University of Turku, Archives of the Department of Archaeology Formisto T (1996) Osteological material. In: Purhonen P (ed) Vainionmäki- a Merovingian period cemetery in Laitila, Finland. Helsinki, National Board of Antiquities, pp 81–87 Frog (2017) Myöhäisrautakautinen uskonto ja mytologia Suomessa. In: Lesell K, Meriluoto M, Raninen S (eds) Tursiannotko. Tutkimuksia hämäläiskylästä viikinkiajalta keskiajalle. Tampereen museoiden julkaisuja 148. Tampereen museot, Tampere, pp 105–126 Gaastra JS (2017) Animal remains from ritual sites: a cautionary tale from the eastern Adriatic. Int J Osteoarchaeol 28:18–30. https://doi.org/10.1002/oa.2627 Gifford-Gonzalez D (2018) An introduction to Zooarchaeology. Springer, Cham Grant A (1982) The use of tooth wear as a guide to the age of domestic ungulates. In: Wilson B, Grigson C, Payne S (eds) Ageing and sexing animal bones from archaeological sites. BAR British Series 109. BAR publishing, Oxford, pp 91–108 Grimes RL (2014) The craft of ritual studies. Oxford University Press, Oxford Hammer Ø (2020) PAST: paleontological statistics. Version 4.01. http://folk.uio.no/ohammer/past/index.Html (accessed March 2020) Hårding B (2002) Människan och djuren om dagligt liv och begravningsritualer under järnåldern. In: Viklund K, Gullberg K (eds) Från Romartid till Vikingatid. Acta Antiqua Ostrobotniensia. Studia Archaeologica Universitatis Umensis, vol 15. Umeå University, Umeå, pp 213–222 Hill JD (1995) Ritual and rubbish in the Iron Age of Wessex. BAR British archaeological report series 242. BAR publishing, Oxford Holmblad P (2013) Luolamiehistä talonpojiksi. Pohjanmaan muinaisuus sanoin ja kuvin. Scriptum, Vaasa Hukantaival S (2016) “For a witch cannot cross such a threshold!” building concealment traditions in Finland c. 1200–1950. Archaeologia Medii Aevi Finlandiae XXIII. SKAS, Helsinki Hukantaival S, Bläuer A (2017) Ritual deposition of animals in late Iron age Finland: a case-study of the Mulli settlement site in Raisio. Estonian J Archaeol 21(2):161–185 Insoll T (2004) Archaeology, ritual, religion. Routledge Taylor & Francis Group, London Kivikoski E (1969) Esihistoriallinen aika. In: Laitilan historia 1. Laitilan kunnan ja seurakunnan asettama historiatoimikunta, Laitila Koivisto L (1988) Nokian Viikin rautakautisen kumpukalmiston kaivaus 1987. Kaivausraportti. Excavation report, University of Turku, archives of the Department of Archaeology Koli L (1969) Osteologinen raportti (määritykset Elaine Anderson, Olavi Kalela, Bjorn Kurtén ja Lauri Koli). In: Sarkamo J Tyrväntö Retulansaari. Kaivauskertomus. Excavation report. Archives of NBA, Finland Kotivuori H (1992) Dwelling-site finds from the Middle Iron Age fieldwork at Kalaschabrannan in Maalahti, southern Ostrobothnia 1987-1989. Fennosc Archaeol IX:57–74 Krohn K (1915) Suomalaisten runojen uskonto. Suomen suvun uskonnot 1. SKS, Helsinki Kunen JL, Galindo MJ, Chase E (2002) Pits and bones: identifying Maya ritual behavior in the archaeological record. Anc Mesoam. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0956536102132032 Lahtinen M, Oinonen M, Tallavaara M, Walker James WP, Rowley-Conwy P (2017) The advance of cultivation at its northern European limit: process or event? Holocene 27:427–438 Lehtosalo P-L (1964) Kertomus kaivauksesta, jonka hum. kand. Pirkko-Liisa Lehtosalo suoritti kesäkuussa 1962 ja elokuussa 1963 Laitilan pitäjän Palttilan kylässä Simo Pohjalaisen omistaman talon pihamaalla. Excavation report, Finnish Heritage Agency archives Lempiäinen-Avci M (2017) Elämää Pirkanmaalla rautakaudella-ruokaa ja rohtoa. In: Lesell K, Meriluoto M, Raninen S (eds) Tursiannotko. Tutkimuksia hämäläiskylästä viikinkiajalta keskiajalle. Tampereen museoiden julkaisuja 148. Tampereen museot, Tampere, pp 79–90 Lentacker A, Ervynck A, Van Neer W (2004) Gastronomy or religion? The animal remains from the Mithraeum at Iienen (Belgium). In: O’Day SJ, Van Neer W, Ervynck A (eds) Behaviour behind bones: the Zooarchaeology of ritual, religion, status and identity. Oxbow Books, Oxford, pp 77–94 Lepokorpi N (1976) Vammala Kalliala. Kertomus kummun numero 1 tutkimisesta 10.6.-28.6. 1974. Excavation report, University of Turku, Archives of the Department of Archaeology Luho V (1953) Kertomus Tutkimuksista Tyrvännön Retulansaaren rautakautisessa kalmistossa toukokuussa v . 1953. Excavation report, Finnish Heritage Agency archives Luoto J (1985) Archaeological excavations at Spurila 1982-1985. Iskos 5:451–459 Luoto J, Pärssinen M, Seppä-Heikka M (1983) Grain impressions in ceramics from Ristimäki, Vammala. Finland Finskt Mus 1981:5–33 Lyman RL (1994) Vertebrate Taphonomy. Cambridge manuals in Archaeology. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge Lyman RL (2018) Observations on the history of zooarchaeological quantitative units: why NISP, then MNI, then NISP again? J Archaeol Sci Rep 18:43–50 Lyman RL, Ames KM (2007) On the use of species-area curves to detect the effects of sample size. J Archaeol Sci 34:1985–1990 Macheridis S (2017) Symbolic connotations of animals at early middle Helladic Asine. Opuscula 10:128–152 Magnell O (2012) Sacred cows or old beasts? A Taphonomic approach to studying ritual killing with an example from Iron Age Uppåkra, Sweden. In: Pluskowski A (ed) The ritual killing and burial of animals. European perspectives. Oxbow books, Oxford, pp 195–19l Mäntylä-Asplund S, Storå J (2010) On the archaeology and osteology of the Rikala cremation cemetery in Salo. SW-Finland Fennosc Archaeol XXVII:53–68 Marjakorpi T (1910) Vanha uhritapa Heinolan pitäjästä. Kotiseutu 4:59–60 Merrifield R (1988) The archaeology of ritual and magic. New Amsterdam Books, New York Morris J (2012) Animal ‘ritual’ killing: from remains to meanings. In: Pluskowski A (ed) The ritual killing and burial of animals. European Perspectives. Oxbow books, Oxford, pp 8–21 Muhonen T (2008) Uhri ja röykkiö- rautakauden uhriröykkiöt tutkimushistorian, kansanperinteen ja arkeologisen aineiston valossa. Pro Gradu-thesis, Department of Archaeology, University of Turku Muhonen T (2009) Something old, something new: excursions into Finnish sacrificial cairns. Temenos Nord J Comp Relig 44(2):293–346 Nurminen T (1990) Nokia Haapaniemi, Tapanila. Kaivausraportti. Rautakautisen muinaisjäännöksen tutkimuskaivaukset 5.7.-28.7. 1989. Excavation report, University of Turku, Archives of the Department of Archaeology O’Connor TP (2003) The analysis of urban animal bone assemblages: a handbook for archaeologist. The archaeology of York. Principles and methods 19/2. Council for British Archaeology, York Pietikäinen T (1989) Nokia Haapaniemi, Huvilaniemi, Pääskylä. Kaivausraportti. Rautakautisen muinaisjäännöksen kaivaus ajalla 23.6.-5.8.1988. Excavation report, University of Turku, Archives of the Department of Archaeology Pihlman S (1999) Kuolema arkeologisena ilmiönä- yleistyksiä esihistoriasta. ABOA Turku Provincian Museum yearbook 59(60):62–70 Raike E, Seppälä S-L (2005) Naarankalmanmäki. An Iron Age complex in Lempäälä, Southern Finland. Fennosc Archaeol XXII, 43-78 Rajala U (1991) Nokia, Keho, Pappila. Kertomus rautakautisen hautaraunion puolikkaan tutkimuskaivauksista 3 .6. - 26.7.1991. Excavation report, University of Turku, Archives of the Department of Archaeology Raninen S (2010) Sodankäynti ja soturit rautakaudella. In: Klemettilä H (ed) Suomalainen sotilas 3: Muinaisurhosta nihtiin. Hämeenlinna, Weilin & Göös, pp 46–79 Raninen S (2017) Pirkkalan Tursiannotkon ja Lähiseudun asutus myöhäisrautakaudella (800–1200). In: Lesell K, Meriluoto M, Raninen S (eds) Tursiannotko. Tutkimuksia hämäläiskylästä viikinkiajalta keskiajalle. Tampereen museoiden julkaisuja 148. Tampereen museot, Tampere, pp 11–29 Raninen S, Wessman A (2014) Finland as a part of the ‘Viking world’. In: Ahola J, Frog, Tolley C (eds) Fibula, Fabula, fact. The Viking Age in Finland. Studia Fennica Historica 18. SKS, Helsinki, pp 327–346 Raninen S, Wessman A (2015) Rautakausi. In: Haggrén G, Halinen P, Lavento M, Raninen S, Wessman A (eds) Muinaisuutemme jäljet. Suomen esi- ja varhaishistoria kivikaudelta keskiajalle. Gaudeamus Oy, Helsinki, pp 215–365 Renvall E (1987) Kaivauskertomus Nokia Viikin kumpukalmistokaivauksista 1.7. – 8.8. 1986. Excavation report, University of Turku, Archives of the Department of Archaeology Rinne J (1906) Nokia, Pirkkala, Keho tutkimuskaivaus 1905. Excavation report, Finnish Heritage Agency archives Russell N (2012) Social Zooarchaeology. Humans and animals in prehistory. Cambridge University Press, New York Salo U (2004) Sastamalan historia 1,1. Esihistoria. Sastamalan historiatoimikunta, Sastamala Sarasmo E (1959) Kertomus kaivauksesta, jonka Hämeen Museon hoitaja, maisteri Esko Sarasmo suoritti Pälkäneen Epaalan kylän Hyllin talon maalla Muinaistieteellisen Toimikunnan varoilla ja valtuuttamana 1–29/6 1955. Excavation report, Finnish Heritage Agency archives Sarkamo J (1970) Retulansaaren uhriröykkiö. Suomen Museo 77:35–47 Sarkamo J (1984) Retulansaaren “uhriröykkiö”. In: Suomen historia 1. WSOY, Espoo p 308 Sarvas A (1976) Hattula (Tyrväntö) Retulansaari Myllymäki. Kumpare n:o 152. Excavation report, Finnish heritage agency archives Sarvas A (1977) Hattula Retulansaari Myllymäki. Kumpare n:o 152:n kaivaus. Excavation report, Finnish heritage agency archives Schultz EL, Schultz HP (1992) Hämeenlinna Varikkoniemi – eine späteisenzeitliche-frühmittelalterliche Kernsiedlung in Häme. Die Ausgrabungen 1986–1990. Suomen Museo 99:41–85 Seppälä SL (1998) Hämeenlinna Kirstula Riihimäki. Rautakautisen polttokenttäkalmiston ja mahdollisen asuinpaikan kaivaus 12.5. - 4. 7.1997. Excavation report, Finnish Heritage Agency archives Sipilä J (1983) Vammala Heinoo, Karkun vanha kirkko ja Kirkkovainionmäki. Kaivausraportti. Rautakautisen maan- ja kivansekaisen röykkiön kaivaus 22.07.-06.08.1982. Excavation report, University of Turku, Archives of the Department of Archaeology Sipilä J (1984) Vammala (ent. Karkku) Heinoo, Kirkkoniemi. Kaivausraportti. Rautakautisen maan- ja kivensekaisen röykkiön kaivaus 27.6.-30.6. 1983. Excavation report, University of Turku, Archives of the Department of Archaeology Sipilä M (1995) Nokia Keho, Pappila. Koekaivaus- ja kaivausraportti. Kertomus rautakautisen kalmiston koekaivauksesta ja kaivauksesta 6.6.-29.7.1994. Excavation report, University of Turku, Archives of the Department of Archaeology Sipilä M (1996) Nokia Keho, Pappila. Kaivausraportti. Kertomus rautakautisen kalmiston kaivauksesta 26.6.-28.7.1995. Excavation report, University of Turku, Archives of the Department of Archaeology Snoek J (2006) Defining ‘rituals’. In: Kreinath J, Snoek J, Stausberg M (eds) Theorizing rituals: issues, topics, approaches, concepts. Brill, Leiden, pp 4–14 Söderholm N (1998) Hämeenlinna, Kirstula, Riihimäki (KM 30304:). Analysis av ben. In: Seppälä, S.-L. 1998. Hämeenlinna Kirstula Riihimäki. Rautakautisen polttokenttäkalmiston ja mahdollisen asuinpaikan kaivaus 12.5. - 4. 7.1997. Excavation report, Finnish Heritage Agency archives Spoof L (1990) Nokia, Keho, Pappila. Rautakautisen hautaraunion (Osa) tutkimuskaivaus 23.7.-10.8.1990. Excavation report, University of Turku, archives of the department of archaeology Spoof L (1991) Nokia Haapaniemi, Tapanila. Kaivausraportti. Rautakautisen muinaisjäännöksen tutkimuskaivaus 18.6. – 20.7. 1990. Excavation report, University of Turku, Archives of the Department of Archaeology Taavitsainen J-P (1992) Cemeteries or refuse heaps? Archaeological formation processes and the interpretation of sites and antiquities. Suomen Museo 1991:5–14 Taavitsainen JP, Vilkuna J, Forssell H (2007) Suojoki at Keuruu : a mid 14th-century site of the wilderness culture in the light of settlement historical processes in Central Finland. Annales Academiae Scientiarum Fennicae 346. Finnish Academy of Science and Letters, Helsinki Talve I (1997) Finnish folk culture. Studia Fennica Ethnologica 4. SKS, Helsinki Tourunen A (2011) Burnt, fragmented and mixed: identification and interpretation of domestic animal bones in Finnish burnt bone assemblages. Fennosc Archaeol XXVIII: 57-69 Tupala U (1994) Nokia, Keho, Pappila. Kertomus rautakautisen hautaraunion puolikkaan tutkimuskaivauksista 7.6. - 16.7. 1993. Excavation report, University of Turku, Archives of the Department of Archaeology Uino P (1986) Iron Age Studies in Salo. I-II. Suomen muinaismuistoyhdistyksen aikakauskirja 89:1. Suomen muinaismuistoyhdistys, Helsinki Väänänen E (1965) Laitila Palttila Kylämäki. Kalmiston kaivaus. Excavation report, Finnish Heritage Agency archives Vormisto T (1985) Osteologisk bearbetning av benmaterial framgrävt av den arkeologiska institutionen vid Åbo Universitet 1975-1983. Karhunhammas 9:135–177 Vormisto T (1991) Nokia Viik. Luuanalyysi. Osteological report, University of Turku, Archives of the Department of Archaeology Vuorinen JM (2009) Rakennukset ja rakentajat Raision Ihalassa rautakauden lopulla ja varhaisella keskiajalla, Annales Universitatis Turkuensis C 281. University of Turku, Turku Waronen M (1898) Vainajainpalvelus muinaisilla suomalaisilla. SKS, Helsinki Wessman A (2010) Death, destruction and commemoration: tracing ritual activities in Finnish Late Iron Age cemeteries (AD 550-1150). Iskos 18. Finnish Antiquarian Society, Helsinki Wickholm A (2008) Reuse in Finnish cremation cemeteries under level ground – examples of collective memory. In: Fahlander F, Oestigaard T (eds) The materiality of death – bodies, burials, believes. BAR international series 1768. BAR publishing Oxford, pp 89–97 Wulf C (2006) Praxis. In: Kreinath J, Snoek J, Stausberg M (eds) Theorizing rituals: issues, topics, approaches, concepts. Brill, Leiden, pp 395–412 Yeshurun R, Bar-Oz G, Kaufman D, Weinstein-Evron M (2014) Purpose, permanence, and perception of 14,000-year-old architecture. Curr Anthropol 55:591–618. https://doi.org/10.1086/678275