Adenylate cyclase activity as a predictor of thyroid tumor aggressiveness

Prior studies in our laboratory have shown that human thyroid neoplasms have a greater adenylate cyclase activity in response to thyroid stimulating hormone (TSH) than does the adjacent histologically normal thyroid tissue. However, there is little information relating activity of the TSH receptor-adenylate cyclase system to the type of thyroid neoplasm. Thyroid tissue from 67 patients was divided by clinical and histological criteria into 6 categories: normal (59), benign tumors (20), stage 1 carcinoma—intrathyroidal involvement only (25), stage 2 carcinomaregional lymph node involvement (6), stage 3 and 4 carcinoma—tissue invasion or distant metastasis (11), and medullary carcinoma (3). Adenylate cyclase activity in an 8,000 x g thyroid membrane preparation was determined in the basal state and when maximally stimulated with 300 mU/ml TSH. The cyclase responsiveness was the ratio of TSH stimulated adenylate cyclase activity compared to basal adenylate cyclase activity. The cyclase responsiveness by category is: normal, 2.8±0.2 (mean ± SEM); benign, 17.9±2.4; stage 1 carcinoma, 9.2±1.9; stage 2 carcinoma, 4.0±1.0; stage 3 and 4 carcinoma, 1.6±0.4; and medullary carcinoma, 1.05±0.04 (for the neoplasms,p <0.02 by ANOVA). Tumor stage was the only correlate with this trend as other prognostic risk factors (age, sex, a history of neck irradiation, or papillary versus follicular histology) showed no difference in cyclase responsiveness. These studies demonstrate a consistent inverse correlation between adenylate cyclase responsiveness and tumor stage or aggressiveness. Cyclase responsiveness appears to have clinical application for predicting which thyroid tumors will behave aggressively.