Ecological Uses of Vertebrate Indicator Species: A Critique

Conservation Biology - Tập 2 Số 4 - Trang 316-328 - 1988
Peter Landres1, Jared Verner2, Jack Ward Thomas3
1Department of Biology, University of Puget Sound, Tacoma, WA 98416, USA
2U.S.D.A. Forest Service Pacific Southwest Forest and Range Experiment Station 2081 East Sierra Avenue Fresno, CA 93710, USA.
3U.S.D.A. Forest Service Range and Wildlife Habitat Laboratory Route 2, Box 2315 LaGrande, OR 97850, USA.

Tóm tắt

Abstract: Plant and animal species have been used for decades as indicators of air and water quality and agricultural and range conditions. Increasingly, vertebrates are used to assess population trends and habitat quality for other species. In this paper we review the conceptual bases, assumptions, and published guidelines for selection and use of vertebrates as ecological indicators. We conclude that an absence of precise definitions and procedures, confounded criteria used to select species, and discordance with ecological literature severely weaken the effectiveness and credibility of using vertebrates as ecological indicators. In many cases the use of ecological indicator species is inappropriate, but when necessary, the following recommendations will make their use more rigorous: (1) clearly state assessment goals, (2) use indicators only when other assessment options are unavailable, (3) choose indicator species by explicitly defined criteria that are in accord with assessment goals, (4) include all species that fulfill stated selection criteria (5) know the biology of the indicator in detail, and treat the indicator as a formal estimator in conceptual and statistical models, (6) identify and define sources of subjectivity when selecting monitoring and intetpreting indicator species, (7) submit assessment design, methods of data collection and statistical analysis, interpretations, and recommendations to peer review and (8) direct research at developing an overall strategy for monitoring wildlife that accounts for natural variability in population attributes and incorporates concepts from landscape ecology.

Từ khóa


Tài liệu tham khảo

Baker R.J., 1986, The Management of Viable Populations: Theory, Applications and Case Studies, 73

Bart J., 1984, Field evaluation of two models developed following the Habitat Evaluation Procedures, Transactions of the North American Wildlife and Natural Resources Conference, 49, 489

Baskett T. s. D. A.Darrow D. L.Hallett M. J.Armbruster J. A.Ellis B. F.Sparrowe andP. A.Korte1980.A Handbook for Terrestrial Habitat Evaluation in Central Missouri. U.S.D.1. Fish and Wildlife Service Resource Publication 133 Washington D.C.

Beanlands G. E., 1983, An Ecological Framework for Environmental Impact Assessment in Canada Institute for Resource and Environmental Studies

Begon M., 1986, Population Ecology: A Unified Study of Animals and Plants

Best L. B., 1986, Wildlife 2000: Modeling Habitat Relationships of Terrestrial Vertebrates, 209

Block W. M., 1986, Wildlife 2000: Modeling Habitat Relationship of Terrestrial Vertebrates, 109

10.2307/3801466

Cairns J., 1986, Community Toxicity Testing, 10.1520/STP920-EB

10.2307/1310388

Capp J. C. W. W.Sandfoot andJ. F.Lipscomb1984.Managing forested lands for wildlife: Roaring Creek Management Area Roosevelt National Park. Pages323–346inR. L.HooverandD. L.Willis editors.Managing Forested Lands for Wildlife. Colorado Division of Wildlife and U.S.D.A. Forest Service Rocky Mountain Region Denver Colorado.

Christensen N. L., 1984, Natural Diversity in Forest Ecosystems, 43

Clements F. E.1920.Plant Indicators. Carnegie Institute of Washington Publication No. 290 Washington D.C.

Code of Federal Regulations.1985. 36 CFR Chapter11219.19:64.

Daniel C., 1974, Evaluating effects of water resource developments on wildlife habitat, Wildlife Society Bulletin, 2, 114

Dedon M. F., 1986, Wildlife 2000: Modeling Habitat Relationships of Terrestrial Vertebrates, 115

Eberhardt L. L.1976.Quantitative ecology and impact assessment.Journal of Environmental Management427–70.

Ellis J. A. J. N.Burroughs M. J.Armbruster D. L.Hallett P. A.Korte andT. S.Baskett1979.Appraising four field methods of terrestrial habitat evaluation.Transactions of the North American Wildlife and Natural Resources Conference4569–46379.

Emlen J. M., 1973, Ecology: An Evolutionary Approach

Faaborg J., 1980, Potential uses and abuses of diversity concepts in wildlife management, Transactions of the Missouri Academy of Science, 14, 41

Flood B. S. M. E.Sangster R D.Sparrowe andT. S.Baskett1977.A Handbook for Habitat Evaluation. U.S.D.I. Fish and Wildlife Service Resource Publication 132 Washington D.C.

10.2307/1308780

Forman R. T. T., 1986, Landscape Ecology

Fry M. E., 1986, Wildlife 2000: Modeling Habitat Relationships of Terrestrial Vertebrates, 105

10.1016/0006-3207(86)90019-4

10.2307/3544112

Grad W. D., 1984, Strengthening ecosystem management approaches, Wildlife Society Bulletin, 12, 282

Hall H. H., 1919, Life‐zone indicators in California, Proceedings of the California Academy of Science, 9, 37

Hawkes H. A., 1979, Biological Indicators of Water Quality, 2

Hawksworth D. L., 1976, Lichens as Air Pollution Monitors

10.1007/BF01867323

Holbrook H. L., 1974, A system for wildlife habitat management on southern National Forests, Wildlife Society Bulletin, 2, 119

Hoover R L.1984.Ecological principles of forest wildlife management. Pages5–41inR L.HooverandD. L.Willis editors.Managing Forested Lands for Wildlife. Colorado Division of Wildlife and U.S.D.A. Forest Service Rocky Mountain Region Denver Colorado.

Hoover R. L. andD. L.Willis editors.1984.Managing Forested Lands for Wildlife. Colorado Division of Wildlife and U.S.D.A. Forest Service Rocky Mountain Region Denver Colorado.

Inhaber H., 1976, Environmental Indices

10.2307/3544138

10.2307/1937041

Jarvinen O., 1985, Conservation indices in land use planning: Dim prospects for a panacea, Ornis Fennica, 62, 101

10.1577/1548-8446(1981)006<0021:AOBIUF>2.0.CO;2

Kirby P. C., 1984, Natural Diversity in Forest Ecosystems, 11

10.1016/0006-3207(79)90049-1

Landres P. B.1983.Use of the guild concept in environmental impact assessment. Environmental Management7593–398.

Laymon S. A., 1986, Wildlife 2000: Modeling Habitat Relationships of Terrestrial Vertebrates, 87

10.1016/0022-5193(81)90077-1

Maguire L. A., 1986, Using decision analysis to manage endangered species populations, Journal of Environmental Management, 22, 345

Mannan R. W., 1984, The use of guilds in forest bird management, Wildlife Society Bulletin, 12, 426

Marcot B. G., 1986, The Management of Viable Populations: Theory, Applications, and Case Studies, 1

Marcot B. G. M. G.Raphael andK H.Berry1983.Monitoring wildlife habitats and validation of wildlife‐habitat relationships models.Transactions of the North American Wildlife and Natural Resources Conference48515–329.

10.1007/978-94-009-7352-7

Martin T. E., 1986, Current Ornithology, 181

10.2307/3800963

Mayr E., 1970, Populations, Species, and Evolution

Mealy S. P., 1981, Integrating wildlife habitat objectives into the forest plan, Transactions of the North American Wildlife and Natural Resources Conference, 46, 488

Merriam C. H.1898.Life Zones and Crop Zones of the United States. U.S.D.A. Division of Biological Survey Bulletin 10.

10.1007/978-1-4615-6784-4_10

10.1086/282957

Murphy D. D., 1986, Wildlife 2000: Modeling Habitat Relationships of Terrestrial Vertebrates, 287

National Academy of Science., 1979, Animals as Monitors of Environmental Pollutants

National Research Council., 1986, Ecological Knowledge and Environmental Problem‐solving

Nelson R. D., 1982, The Forest Service Wildlife and Fish Habitat Relationship Program, Transactions of the North American Wildlife and Natural Resources Conference, 47, 174

Newman J. R. andR. KSchreiber1984.Animals as indicators of ecosystem responses to air emissions. Environmental Management8509–324.

10.1007/BF01867252

Odum E. P., 1971, Fundamentals of Ecology

Olendorff R R. R. S.Motroni andM. W.Call1980.Raptor management—the state of the art in 1980. Pages468–523inManagement of Western Forests and Grasslands for Nongame Birds USDA Forest Service General Technical Report INT‐86.

Ott W. R., 1978, Environmental Indices: Theory and Practice

10.1016/0006-3207(87)90029-2

Patton D. R., 1987, Is the use of “Management Indicator Species” feasible, Western Journal of Applied Forestry, 2, 33, 10.1093/wjaf/2.1.33

10.1111/j.1744-7429.2007.00272.x

Phillips D.J. H., 1980, Quantitative Aquatic Biological Indicators

10.1016/0006-3207(78)90016-2

Pickett S. T. A., 1985, Ecology of Natural Disturbance and Patch Dynamics, 371

10.1016/0006-3207(86)90001-7

Raphael M. G., 1986, Wildlife 2000: Modeling Habitat Relationships of Terrestrial Vertebrates, 129

Risser P. G. J. R.Karr andR. T. T.Forman1984.Landscape Ecology: Directions and Approaches. Illinois Natural History Survey Special Publication 2 Champaign Illinois.

10.1016/0013-9327(78)90080-0

10.1007/BF01867655

Roberts T. H., 1985, Species selection for habitat assessments, Transactions of the North American Wildlife and Natural Resources Conference, 50, 352

10.2307/1942327

10.1007/BF01867730

10.1007/BF00384286

Salwasser H., 1986, Wildlife 2000: Modeling Habitat Relationships of Terrestrial Vertebrates, 419

Salwasser H. J. C.Capp H.Black andJ. F.Hurley1980.The California Wildlife Habitat Relationships Program: An overview. Pages369–378inManagement of Western Forests and Grasslands for Nongame Birds. U.S.D.A. Forest Service General Technical Report INT‐86.

Salwasser H., 1983, Monitoring wildlife and fish: Mandates and their implications, Transactions of the North American Wildlife and Natural Resources Conference, 48, 297

Salwasser H., 1984, Wildlife population viability, A question of risk Transactions of the North American Wildlife and Natural Resources Conference, 49, 421

Samson F. B., 1982, In search of a diversity ethic for wildlife management, Transactions of the North American Wildlife and Natural Resources Conference, 47, 421

10.1086/284133

Schroeder R. L.1987.Community Models for Wildlife Impact Assessment: A review of Concepts and Approaches. USDI Fish and Wildlife Service Biological Report87(2).

10.1007/BF01873277

Shantz H. L.1938.Plants as soil indicators. Pages835–860inSoils and Man U.S.D.A. Yearbook of Agriculture.

Shelford V. E., 1963, The Ecology of North America

Shubert L. E., 1984, Algae as Ecological Indicators

Sidle W. B. andL. H.Suring1986.Management Indicator Species for the National Forest Lands in Alaska. U.S.D.A. Forest Service Alaska Region Technical Publication R10‐TP‐2 Juneau. Alaska.

Soulé M. E., 1986, Viable Populations for Conservation, 1

Stauffer D. F., 1986, Wildlife 2000: Modeling Habitat Relationships of Terrestrial Vertebrates, 71

Stoddart L.A., 1975, Range Management

Susskind L. E. andL.Dunlap1981.The importance of non‐objective judgments in environmental impact assessments.Environmental Impact Assessment Review2535–366.

10.1007/BF01866772

Szaro R. C. andR. P.Balda1982.Selection and Monitoring of Avian Indicator Species: An Example from a Ponderosa Pine Forest in the Southwest. U.S.D.A. Forest Service General Technical Report RM‐89.

Thomas J. M. D. H.McKenzie andL. L.Eberhardt1981.Some limitations of biological monitoring.Environment International55–10.

Thomas J. W. editor.1979.Wildlife Habitats in Managed Forests: The Blue Mountains of Oregon and Washington.U.S.D.A. Forest Service Agricultural Handbook553.

Thomas J. W.1982.Needs for and approaches to wildlife habitat assessment.Transactions of the North American Wildlife and Natural Resources Conference4755–46.

Thomas J. W., 1986, Wildlife habitat by design: National Forests in the Blue Mountains of Oregon and Washington, Transactions of the North American Wildlife and Natural Resources Conference, 51, 203

10.1007/978-1-4684-1698-5_1

10.2307/1366850

10.2307/1310366

USDI., 1976, Habitat Evaluation Procedures

USDI.1980.Habitat as a Basis for Environmental Assessment. Ecological Services Manual Number 101. Division of Ecological Services U.S.D.I. Fish and Wildlife Service Washington D.C.

USDI.1980.Habitat Evaluation Procedures (HEP). Ecological Services Manual Number 102. Division of Ecological Services U.S.D.I. Fish and Wildlife Service Washington D.C.

USDI.1980.Standards for the Development of Habitat Suitability Index Models. Ecological Services Manual Number 103. Division of Ecological Services U.S.D.I. Fish and Wildlife Service Washington D.C.

10.2307/3808148

Verner J., 1983, An integrated system for monitoring wildlife on the Sierra National Forest, Transactions of the North American Wildlife and Natural Resources Conference, 48, 355

10.1007/BF01867868

10.1007/978-1-4613-2385-3_8

Verner J.1986.Future trends in management of nongame wildlife: A researcher's viewpoint. Pages149–171inJ. B.Hale L. B.Best andR. L.Clawson editors.Management of Nongame Wildlife in the Midwest: A Developing Art. Proceedings of the 47th Midwest Fish and Wildlife Conference Grand Rapids Michigan.

Verner J., 1986, Wildlife 2000: Modeling Habitat Relationships of Terrestrial Vertebrates

Ward D. V., 1978, Biological Environmental Impact Studies: Theory and Methods

Webster N., 1979, Webster's New Universal Unabridged Dictionary

Westman W. E., 1985, Ecology, Impact Assessment, and Environmental Planning

Wilcox B. A., 1984, National Parks, Conservation, and Development: The Role of Protected Areas in Sustaining Society, 63

10.1007/BF00395625

10.1007/BF00396213