The paradox of externally driven localisation: a case study on how local actors manage the contradictory legitimacy requirements of top-down bottom-up aid
Tóm tắt
There are ongoing calls in the humanitarian and development sectors to localise aid, make it more participatory and involve communities. A common response to these calls by INGOs and national governments is to work with local actors to jointly deliver local, community-based, participatory aid. However, this setup tends to be hierarchical, with external actors taking the lead on project design and local actors on implementation. As a result, key outcomes envisioned for localisation and participation in aid often do not materialise. This paper explores the role legitimacy work plays in maintaining this unhelpful status quo. To this end, it provides a qualitative case study analysis of an aid project in Ethiopia (2016–2020) that was initiated by two INGOs and built on government structures designed to facilitate mass volunteering at community level: the Women’s Development Army. The paper argues that externally driven localisation is often organised around project models that are shaped by two contradictory paradigms: one centring resilience and one centring surveillance. As a result, local aid workers and civil servants are faced with incompatible legitimacy requirements in their work. This paper uses a paradox perspective as a theoretical lens to explore how these local actors navigate these conflicting needs. It finds that they use impression management, especially visuals and performances, to sidestep the contradictions. This imagery conceals the disconnects between project strategy, implementation and the reality on the ground. As a side effect, it renders the problems with the externally driven approach invisible and legitimises the hierarchical status quo.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Aldrich DP, Meyer MA (2015) Social Capital and Community Resilience. Am Behav Sci 59(2):254–269. https://doi.org/10.1177/0002764214550299
Aloudat T (2021) The damage aid workers can do just with their words. The National News. Available on line at: https://www.thenationalnews.com/opinion/comment/the-damage-aid-workers-can-do-with-just-their-words-1.1190907
Anholt RM (2022) Governing (in)security and the politics of resilience: The politics, policy, and practice of building resilience in fragile and conflict-affected contexts [PhD Thesis, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam] https://research.vu.nl/en/publications/governing-insecurity-and-the-politics-of-resilience-the-politics
Assefa Y, Gelaw YA, Hill PS, Taye BW, van Damme W (2019) Community health extension program of Ethiopia, 2003–2018: successes and challenges toward universal coverage for primary healthcare services. Glob Health 15(1):24. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12992-019-0470-1
Attride-Stirling J (2001) Thematic networks: an analytic tool for qualitative research. Qual Res 1(3):385–405. https://doi.org/10.1177/146879410100100307
Baguios A, King M, Martins A, Pinnington R (2021) Are we there yet? Localisation as the journey towards locally led practice: models, approaches and challenges. ODI Repor. ODI, London (https://odi.org/en/publications/are-we-there-yet-localisation-as-thejourney-towards-locally-led-practice)
Barbelet V (2018) As local as possible, as international as necessary: understanding capacity and complementarity in humanitarian action (HPG Working Paper) https://cdn.odi.org/media/documents/As_local_as_possible_as_international_as_necessary_understanding_capacity_and_comp.pdf
Barnett M (2013) Empire of Humanity: A History of Humanitarianism. Ithaca, Cornell University Press.
Boersma K, van Brakel R, Fonio C, Wagenaar P (2014) Histories of state surveillance in Europe and beyond. In: Boersma K, van Brakel R, Fonio C, Wagenaar P (eds). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203366134
Chambers R (1983) Rural Development: Putting the Last First. 1st ed. Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315835815
Claeyé F, Jackson T (2012) The iron cage re-revisited: institutional isomorphism in non-profit organisations in South Africa. J Int Dev 24(5):602–622
Closser S, Napier H, Maes K, Abesha R, Gebremariam H, Backe G, Fossett S, Tesfaye Y (2019) Does volunteer community health work empower women? Evidence from Ethiopia’s Women’s Development Army. Health Policy Plan 34(4):298–306. https://doi.org/10.1093/heapol/czz025
Cohen AP (1985) The symbolic construction of community. Taylor & Francis. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203323373
Collinson S (2016) Constructive deconstruction: making sense of the international humanitarian system (HPG working paper). https://www.odi.org/publications/10503-constructive-deconstruction-making-sense-international-humanitarian-system
Conway SL, O'Keefe PA, Hrasky SL (2015) Legitimacy, accountability and impression management in NGOs: the Indian Ocean tsunami. Account Audit Account J 28(7):1075–1098. https://doi.org/10.1108/AAAJ-04-2012-01007
Croke K (2021) The origins of Ethiopia’s primary health care expansion: the politics of state building and health system strengthening. Health Policy Plan 35(10):1318–1327. https://doi.org/10.1093/heapol/czaa095
Davison J (2014) Visual rhetoric and the case of intellectual capital. Acc Organ Soc 39(1):20–37
Deegan CM (2019) Legitimacy theory. Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal 32(8):2307–2329
Development Initiatives (2015) Global Humanitarian Assistance Report 2015. http://devinit.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/GHA-Report-2015_-Interactive_Online-1.pdf
Dhanani A, Kennedy D (2023) Envisioning legitimacy: visual dimensions of NGO annual reports. Account Audit Account J 36(1):348–377
Dhungana N, Curato N (2021) When participation entrenches authoritarian practice: ethnographic investigations of post-disaster governance. Int J Disaster Risk Reduction 59:102159
Eisenhardt KM (1989) Building theories from case study research. Acad Manag Rev 14(4):532. https://doi.org/10.2307/258557
Eisenhardt KM, Graebner ME (2007) Theory building from cases: opportunities and challenges. Acad Manag J 50(1):25–32. https://doi.org/10.5465/amj.2007.24160888
Faas AJ, Marino EK (2020) Mythopolitics of “community”: an unstable but necessary category. Disaster Prevention and Management: an International Journal 29(4):481–484. https://doi.org/10.1108/DPM-04-2020-0101
FAO (2016) Ethiopia Situation Report – February 2016. https://www.fao.org/fileadmin/user_upload/emergencies/docs/FAO%20Ethiopia_El%20Nino%20Situation%20Report_February%202016.pdf
Fick M (2019) Ethiopia’s surveillance network crumbles, meaning less fear and less control. Reuters. https://www.reuters.com/article/uk-ethiopia-politics-surveillance-insigh-idUKKBN1YL1BS
Hilhorst D (2018) Classical humanitarianism and resilience humanitarianism: making sense of two brands of humanitarian action. Journal of International Humanitarian Action 3(1):15. https://doi.org/10.1186/s41018-018-0043-6
Hrasky S (2012) Visual disclosure strategies adopted by more and less sustainability-driven companies. Accounting Forum 36(3):154–65. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.accfor.2012.02.001
Kafle SK, Murshed Z (2006) Community-based disaster risk management for local authorities
Keating VC, Thrandardottir E (2017) NGOs, trust, and the accountability agenda. The British Journal of Politics and International Relations 19(1):134–151
Kuipers E, Desportes I, Hordijk M (2019) Of locals and insiders: a “localized” humanitarian response to the 2017 mudslide in Mocoa, Colombia? Disaster Prev Manag 29(3):352–364
Lefsrud L, Graves H, Phillips N (2020) “Giant toxic lakes you can see from space”: a theory of multimodal messages and emotion in legitimacy work. Organ Stud 41(8):1055–1078
Lin N (2001) Social capital. Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511815447
Maes K, Closser S, Vorel E, Tesfaye Y (2015) Using community health workers: discipline and hierarchy in Ethiopia's Women's Development Army. Practice 39(1):42–57. https://doi.org/10.1111/napa.12064
Maskrey A (1984) Community based disaster mitigation. International conference on disaster mitigation program implementation
Melis S, Apthorpe R (2020) The politics of the multi-local in disaster governance. Politics Gov 8(4):366–74. https://doi.org/10.17645/pag.v8i4.3174
Meyer RE, Hollerer MA, Jancsary D, Van Leeuwen T (2013) The visual dimension in organizing, organization, and organization research: core ideas, current developments, and promising avenues. Acad Manag Ann 7(1):489–555
Mosse D (2003) The making and marketing of participatory development. In: van Ufford PQ, Kumar Giri A, editors. A moral critique of development. London, Routledge, pp. 57–89
Mulder F (2020) Humanitarian data justice: a structural data justice lens on civic technologies in post-earthquake Nepal. Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management 28(4):432–445
Mulder F (2023) Localizing humanitarian knowledge management: a call for pragmatic robust action. In: van Wessel M, Kontinen T, Bawole JN (eds) Reimagining civil society collaborations in development. Routledge, Starting from the south
Poole MS, van de Ven AH (1989) Using paradox to build management and organization theories. Acad Manag Rev 14(4):562. https://doi.org/10.2307/258559
Ridder H-G (2017) The theory contribution of case study research designs. Bus Res 10(2):281–305. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40685-017-0045-z
Scaling Up Nutrition (2011) A Framework for Action. Available at: https://scalingupnutrition.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/SUN_Framework.pdf
Schad J, Lewis MW, Raisch S, Smith WK (2016) Paradox research in management science: looking back to move forward. Acad Manag Ann 10(1):5–64. https://doi.org/10.5465/19416520.2016.1162422
Smith WK, Lewis MW (2011) Toward a theory of paradox: a dynamic equilibrium model of organizing. Acad Manag Rev 36(2):381–403. https://doi.org/10.5465/amr.2009.0223
Stake RE (1995) The art of case study research. Thousand Oaks, California, SAGE Publications Ltd
Suchman MC (1995) Managing legitimacy: strategic and institutional approaches. Acad Manag Rev 20(3):571. https://doi.org/10.2307/258788
Teklehaimanot HD, Teklehaimanot A (2013) Human resource development for a community-based health extension program: a case study from Ethiopia. Hum Resour Health 11(1):39. https://doi.org/10.1186/1478-4491-11-39
The Lancet (2013) Maternal and Child Nutrition. Series from the Lancet journals. Available at: https://www.thelancet.com/series/maternal-and-child-nutrition
Thrandardottir E (2015) NGO legitimacy: four models. Representation 51(1):107–123
Tierney K (2014) The social roots of risk. Stanford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1515/9780804791403
Titz A, Cannon T, Krüger F (2018) Uncovering ‘community’: challenging an elusive concept in development and disaster related work. Societies 8(3):71. https://doi.org/10.3390/soc8030071
UNDRR (2015) Sendai framework for disaster risk reduction 2015 - 2030. Third UN world conference on disaster risk reduction. pp 1–32
UNICEF (2016) ETHIOPIA humanitarian situation report #4. https://reliefweb.int/report/ethiopia/unicef-ethiopia-humanitarian-situation-report-4-reporting-period-april-2016
UNISDR (2005) Hyogo Framework for Action 2005-2015: Building the Resilience of Nations and Communities to Disasters. World Conference on Disaster Reduction. Kobe, Hyogo, Japan. Available at: https://www.unisdr.org/2005/wcdr/intergover/official-doc/L-docs/Hyogo-framework-for-action-english.pdf
Van Brabant K, Patel S (2017) Understanding the localisation debate. ALNAP, London (https://www.alnap.org/help-library/understanding-the-localisation-debate)
van Hille I (2020) A balancing act: convening cross-sector partnerships to strengthen sustainable development in global supply chains. [PhD Thesis, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam]. https://research.vu.nl/en/publications/a-balancing-act-convening-cross-sector-partnerships-to-strengthen
Van Wessel M, Kontinen T, Bawole JN (2023) Reimagining Civil Society Collaborations in Development: Starting from the South. New York, Taylor & Francis
Woldie M, Balabanova D (2018) Facilitating accessible community-oriented health systems: the Health Development Army in Ethiopia. https://healthsystems.lshtm.ac.uk/files/2018/03/Health-Development-Army-in-Ethiopia-1-webpdf.pdf
Ybema S, Yanow D, Wels H, Kamsteeg F (2009) Organizational ethnography: studying the complexities of everyday life. SAGE Publications Ltd. https://doi.org/10.4135/9781446278925
Yin RK (1981) The case study as a serious research strategy. Knowledge 3(1):97–114. https://doi.org/10.1177/107554708100300106