The myth of contextual interference learning benefit in sports practice: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Aiken, 2018, The effects of blocked and random practice on the learning of three variations of the golf chip shot, International Journal of Performance Analysis in Sport, 18, 339, 10.1080/24748668.2018.1475199 Albaret, 1998, Differential effects of task complexity on contextual interference in a drawing task, Acta Psychologica, 100, 9, 10.1016/S0001-6918(98)00022-5 Ammar, 2020, Moderators of the impact of (poly) phenols interventions on psychomotor functions and bdnf: Insights from subgroup analysis and meta-regression, Nutrients, 12, 2872, 10.3390/nu12092872 Ammar, 2020, Effects of polyphenol-rich interventions on cognition and brain health in healthy young and middle-aged adults: Systematic review and meta-analysis, Journal of Clinical Medicine, 9, 1598, 10.3390/jcm9051598 Ammar, 2020, The effect of (poly) phenol-rich interventions on cognitive functions and neuroprotective measures in healthy aging adults: A systematic review and meta-analysis, Journal of Clinical Medicine, 9, 835, 10.3390/jcm9030835 Barreiros, 2007, The contextual interference effect in applied settings, European Physical Education Review, 13, 195, 10.1177/1356336X07076876 Battig, 1966, Facilitation and interference, 215 Battig, 1972, Intratask interference as a source of facilitation in transfer and retention, Topics in Learning and Performance, 131 Battig, 1979, The flexibility of human memory, Levels of Processing in Human Memory, 23–44 Begg, 1994, Operating characteristics of a rank correlation test for publication bias, Biometrics, 50, 1088, 10.2307/2533446 Bertollo, 2010, Blocked and random practice organization in the learning of rhythmic dance step sequences, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 110, 77, 10.2466/pms.110.1.77-84 Bjork, 1994, Memory and metamemory considerations in the metacognition, Knowing about knowing, 185, 10.7551/mitpress/4561.003.0011 Bjork, 1994, Institutional impediments to effective training, 295 Bluemke, 2010, Exercise might be good for me, but I don't feel good about it: Do automatic associations predict exercise behavior?, Journal of Sport & Exercise Psychology, 32, 137, 10.1123/jsep.32.2.137 Bortoli, 1992, Effects of contextual interference on learning technical sports skills, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 75, 555, 10.2466/pms.1992.75.2.555 Bortoli, 2001, Variability effects on retention of a motor skill in elementary school children, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 93, 51, 10.2466/pms.2001.93.1.51 Boyce, 1990, Designing applied research in a naturalistic setting using a contextual interference paradigm, Journal of Human Movement Studies, 18, 189 Brady, 1998, A theoretical and empirical review of the contextual interference effect and the learning of motor skills, Quest, 50, 266, 10.1080/00336297.1998.10484285 Brady, 2004, Contextual interference: A meta-analytic study, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 99, 116, 10.2466/pms.99.1.116-126 Brady, 2008, The contextual interference effect and sport skills, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 106, 461, 10.2466/pms.106.2.461-472 Broadbent, 2015, Contextual interference effect on perceptual–cognitive skills training, Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 47, 1243, 10.1249/MSS.0000000000000530 Buszard, 2017, Quantifying contextual interference and its effect on skill transfer in skilled youth tennis players, Frontiers in Psychology, 8, 1931, 10.3389/fpsyg.2017.01931 Buxton, 1940, Retroaction and gains in motor learning: III. Evaluation of results, The Journal of General Psychology, 22, 309, 10.1080/00221309.1940.9710037 Cashin, 2019, Clinimetrics: Physiotherapy evidence database (PEDro) scale, Journal of Physiotherapy, 66, 10.1016/j.jphys.2019.08.005 Catalano, 1984, Distant transfer in coincident timing as a function of variability of practice, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 58, 851, 10.2466/pms.1984.58.3.851 Cheong, 2012, Practicing field hockey skills along the contextual interference continuum: A comparison of five practice schedules, Journal of Sports Science and Medicine, 11, 304 Cheong, 2016, Investigating the contextual interference effect using combination sports skills in open and closed skill environments, Journal of Sports Science and Medicine, 15, 167 Cohen, 1988 Cross, 2007, Neural substrates of contextual interference during motor learning support a model of active preparation, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience, 19, 1854, 10.1162/jocn.2007.19.11.1854 Dean, 2008, Transfer of movement sequences: Bigger is better, Acta Psychologica, 127, 355, 10.1016/j.actpsy.2007.07.004 Del Rey, 1982, Effects of contextual interference on the memory of older females differing in levels of physical-activity, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 55, 171, 10.2466/pms.1982.55.1.171 Del Rey, 1989, Training and contextual interference effects on memory and transfer, Research Quarterly for Exercise & Sport, 60, 342, 10.1080/02701367.1989.10607461 Del Rey, 1994, Does retroactive inhibition influence contextual interference effects?, Research Quarterly for Exercise & Sport, 65, 120, 10.1080/02701367.1994.10607606 Duval, 2000, Trim and fill: A simple funnel–plot–based method of testing and adjusting for publication bias in meta-analysis, Biometrics, 56, 455, 10.1111/j.0006-341X.2000.00455.x Egger, 1997, Bias in meta–analysis detected by a simple, graphical test, British Medical Journal, 315, 629, 10.1136/bmj.315.7109.629 Farrow, 1997, The effects of contextual interference on children learning forehand tennis groundstrokes, Journal of Human Movement Studies, 33, 47 Fazeli, 2017, Random versus blocked practice to enhance mental representation in golf putting, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 124, 674, 10.1177/0031512517704106 French, 1990, Effects of contextual interference on retention of three volleyball skills, And Motor Skills, 71, 179, 10.2466/pms.1990.71.1.179 Frömer, 2016, (Don't) Mind the effort: Effects of contextual interference on ERP indicators of motor preparation, Psychophysiology, 53, 1577, 10.1111/psyp.12703 Gallicchio, 2019, Don't look, don't think, just do it! Toward an understanding of alpha gating in a discrete aiming task, Psychophysiology, 56, 14, 10.1111/psyp.13298 Gebkenjans, 2007, Does low and high contextual interference lead to different levels of noise? [Abstract], 153 Gentile, 1972, A working model of skill acquisition with application to teaching, Quest, 17, 3, 10.1080/00336297.1972.10519717 Gentile, 1998, Movement science: Implicit and explicit processes during acquisition of functional skills, Scandinavian Journal of Occupational Therapy, 5, 7, 10.3109/11038129809035723 Goodwin, 1996, Investigation of the contextual interference effect in the manipulation of the motor parameter of over-all force, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 83, 735, 10.2466/pms.1996.83.3.735 Graser, 2019, The role of the practice order: A systematic review about contextual interference in children, PLoS One, 14, 10.1371/journal.pone.0209979 Guadagnoli, 2004, Challenge point: A framework for conceptualizing the effects of various practice conditions in motor learning, Journal of Motor Behavior, 36, 212, 10.3200/JMBR.36.2.212-224 Gucciardi, 2022, Handling effect size dependency in meta-analysis, International Review of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 15, 152, 10.1080/1750984X.2021.1946835 Gu, 2014, What contributes to individual differences in brain structure?, Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, 8, 262, 10.3389/fnhum.2014.00262 Hagger, 2022, Meta-analysis, International Review of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 15, 120, 10.1080/1750984X.2021.1966824 Hajihosseini, 2016, The effect of moderate contextual interference on motor-skill learning, Biology and Medicine, 8, 1, 10.4172/0974-8369.1000339 Hall, 1994, Contextual interference effects with skilled baseball players, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 78, 835, 10.1177/003151259407800331 Hardwick, 2013, A quantitative meta-analysis and review of motor learning in the human brain, NeuroImage, 67, 283, 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2012.11.020 Haubenstricker, 1986, Acquisition of motor skills during childhood, Physical Activity and Well-Being, 41 Hebert, 1996, Practice schedule effects on the performance and learning of low-and high-skilled students: An applied study, Research Quarterly for Exercise & Sport, 67, 52, 10.1080/02701367.1996.10607925 Hedges, 1981, Distribution theory for Glass's estimator of effect size and related estimators, Journal of Educational Statistics, 6, 107, 10.3102/10769986006002107 Henz, 2018, Post-task effects on EEG brain activity differ for various differential learning and contextual interference protocols, Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, 19 Higgins, 2011 Higgins, 2003, Measuring inconsistency in meta–analyses, British Medical Journal, 327, 557, 10.1136/bmj.327.7414.557 Horst, 2017, Intra-individual gait patterns across different time-scales as revealed by means of a supervised learning model using kernel-based discriminant regression, PLoS One, 12, 10.1371/journal.pone.0179738 Horst, 2020, Can individual movement characteristics across different throwing disciplines be identified in high-performance decathletes?, Frontiers in Psychology, 11, 2262, 10.3389/fpsyg.2020.02262 Huskey, 2020, Individual differences in brain responses: New opportunities for tailoring health communication campaigns, Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, 14, 10.3389/fnhum.2020.565973 Immink, 1998, Contextual interference: A response planning account, Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology Section A—Human Experimental Psychology, 51, 735, 10.1080/713755789 Janssen, 2010, Analyzing learning approaches by means of complex movement pattern analysis, International Journal of Sport Psychology, 41, 18 Jarus, 1999, Effects of contextual interference and age on acquisition, retention, and transfer of motor skill, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 88, 437, 10.2466/pms.1999.88.2.437 Jeon, 2021, Block and random practice: A wii fit dynamic balance training in older adults, Research Quarterly for Exercise & Sport, 92, 352, 10.1080/02701367.2020.1733456 Jones, 2007, Effects of contextual interference on acquisition and retention of three volleyball skills, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 105, 883, 10.2466/pms.105.3.883-890 Kalkhoran, 2015, The effects of contextual interference on learning volleyball motor skills, Journal of Sports Science, 6, 12 Keller, 2006, Contextual interference effect on acquisition and retention of pistol-shooting skills, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 103, 241, 10.2466/pms.103.1.241-252 Kelly, 2005, Human functional neuroimaging of brain changes associated with practice, Cerebral Cortex, 15, 1089, 10.1093/cercor/bhi005 Krause, 2014, Learning of a golf putting task with varying contextual interference levels induced by feedback schedule in novices and experts, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 118, 384, 10.2466/23.30.PMS.118k17w3 Kulinskaya, 2010, Use of quality control charts for detection of outliers and temporal trends in cumulative meta‐analysis, Research Synthesis Methods, 1, 297, 10.1002/jrsm.29 Lee, 1983, The locus of contextual interference in motor-skill acquisition, Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 9, 730 Lee, 1985, Can forgetting facilitate skill acquisition?, InAdvances in Psychology, 27, 3 Lin, 2012, Age related differences in the neural substrates of motor sequence learning after interleaved and repetitive practice, NeuroImage, 62, 2007, 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2012.05.015 Lin, 2018, Empirical comparison of publication bias tests in meta-analysis, Journal of General Internal Medicine, 33, 1260, 10.1007/s11606-018-4425-7 Lin, 2011, Brain-behavior correlates of optimizing learning through interleaved practice, NeuroImage, 56, 1758, 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2011.02.066 Li, 2000, An assessment of the attention demands during random- and blocked-practice schedules, Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology Section a-Human Experimental Psychology, 53, 591, 10.1080/713755890 Macaskill, 2001, A comparison of methods to detect publication bias in meta-analysis, Statistics in Medicine, 20, 641, 10.1002/sim.698 Magill, 2007 Magill, 2010 Magill, 1990, A review of the contextual interference effect in motor skill acquisition, Human Movement Science, 9, 241, 10.1016/0167-9457(90)90005-X Maher, 2003, Reliability of the PEDro scale for rating quality of randomized controlled trials, Physical Therapy, 83, 713, 10.1093/ptj/83.8.713 Meira, 2015, Contextual interference and introversion/extraversion in motor learning, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 121, 447, 10.2466/23.PMS.121c20x6 Meira, 2003, Contextual interference effects assessed by extended transfer trials in the acquisition of the volleyball serve, Journal of Human Movement Studies, 45, 449 Memmert, 2006, Long-term effects of type of practice on the learning and transfer of a complex motor skill, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 103, 912, 10.2466/pms.103.3.912-916 Menayo, 2010, Simultaneous treatment effects in learning four tennis shots in contextual interference conditions, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 110, 661, 10.2466/pms.110.2.661-673 Merbah, 2011, Learning a motor skill: Effects of blocked versus random practice: A review, Psychologica Belgica, 51, 15, 10.5334/pb-51-1-15 Morris, 2008, Estimating effect sizes from pretest-posttest-control group designs, Organizational Research Methods, 11, 364, 10.1177/1094428106291059 Moxley, 1979, Schema: The variability of practice hypothesis, Journal of Motor Behavior, 11, 65, 10.1080/00222895.1979.10735173 Naimo, 2013, Contextual interference effects on the acquisition of skill and strength of the bench press, Human Movement Science, 32, 472, 10.1016/j.humov.2013.02.002 Newell, 1989, Search strategies and the acquisition of coordination, 85 North, 2019, The effect of consistent and varied follow-through practice schedules on learning a table tennis backhand, Journal of Sports Sciences, 37, 613, 10.1080/02640414.2018.1522683 Page, 2021, The PRISMA 2020 statement: An updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews, Systematic Reviews, 10, 1, 10.1186/s13643-021-01626-4 Page, 2021, PRISMA 2020 explanation and elaboration: Updated guidance and exemplars for reporting systematic reviews, British Medical Journal, 372 Parab, 2018, Influence of random and blocked practice schedules on motor learning in children aged 6–12 years, Critical Reviews in Physical and Rehabilitation Medicine, 30, 10.1615/CritRevPhysRehabilMed.2018027737 Pasand, 2016, The effect of gradual increase in contextual interference on acquisition, retention and transfer of volleyball skills, International Journal of Kinesiology & Sports Science, 4, 72 Penhune, 2012, Parallel contributions of cerebellar, striatal and M1 mechanisms to motor sequence learning, Behavioural Brain Research, 226, 579, 10.1016/j.bbr.2011.09.044 Pollatou, 1997, Contextual interference effects in learning novel motor skills, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 84, 487, 10.2466/pms.1997.84.2.487 Pollock, 1997, Dissociated contextual interference effects in children and adults, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 84, 851, 10.2466/pms.1997.84.3.851 Porter, 2020, Learner-adapted practice promotes skill transfer in unskilled adults learning the basketball set shot, European Journal of Sport Science, 20, 61, 10.1080/17461391.2019.1611931 Rendell, 2011, An implicit basis for the retention benefits of random practice, Journal of Motor Behavior, 43, 1, 10.1080/00222895.2010.530304 Renshaw, 2019 Rico-González, 2022, Guidelines for performing systematic reviews in sports science, Biology of Sport, 39, 10.5114/biolsport.2022.106386 Rink, 2006 Sadri, 2013, The effect of contextual interference on acquisition and learning badminton skills among children aged from 10 to 12, Annals of Applied Sport Science, 1, 39 Sana, 2018, Does working memory capacity moderate the interleaving benefit?, Journal of Applied Research in Memory and Cognition, 7, 361, 10.1016/j.jarmac.2018.05.005 Schmidt, 1975, A schema theory of discrete motor skill learning, Psychological Review, 82, 225, 10.1037/h0076770 Schmidt, 2003, Motor schema theory after 27 years: Reflections and implications for a new theory, Research Quarterly for Exercise & Sport, 74, 366, 10.1080/02701367.2003.10609106 Schmidt, 1999 Schmidt, 2011 Schöllhorn, 1993 Schöllhorn, 1997, Zur quantifizierung qualitativer bewegungsmuster und ihrer veränderungen, 293 Schöllhorn, 1999, Practical consequences of biomechanically determined individuality and fluctuations on motor learning, 147 Schöllhorn, 1999, Individualität-Ein vernachlässigter parameter?, Leistungssport, 29, 5 Schöllhorn, 2000, Practical consequences of systems dynamic approach to technique and strength training, Acta Academiae Olympique Estonia, 8, 25 Schöllhorn, 2005, Differenzielles Lehren und Lernen von Bewegung - durch veränderte Annahmen zu neuen Konsequenzen, 125 Schöllhorn, 2016, Invited commentary: Differential learning is different from contextual interference learning, Human Movement Science, 47, 240, 10.1016/j.humov.2015.11.018 Schöllhorn, 2022, Studies of specific movements and their stabilization do not allow general inferences on motor learning, even at the neurophysiological level-comment on lage et al (2021): Comment on lage et al (2021), Brazilian Journal of Motor Behavior, 16, 8, 10.20338/bjmb.v16i1.295 Schöllhorn, 1998, Identifying individual movement styles in high performance sports by means of self organizing kohonen maps, 574 Schöllhorn, 2006, Does noise provide a basis for the unification of motor learning theories?, International Journal of Sport Psychology, 37, 186 Schöllhorn, 2009, Time scales of adaptive behavior and motor learning in the presence of stochastic perturbations, Human Movement Science, 28, 319, 10.1016/j.humov.2008.10.005 Schöllhorn, 2022, Always pay attention to which model of motor learning you are using, International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 19, 711, 10.3390/ijerph19020711 Sharp, 2020, The effect of blocked versus random practice on dominant and non-dominant baseball swing, Journal of Sport and Human Performance, 8 Shea, 1994, A model for contextual interference effects in motor learning, 73 Shea, 1990, Contextual interference: Contributions of practice, Acta Psychologica, 73, 145, 10.1016/0001-6918(90)90076-R Shea, 1979, Contextual interference effects on the acquisition, retention, and transfer of a motor skill, Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Learning & Memory, 5, 179 Shea, 1993, The influence of reminder trials on contextual interference effects, Journal of Motor Behavior, 25, 264, 10.1080/00222895.1993.9941647 Shea, 1983, Context effects in memory and learning movement information, Advances in Psychology, 12, 345, 10.1016/S0166-4115(08)61998-6 Shewokis, 1997, Is the contextual interference effect generalizable to computer games?, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 84, 3, 10.2466/pms.1997.84.1.3 Shewokis, 1998, A test of retroactive inhibition as an explanation of contextual interference, Research Quarterly for Exercise & Sport, 69, 70, 10.1080/02701367.1998.10607669 Siedentop, 1983 Smith, 2022, How to coach: A review of theoretical approaches for the development of a novel coach education framework, International Journal of Sports Science & Coaching, 0 Smith, 2003, Alternating versus blocked practice in learning a cartwheel, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 96, 1255, 10.2466/PMS.96.3.1255-1264 Stachowiak, 1973 Stegenga, 2011, Is meta-analysis the platinum standard of evidence?, Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences, 42, 497, 10.1016/j.shpsc.2011.07.003 1994, A proposal for structured reporting of randomized controlled trials, Journal of the American Medical Association, 272, 1926, 10.1001/jama.1994.03520240054041 Thomas, 1997, Planning significant and meaningful research in exercise science: Estimating sample size, Research Quarterly for Exercise & Sport, 68, 33, 10.1080/02701367.1997.10608864 Travlos, 2010, Specificity and variability of practice, and contextual interference in acquisition and transfer of an underhand volleyball serve, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 110, 298, 10.2466/pms.110.1.298-312 Vera, 2008, Effects of different practice conditions on acquisition, retention, and transfer of soccer skills by 9-year-old schoolchildren, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 106, 447, 10.2466/pms.106.2.447-460 Vera, 2003, Practice schedule and acquisition, retention, and transfer of a throwing task in 6-YR.-old children, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 96, 1015, 10.2466/pms.2003.96.3.1015 Verhagen, 1998, The Delphi list: A criteria list for quality assessment of randomized clinical trials for conducting systematic reviews developed by Delphi consensus, Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 51, 1235, 10.1016/S0895-4356(98)00131-0 Von Cube, 1965 Wang, 2022, The effect of contextual interference on motor learning among healthy adolescents: A systematic review, Journal of Positive School Psychology, 6, 4545 Wright, 2004, Long-term motor programming improvements occur via concatenation of movement sequences during random but not during blocked practice, Journal of Motor Behavior, 36, 39, 10.3200/JMBR.36.1.39-50 Wright, 2019, Contextual interference: New findings, insights, and implications for skill acquisition, Skill acquisition in sport, 99, 10.4324/9781351189750-6 Wright, 2016, Consolidating behavioral and neurophysiologic findings to explain the influence of contextual interference during motor sequence learning, Psychonomic Bulletin & Review, 23, 1, 10.3758/s13423-015-0887-3 Wrisberg, 1991, The effect of contextual variety on the practice, retention, and transfer of an applied motor skill, Research Quarterly for Exercise & Sport, 62, 406, 10.1080/02701367.1991.10607541 Wulf, 1993, Contextual interference in movements of the same class: Differential effects on program and parameter learning, Journal of Motor Behavior, 25, 254, 10.1080/00222895.1993.9941646 Wulf, 1994, Feedback-induced variability and the learning of generalized motor programs, Journal of Motor Behavior, 26, 348, 10.1080/00222895.1994.9941691 Wulf, 2002, Principles derived from the study of simple skills do not generalize to complex skill learning, Psychonomic Bulletin & Review, 9, 185, 10.3758/BF03196276 Wymbs, 2009, Neural substrates of practice structure that support future off-line learning, Journal of Neurophysiology, 102, 2462, 10.1152/jn.00315.2009 Yanci, 2015, Effects of different agility training programs among first-grade elementary school students, Collegium Antropologicum, 39, 87 Yanci, 2013, Effects of different contextual interference training programs on straight sprinting and agility performance of primary school students, Journal of Sports Science and Medicine, 12, 601 Zetou, 2007, Contextual interference effects in learning volleyball skills, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 104, 995, 10.2466/pms.104.3.995-1004 Zipp, 2010, Practice schedule and the learning of motor skills in children and adults: Teaching implications, Journal of College Teaching & Learning, 7