A Critical Review of the Durability of Adhesion to Tooth Tissue: Methods and Results
Tóm tắt
The immediate bonding effectiveness of contemporary adhesives is quite favorable, regardless of the approach used. In the long term, the bonding effectiveness of some adhesives drops dramatically, whereas the bond strengths of other adhesives are more stable. This review examines the fundamental processes that cause the adhesion of biomaterials to enamel and dentin to degrade with time. Non-carious class V clinical trials remain the ultimate test method for the assessment of bonding effectiveness, but in addition to being high-cost, they are time- and labor-consuming, and they provide little information on the true cause of clinical failure. Therefore, several laboratory protocols were developed to predict bond durability. This paper critically appraises methodologies that focus on chemical degradation patterns of hydrolysis and elution of interface components, as well as mechanically oriented test set-ups, such as fatigue and fracture toughness measurements. A correlation of in vitro and in vivo data revealed that, currently, the most validated method to assess adhesion durability involves aging of micro-specimens of biomaterials bonded to either enamel or dentin. After about 3 months, all classes of adhesives exhibited mechanical and morphological evidence of degradation that resembles in vivo aging effects. A comparison of contemporary adhesives revealed that the three-step etch-and-rinse adhesives remain the ‘gold standard’ in terms of durability. Any kind of simplification in the clinical application procedure results in loss of bonding effectiveness. Only the two-step self-etch adhesives approach the gold standard and do have some additional clinical benefits.
Từ khóa
Tài liệu tham khảo
Abdalla AI, Davidson CL -1990- Effect of mechanical load cycling on the marginal integrity of adhesive Class I resin composite restorations. J Dent 24:87–90.
Armstrong SR, Vargas MA, Fang Q, Laffoon JE -2003- Microtensile bond strength of a total-etch 3-step, total-etch 2-step, self-etch 2-step, and a self-etch 1-step dentin bonding system through 15-month water storage. J Adhes Dent 5:47–56.
Baratieri LN, Canabarro S, Lopes GC, Ritter AV -2003- Effect of resin viscosity and enamel beveling on the clinical performance of class V composite restorations: three-year results. Oper Dent 28:482–487.
Bayne SC, Heymann HO, Sturdevant JR, Wilder AD, Sluder TB -1991- Contributing co-variables in clinical trials. Am J Dent 4:247–250.
Blunck U, Roulet JF -2002- Effect of one-year water storage on the effectiveness of dentin adhesives in class V composite resin restorations -abstract- J Dent Res 81-Spec Iss B-946 -www.dentalresearch.org-
Boghosian A -1996- Clinical evaluation of a filled adhesive system in Class 5 restorations. Compend Contin Educ Dent 17:750–754.
Bouillaguet S, Duroux B, Ciucchi B, Sano H -2000- Ability of adhesive systems to seal dentin surfaces: an in vitro study. J Adhes Dent 2:201–208.
Brackett MG, Dib A, Brackett WW, Estrada BE, Reyes AA -2002- One-year clinical performance of a resin-modified glass ionomer and a resin composite restorative material in unprepared class V restorations. Oper Dent 27:112–116.
Brackett WW, Covey DA, St-Germain HA Jr -2002- One-year clinical performance of a self-etching adhesive in class V resin composites cured by two methods. Oper Dent 27:218–222.
Brackett WW, Dib A, Brackett MG, Reyes AA, Estrada BE -2003- Two-year clinical performance of class V resin-modified glass-ionomer and resin composite restorations. Oper Dent 28:477–481.
Browning WD, Brackett WW, Gilpatrick RO -2000- Two-year clinical comparison of a microfilled and a hybrid resin-based composite in non-carious class V lesions. Oper Dent 25:46–50.
Burrow MF, Tyas MJ -1999- 1-year clinical evaluation of one-step in non-carious cervical lesions. Am J Dent 12:283–285.
Cardoso PE, Placido E, Moura SK -2002- Micro-leakage of four simplified adhesive systems under thermal and mechanical stresses. Am J Dent 15:164–168.
Carvalho RM, Pereira JC, Yoshiyama M, Pashley DH -1996- A review of polymerization contraction: the influence of stress development versus stress relief. Oper Dent 21:17–24.
Castelnuovo J, Tjan AHL, Liu P -1996- Micro-leakage of multi-step and simplified-step bonding systems. Am J Dent 9:245–248.
Davidson CL, Abdalla AI -1994- Effect of occlusal load cycling on the marginal integrity of adhesive class V restorations. Am J Dent 7:111–114.
De Munck J, Van Meerbeek B, Inoue S, Vargas M, Yoshida Y, Armstrong S, et al. -2003a- Micro-tensile bond strength of one- and two-step self-etch adhesives to bur-cut enamel and dentin Am J Dent 16:414–420.
De Munck J, Van Meerbeek B, Vargas M, Iracki J, Van Landuyt K, Poitevin A, et al. -2005b- One day bonding effectiveness of new self-etch adhesives to bur-cut enamel and dentin. Oper Dent 30:39–49.
Del-Nero MO, Escribano N, de la Macorra JC -2000- Analysis of sealing vs. tensile bond strength of eight adhesive restorative material systems. J Adhes Dent 2:117–127.
Dunn WJ, Söderholm KJ -2001- Comparison of shear and flexural bond strength tests versus failure modes of dentin bonding systems. Am J Dent 14:297–303.
Eick JD, Gwinnett AJ, Pashley DH, Robinson SJ -1997- Current concepts on adhesion to dentin. Crit Rev Oral Biol Med 81:306–335.
Folwaczny M, Loher C, Mehl A, Kunzelmann KH, Hickel R -2000- Tooth-colored filling materials for the restoration of cervical lesions: a 24-month follow-up study. Oper Dent 25:251–258.
Frankenberger R, Krämer N, Petschelt A -2000- Long-term effect of dentin primers on enamel bond strength and marginal adaptation. Oper Dent 25:11–19.
Frankenberger R, Strobel WO, Kramer N, Lohbauer U, Winterscheidt J, Winterscheidt B, et al. -2003b- Evaluation of the fatigue behavior of the resin-dentin bond with the use of different methods. J Biomed Mater Res Part B: Appl Biomater 67-B-712–721.
Gladys S, Van Meerbeek B, Lambrechts P, Vanherle G -1999- Evaluation of esthetic parameters of resin-modified glass-ionomer materials and a polyacid-modified resin composite in Class V cervical lesions. Quintessence Int 30:607–614.
Grobler SR, Oberholzer TG, Rossouw RJ, Grobler-Rabie A, Van Wyk Kotze TJ -2000- Shear bond strength, micro-leakage, and confocal microscopy of 4 amalgam alloy bonding agents. Quintessence Int 31:501–508.
Gwinnett AJ, Yu S -1994- Effect of long-term water storage on dentin bonding. Am J Dent 7:109–111.
Hashimoto M, Tay FR, Ohno H, Sano H, Kaga M, Yiu C, et al. -2003b- SEM and TEM analysis of water degradation of human dentinal collagen. J Biomed Mater Res 66-B-287–298.
Hilton TJ -2002a- Can modern restorative procedures and materials reliably seal cavities? In vitro investigations. Part 1. Am J Dent 15:198–210.
Hilton TJ -2002b- Can modern restorative procedures and materials reliably seal cavities? In vitro investigations. Part 2. Am J Dent 15:279–289.
Ianzano JA, Gwinnett AJ -1993- Clinical evaluation of Class V restorations using a total etch technique: 1-year results. Am J Dent 6:207–210.
Inoue S, Vargas MA, Van Meerbeek B, Abe Y, Yoshida Y, Lambrechts P, et al. -2001b- Micro-tensile bond strength of eleven modern adhesives to dentin. J Adhes Dent 3:237–246.
Inoue S, Vargas MA, Abe Y, Yoshida Y, Lambrechts P, Vanherle G, et al. -2003- Micro-tensile bond strength of eleven contemporary adhesives to enamel. Am J Dent 16:329–334.
Iracki J, De Munck J, Shirai K, Lambrechts P, Van Meerbeek B -2003- Micro-tensile bond strength of a contemporary total-etch and self-etch adhesive after in vivo degradation -abstract- J Dent Res 82-Spec Iss B-46 -www.dentalresearch.org-
Jang KT, Chung DH, Shin D, Garcia-Godoy F -2001- Effect of eccentric load cycling on micro-leakage of Class V flowable and packable composite resin restorations. Oper Dent 26:603–608.
Kanca J -1992- Effect of resin primer solvents and surface wetness on resin composite bond strength to dentin. Am J Dent 5:213–215.
Krejci I, Kuster M, Lutz F -1993- Influence of dentinal fluid and stress on marginal adaptation of resin composites. J Dent Res 71:490–494.
Kubo S, Yokota H, Sata Y, Hayashi Y -2001- The effect of flexural load cycling on the micro-leakage of cervical resin composites. Oper Dent 26:451–459.
Loguercio AD, Reis A, Barbosa AN, Roulet J-F -2003- Five-year double-blind randomized clinical evaluation of a resin-modified glass ionomer and a polyacid-modified resin in noncarious cervical lesions. J Adhes Dent 5:323–332.
Meiers JC, Young D -2001- Two-year composite/dentin bond stability. Am J Dent 14:141–144.
Mitsui FH, Bedran de Castro AK, Ritter AV, Cardoso PE, Pimenta LA -2003- Influence of load cycling on marginal micro-leakage with two self-etching and two one-bottle dentin adhesive systems in dentin. J Adhes Dent 5:209–216.
Miyazaki M, Sato M, Onose H, Moore BK -1998- Influence of thermal cycling on dentin bond strength of two-step bonding systems. Am J Dent 11:118–122.
Miyazaki M, Sato M, Onose H -2000- Durability of enamel bond strength of simplified bonding systems. Oper Dent 25:75–80.
Mjör IA, Gordan VV -2002- Failure, repair, refurbishing and longevity of restorations. Oper Dent 27:528–534.
Mjör IA, Shen C, Eliasson ST, Richter S -2002- Placement and replacement of restorations in general dental practice in Iceland. Oper Dent 27:117–123.
Nakabayashi N, Kojima K, Masuhara E -1982- The promotion of adhesion by the infiltration of monomers into tooth substrates. J Biomed Mater Res 16:1240–1243.
Nikaido T, Kunzelmann KH, Ogata M, Harada N, Yamaguchi S, Cox CF, et al. -2002b- The in vitro dentin bond strengths of two adhesive systems in class I cavities of human molars. J Adhes Dent 4:31–39.
Okuda M, Pereira PN, Nakajima M, Tagami J -2001- Relationship between nano-leakage and long-term durability of dentin bonds. Oper Dent 26:482–490.
Okuda M, Pereira PNR, Nakajima M, Tagami J, Pashley DH -2002- Long-term durability of resin dentin interface: nano-leakage vs. microtensile bond strength. Oper Dent 27:289–296.
Pagliarini A, Rubini R, Rea M, Campese C, Grandini R -1996- Effectiveness of the current enamel-dentinal adhesives: a new methodology for its evaluation. Quintessence Int 27:265–270.
Pashley DH, Carvalho RM, Sano H, Nakajima M, Shono Y, Fernandes CA, et al. -1999- The microtensile bond test: a review. J Adhes Dent 1:299–309.
Paul SJ, Welter DA, Ghazi M, Pashley D -1999- Nano-leakage at the dentin adhesive interface vs μ-tensile bond strength. Oper Dent 24:181–188.
Perdigão J, Carmo AR, Geraldeli S, Dutra HR, Masuda MS -2001- Six month clinical evaluation of two dentin adhesives applied on dry vs moist dentin. J Adhes Dent 3:343–352.
Peumans M, Van Meerbeek B, Lambrechts P, Vanherle G -2003a- Two-year clinical effectiveness of a resin-modified glass-ionomer adhesive. Am J Dent 16:363–368.
Peumans M, Van Meerbeek B, De Munck J, Lambrechts P -2003b- Two-year clinical effectiveness of a self-etch adhesive in cervical lesions -abstract- J Dent Res 82-Spec Iss B-911 -www.dentalresearch.org-
Prati C, Chersoni S, Mongiorgi G, Pashley DH -1999- Thickness and morphology of resin-infiltrated dentin layer in young, old, and sclerotic dentin. Oper Dent 24:66–72.
Roulet J-F, Reich T, Blunk U, Noack M -1989- Quantitative marginal analysis in the scanning electron microscope. Scanning Microsc 3:147–158.
Sano H, Shono T, Takatsu T, Hosoda H -1994- Microporous dentin zone beneath resin-impregnated layer. Oper Dent 19:59–64.
Sano H, Takatsu T, Ciucchi B, Horner JA, Matthews WG, Pashley DH -1995- Nano-leakage: leakage within the hybrid layer. Oper Dent 20:18–25.
Shirai K, De Munck J, Yoshida Y, Inoue S, Lambrechts P, Shintani H, et al. -2005- Effect of cavity configuration and ageing on the bonding effectiveness of six adhesives to dentin. Dent Mater -in press-
Shono Y, Terashita M, Shimada J, Kozono Y, Carvalho RM, Russell CM, et al. -1999- Durability of resin-dentin bonds. J Adhes Dent 1:211–218.
Sudsangiam S, Van Noort R -1999- Do dentin bond strength tests serve a useful purpose? J Adhes Dent 1:57–67.
Takahashi A, Inoue S, Kawamoto C, Ominato R, Tanaka T, Sato Y, et al. -2002- In vivo long-term durability of the bond to dentin using two adhesive systems. J Adhes Dent 4:151–159.
Tay FR, King NM, Chan KM, Pashley DH -2002b- How can nano-leakage occur in self-etching adhesive systems that demineralize and infiltrate simultaneously? J Adhes Dent 4:255–269.
Tay FR, Pashley DH, Peters MC -2003- Adhesive permeability affects composite coupling to dentin treated with a self-etch adhesive. Oper Dent 28:610–621.
Tjan AHL, Castelnuovo J, Liu P -1996- Bond strength of multi-step and simplified-step systems. Am J Dent 9:269–272.
Tyas MJ, Burrow MF -2001- Clinical evaluation of a resin-modified glass ionomer adhesive system—results at three years. Oper Dent 26:17–20.
Tyas MJ, Burrow MF -2002- Clinical evaluation of a resin-modified glass ionomer adhesive system—results at five years. Oper Dent 27:438–441.
Van Dijken JW, Hörstedt P -1997- Marginal adaptation to enamel of a polyacid-modified resin composite -compomer- and a resin-modified glass ionomer cement in vivo. Clin Oral Invest 1:185–190.
Van Meerbeek B, Peumans M, Gladys S, Braem M, Lambrechts P, Vanherle G -1996b- Three-year clinical effectiveness of four total-etch dentinal adhesive systems in cervical lesions. Quintessence Int 27:775–784.
Van Meerbeek B, Vargas M, Inoue S, Yoshida Y, Peumans M, Lambrechts P, et al. -1999- Hybridization effectiveness of a two-step versus a three-step smear layer removing adhesive system examined correlatively by TEM and AFM. J Adhes Dent 1:7–23.
Van Meerbeek B, Vargas S, Inoue S, Yoshida Y, Peumans M, Lambrechts P, et al. -2001- Adhesives and cements to promote preservation dentistry. Oper Dent 26:S119–S144.
Van Meerbeek B, De Munck J, Yoshida Y, Inoue S, Vargas M, Vijay P, et al. -2003- Buonocore memorial lecture: adhesion to enamel and dentin: current status and future challenges. Oper Dent 28:215–235.
Van Meerbeek B, De Munck J, Van Landuyt K, Kanumilli P, Lambrechts P, Peumans M -2005a- Restoring cervical lesions with flexible adhesives and composites. J Dent Res -submitted-
Van Meerbeek B, Kanumilli P, De Munck J, Van Landuyt K, Lambrechts P, Peumans M -2005b- A randomized controlled trial evaluating the three-year clinical effectiveness of two etch-and-rinse adhesives in cervical lesions. Oper Dent -in press-
Xie B, Dickens SH, Giuseppetti AA -2002- Microtensile bond strength of thermally stressed composite-dentin bonds mediated by one-bottle adhesives. Am J Dent 12:177–184.
Zheng L, Pereira PN, Nakajima M, Sano H, Tagami J -2001- Relationship between adhesive thickness and microtensile bond strength. Oper Dent 26:97–104.