The role of cognitive and socio-cognitive conflict in learning to reason

Mind & Society - Tập 7 - Trang 1-19 - 2007
Katiuscia Sacco1, Monica Bucciarelli1
1Centro di Scienza Cognitiva and Dipartimento di Psicologia, Università di Torino, Torino, Italy

Tóm tắt

The mental model theory claims that the ability to falsify is at the core of human rationality. We assume that cognitive conflicts (CCs) and socio-cognitive conflicts (SCCs) induce falsification, and thus improve syllogistic reasoning performance. Our first study assesses adults’ ability to reason in two different conditions in a single experimental session. In both conditions the participants are presented with conclusions alternative to their own. In the CC condition they are told that these conclusions are casual, in the SCC condition they are told they have been produced by another individual. The second study is analogous to the first, with the exception that the participants deal with the two conditions in two different experimental sessions. The overall results reveal that falsification is enhanced by conflicts experienced at the cognitive level. The results also reveal that learning to reason occurs in adults, when tested in two distinct experimental periods.

Tài liệu tham khảo

Ames GJ, Murray FB (1982) When two wrongs make a right: promoting cognitive change by social conflict. Dev Psychol 18:894–897 Bahrick HP, Phelps E (1987) Retention of Spanish vocabulary over eight years. J Exp Psychol Learn Mem Cogn 13:344–349 Bara BG, Bucciarelli M, Johnson-Laird PN (1995) Development of syllogistic reasoning. Am J Psychol 2:157–193 Bara BG, Bucciarelli M, Lombardo V (2001) The mental model theory of deduction: a unified computational approach. Cognit Sci 25:839–901 Baron-Cohen S (1994) How to build a baby that can read minds: cognitive mechanism in mind reading. Cah Psychol Cognit 13:1–40 Bearison DJ (1986) Transactional cognition in context: new models of social understanding. In: Bearison DJ, Zimiles H (eds) Thought and emotion: development perspectives. Erlbaum, Hillsdale, pp 129–146 Braine MDS (1998) Steps towards a mental predicate logic. In: Braine MDS, O’Brien DP (eds) Mental logic. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, pp 27–331 Bruner J, Oliver R, Greenfield P (1966) Studies in cognitive growth. New York, John Wiley & Sons Bucciarelli M (2007) How the construction of mental models improves learning. Mind Soc 6(1) (in press) Bucciarelli M, Johnson-Laird PN (1999) Strategies in syllogistic reasoning. Cognit Sci 23:247–303 Bucciarelli M, Johnson-Laird PN (2001) Falsification and the role of the theory of mind in the reduced array selection task. Curr Psychol Lett 4:7–22 Butera F, Caverni J-P, Rossi S (2005) Interaction with a high- versus low-competence influence source in inductive reasoning. J Soc Psychol 145:173–190 Cheng P, Holyoak KJ (1985) Pragmatic reasoning schemas. Cognit Psychol 17:391–416 Cummins DD (1996) Evidence of deontic reasoning in 3- and 4-year-old children. Mem Cognit 24:823–829 Dempster FN (1996) Distributing and managing the conditions of encoding and practice. In: Bjork EL, Bjork RA (eds) Memory. Academic, San Diego, pp 318–344 Doise W, Mugny G (1984) The social development of the intellect. Pergamon, Oxford Druyan S (2001) A comparison of four types of cognitive conflict and their effect on cognitive development. Int J Behav Dev 25:226–236 Druyan S, Levin L (1996) The differential contribution of field-dependent-independent cognitive styles to socio-cognitive transaction in promoting scientific reasoning. Int J Behav Dev 19:831–850 Ebbinghaus H (1985) Uber das Gedachtnis. Duncker and Humblot, Leipzig Evans JStBT (1982) The psychology of deductive reasoning. Routledge & Kegan Paul, London Evans JStBT (2000) What could and could not be a strategy in reasoning. In: Schaeken W, De Vooght G, Vandierendonck A, d’Ydewalle G (eds) Deductive reasoning and strategies. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, London, pp 1–22 Evans JStBT, Over DE (1996) Rationality and reasoning. Psychology Press, Hove Evans JStBT, Handley SJ, Harper C, Johnson-Laird PN (1999) Reasoning about necessity and possibility: a test of the mental model theory of deduction. J Exp Psychol Learn Mem Cogn 25:1495–1513 Evans JStBT, Handley SJ, Harper C (2001) Necessity, possibility and belief: a study of syllogistic reasoning. Q J Exp Psychol 54A:935–958 Glenberg AM (1977) Influences of retrieval processes on the spacing effect in free recall. J Exp Psychol [Hum Learn] 3:282–294 Glenberg AM (1979) Component-levels theory of the effects of spacing of repetitions on recall and recognition. Mem Cognit 7:95–112 Griggs RA (1983) The role of problem content in the selection task and THOG problem. In: Evans JStBT (ed) Thinking and reasoning: psychological approaches. Routledge & Kegan Paul, London Johnson-Laird PN (1983) Mental models: towards a cognitive science of language, and consciousness. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge Johnson-Laird PN, Byrne RMJ (1991) Deduction. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Ltd, London Klauer KC, Musch J, Naumer B (2000) On belief bias in syllogistic reasoning. Psychol Rev 107:852–884 Legrenzi P, Butera F, Mugny G, Pérez JA (1991) Majority and minority influence in inductive reasoning. Eur J Soc Psychol 21:359–363 Leicht KL, Overton R (1987) Encoding variability and spacing repetitions. Am J Psychol 100:61–68 Leslie AM (1987) Pretense and representation: the origins of “Theory of mind.” Psychol Rev 94:412–426 Levin I, Siegler RS, Druyan S (1990) Misconceptions about motion: development and training effects. Child Dev 61:1544–1557 Lyons JC (1999) Carving the mind and its (not necessarily modular) joints. In: Wilson RA, Keil F (eds) The MIT encyclopedia of the cognitive sciences. MIT, Cambridge Neth H, Johnson-Laird PN (1999) The search for counterexamples in human reasoning. In: Hahn N, Stoness SC (eds) Proceedings of the twenty first annual conference of the Cognitive Science Society. Lawrence Erlbaum, Mahwah, p 806 Newstead SE, Handley SJ, Buck E (1999) Falsifying mental models: testing the predictions of theories of syllogistic reasoning. J Mem Lang 27:344–354 Perret-Clermont AN (1980) Social interaction and cognitive development in children. Academic, London Premack D, Woodruff G (1978) Does the chimpanzee have a theory of mind? Behav Brain Sci 1:515–526 Rips LJ (1994) The psychology of proof: deductive reasoning in human thinking. MIT, Cambridge Saljo R, Wyndhamm J (1990) Problem solving, academic performance and situated learning. A study of joint cognitive activity in the formal setting. Brit J Educ Psychol 60:245–254 Schacter DL (1989) Memory. In: Posner MI (ed) Foundations of cognitive science. MIT, Cambridge, pp 683–725 Schaeken W, De Vooght G, Vandierendonck A, d’Ydewalle G (2000) Deductive reasoning and strategies. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, London Siegler RS (1995) How does change occur: a microgenetic study of number conservation. Cognit Psychol 28:225–273 Stanovich KE, West RF (2000) Individual differences in reasoning: implications for the rationality debate? Behav Brain Sci 23:645–665 Vygotskij LS (1978) Mind in society: the development of higher psychological processes. Harvard University Press, Cambridge Wason P (1968) Reasoning about a rule. Q J Exp Psychol 20:273–281