The quest for harmonisation in anti-doping: an Indian perspective

The International Sports Law Journal - Tập 23 Số 1 - Trang 44-63 - 2023
Shaun Star1
1Professor, Jindal Global Law School, O.P. Jindal Global University, Sonipat, Haryana, India

Tóm tắt

AbstractThe World Anti-Doping Agency aims to promote clean sport through the introduction and implementation of harmonised rules under the World Anti-Doping Code, 2021 (the Code). Since WADA relies heavily on National Anti-Doping Organisations to implement the Code, the experience of anti-doping differs across countries. Some scholars argue that the current framework disproportionately impacts athletes from developing countries. This paper contributes to this debate by analysing systemic issues in the implementation of the Code in one such country—India. The legitimacy of anti-doping in India has been questioned as a result of the recent suspension of the National Dope-Testing Laboratory, a series of false positive tests, accusations of significant procedural and substantive errors by domestic tribunals, and access to justice challenges. Given the prevalence of doping in India, alongside the accumulation of recent controversies and push for reform, a deeper analysis of anti-doping in the country is warranted. The lack of compliance in India with certain requirements set out in the Code, as well as the failure to meet “best practice” standards set by other jurisdictions, is evidence that there is a lack of harmonisation in implementing anti-doping rules and procedures across countries. This paper contributes to the debate on the impact that a lack of harmonisation in the implementation of the Code can have on the legitimacy of the anti-doping framework. From a policy perspective, the proposed research agenda and recommendations can be applied to promote reform in India and other jurisdictions, especially in developing and emerging countries.

Từ khóa


Tài liệu tham khảo

Abrahamson A (2009) Jessica Hardy, advocare file suit against each other. 30 January 2009, Swimming World Magazine. https://www.swimmingworldmagazine.com/news/jessica-hardy-advocare-file-suit-against-each-other/. Accessed 29 Sept 2021

Backhouse SH, Collins C, Defoort Y, McNamee M, Parkinson A, Sauer M (2014) Study on doping prevention: a map of legal, regulatory and prevention practice provisions in EU 28. Publications Office, Luxembourg

Batt A (2011) The role of UK Anti-Doping in the fight against doping in sport. Int J Sport Policy Polit 3(2):261–270. https://doi.org/10.1080/19406940.2011.577794

CAS, (2020) Guidelines on legal aid before the Court of Arbitration for Sport. 1 November 2020. https://www.tas-cas.org/en/add/legal-aid.html. Accessed 29 Sep 2021

Cléret L (2011) The role of anti-doping education in delivering WADA’s mission. Int J Sport Policy Polit 3(2):271–277. https://doi.org/10.1080/19406940.2011.577084

Cyriac BB (2018) NADA claims quality of dope tests important, not quantity. 26 July 2018, The Times of India. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/sports/more-sports/others/nada-claims-quality-of-dope-tests-important-not-quantity/articleshow/65144573.cms. Accessed 21 Feb 2022

Das I (2021) In a first, DNA test clears Indian motorbike rider of doping taint. 4 June 2021. The New Indian Express. https://www.newindianexpress.com/sport/other/2021/jun/04/in-a-first-dna-test-clears-indian-motorbike-rider-of-doping-taint-2311733.html. Accessed 29 Sep 2021

Dasgupta L (2019) The World Anti-Doping Code: fit for purpose? Routledge, London

David P (2016) Hearing anti-doping cases in New Zealand. In: Haas U, Healey D (eds) Doping in sport and the law. Hart Publishing, Oxford, pp 127–146

Dayal A (2018) The error in zero tolerance. 1 June 2018, The Indian Express. https://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/indian-olympics-sports-anti-doping-athletes-the-error-in-zero-tolerance-5199304/. Accessed 29 Sep 2021

Dayal A (2019) Athletes and medication—duty of care. The Times of India, 3 August. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/blogs/toi-edit-page/athletes-and-medication-duty-of-care/. Accessed 29 Sep 2021

de la Torre X, Jardines D, Curcio D, Colamonici C, Botrè F (2019) Isotope ratio mass spectrometry in antidoping analysis: the use of endogenous reference compounds. Rapid Commun Mass Spectrom 33(6):579–586. https://doi.org/10.1002/rcm.8377

Dimeo P, Møller V (2018) The anti-doping crisis in sport: causes, consequences, solutions. Routledge, New York

Efverström A, Bäckström Å (2017) Different societies—different conditions: lessons from anti-doping in elite sport on a global level. In: International network for doping research, conference on doping in sport, doping in society: lessons, themes, and connections. https://ph.au.dk/fileadmin/user_upload/INDR_2017_Book_of_Abstracts.pdf. Accessed 29 Sep 2021

Gatterer K, Gumpenberger M, Overbye M, Streicher B, Schobersberger W, Blank C (2020) An evaluation of prevention initiatives by 53 national anti-doping organizations: achievements and limitations. J Sport Health Sci 9(3):228–239

Gray S (2019) Achieving compliance with the World Anti-Doping Code: learning from the implementation of another international agreement. Int J Sport Policy Polit 11(2):247–260

Hanstad DV, Skille EÅ, Loland S (2010) Harmonization of anti-doping work: myth or reality? Sport Soc 13(3):418–430. https://doi.org/10.1080/17430431003588036

Houlihan B (2013) Achieving compliance in international anti-doping policy: an analysis of the 2009 world anti-doping code. Sport Manag Rev 17(3):265–276. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.smr.2013.10.002

Hussain S (2019) WADA had serious trust issues with NDTL’s testing procedures. 24 August 2019, Times of India. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/sports/more-sports/others/wada-had-serious-trust-issues-with-ndtls-testing-procedures/articleshow/70813844.cms. Accessed 29 Sep 2021

Hussain S (2020a) NADA decriminalises doping offence by athletes. 29 August 2020a, The Times of India. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/sports/more-sports/nada-decriminalises-doping-offence-by-athletes/articleshow/77813929.cms. Accessed 29 Sep 2021

Hussain S (2020b) NADA, NDTL to become independent of government control. 16 December 2020b, The Times of India. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/sports/more-sports/others/nada-ndtl-to-become-independent-of-government-control/articleshow/79751640.cms. Accessed 29 Sep 2021

Hussain S (2022) Anti-doping bill proposes to give 'full policing authority' to NADA officials. 8 January 2022, The Times of India. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/sports/more-sports/others/anti-doping-bill-proposes-to-give-full-policing-authority-to-nada-officials/articleshow/88768785.cms. Accessed 10 Mar 2022.

Kambhampati A, Star S (2021) Playing true? A critique of the 2021 WADA code. Int Sports Law J. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40318-021-00193-z

Klüttermann S (2019). Vorstoß von Ländern und Nada: Doping-Prävention soll Schulstoff werden [Advance by Federal States and Nada: Doping Prevention to be Taught in Schools]. https://rp-online.de/sport/andere/sportministerkonferenz-2019-doping-praevention-soll-schulstoff-werden_aid-47015209. Accessed 8 Mar 2022

Kothari A, Mehrotra A (2019) Why the National Dope Testing Laboratory (New Delhi) has been suspended by WADA and what it means for Indian sport. 8 October 2019, LawInSport. https://www.lawinsport.com/topics/item/why-the-national-doping-test-laboratory-new-delhi-has-been-suspended-by-wada-and-what-it-means-for-indian-sport. Accessed 29 Sep 2021

Krishnan A, Datta K, Sharma D, Sharma SD, Mahajan U, Jhajharia S, Yadav M (2022) Survey of antidoping knowledge, attitudes and practices amongst elite Indian sportsmen and the way forward. Med J Arm Forces India 78:88–93

Krishnan JK, Kavadi SN, Girach A, Khupkar D (2014) Grappling at the grassroots: access to justice in India’s lower tier. Harv Hum Rts J 27:151

Krolak J (2015) Banned Olympian blames diet supplements. 26 August 2015, Courthouse News Service. https://www.courthousenews.com/banned-olympian-blames-diet-supplements/. Accessed 29 Sep 2021

Martinez-Sanz JM, Sospedra I, Ortiz CM, Baladia E, Gil-Izquierdo A, Ortiz-Moncada R (2017) Intended or unintended doping? A review of the presence of doping substances in dietary supplements used in sports. Nutrients 9:E1093

McArdle D (2015) ‘Strict liability’ and legal rights: nutritional supplements, ‘intent’ and ‘risk’ in the parallel world of WADA. In: Møller V, Waddington I, Hoberman JM (eds) Routledge handbook of drugs and sport. Routledge, Abingdon, pp 293–309

Mohan KP (2019) NDTL losing accreditation comes as no surprise. 23 August 2019, Sportsstar. https://sportstar.thehindu.com/other-sports/wada-suspends-ndtl-accreditation-setback-for-nada-davinder-singh-kang-doping/article29235674.ece. Accessed 29 Sep 2021

Mohan KP (2020) Anti-doping cases: panels err in handing out sanctions for specified substances. 10 December 2020, Sportsstar. https://sportstar.thehindu.com/other-sports/anti-doping-cases-sanctions-for-specified-substances-nada-wada/article33301910.ece. Accessed 29 Sep 2021

Moston S, Engelberg T (2019) And justice for all? how anti-doping responds to ‘innocent mistakes.’ Int J Sport Policy Polit 11(2):261–274. https://doi.org/10.1080/19406940.2018.1550799

Müller D (2017) How to protect the clean athletes? German J Exerc Sport Res 47(3):1–11. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12662-017-0446-3

NADA 2021. Primary functions. https://www.nadaindia.org/en/primaryfunctions. Accessed 29 Sep 2021

NADA 2022. List of sportspersons tested positive against dope substances and sanction imposed by Anti Doping Disciplinary Panel w. e. f. 01-01-2009 till date. https://www.nadaindia.org/upload_file/document/1642661657.pdf. Accessed 23 Feb 2022

Park J (2005) Governing doped bodies: the world anti-doping agency and the global culture of surveillance. Crit Methodol 5(2):174–188. https://doi.org/10.1177/1532708605274945

Pielke R Jr, Boye E (2019) Scientific integrity and anti-doping regulation. Int J Sport Policy Polit. https://doi.org/10.1080/19406940.2019.1596968

Pöppel K (2021) Efficient ways to combat doping in a sports education context!? A systematic review on doping prevention measures focusing on young age groups. Front Sports Act Liv. https://doi.org/10.3389/fspor.2021.673452

Press Information Bureau, Ministry of Youth Affairs and Sports, Government of India (2016) NADA outreach programme to make Indian athletes aware about pitfalls of taking substances prohibited by WADA. 29 April 2016. http://pib.nic.in/newsite/PrintRelease.aspx?relid=142588. Accessed 29 Sep 2021

PTI (2019) NDTL’s suspension will hamper India’s anti-doping programme: Expert. 23 August 2019, Economic Times. https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/sports/ndtls-suspension-will-hamper-indias-anti-doping-programme-expert/articleshow/70804328.cms?from=mdr. Accessed 29 Sep 2021

Rajaraman G (2020) ADDP mess up orders. 20 July 2020, Mail Today. https://circleofsport.com/addps-mess-up-orders/. Accessed 29 Sep 2021

Read D, Skinner J, Lock D, Houlihan B (2019) Legitimacy driven change at the World Anti-Doping Agency. Int J Sport Policy Polit 11(2):233–245. https://doi.org/10.1080/19406940.2018.1544580

Rehn N, Naik A, Jain D, Singh A, Robinson N, So WW, Aniruddha J, Rai S, Rai S, Patil C, Bindal A, Goel R, Kanwar V (2011) Justice without delay: recommendations for legal and institutional reforms in the indian courts. Jindal Global Legal Research Paper No. 4/2011, https://ssrn.com/abstract=1679350

Sharma D (2020) Notice issued to NADA on athlete's petition challenging Art. 7.3.1

(f) of NADA Rules, 2015. 8 October 2020, SCC Blog. https://www.scconline.com/blog/post/2020/10/08/del-hc-notice-issued-to-nada-on-athletes-petition-challenging-art-7-3-1f-of-nada-rules-2015/. Accessed 29 Sep 2021

Singhania V, Kothari C (2021) Is national sports arbitration the way forward?. In: Samant Y, Balyan C (eds) Specialized arbitration: emerging international trends and practices. Thomson Reuters, Mumbai, pp 332–352

Singhania V, Dhingra A (2021) How DNA determined sample identity in an anti-doping first for India—the case of Vijay Singh. 3 September 2021, LawInSport. https://www.lawinsport.com/topics/item/how-dna-was-used-to-determine-sample-identity-in-an-anti-doping-first-for-india-the-case-of-vijay-singh. Accessed 29 Sep 2021

Star S, Kelly S (2021) A level playing field in anti-doping disputes? The need to scrutinize procedural fairness at first instance hearings. Int Sports Law J 21:94–117. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40318-020-00176-6

Star S, Kelly S (2022) Examining procedural fairness in anti-doping disputes: a comparative empirical analysis. Int Sports Law J. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40318-022-00222-5

The Economic Times (2011) Coach sacked, probe ordered in doping scandal. 6 July 2011, The Economic Times. https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/news-by-industry/et-cetera/coach-sacked-probe-ordered-in-doping-scandal/articleshow/9120378.cms?curpg=2. Accessed 29 Sep 2021

The Economic Times (2019) NDTL’s suspension will hamper India's anti-doping programme. 23 August 2019, The Economic Times. https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/articleshow/70804328.cms?from=mdr&utm_source=contentofinterest&utm_medium=text&utm_campaign=cppst. Accessed 29 Sep 2021

The Hindu (2017) India ranks 3rd for third year in a row in world doping chart. 4 April 2017, The Hindu. http://www.thehindu.com/sport/india-ranked-3rd-for-third-year-in-row-in-wada-doping-charts/article17804673.ece. Accessed 29 Sep 2021

The Times of India (2017) Food supplements to be audited by FSSAI: Vijay Goel. 30 June 2017, The Times of India. http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/sports/more-sports/others/food-supplements-to-be-audited-by-fssai-vijay-goel/articleshow/59382127.cms. Accessed 29 Sep 2021

Vasavda M (2017) Sports Ministry clears move to make doping a criminal offence. 25 March 2017, The Indian Express. http://indianexpress.com/article/sports/sports-ministry-clears-move-to-make-doping-a-criminal-offence-wada-4584518/. Accessed 29 Sep 2021

Vasavda M (2020a) Four samples tested positive at Delhi lab turn out negative in Rome. 4 March 2020a, The Indian Express. https://indianexpress.com/article/sports/sport-others/four-samples-tested-positive-at-delhi-lab-turns-out-negative-in-rome-6297994/. Accessed 29 Sep 2021

Vasavda M (2020b) Cost of India’s dope-testing lab suspension: Higher testing costs, reduction in tests. 23 July 2020b, The Indian Express. https://indianexpress.com/article/sports/sport-others/cost-of-india-dope-testing-lab-suspension-higher-testing-costs-reduction-6518891/. Accessed 29 Sep 2021

WADA (2010) WADA Suspends Penang Laboratory from Anti-Doping Analyses. 27 May 2010. https://www.wada-ama.org/en/media/news/2010-05/wada-suspends-penang-laboratory-from-anti-doping-analyses. Accessed 29 Sep 2021

WADA (2015) 2013 Anti-doping rule violations (ADRVs) report. https://www.wada-ama.org/sites/default/files/resources/files/wada-2013-adrv-report-en.pdf

WADA (2016a) Indian Anti-Doping Program receives boost after striking partnership with ASADA. 5 July 2016. https://www.wada-ama.org/en/media/news/2016-07/indian-anti-doping-program-receives-boost-after-striking-partnership-with-asada. Accessed 29 Sep 2021

WADA (2016b) 2014 Anti-doping rule violations (ADRVs) report. https://www.wada-ama.org/sites/default/files/resources/files/wada-2014-adrv-report-en_0.pdf

WADA (2017) 2015 Anti-doping rule violations (ADRVs) report. http://www.wada-ama.org/sites/default/files/resources/files/2015_adrvs_report_web_release_0.pdf

WADA (2018) 2016 Anti-doping rule violations (ADRVs) report. https://www.wada-ama.org/sites/default/files/resources/files/2016_anti-doping_testing_figures.pdf

WADA (2019a) 2017 Anti-doping rule violations (ADRVs) report. https://www.wada-ama.org/sites/default/files/resources/files/2017_adrv_report.pdf

WADA (2019b) WADA suspends accreditation of New Delhi Laboratory. https://www.wada-ama.org/en/media/news/2019b-08/wada-suspends-accreditation-of-new-delhi-laboratory. Accessed 29 Sep 2021

WADA (2019c) WADA education—helping athlete who want to compete clean. https://www.wada-ama.org/en/media/news/2019c-10/wada-education-helping-athletes-who-want-to-compete-clean. Accessed 29 Sep 2021

WADA (2020a) 2018 Anti-doping rule violations (ADRVs) report. http://www.wada-ama.org/sites/default/files/resources/files/2018_adrv_report.pdf.

WADA (2020b) 2019 Anti-doping testing figures. https://www.wada-ama.org/sites/default/files/resources/files/2019_anti-doping_testing_figures_en.pdf

WADA (2020c) 2021 Code Implementation Support Program Guidelines for the International Standard for Education (ISE). September 2020c. https://www.wada-ama.org/sites/default/files/resources/files/guidelinesforeducation_final.pdf. Accessed 8 Mar 2022

WADA (2021a) World anti-doping code. https://www.wada-ama.org/en/questions-answers/world-anti-doping-code. Accessed 29 Sep 2021a

WADA (2021b) 2020 Anti-doping testing figures. https://www.wada-ama.org/sites/default/files/2022-01/2020_anti-doping_testing_figures_en.pdf

WADA (2021c) WADA reinstates accreditation of New Delhi Laboratory. 22 December 2021c. https://www.wada-ama.org/en/news/wada-reinstates-accreditation-new-delhi-laboratory. Accessed 8 Mar 2022

WADA (2021d) WADA Executive Committee endorses recommendations of non-compliance of eight Anti-Doping Organizations. 14 September 2021d. https://www.wada-ama.org/en/news/wada-executive-committee-endorses-recommendations-non-compliance-eight-anti-doping. Accessed 8 Mar 2022

Weston MA (2009) Doping control, mandatory arbitration, and process dangers for accused athletes in international sports. Pepperdine Dispute Resol Law J 10(1):5–50

Winand M (2015) Analysis of the role and challenges of sport federations in doping prevention in the UK [Anti-doping education in the UK]. The Carnegie Trust. School of Sport, University of Stirling, UK. http://hdl.handle.net/1893/21984

Woolf JR (2020) An examination of anti-doping education initiatives from an educational perspective: Insights and recommendations for improved educational design. Perform Enhanc Health. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.peh.2020.100178

Yang K, Dimeo P, Winand M (2021) Anti-doping in China: an analysis of the policy implementation processes through stakeholders’ perspectives. Sport Manag Rev. https://doi.org/10.1080/14413523.2021.1917247