The undefined relationship between tumor antigens and histocompatibility antigens on cancer cells
Tóm tắt
The data pertaining to the possible relationship between histocompatibility antigens (HA) and tumor-specific transplantation or tumor surface antigen (TSTA or TSA) are reviewed. The HA profiles of certain experimental and human neoplasms have been found to be altered either from the quantitative (increased expression of some antigenic specificities and decreased expression or even lack of other HA) or qualitative point of view (appearance of alien, genetically inappropriate HA). The authors entertain the possibility that the presence of TSTA or TSA on cancer cells may be linked to alterations of the HA profile. Evidence in favour of the idea that tumor antigens may actually be alien MHC products, alien minor HA or modified HA, is reviewed. Findings on structural relationships between TSA and β2-microglobulin are also summarized. In the authors’ opinion, no definitive conclusions can be reached at the present time on the relationship between TSTA or TSA and HA of cancer cells.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Albright A. L., Gill T. J. III,Geyer S. J.: Immunogenic control of brain tumor growth in rats- Cancer Res.37, 2512, 1977.
Baldwin R. W.: Immunological aspects of chemical carcinogenesis - Advanc. Cancer Res.18, 1, 1973.
Basombrio M. A.: Search for common antigenicities among twenty-five sarcomas induced by methylcholanthrene - Cancer Res.30, 2058, 1970.
Bear R. H., Jr.,Roholt O. A., Pressman D.: Protection against syngeneic tumor grafts induced by inoculation with normal allogeneic tissues - Immunol. Commun.6, 547, 1977.
Blank K. J., Lilly F.: Evidence for an H-2/viral protein complex on the cell surface as the basis for the H-2 restriction of cytotoxicity - Nature (Lond.)269, 808, 1977.
Bodmer W. F.: A new genetic model for allelism at histocompatibility loci: polymorphism for control of gene expression -Transplant. Proc.5, 1471, 1973.
Bowen J. G., Baldwin R. W.: Tumour-specific antigen related to rat histocompatibility antigens - Nature (Lond.)258, 15, 1975.
Bowen J. G., Baldwin R. W.: Tumour antigens and alloantigens. II. Lack of association of rat hepatoma-D23-specific antigen with β20-microglobulin - Int. J. Cancer23, 833, 1979.
Burton R. C., Chism S. E., Warner N. L.:In vitro induction of tumor-specific immunity. III. Lack of requirement for H-2 compatibility in lysis of tumor targets by T cells activatedin vitro to oncofetal and plasmocytoma antigens - J. Immunol.118, 971, 1977.
Callahan G. N., Allison J. P., Pellegrino M. A., Reisfeld R. A.: Physical association of histocompatibility antigens and tumor-associated antigens on the surface of murine lymphoma cells - J. Immunol.122, 70, 1979.
Carbone G., Invernizzi G., Meschini A., Parmiani G.:In vitro andin vivo expression of original and foreign H-2 antigens and of the tumor-associated transplantation antigen of a murine fibrosarcoma - Int. J. Cancer21, 85, 1978.
Chauvenet P. H., Smith R. T.: Relationship of tumor-specific transplantation antigens to the histocompatibility complex: dissociation ofin vitro alloantigen expression andin vivo alloimmunity from tumor-specific transplantation antigen strength -Int. J. Cancer22, 79, 1978.
Cikes M., Friberg S., Jr.,Klein G.: Progressive loss of H-2 antigens with concomitant increase of cell-surface antigen(s) determined by Moloney leukemia virus in cultured murine lymphomas - J. nat. Cancer Inst.50, 347, 1973.
Collavo D., Parenti A., Biasi G., Chieco-Bianchi L., Colombatti A.: Secondaryin vitro generation of cytolytic T-lymphocytes (CTL’s) in the murine sarcoma virus system. Virusspecific CTL induction across the H-2 barriers - J. nat. Cancer Inst.61, 885, 1978.
Demant P.: H-2 gene complex and its role in alloimmune reactions - Transplant. Rev.15, 162, 1973.
De Vries J. E., Cornain S., Rumke P.: Cytotoxicity of non-T versus T-lymphocytes from melanoma patients and healthy donors on shortand long-term cultured melanoma cells - Int. J. Cancer14, 427, 1974.
Doherty P. C., Zinkernagel R. M.: H-2 compatibility is required for T-cell-mediated lysis of target cells infected with lymphocyte choriomeningitis virus - J. exp. Med.141, 502, 1975.
Fenyo E. M., Yefenof E., Klein E., Klein G.: Immunization of mice with syngeneic Moloney lymphoma cells induces antibodies against virion envelope glycoprotein and virusinduced cell surface antigens - J. exp. Med.146, 1521, 1977.
Forni G., Giovarelli M., Negro-Ponzi A., Landolfo S.: H-2 restriction and Ia-dependence of the efficient immune recognition of minor histocompatibility antigensin vivo - Immunogenetics9, 199, 1979.
Fossati G., Holden H. T., Herberman R. B.: Evaluation of the cell-mediated immune response to murine sarcoma virus by (125I) iododeoxyuridine assay and comparison with chromium 51 and microcytotoxicity assays - Cancer Res.35, 2600, 1975.
Fujimoto S., Chen C. H., Sabbadini E., Sehon A. H.: Association of tumor and histocompatibility antigens in sera of lymphoma-bearing mice - J. Immunol,111, 1093, 1973.
Fujiwara H., Aoki H., Tsuchida T., Hamaoka T.: Immunologic characterization of tumorassociated transplantation antigens on MM102 mammary tumor eliciting preferentially helper T cell activity - J. Immunol.121, 1591, 1978.
Garrido F., Festenstein H., Schirrmacher V.: Further evidence for derepression of H-2 and Ia-like specificities of foreign haplotypes in mouse tumour cell lines - Nature (Lond.)261, 271, 1976.
Garrido F., Perez M., Torres M. D.: Absence of four H-2d antigenic specificities in an H-2d sarcoma - J. Immunogenet.6, 83, 1979.
Germain R. W., Dorf H. E., Benacerraf B.: Inhibition of T lymphocyte-mediated tumorspecific lysis by alloantisera directed against the H-2 serological specificities of the tumor - J. exp. Med.142, 1023, 1975.
Gipson T. G., Imamura M., Conliffe M. D., Martin W. J.: Lung tumor-associated derepressed alloantigen coded for by the K region of the H-2 major histocompatibility complex - J. exp. Med.147, 1363, 1978.
Gomard E., Duprez V., Henin Y., Levy J. P.: H-2 region product determinant in immune cytolysis of syngeneic tumour cells by anti-MSV T lymphocytes - Nature (Lond.)250, 707, 1976.
Haywood G. R., McKahn C. F.: Antigenic specificities on murine sarcoma cells. Reciprocal relationship between normal transplantation antigens (H-2) and tumor-specific immunogenicity - J. exp. Med.133, 1171, 1971.
Herberman R. B.: Existence of tumor immunity in man - In:Cohen S., Green I. (Eds): Mechanisms of tumor immunity. J. Wiley and sons, New York, 1977; p. 175.
Hewitt H. B.: A critical examination of the foundations of immunotherapy for cancer - Clin. Radiol.30, 361, 1979.
Holden H. T., Landolfo S., Herberman R. B.: T-cell dependent reactivity against tumorassociated antigens on allogeneic target cells - Transplant. Proc.9, 1149, 1977.
Invernizzi G., Carbone G., Meschini A., Parmiani G.: Multiple foreign non-H-2 determinants on the surface of a chemically induced murine sarcoma - J. Immunogenet.4, 47, 1977.
Invernizzi G., Parmiani G.: Tumour-associated transplantation antigens of chemically induced sarcomata cross-reacting with allogeneic histocompatibility antigens - Nature (Lond.)254, 713, 1975.
Jondal M., Svedmyr E., Klein E., Singh S.: Killer T cells in a Burkitt’s lymphoma biopsy - Nature (Lond.)266, 405, 1975.
Kaneko Y., Natsuume-Sakai S., Migita S.: Cytotoxic T lymphocytes to murine plasmocytoma cells in allogeneic and syngeneic mice: H-2 antigens are essential in the induction and effector stages of CTL - J. Immunol.121, 427, 1978.
Kearney R., Basten A., Nelson D. S.: Cellular basis for the immune response to methylcholanthrene-induced tumors in mice. Heterogenicity of effector cells - Int. J. Cancer15, 438, 1975.
Law L. W., Dubois G. C., Rogers M. J., Appella E., Pierotti M. A., Parmiani G.: Tumor rejection activity of antigens isolated from the membranes of a methylcholanthreneinduced sarcoma, C-l, bearing alien H-2 antigens - Transplant. Proc.12, 46, 1980.
Lee S. K., Oliver R. T. D.: Autologous leukemia specific T cell-mediated lymphocytotoxicity in patients with acute myelogenous leukemia - J. exp. Med.147, 912, 1978.
Lennox E.: Personal communication.
Lennox E., Sikora K., Koch G.: The tumor specific transplantation antigens of methylcholanthrene induced murine sarcomas - In:Ferrone S., Herberman R. B., Reisfeld R. A., Gorini L. (Eds): Current trends in tumor immunology. Garland Publ. Inc., New York, 1979.
Leonard E. J.: Cell surface antigen movement: induction in hepatoma cells by antitumor antibody - J. Immunol.110, 1167, 1973.
Livingston P. O., Shiku H., Bean M. A., Pinsky C. M., Oettgen H. F., Old L. J.: Cellmediated cytotoxicity for cultured autologous melanoma cells - Int. J. Cancer24, 34, 1979.
Malley A., Burger D. R., Vandenbark A. A., Frikke H., Finke P., Begley D., Acott K., Black J., Vetto R. M.: Association of melanoma tumor antigen activity with β2-microglobulin - Cancer Res.39, 619, 1979.
Martin W. J.: Personal communication.
Martin W. J., Esber E., Cotton W. G., Rice J. M.: Derepression of alloantigens in malignancy. Evidence for tumor susceptibility alloantigens and for possible self-reactivity of lymphoid cells active in the microcytotoxicity assay - Brit. J. Cancer28 (Suppl. 1), 48, 1973.
Martin W. J., Gipson T. G., Conliffe M. D., Friedman R. J., Dove L., Rice J. M.: Common tumor-associated transplantation alloantigen detected on a proportion of lung tumors induced transplacentally in several strains of mice - Transplantation24, 294, 1977.
Martin W. J., Gipson T. G., Rice J. M.: H-2a associated alloantigen expressed by several transplacentally induced lung tumors of C3Hf mice - Nature (Lond.)265, 738, 1977.
McCabe R. P., Ferrone S., Pellegrino M. A., Kern D. H., Holmes E. C., Reisfeld R. A.: Purification and immunologic evaluation of human melanoma-associated antigens - J. nat. Cancer Inst.60, 773, 1978.
Meruelo D., Deak B., McDevitt H. O.: Genetic control of cell-mediated responsiveness to an AKR tumor-associated antigen. Mapping of the locus involved to the I region of the H-2 complex - J. exp. Med.146, 1367, 1977.
Meschini A., Invernizzi G., Parmiani G.: Expression of alien H-2 specificities on a chemically induced BALB/c flbrosarcoma - Int. J. Cancer20, 271, 1977.
Meschini A., Parmiani G.: Anti-H-2 alloantibodies elicited by syngeneic immunizations with a chemically induced flbrosarcoma - Immunogenetics6, 117, 1978.
Natori T., Law L. W., Appella E.: Biologic and biochemical properties of detergent-solubilized tumor-specific transplantation antigen from a simian virus 40-induced neoplasm - J. nat. Cancer Inst.59, 1331, 1977.
Natori T., Law L. W., Appella E.: Immunochemical evidence of a tumor-specific surface antigen obtained by detergent solubilization of the membranes of a chemically induced sarcoma, Meth-A - Cancer Res.38, 359, 1978.
Nelson D. S., Hopper K. E., Blanden R. V., Gardner I. D.: Failure of immunogenetic tumors to elicit cytolytic T cells in syngeneic hosts - Cancer Lett.5, 61, 1978.
Old L. J., Stockert E.: Immunogenetics of cell surface antigens of mouse leukemia - Ann. Rev. Genet.11, 127, 1977.
O’Toole C., Stejskal V., Perlmann P., Karlsson M.: Lymphoid cells mediating tumorspecific cytotoxicity to carcinoma of the urinary bladder - J. exp. Med.139, 457, 1974.
Parmiani G.: Unpublished observations.
Parmiani G.: Lack of identity between TSTA and alien antigens of methylcholanthrene-induced murine sarcomas - Transplant. Proc.12, 50, 1980.
Parmiani G., Ballinari D.: Genetic control ofin vivo immunity to tumor-specific transplantation antigens of chemically induced murine fibrosarcomas - Int. J. Cancer23, 697, 1979.
Parmiani G., Ballinari D., Sensi M. L.: Tumor-associated alien alloantigens of BALB/c tumors encoded by the MHC and by non-H-2 genes: a histogenetic study - J. Immunol.124, 662, 1980.
Parmiani G., Carbone G., Invernizzi G., Meschini A., Della Porta G.: Expression of genetically inappropriate histocompatibility antigens on the cell surface of experimental tumors and their relationship to tumor-associated transplantation antigens - In:Spreafico F., Arnon R. (Eds): Tumor-associated antigens and their specific immune response. Academic Press, New York, 1979; p. 31.
Parmiani G., Carbone G., Invernizzi G., Pierotti M. A., Sensi M. L., Rogers M. J., Appella E.: Alien histocompatibility antigens on tumor cells - Immunogenetics9, 1, 1979.
Parmiani G., Invernizzi G.: Alien histocompatibility determinants on the cell surface of sarcomas induced by methylcholanthrene. I.In vivo studies - Int. J. Cancer16, 756, 1975.
Parmiani G., Meschini A., Invernizzi G., Carbone G.: Tumor-associated transplantation antigen distinct from H-2k-like antigens on a BALB/c (H-2d) fibrosarcoma - J. nat. Cancer Inst.61, 1229, 1978.
Pellegrino M. A., Ferrone S., Hayflick L.: Changes in HL-A antigens profiles on SV40-transformed human fibroblasts - Exp. Cell Res.97, 340, 1976.
Phillips-Quagliata J. M., Walker M. C.: Genetic control of resistance to tumors - Amer. J. Path.93, 487, 1978.
Prehn L. M., Outzen H. C.: Primary tumor immunity in nude mice - Int. J. Cancer19, 688, 1978.
Robert F., Oth D., Dumont F.: Appearance of alien antigens in three ascitic sublines of a strain-specific solid polyoma-induced tumor line — (Submitted for publication).
Rogers M. J., Appella E., Pierotti M. A., Invernizzi G., Parmiani G.: Biochemical characterization of alien H-2 antigens expressed on a methylcholanthrene-induced tumor - Proc. nat. Acad.Sci.(Wash.)76, 1415, 1979.
Rogers M. J., Law L. W., Prat M., Oroszlan S., Appella E.: Separation of the tumor rejection antigen (TSTA) from the major viral structural proteins associated with the membrane of an R-MuLV-induced leukemia - Int. J. Cancer21, 246, 1978.
Rollinghoff M., Warner N. L.: Specificity ofin vivo tumor rejection assessed by mixing immune spleen cells with target and unrelated tumor cells - Proc. Soc. exp. Biol. (N.Y.)144, 813, 1973.
Rouse B. T. M., Rollinghoff M., Warner N. L.: Tumor-immunity to murine plasma cell tumors. III. Essential role of T lymphocytes in immune response - Europ. J. Immunol.3, 218, 1973.
Russell J. H., Ginns L. C., Terres G., Eisen H. N.: Tumor antigens as inappropriately expressed normal alloantigens - J. Immunol.122, 912, 1979.
Sato H., Boyse E. A., Aoki T., Iritani C., Old L. J.: Leukemia associated transplantation antigens related to murine leukemia virus. The X.1 system immune response controlled by a locus linked to H-2 - J. exp. Med.138, 593, 1973.
Schirrmacher V., Garrido F., Garcia-Olivares E., Perez M., Torres M. D.: Expression of alien H-2-like antigens by a chemically induced murine tumor (MCG4) - J. Immunogenet.7, 51, 1980.
Schirrmacher V., Garrido F., Hubsch D., Garcia-Olivares E., Koszinowski U.: Alien H-2-like molecules on a murine tumor (MCGA): target antigens for alloreactive cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) and restricting elements for virus specific CTL - Transplant. Proc.12, 32, 1980.
Schrader J. W., Edelman G. M.: Participation of the H-2 antigens of tumor cells in their lysis by syngeneic T cells - J. exp. Med.143, 601, 1976.
Sensi M. L., Carbone G., Parmiani G.: Unpublished observations.
Snell G. D., Cherry M., Demant P.: H-2: its structure and similarity to HL-A - Transplant. Rev.15, 3, 1973.
Thomson D. M. P., Gold P., Freedman S. O., Shuster J.: The isolation and characterization of tumor-specific antigens of rodent and human tumors - Cancer Res.36, 3518, 1976.
Thomson D. M. P., Rauch J. E., Weatherhead J. C., Friedlander P., O’Connor R., Grosser N., Shuster J., Gold P.: Isolation of human tumour-specific antigens associated with β2-microglobulin - Brit. J. Cancer37, 153, 1978.
Thomson D. M. P., Tataryn D. N., O’Connor R., Rauch J., Friedlander P., Gold P., Shuster J.: Evidence for the expression of human tumor-specific antigens associated with β2-microglobulin in human cancer and in some colon adenomas and benign breast lesions - Cancer Res.39, 604, 1979.
Ting C. C., Herberman R. B.: Inverse relationship of polyoma tumor specific cell surface antigen to H-2 histocompatibility antigens - Nature (Lond.)232, 118, 1971.
Ting C. C., Law L. W.: Studies of H-2 restriction in cell-mediated cytotoxicity and transplantation immunity to leukemia-associated antigens - J. Immunol.118, 4, 1977.
Trinchieri G., Aden D. P., Knowles B. B.: Cell-mediated cytotoxicity to SV40-specific tumor-associated antigens - Nature (Lond.)261, 312, 1976.
Vanky F., Klein E., Stjernsward J., Rodriguez L., Peterffy A., Steiner L., Nilsonne U.: Human tumor-lymphocyte interactionin vitro. III. T-lymphocytes in autologous tumor stimulation (ATS) - Int. J. Cancer22, 679, 1978.
Vose B. M., Vanky F., Fopp M., Klein E.:In vitro generation of cytotoxicity against autologous human tumor biopsy cells - Int. J. Cancer21, 588, 1978.
Vose B. M., Vanky F., Klein E.: Lymphocyte cytotoxicity against autologous tumour biopsy cells in humans - Int. J. Cancer20, 512, 1977.
Williams R. M., Dorf M. E., Benacerraf B.: H-2 linked genetic control of resistance to histocompatibility tumors - Cancer Res.35, 1586, 1975.
Wrathmell A., Gauci C. L., Alexander P.: Cross-reactivity of an allo-antigen present on normal cells with the tumour-specific transplantation type antigen of the acute myeloid leukemia (SAL) of rats - Brit. J. Cancer37, 187, 1976.
Wybran J., Hellstrom I., Hellstrom K. E., Fudenberg H. H.: Cytotoxicity of human rosette-forming blood lymphocytes on cultivated human tumor cells - Int. J. Cancer13, 515, 1974.
Yefenof E., Klein G.: Antibody-induced redistribution of normal and tumor associated surface antigens -Exp. Cell Res.88, 211, 1974.
Zarling J. M., Bach F. H.: Sensitization of lymphocytes against pooled allogeneic cells. I. Generation of cytotoxicity against autologous human lymphoblastoid cell lines - J. exp. Med.147, 1334, 1978.