“Freedom of choice” and “flexibility” in the retail sector?

International Journal of Manpower - Tập 19 Số 4 - Trang 281-295 - 1998
ColumMcLaughlin1, ErlingRasmussen1
1University of Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand

Tóm tắt

The Employment Contracts Act 1991 radically transformed the system of employment relations in New Zealand. Proponents of the Act claim that it gives employers and employees “freedom of choice” and the ability to arrive at “flexible” working arrangements which are mutually beneficial. But how much “freedom of choice” do employees in the secondary labour market have, and to what extent are the “flexible” agreements mutually beneficial? This paper reports on research carried out in the retail sector. It finds that retail workers have little freedom of choice, and flexibility is all one way. The paper also raises questions about research in the secondary labour market. Given the concerns of so many about issues of equity under the Employment Contracts Act, why has there been so little research in this area?

Từ khóa


Tài liệu tham khảo

Brook, P. (1990), Freedom at Work: The Case for Reforming Labour Law in New Zealand, Oxford University Press, Auckland.

Brosnan, P. (1991), “Labour market flexibility and the quality of work: a case study of the retail industry”, New Zealand Journal of Industrial Relations, Vol. 16, pp. 13‐36.

Brosnan, P. and Rea, D. (1991), “An adequate minimum code: a basis for freedom, justice and efficiency in the labour market”, New Zealand Journal of Industrial Relations, Vol. 16, pp. 143‐58.

Crawford, A., Harbridge, R. and Hince, K. (1997), “Unions and union membership in New Zealand: annual review for 1996”, New Zealand Journal of Industrial Relations, Vol. 22 No. 2, pp. 209‐16.

Dannin, E. (1997), Working Free: The Origins and Impact of New Zealand’s Employment Contracts Act, Auckland University Press, Auckland.

Deeks, J., Parker, J. and Ryan, R. (1994), Labour and Employment Relations in New Zealand, Longman Paul, Auckland.

Dixon, C. (1994), “Segmentation theory and the New Zealand labour market”, Labour, Employment and Work in New Zealand 1994, Wellington..

Gosche, M. (1992), “The impact of the Employment Contracts Act 1991”, paper presented to a Public Seminar, Victoria University, Wellington.

Grills, W. (1994), “The impact of the Employment Contracts Act on labour law: implications for unions”, New Zealand Journal of Industrial Relations, Vol. 19 No. 1, pp. 85‐101.

Hammond, S. and Harbridge, R (1993), “The impact of the Employment Contracts Act on women at work”, New Zealand Journal of Industrial Relations, Vol. 18 No. 1, pp. 15‐30.

Harbridge, R. (1993), “Bargaining and the Employment Contracts Act: an overview”, in Harbridge, R. (Ed.), Employment Contracts: New Zealand Experiences, Victoria University Press, Wellington.

Harbridge, R. and Street, M. (1995), “Labour market adjustment and women in the service industry: a survey”, New Zealand Journal of Industrial Relations, Vol. 20 No. 1, pp. 23‐34.

Hector, J. and Hobby, M. (1997), “Labour market adjustment under the Employment Contracts Act: 1996”, New Zealand Journal of Industrial Relations, Vol. 22/23 No. 3/1.

Hector, J., Henning, J. and Hubble, M. (1993), “Industrial relations bargaining in the retail non‐food sector: 1991‐1992”, New Zealand Journal of Industrial Relations, Vol. 18 No. 3, pp. 326‐41.

Heylen Research Centre and Teesdale Meuli and Co. (1992), A Survey of Labour Market Adjustment under the Employment Contracts Act 1991, report prepared for the Department of Labour, October.

Heylen Research Centre and Teesdale Meuli and Co. (1993), A Survey of Labour Market Adjustment under the Employment Contracts Act 1991, report prepared for the Department of Labour, November.

James, C. (1992), New Territory: The Transformation of New Zealand, 1984‐92, Bridget Williams Books, Wellington.

Kelsey, J. (1995), The New Zealand Experiment, Auckland University Press, Auckland.

Kerr, R. (1996), “Employment, productivity and growth all blossom under the employment contracts act”, NZ Herald, 5 October.

Kerr, R. (1997), “New Zealand must wise up to employment growth obstacles”, The Independent, 7 March, pp. 8‐9.

McAndrew, I. (1993), “The process of developing employment contracts: a management perspective”, in Harbridge, R. (Ed.), Employment Contracts: New Zealand Experiences, Victoria University Press, Wellington.

National Distribution Union (1996), Shortchanged: Retail Workers and the ECA, Auckland..

Oxenbridge, S. (1995), “Organising the secondary labour force: the New Zealand experience”, in Sonder, L. (Ed.), Current Research in Industrial Relations, Proceedings of the 9th AIRAANZ Conference..

Rasmussen, E. (1996a), “Workplace transformation under the employment contracts act”, in Fells, R. and Todd, T. (Eds), Current Research in Industrial Relations, AIRAANZ, Perth.

Rasmussen, E. (1996b), “Employee awareness and attitudes ‐ a pilot survey”, Labour Market Bulletin, Vol. 2, pp. 89‐101.

Rasmussen, E. and Deeks, J. (1997), “Contested outcomes: assessing the impacts of the Employment Contracts Act”, Californian Western International Law Journal, Vol. 28 No. 1, pp. 275‐96

Rasmussen, E., Boxall, P., Haworth, N., Hughes, S., Powell, M., Maloney, T. and Wilson, M. (1996), “Industrial relations and labour market reforms in New Zealand”, Human Resource Development Outlook 1995‐96, Pacific Economic Cooperation Council..

Report of the Second New Zealand Sweating Commission (1990), Across the Counter: The Lives of the Working Poor in New Zealand, Wellingtonn

Ryan, R. (1996), Employment Relations in Hotels, Cafes and Restaurants: Summary of Survey Results, Working Paper 3/96, Industrial Relations Centre, Victoria University, Wellington.

Statistics New Zealand (1997), Quarterly Employment Survey, August, Wellington.

Walsh, P. (1992), “The Employment Contracts Act”, in Boston, J. and Dalziel, P. (Eds), The Decent Society? Essays in Response to National’s Economic and Social Policies, Oxford University Press, Auckland.

Walsh, P. and Ryan, R. (1993), “The making of the Employment Contracts Act”, in Harbridge, R. (Ed.), Employment Contracts: New Zealand Experiences, Victoria University Press, Wellington.

Whatman, R., Armitage, C. and Dunbar, R. (1994), “Labour market adjustment under the Employment Contracts Act”, New Zealand Journal of Industrial Relations, Vol. 19 No. 1, pp. 53‐73.