A Sociological Critique of Youth Strategies and Educational Policies that Address LGBTQ Youth Issues
Tóm tắt
This paper adopts sociological and “after-queer” lenses in order to problematise anti-bullying approaches that are justified on the basis of the apparent “vulnerability” of LGBTQ youth to a range of negative mental health outcomes, including self-harm and suicidality. Subjecting recent youth strategies, educational policies and instructional resources to critical discourse analysis (Fairclough 2003), it identifies the discourse of risk/vulnerability as a dominant or “nodal” discourse around which other sub-discourses—including the discourses of homophobic bullying, isolation, suicidality, self-harm and resilience—cluster. It considers the discursive effects of this configuration of discourses which foreground or include certain aspects or experiences of being LGBTQ to the exclusion of others, resulting in a “selective representation,” “simplification” and “condensation” of a much more complex social and cultural reality (Fairclough 2005). It argues that the singling out of LGBTQ youth as being “at risk” of homophobic bullying and mental health difficulties has a range of abnormalising, othering, re-stigmatising and heteronormativity-bolstering effects that obfuscate the role that schools themselves play in creating and sustaining the conditions that produce bullying. Rather than positioning LGBTQ youth as victims, and specifically targeting those who identify as LGBTQ as the beneficiaries of anti-homophobic bullying initiatives, it advocates a range of alternative frameworks that privilege the conditions and effects of gender regulation and normativity to which all children and youth are routinely subjected. The paper concludes by highlighting the need to address school-based organisational and cultural practices in order to reduce the incidence of gender and sexuality-based bullying in schools.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Airton, L. (2013). Leave ‘those kids’ alone: On the conflation of school homophobia and suffering queers. Curriculum Inquiry, 43(5), 532–562.
Allen, L. (2014). Pleasure’s perils? Critically reflecting on pleasure’s inclusion in sexuality education. In L. Allen, M. L. Rasmussen, & K. Quinlivan (Eds.), The politics of pleasure in sexuality education: Pleasure bound (pp. 169–185). New York: Routledge.
Bailey, S. (2017). From invisibility to visibility: a policy archaeology of the introduction of anti-transphobic and anti-homophobic bullying guidelines into the Irish primary education system. Irish Educational Studies, 36(1), 25–42. https://doi.org/10.1080/03323315.2016.1243066.
Bansel, P., Davies, B., Laws, C., & Linnell, S. (2009). Bullies, bullying and power in the contexts of schooling. British Journal of Sociology of Education, 30(1), 59–69.
Bryan, A. (2017). Queer youth and mental health: What do educators need to know?. Irish Educational Studies, 36(1):73–89.
Bryan, A., & Mayock, P. (2017). Supporting LGBT Lives? Complicating the suicide consensus in LGBT mental health research. Sexualities, 20(1–2), 65–85.
Brenick, A., & Halgunseth, L. (2017). Brief note: applying developmental intergroup perspectives to the social ecologies of bullying: lessons from developmental social psychology. Journal of Adolescence, 59, 90–95.
Central Statistics Office (2018). Educational attainment thematic report. Retrived June 22, 2019 from https://www.cso.ie/en/releasesandpublications/er/eda/educationalattainmentthematicreport2017/.
Cohen, J., & Brooks, R. (2018). The construction of school bullying as a social problem. In A. Trevino (Ed.), The Cambridge handbook of social problems (pp. 237–252). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Cover, R. (2012). Queer youth suicide, culture and identity: unliveable lives? London: Ashgate.
Cover, R. (2016). Suicides of the marginalised: Cultural approaches to suicide, minorities and rationality. Cultural Studies Review, 22(2), 90–113.
Department of Children and Youth Affairs (2015). National Youth Strategy 2015–2020 Dublin: Government Publications. Retrieved from https://www.dcya.gov.ie/documents/publications/20151008NatYouthStrat2015to2020.pdf.
Department of Children and Youth Affairs. (2017). LGBTI+ National Youth Strategy: report of the consultations with young people in Ireland. Dublin: Government Publications.
Department of Children and Youth Affairs. (2018). LGBTI+ National Youth Strategy 2018–2020 LGBTI+ young people: visible, valued and included. Dublin: Government Publications.
Department of Education and Skills (2013a). Anti-bullying procedures for primary and post-primary schools. Dublin: Government of Ireland. Accessed December 23. http://www.education.ie/en/Publications/Policy-Reports/Anti-Bullying-Procedures-forPrimary-and-Post-Primary-Schools.pdf.
Department of Education and Skills (2013b). Action plan on bullying: report of the anti-bullying working group to the minister for education and skills. Accessed December 23 https://www.education.ie/en/Publications/Education-Reports/Action-Plan-On-Bullying2013.pdf .
Department of Education and Skills/Health Services Executive (2012). Growing up LGBT: a resource for SPHE and RSE. Dublin Accessed December 23 https://pdst.ie/sites/default/files/LGBT%20English%20Print.pdf.
Dooley, B. & Fitzgerald, A. (2012). My world survey: National Study of Youth Mental Health in Ireland. Dublin: Headstrong/UCD. Retrieved June 22, 2019 from: https://researchrepository.ucd.ie/bitstream/10197/4286/1/My_World_Survey_2012_Online%284%29.pdf.
Driver, S. (2008). Queer youth cultures. Albany: State University of New York Press.
Duncan, N. (2013a). Using disability models to rethink bullying in schools. Education, Citizenship and Social Justice, 8(3), 254–262. https://doi.org/10.1177/1746197913486250.
Duncan, N. (2013b). “If you tolerate this, then your children will be next.” Compulsion, compression, control, and competition in secondary schooling. International Journal on School Disaffection, 10(1), 29–45.
Eliason, M. (2010). Introduction to special issue on suicide, mental health, and youth development. Journal of Homosexuality, 58(1), 4–9.
Fahie, D. (2016). “Spectacularly exposed and vulnerable”: how Irish equality legislation subverted the personal and professional security of lesbian, gay and bisexual teachers. Sexualities, 19(4), 393–411.
Fahie, D. (2017). Faith of our fathers: lesbian, gay and bisexual teachers’ attitudes towards the teaching of religion in Irish denominational primary schools. Irish Educational Studies, 36(1), 9–24.
Fairclough, N. (2003). Analysing discourse: textual analysis for social research. New York: Routledge.
Fairclough, N. (2005). Discourse in processes of social change: “Transition” in Central and Eastern Europe. British and American Studies, 11, 9–35.
Fairclough, N. (2010). Critical discourse analysis: the critical study of language. New York: Routledge.
Fields, J. (2008). Risky lessons: sex education and social inequality. New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press.
Foody, M., Murphy, H., Downes, P., & O’Higgins-Norman, J. (2018). Anti-bullying procedures for schools in Ireland: principals’ responses and perceptions. Pastoral Care in Education: An International Journal of Personal, Social and Emotional Development, 36(2), 126–140.
Formby, E. (2015). Limitations of focussing on homophobic, biphobic and transphobic ‘bullying’ to understand and address LGBT young people’s experiences within and beyond school. Sex Education: Sexuality, Society and Learning, 15(6), 626–640.
Formby, E. (2017). How should we ‘care’ for LGBT+ students within higher education? Pastoral Care in Education, 35(3), 203–220. https://doi.org/10.1080/02643944.2017.1363811.
Foucault, M (1990) The History of Sexuality Volume 1: An introduction. London: Penguin
Gansen, H. (2017). Reproducing (and disrupting) heteronormativity: gendered sexual socialization in preschool classrooms. Sociology of Education, 90(3), 255 227. https://doi.org/10.1177/0038040717720981.
Gay and Lesbian Equality Network (2016). Being LGBT in school: A resource for post primary schools to prevent homophobic and transphobic bullying and support LGBT students. Dublin: GLEN. Retrieved June 22, 2019 from https://www.education.ie/en/Publications/EducationReports/Being-LGBT-in-School.pdf.
Gay and Lesbian Equality Network and BeLonG To (2009). Supporting LGBT lives: A study of the mental health and well-being of lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender people: key findings. Retrieved June 22, 2019 from https://lgbt.ie/wpcontent/uploads/2018/06/attachment_233_Supporting_LGBT_Lives_Key_Findings_Report_Card.pdf.
Gay and Lesbian Equality Network and BeLonG To (2016). Key findings: The LGBTIreland report: National study of the mental health and well-being of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and intersex people in Ireland. Retrieved from https://www.tcd.ie/equality/assets/docs/LGBTIrelandReport_KeyFindings.pdf.
Gilbert, J., Fields, J., Mamo, L., & Lesko, N. (2018). Intimate possibilities: the beyond bullying project and stories of LGBTQ sexuality and gender in US schools. Harvard Educational Review, 88(2), 163–183.
Hacking, I. (1999). The social construction of what? Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Harris, A., & Farrington, D. (2014). “It gets narrower”: creative strategies for re-broadening queer peer education. Sex Education: Sexuality, Society and Learning., 14(2), 144–158.
Higgins, A., Doyle, L., Downes, C., Murphy, R., Sharek, D., DeVries, J., Begley, T., McCann, E., Sheerin, F., & Smyth, S. (2016). The LGBTI Ireland report: National study of the mental health and well-being of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and intersex people in Ireland. Dublin: GLEN and BelongTo Youth Services.
Jones, T. (2013). How sex education research methodologies frame GLBTIQ students. Sex Education, 13(6), 687–701.
Kitzinger, C. (2005). Heteronormativity in action: reproducing the heterosexual nuclear family in after-hours medical calls. Social Problems, 52(4), 477–498.
Kuzmic, J. (2000). Textbooks, knowledge, and masculinity: examining patriarchy from within. In N. Lesko (Ed.), Masculinities at school (pp. 105–126). Sage.
Marshall, D. (2010). Popular culture, the ‘victim’ trope and queer youth analytics. International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education., 23(1), 65–85.
Mayock, P., Bryan, A., Carr, N., & Kitching, K. (2009). Supporting LGBT lives. A study of the mental health and well-being of lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender people. Dublin: Gay and Lesbian Equality Network and BelongTo Youth Services.
Minton, S., Dahl, T., O’Moore, M., & Donnely, T. (2008). An exploratory survey of the experiences of homophobic bullying among lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgendered young people in Ireland. Irish Educational Studies, 27(2), 177–191. https://doi.org/10.1080/03323310802021961.
Monk, D. (2011). Challenging homophobic bullying in schools: the politics of progress. International Journal of Law in Context, 7(2), 181–207.
Neary, A. (2012). Lesbian and gay teachers’ experiences of ‘coming out’ in Irish schools. British Journal of Sociology of Education, 34(4), 583–602.
Neary, A. (2017). Lesbian, gay and bisexual teachers’ ambivalent relations with parents and students while entering into a civil partnership. Irish Educational Studies, 36(1), 57–72. https://doi.org/10.1080/03323315.2017.1289702.
Neary, A. (2018). New trans* visibilities: working the limits and possibilities of gender at school. Sex Education, 18(4), 435–448.
Norman, J., & Galvin, M. (2006). Straight talk: an investigation of attitudes and experiences of homophobic bullying in second-level schools. Dublin: Department of Education and Science.
Pascoe, C. (2013). Notes on a sociology of bullying. Young men’s homophobia as gender socialization. QED: A Journal in GLBTQ Worldmaking, 1(1), 87–104.
Pascoe, C. (n.d.). Bullying as social inequality. The enemy. Retrieved October 21, 2019, from http://theenemyreader.org/bullying-as-social-inequality/.
Payne, E., Smith, M. (2012). Rethinking safe schools approaches for LGBTQ students: Changing the questions we ask. Multicultural Perspectives, 14(4), 187–193. https://doi.org/10.1080/15210960.2012.725293.
Payne, E., & Smith, M. (2013). LGBTQ kids, school safety, and missing the big picture: how the dominant bullying discourse prevents school professionals from thinking about systemic marginalization or…why we need to rethink LGBTQ bullying. QED: A Journal in GLBTQ Worldmaking, 1, 1): 1–1):36.
Payne, E., & Smith, M. (2016). Gender policing. In N. Rodriguez, W. Martino, J. Ingrey, & E. Brockenbrough (Eds.), Critical concepts in queer studies and education (pp. 127–136). New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Payne, E., & Smith, M. (2018). Violence against LGBTQ students: punishing and marginalizing difference. In H. Shapiro (Ed.), The Wiley handbook on violence in education: forms, factors, and preventions (pp. 393–416). Hoboken: Wiley.
Pearson, J., & Wilkinson, L. (2018). School experiences and educational opportunities for LGBTQ students. In B. Schneider (Ed.), Handbook of the sociology of education in the 21st century (pp. 193–218). Cham: Springer.
Quinlivan, K. (2012). Popular culture as emotional provocation: the material enactment of queer pedagogies in a high school classroom. Sex Education: Sexuality, Society and Learning, 12(5), 511–522.
Quinlivan, K. (2013). The methodological im/possibilities of researching sexuality education in schools: working queer conundrums. Sex Education: Sexuality, Society and Learning, 13(1), S56–S69.
Rand, E. (2015). “Gay boys kill themselves”: the queer figuration of the suicidal gay teen. In J. Rhodes & J. Alexander (Eds.), Sexual rhetorics: methods, identities, publics (pp. 175–187). New York: Routledge.
Rasmussen, M. L. (2006). Becoming subjects: sexualities and secondary schooling. New York: Routledge.
Rasmussen M. L., Rofes, E., Talburt S (Eds). (2004). Youth and sexualities: Pleasure, subversion, and insubordination in and out of schools. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Ringrose, J., & Renold, E. (2010). Normative cruelties and gender deviants: the performative effects of bully discourses for girls and boys in school. British Educational Research Journal, 36(4), 573–596.
Robinson, K. (2012). “Difficult citizenship”: the precarious relationships between childhood, sexuality, and access to knowledge. Sexualities, 15(3/4), 257–276.
Russell, G., Bohan, J., & Lilly, D. (2000). Queer youth: old stories, new stories. In S. Jones (Ed.), A sea of stories: the shaping power of narrative in gay and lesbian cultures (pp. 62–69). New York: Haworth.
Savin-Williams, R. (2005). The new gay teenager. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Skattebol, J. (2007). Through their mother’s eyes: the impact of heteronormative paradigms in child care on lesbian- and gay-headed families. International Journal of Equity and Innovation in Early Childhood, 5(2), 47–63.
Sinclair-Palm, J. (2017). “It’s nonexistent”: Haunting in trans youth narratives about naming. Bank street occasional paper series 37. Retrieved from http://bankstreet.edu/occasional-paper-series/37
Søndergaard, D. M. (2012). Bullying and social exclusion anxiety in schools. British Journal of Sociology of Education, 33(3), 355–372. https://doi.org/10.1080/01425692.2012.662824.
Talburt, S. (2010). ‘After-queer’: subjunctive pedagogies. International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education, 23(1), 49–64.
Talburt, S., & Rasmussen, M. L. (2010). “After-queer” tendencies in queer research. International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education, 23(1), 1–14.
Talburt, S., Roffes, E., & Rasmussen, M. L. (2004). Introduction: transforming discourses of queer youth and educational practices surrounding gender, sexuality, and youth. In M. L. Rasmussen, E. R. ML, & S. Talburt (Eds.), Youth and sexualities: pleasure, subversion, and insubordination in and out of schools (pp. 1–15). New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Temko, E. (2019). Missing structure: a critical content analysis of the Olweus bullying prevention program. Children and Society, 33, 1–12.
Waidzunas, T. (2012). Young, gay, and suicidal: dynamic nominalism and the process of defining a social problem with statistics. Science, Technology and Human Values, 37(2), 199–225.
Watson, D., Kenny, O, & McGinnity, F. (2017). A social portrait of travellers in Ireland. Dublin: ESRI. Retrieved June 22, 2019 from: https://www.esri.ie/system/files?file=media/file-uploads/2017-01/RS56.pdf.
Wilkinson, L., & Pearson, J. (2009). School culture and the well-being of same-sex-attracted youth. Gender & Society, 23(4), 542–568. https://doi.org/10.1177/0891243209339913.
Worthen, M. G.F. (2016) Hetero-cis–normativity and the gendering of transphobia. International Journal of Transgenderism, 17(1), 31–57. https://doi.org/10.1080/15532739.2016.1149538.
Yoneyama, S. (2015). Theorizing school bullying: insights from Japan. Confero, 3(2), 1–37.
Yoneyama, S., & Naito, A. (2003). Problems with the paradigm: the school as a factor in understanding bullying (with special reference to Japan). British Journal of Sociology of Education, 24(3), 315–330. https://doi.org/10.1080/01425690301894.
Youdell, D. (2009). Lessons in praxis: thinking about knowledge, subjectivity and politics, in education. In R. DePalma & E. Atkinson (Eds.), Interrogating heteronormativity in primary schools (pp. 35–50). Stoke-on-Trent: Trentham.