A critical review of the arguments debating the role of the nurse advocate

Journal of Advanced Nursing - Tập 37 Số 5 - Trang 439-445 - 2002
Jeanette Hewitt1
1Tutor, School of Health Science, University of Wales, Swansea, UK

Tóm tắt

A critical review of the arguments debating the role of the nurse advocate Aims of the paper. This paper critically reviews the arguments for and against undertaking the role of nurse advocate. Background. Advocacy has become a popular concept in nursing literature over the past two decades. By addressing issues of power and accountability, conclusions are drawn about the risks facing nurses who would practice patient advocacy. Methods. Review and analysis of theoretical debate. Results. Empirical evidence is sparse and philosophical arguments predominate in the field of patient advocacy. Humanistic arguments that promote advocacy as a moral imperative are compelling. However, in reality nurses appear to lack the power base to comply except by covert means. Informed consent with a knowledge of the consequences of undertaking such an intervention is as relevant to the nurse as it is to the patient. Conclusion. Nurses need to be empowered first, if they are to empower their patients. There may however, be more suitable candidates for the role of patient advocate and nurses should recognize that they do not have a monopoly on ethical decision making.

Từ khóa


Tài liệu tham khảo

10.1016/0964-3397(92)90009-9

Allmark P., 1992, The case against nurse advocacy, British Journal of Nursing, 2, 33, 10.12968/bjon.1992.1.12.33

AshcroftR.(1994)Complementary therapy in the critical care unit. InCritical Care Nursing(Millar B. & Burnard P. eds). Ballière‐Tindall London pp. 93–106.

BandmanE.L.(1983)Who will advocate for the nurse advocate?InEthical Problems in the Nurse–Patient Relationship(Murphy C. & Hunter M. eds). Allyn and Bacon MA pp. 85–97.

BeardshawV.(1981)Conscientious Objectors at Work. Social Audit London.

BennerP.&WrubelJ.(1989)The Primacy of Caring. Addis Wesley CA.

BernardM.&GlendenningF.(1990)Advocacy Consumerism and the Older Person. Beth Johnson Foundation Publications University of Keele Keele.

BishopA.H.&ScudderJ.R.(1990)The Practical Moral and Personal Sense of Nursing: a Phenomenological Philosophy of Practice. State University of N.Y. Press Albany.

Booth W., 1991, A cry for help in the wilderness, Health Service Journal, 14, 36

Branch R., 1985, Citizen advocacy, Nursing Mirror, 160, 31

ButlerK. CarrS.&SullivanF.(1988)Citizen Advocacy: a Powerful Partnership. Adept Press London.

Carpenter D., 1992, Advocacy, Nursing Times, 86, 26

Castledine G., 1981, The nurse as the patient's advocate: pros and cons, Nursing Mirror, 153, 38

ChadwickR.&TaddW.(1992)Ethics and Nursing Practice. Macmillan Basingstoke.

10.1111/j.1365-2648.1986.tb01246.x

10.1097/00012272-197904000-00003

CurtinL.L.&FlahertyM.J.(1981)Nursing Ethics Theories and Pragmatics. Prentice Hall Englewood Cliffs NJ.

Department of Health(1991)The Patient's Charter. HMSO London.

DimondB.(1995)Legal Aspects of Nursing 2nd edn. Prentice Hall London.

Dubler N.N., 1992, Individual advocacy as a governing principle, Journal of Case Management, 13, 82

FitzpatrickF.J.(1988)Ethics in Nursing Practice: Basic Principles and Their Application.The Linacre Centre London.

Fowler M.D., 1989, Social advocacy: ethical issues in critical care, Heart and Lung, 18, 97

GadowS.(1980)Existential advocacy: philosophical foundation of nursing. InNursing: Images and Ideals(Spicker S.F. & Gadow S. eds). Springer Publications Co New York pp. 79–101.

Gates B., 1995, Whose best interest?, Nursing Times, 91, 31

HandyC.(1985)Understanding Organisations 3rd edn. Penguin Books London.

HendersonV.(1960)Basic Principles of Nursing Care. International Council of Nurses Geneva.

10.1111/j.1365-2648.1991.tb03428.x

Holmes P., 1991, The patient's friend, Nursing Times, 87, 16

IllichI.(1977)Limits to Medicine. Medical Nemesis: the Exploration of Health. Marion Boyars London.

JametonA.(1984)Nursing Practice: the Ethical Issues. Prentice Hall NJ.

Jones E., 1982, Advocacy as a tool for radical curriculum planners, Journal of Nurse Education, 21, 40

KennedyI.(1983)The Unmasking of Medicine. Paladin London.

KohnkeM.F.(1982)Advocacy Risk and Reality.CV Mosby Co. St Louis.

10.2307/3422062

10.1046/j.1365-2648.1997.1997025130.x

10.1046/j.1365-2648.1998.00734.x

Mallik M., 1995, Support for advocacy, Nursing Times, 25, 28

Mardell A., 1996, Advocacy: exploring the concept, British Journal of Theatre Nursing, 6, 34

Marshall M., 1991, Advocacy within the multidisciplinary team, Nursing Standard, 6, 28, 10.7748/ns.6.10.28.s43

10.1046/j.1365-2648.1998.00492.x

McFadyen J.A., 1989, Who will speak for me?…psychiatric patients' rights, Nursing Times, 85, 45

McIvorS.(1993)Investing in Patients' Representatives.NAHAT Birmingham.

Melia K., 1987, Everyday ethics – whose side are you on?, Nursing Times, 83, 46

10.12968/bjon.1997.6.6.337

MontgomeryJ.(1992)Doctors handmaidens – the legal contribution. InLaw Health and Medical Regulations(McVeigh S. & Wheeler S. eds). Davenmouth. Publications Aldershot pp. 141–168.

MorrisonP.(1994)Psychological aspects of care. InCritical Care Nursing(Millar B. & Burnard P. eds). Ballière‐Tindall London pp. 273–289.

10.1111/j.1365-2648.1991.tb03436.x

Nelson M.L., 1988, Advocacy in nursing, Nursing Outlook, 36, 136

Oxford English Dictionary(1989)Oxford English Dictionary 2nd edn. Prepared by Simpson J.A. Weiner E.S.L. Claredon Press Oxford.

ParsonsE.P.(1994)Technology and the nursing dilemma. InCritical Care Nursing(Millar B. & Burnard P. eds). Ballière‐Tindall London pp. 290–312.

Ramos M.C., 1992, The nurse–patient relationship: theme variations, Journal of Advanced Nursing, 17, 469

SalvageJ.(1985)The Politics of Nursing. Heinemann London.

SeligmanM.E.P.(1975)Helplessness: On Depression Development and Death. Freeman San Francisco.

10.1046/j.1365-2648.1996.01719.x

StarrP.(1982)The Social Transformation of American Medicine. Basic Books New York.

10.1056/NEJM199002223220810

Turner T., 1990, Crushed by the system, Nursing Times, 86, 19

TuxhillC.(1994)Ethical aspects of critical care. InCritical Care Nursing(Millar B. & Burnard P. eds). Ballière‐Tindall London.

UKCC(1989)Exercising Accountability. UKCC London pp. 251–270.

UKCC(1992)Code of Professional Conduct for the Nurse Midwife and Health Visitor. UKCC London.

UKCC(1996)Guidelines for Professional Practice. UKCC London.

WalshM.&FordP.(1989)Nursing Rituals Research and Rational Action. Butterworth Heinemann Oxford.

WeberM.(1978)Economy and Society(Translated and edited by Roth G. & Wittick C.). University of California Press CA.

WinslowG.R.(1984)From loyalty to advocacy: a new metaphor for nursing.Hastings Centre ReportJune 32–40.

WittsP.(1992)Patient advocacy in nursing. InThemes and Perspectives in Nursing(Soothill K. Henry C. & Kendrick K. eds). Chapman & Hall London pp. 158–180.

10.12968/bjon.1997.6.4.225

10.1097/00012272-198601000-00010