Whistle-blowing regulation in different corporate governance systems: an analysis of the regulation approaches from the view of path dependence theory
Tóm tắt
The research question of this paper is, if and why countries need different legal approaches to whistle-blowing regulation. The paper specifically explores whether regulation approaches from other countries are suitable to regulate whistle-blowing in the German corporate governance system. First, it is clarified which factors influence the choice of the desired action—that is, “internal whistle-blowing”—and it is demonstrated that the underlying corporate governance system has a potential influence on these factors. Next, it is shown that the consistency of systems is responsible for the lack of success of some legal approaches of the whistle-blowing regulation in special corporate governance systems, whereas in other systems they can be very successful. Finally, the paper presents the requirements for whistle-blowing regulation that does not damage the consistency of the underlying corporate governance system. The findings support path dependence theory, which claims that legal approaches of one country cannot be transferred to other countries. Moreover, whistle-blowing literature is expanded by the fact that the underlying corporate governance system of a country influences the power and loyalty of the employee. It suggests new avenues for whistle-blowing research as well as for the potential convergence of corporate governance regulation. The findings offer insights for policy makers interested in the development of legal proposals for whistle-blowing regulation in their countries. Moreover, it provides a new perspective to enable managers of multinational firms to design whistle-blowing systems within different corporate governance systems.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Aguilera, R. V., & Jackson, G. (2003). The crossnational diversity of corporate governance: Dimensions and determinants. Academy of Management Review, 28(3), 447–465.
Anechiarico, F., & Jacobs, J. B. (1996). The pursuit of absolute integrity. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Arthur, W. B. (1989). Competing technologies, increasing returns, and lock-in by historical events. Tec Economic Journal, 99, 116–131.
Baums, T., & Scott, K. E. (2005). Taking shareholder protection seriously? Corporate governance in the U.S. and Germany. Journal of Applied Corporate Finance, 17(4), 44–63.
Bebchuk, L. A., & Roe, M. J. (1999). A theory of path dependence in corporate ownership and governance. Stanford Law Review, 52(1), 127–170.
Beyer, J. (2005). Pfadabhängigkeit ist nicht gleich Pfadabhängigkeit—Wider den impliziten Konservatismus eines gängigen Konzepts. Zeitschrift für Soziologie, 34(1), 5–21.
Bok, S. (1988). Whistleblowing and professional responsibility. In T. L. Beauchamp & N. E. Bowie (Eds.), Ethical theory and business (3rd ed., pp. 292–299). Englewood Cliffs: Prentice Hall.
Brown, A. J. (2008). Whistleblowing in the Australian public sector. Canberra: ANU E Press.
Brühl, K. (2009). Corporate Governance, Strategie und Unternehmenserfolg. Wiesbaden: Gabler.
BSI. (2008). PAS 1998:2008 whistleblowing arrangements. Code of practice. British Standards Institute, London.
Buchert, C. (2013). Der Irrweg der EU-Kommission—Zu den Überlegungen über die Einführung einer staatlichen Whistleblower-Prämie. Corporate Compliance Zeitschrift, 6, 144–149.
Buck, T., & Shahrim, A. (2005). The translation of corporate governance changes across national cultures: The case of Germany. Journal of International Business Studies, 36(1), 42–61.
Callahan, E. S., & Dworkin, T. M. (1992). Do good and get rich: Financial incentives for whistleblowing and the False Claims Act. Villanova Law Review, 37, 273–336.
Callahan, E. S., Dworkin, T. M., Fort, T. L., & Schipani, C. A. (2002). Integrating trends in whistleblowing and corporate governance: Promoting organizational effectiveness, societal responsibility and employee empowerment. American Business Law Journal, 40(1), 177–215.
Chizema, A., & Buck, T. (2006). Neo-institutional theory and institutional change: Towards empirical tests on the ‘‘Americanization’’ of German executive pay. International Business Review, 15, 488–504.
Data-Protection-Group. (2006). ‘Stellungnahme 1/2006 zur Anwendung der EU-Datenschutzvorschriften auf interne Verfahren zur Meldung mutmaßlicher Missstände in den Bereichen Rechnungslegung, interne Rechnungslegungskontrollen, Fragen der Wirtschaftsprüfung, Bekämpfung von Korruption, Ban’, Artikel-29-Datenschutzgruppe, WP 117 00195/06/DE.
David, P. A. (1985). Clio and the economics of qwerty. American Economic Review, 75, 332–337.
Donkin, M., Smith, R., & Brown, A. J. (2008). How do officials report? Internal and external whistleblowing. In A. J. Brown (Ed.), Whistleblowing in the Australian public sector (pp. 83–108). Canberra: ANU E Press.
Dowling, D. C, Jr. (2008). Sarbanes–Oxley whistleblower hotlines across Europe: Directions through the maze. International Lawyer, 42(1), 1–58.
Dozier, J. B., & Miceli, M. P. (1985). Potential predictors of whistle-blowing: A prosocial behavior perspective. The Academy of Management Review, 10 (4), 823–836.
Dworkin, T. M. (2007). SOX and whistleblowing. Michigan Law Review, 105, 1757–1780.
Dworkin, T. M., & Near, J. P. (1997). A better statutory approach to whistle-blowing. Business Ethics Quarterly, 7, 1–16.
Dyck, A. J., Morse, A., & Zingales, L. (2010). Who blows the whistle on corporate fraud. Journal of Finance, 65, 2213–2254.
Fleischer, H., & Schmolke, K. U. (2012). Finanzielle Anreize für Whistleblower im Europäische Kapitalmarktrecht? Rechtspolitische Überlegungen zur Reform des Marktmissbrauchsregimes. Neue Zeitung für Gesellschaftsrecht, 15(10), 361–368.
Fröhlich, O., & Schelp, T. (2009). Die geplante Neufassung des § 612a BGB—mehr als, alter Wein in neuen Schläuchen? Arbeits-Rechts-Berater, 1, 48–51.
Garcia-Castro, R., Arino, M. A., Rodriguez, M. A., & Ayuso, S. (2008). A cross-national study of corporate governance and employment contracts. Business Ethics: A European Review, 17(3), 259–284.
Gobert, J., & Punch, M. (2000). Whistleblowers, the public interest, and the Public Interest Disclosure Act 1998. The Modern Law Review, 63, 25–54.
Grimm, D., & Windeln, N. (2009). “Whistleblowing”—Zum Vorschlag für eine gesetzliche Regelung des Informantenschutzes für Arbeitnehmer. Arbeits-Rechts-Berater, 1, 21–24.
Groenewegen, J. (1997). Institutions of capitalisms: American, European, and Japanese systems compared. Journal of Economic Issues, 31(2), 333–347.
Groneberg, R. (2011). Whistleblowing: Eine rechtsvergleichende Untersuchung des US-amerikanischen, englischen und deutschen Rechts unter besonderer Berücksichtigung des Entwurfs eines neuen § 612a BGB. Berlin: Duncker & Humblot.
Hall, P. A., & Gingerich, D. W. (2009). Varieties of capitalism and institutional complementarities in the political economy: An empirical analysis. British Journal of Political Science, 39(3), 449–482.
Hall, P. A., & Soskice, D. (2001). An introduction to varieties of capitalism. In P. A. Hall & D. Soskice (Eds.), Varieties of capitalism. The institutional foundations of comparative advantage (pp. 1–68). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Hassink, H., de Vries, M., & Bollen, L. (2007). A content analysis of whistleblowing policies of leading European companies. Journal of Business Ethics, 75, 25–44.
Heine, K. (2003). Regulierungswettbewerb im Gesellschaftsrecht. Berlin: Duncker & Humblot.
Herbert, M., & Oberrath, J.-D. (2005). Schweigen ist Gold? - Rechtliche Vorgaben für den Umgang des Arbeitnehmers mit seiner Kenntnis über Rechtsverstöße im Betrieb. Neue Zeitschrift für Arbeitsrecht, 23, 193–199.
Hirschman, A. O. (1970). Exit, voice and loyalty: Responses to decline in firms, organizations, and states. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Jos, P. H., Tompkins, M. E., & Hays, S. W. (1989). In praise of difficult people: A portrait of the committed whistleblower. Public Administration Review, 49, 552–561.
Joshi, A. W., & Arnold, S. J. (1997). The impact of buyer dependence on buyer opportunism in buyer–supplier relationships: The moderating role of relational norms. Psychology & Marketing, 14(8), 823–845.
Kaptein, M. (2011). From inaction to external whistleblowing: The influence of the ethical culture of organizations on employee responses to observed wrongdoing. Journal of Business Ethics, 98, 513–530.
Kostant, P. C. (1999). Exit, voice and loyalty in the course of corporate governance and counsel’s changing role. Journal of Socio-Economics, 28, 203–246.
La Porta, R., Lopez-de-Silanes, F., Shleifer, A., & Vishny, R. W. (1998). Law and finance. Journal of Political Economy, 106(6), 1113–1155.
Lacayo, R., & Ripley, A. (2002). Persons of the year 2002, Cynthia Cooper, Coleen Rowley and Sherron Watkins. Time Magazine, 160(27), 30–33.
Lambsdorff, J. G., & Frank, B. (2011). Corrupt reciprocity—Experimental evidence on a men’s game. International Review of Law & Economics, 31(2), 116–125.
Lee, G., & Fargher, N. (2013). Companies’ use of whistle-blowing to detect fraud: An examination of corporate whistle-blowing policies. Journal of Business Ethics, 114(2), 283–295.
Lentfer, T. (2005). Einflüsse der internationalen Corprate-Governance-Diskussion auf die Überwachung der Geschäftsführung. Wiesbaden: Deutscher Universitäts-Verlag.
Lewis, D. (2011). Whistleblowing in a changing legal climate: Is it time to revisit our approach to trust and loyalty at the workplace? Business ethics: A European review, 20(1), 7187.
Lindblom, L. (2007). Dissolving the moral dilemma of whistleblowing. Journal of Business Ethics, 76, 413–426.
Lobel, O. (2009). Citizenship, organizational citizenship, and the laws of overlapping obligations. California Law Review, 97, 433–499.
Lombardi, L. G. (1988). Moral analysis—Foundations, guides and applications. New York: State University of New York Press.
Mahoney, J. (2000). Path dependence in historical sociology. Theory and Society, 29(4), 507–548.
Melis, A. (2000). Corporate governance in Italy. Corporate Governance: An International Review, 8(4), 347–355.
Miceli, M. P., & Near, J. P. (1984). The relationships among beliefs, organizational position, and whistle-blowing status: A discriminant analysis. Academy of Management Journal, 27, 687–705.
Miceli, M. P., & Near, J. P. (1985). Characteristics of organizational climate and perceived wrongdoing associated with whistleblowing decisions. Personnel Psychology, 38(3), 525–544.
Miceli, M. P., & Near, J. P. (1992). Blowing the whistle. New York: Lexington Books.
Miceli, M. P., & Near, J. P. (1994). Whistleblowing: Reaping the benefits. Academy of Management Executive, 8(3), 65–72.
Miceli, M. P., Near, J. P., & Dworkin, T. M. (2008). Whistle-blowing in organizations. New York: Taylor & Francis Group.
Miceli, M. P., Near, J. P., Rehg, M. T., & van Scotter, J. R. (2012). Predicting employee reactions to perceived organizational wrongdoing: Demoralization, justice, proactive personality and whistle-blowing. Human Relations, 65(8), 923–954.
Moberly, R. E. (2006). Sarbanes Oxley’s structural model to encourage corporate whistleblowers. Brigham Young University Law Review, 5, 1107–1176.
Moberly, R. E. (2007). Unfulfilled expectations: An empirical analysis of why Sarbanes-Oxley whistleblowers rarely win. William and Mary Law Review, 59, 65–155.
Moberly, R. E. (2008). Protecting whistleblowers by contract. University of Colorado Law Review, 79, 975–1043.
Monks, R. A. G., & Minow, N. (2008). Corporate governance (4th ed.). Chichester: Wiley.
Morrell, K., Loan-Clarke, J., Arnold, J., & Wilkinson, A. (2008). Mapping the decision to quit: A refinement and test of the unfolding model of voluntary turnover. Applied Psychology: An International Review, 57(1), 128–150.
Müller, M. (2002). Whistleblowing—Ein Kündigungsgrund? Neue Zeitschrift für Arbeitsrecht, 20, 424–437.
Near, J. P., & Miceli, M. P. (1985). Organizational dissidence: The case of whistle-blowing. Journal of Business Ethics, 4(1), 1–16.
Near, J. P., & Miceli, M. P. (1995). Effective whistle blowing. Academy of Management Review, 20(3), 679–708.
Nitsch, D., Baetz, M., & Christensen Hughes, J. (2005). Why codes of conduct violations go unreported: A conceptual framework to guide intervention and future research. Journal of Business Research, 57, 327–341.
Nooteboom, B. (1999). Voice- and exit-based forms of corporate control: Anglo-American, European, and Japanese. Journal of Economic Issues, 33(4), 845–860.
North, D. C. (1990). Institutions, institutional change and economic performance. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Orren, K. (1991). Labor, the law, and liberal development in the United States. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Pierson, P. (2000a). Increasing returns, path dependence, and the study of politics. The American Political Science Review, 94(2), 251–267.
Pierson, P. (2000b). Not just what, but when: Timing and sequence in political processes. Studies in American Political Development, 14(1), 72–92.
Pittroff, E. (2011). Whistle-Blowing-Systeme in deutschen Unternehmen—Eine Untersuchung zur Wahrnehmung und Implementierung. Wiesbaden: Gabler.
Pittroff, E. (2014a). Finanzielle Belohnungen für Whistle Blower in Deutschland—ein Vergleich mit dem Kündigungsschutz. Zeitschrift für Wirtschaftsstrafrecht und Haftung im Unternehmen, 4(11), 417–423.
Pittroff, E. (2014b). Whistle-blowing systems and legitimacy theory: A study of the motivation to implement whistle-blowing systems in German organizations. Journal of Business Ethics, 124, 399–412.
Pope, K. R., & Lee, C.-C. (2013). Could the Dodd–Frank wall street reform and Consumer Protection Act of 2010 be helpful in reforming corporate America? An investigation on financial bounties and whistle-blowing behaviors in the private sector. Journal of Business Ethics, 112, 597–607.
Rappaport, A. (1999). Shareholder value: Ein Handbuch für Manager und Investoren. Stuttgart: Schaeffer-Pöschel.
Rauhofer, J. (2007). Blowing the whistle on Sarbanes–Oxley: Anonymous hotlines and the historical stigma of denunciation in modern Germany. International Review of Law Computers and Technology, 21(3), 363–376.
Schmidt, M. (2005). Whistle blowing regulation and accounting standards enforcement in Germany and Europe—An economic perspective. International Review of Law and Economics, 25, 143–168.
Schmidt, R. H. (2006). Stakeholderorientierung, Systemhaftigkeit und Stabilität der corporate governance in Deutschland. In U. Jürgens, D. Sadowski, G. F. Schuppert, & M. Weiss (Eds.), Perspektiven der Corporate Governance (pp. 31–54). Baden-Baden: Nomos.
Schmidt, R. H., & Spindler, G. (2002). Path dependence, corporate governance and complementarity. International Finance, 5(3), 311–333.
Schmolke, K. (2012). Whistleblowing-Systeme als Corporate Governance-Instrument transnationaler Unternehmen. Recht der internationalen Wirtschaft, 58(4), 224–232.
Schreyögg, G., & Sydow, J. (2011). Organizational path dependence: A process view. Organization Studies, 32(3), 321–335.
Skivenes, M., & Trygstad, S. C. (2010). When whistle-blowing works: The Norwegian case. Human Relations, 63(7), 1071–1097.
Söllner, A. (2000). Die Schmutzigen Hände—Individuelles Verhalten in Fällen von institutionellen Misfits, Tübingen.
Sydow, J., Schreyögg, G., & Koch, J. (2009). Organizational path dependence: Opening the black box. Academy of Management Review, 34(4), 689–709.
Trongmateerut, P., & Sweeney, J. T. (2013). The influence of subjective norms on whistle-blowing: A cross-cultural investigation. Journal of Business Ethics, 112, 437–451.
Vandekerckhove, W., & Commers, R. (2004). Whistle blowing and rational loyalty. Journal of Business Ethics, 53, 225–233.
Vandekerckhove, W., & Lewis, D. (2012). The content of whistleblowing procedures: A critical review of recent official guidelines. Journal of Business Ethics, 108, 253–264.
Velte, P., & Weber, S. C. (2011). Outsider- und Insider-Systeme der Corporate Governance. Zeitschrift für Planung und Unternehmenssteuerung, 21, 473–482.
von Busekist, K., & Fahrig, S. (2013). Whistleblowing und der Schutz von Hinweisgebern. Betriebs Berater, 68, 119–124.
von Werder, A. (2004). Corporate governance. In G. Schreyögg & A. von Werder (Eds.), Handwörterbuch Unternehmensführung und Organisation (4th ed., pp. 160–170). Stuttgart: Schaeffer-Pöschel.
von Werder, A. (2011). Neue Entwicklungen der Corporate Governance in Deutschland. Schmalenbachs Zeitschrift für betriebswirtschaftliche Forschung, 63, 48–62.
Weimer, J., & Pape, J. C. (1999). A taxonomy of systems of corporate governance. Corporate Governance: An International Review, 7(2), 152–166.
Williamson, O. E. (1985). The economic institutions of capitalism: Firms, markets, relational contracting. New York: The Free Press.
Wisskirchen, G., Körber, A., & Bissels, A. (2006). Whistleblowing und Ethikhotlines. Probleme des deutschen Arbeits- und Datenschutzrechts. Betriebs-Berater, 61, 1567–1572.
Wrase, S., & Fabritius, C. (2011). Prämien für Hinweisgeber bei Kartellverstößen? Zeitschrift für Corporate Compliance, 4, 69–73.
Zhuang, J., Tomas, S., & Miller, D. L. (2005). Examining culture’s effect on whistle-blowing and peer reporting. Business & Society, 44(4), 462–486.