The impact of public pension board of trustee composition on state bond ratings

Springer Science and Business Media LLC - Tập 19 - Trang 51-73 - 2018
John A. Dove1, Courtney A. Collins2, Daniel J. Smith1
1Manuel H. Johnson Center for Political Economy, Troy University, Troy, USA
2Department of Economics, Rhodes College, Memphis, USA

Tóm tắt

The declining financial health of public pension systems is increasingly becoming a budgetary concern for many state and local governments. While the academic literature has identified several factors behind the growth in unfunded state and local public pension liabilities, there is mixed evidence on how the composition of a pension system’s board of trustees affects a pension’s financial health. This article contributes to this literature by measuring how public pension board composition affects fund financial health as measured by state bond ratings. With a panel dataset of state pensions between 2001 and 2014 our results indicate that elected board members are consistently associated with lower bond ratings (and thus higher borrowing costs) while appointed and ex-officio board members are associated with higher bond ratings. These results are robust to a number of specifications.

Tài liệu tham khảo

Adams RB, Hermalin BE, Weisbach MS (2010) The role of boards of directors in corporate governance: a conceptual framework and survey. J Econ Lit 48(1):58–107 Alesina A, Tabellini G (2007) Bureaucrats or politicians? Part I: a single policy task. Am Econ Rev 97(1):169–79 Andonov A, Hochberg YV, Rauh JD (2017) Political representation and governance: evidence from the investment decisions of public pension funds. Rock center for corporate governance at Stanford University working paper no. 226. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2754820. Accessed 3 May 2016 Aneiro M (2014) Bondholders and pension risk,” Barron’s. http://www.barrons.com/articles/bondholders-and-pension-risk-1415436717. Accessed 17 June 2016 Barkley R (2012) The State of State Pension Plans, MorningStar. http://media.navigatored.com/documents/StateofStatePensionsReport.pdf. Accessed 17 June 2016 Barnhart SW, Rosenstein S (1998) Board composition, managerial ownership, and firm performance: An empirical analysis. Financ Rev 33(4):1–16 Beasley MS, Salterio SE (2001) The relationship between board characteristics and voluntary improvements in audit committee composition and experience. Contemp Acc Res 18(4):539–570 Beermann JM (2013) The public pension crisis. Wash Lee Law Rev 7(1):1–94 Belasen AR, Hafer RW, Jategaonkar SP (2015) Economic freedom and state bond ratings. Contemp Econ Policy 33(4):668–677 Bhagat S, Black B (1999) The uncertain relationship between board composition and firm performance. Bus Lawyer 54(3):921–963 Bhagat S, Black B (2002) The non-correlation between board independence and long-term firm performance. J Corp Law 27(2):231–273 Bradley D, Pantzalis C, Yuan X (2016) The influence of political bias in state pension funds. J Financ Econ 119(1):69–91 Brown JR, Wilcox DW (2009) Discounting state and local pension liabilities. Am Econ Rev Pap Proc 99(2):538–542 Burns DB (2012) Too big to fail and too big to pay: states, their public- pension bills, and the constitution. Hastings Const Law Q 39:253 Calcagno PT, Benefield JD (2013) Economic freedom, the cost of public borrowing, and state bond ratings. J Financ Econ Policy 5(1):72–85 Carmichael J, Palacios R(2003) A framework for public pension fund management. Paper presentation at \(2^{{\rm nd}}\) public pension fund management conference, World Bank, Washington D.C., May 5–7. http://www1.worldbank.org/finance/assets/images/Carmichael___Palacios--pension_frmwrk--doc.pdf. Accessed 21 June 2016 Carroll TJ, Niehaus G (1998) Pension plan funding and corporate debt ratings. J Risk Insur 65(3):427–443 Carter DA, Simkins BJ, Simpson G (2003) Corporate governance, board diversity, and firm value. Financ Rev 38(1):33–53 Chappatta, B (2014). Largest public pensions face $2 Trillion Hole, Moody’s Says,” Bloomberg.com. http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2014-09-25/largest-u-s-public-pensions-face-2-trillion-gap-moody-s-says. Accessed 14 June 2016 Choi SJ, Mitu Gulati G, Posner EA (2010) Professionals or politicians: the uncertain empirical case for an elected rather than appointed judiciary. J Law Econ Organ 26(2):290–336 Clark GL (2004) Pension fund governance: expertise and organizational form. J Pension Econ Finance 3(2):233–253 Clark GL, Caerlewy-Smith E, Marshall JC (2006) Pension fund trustee competence: decision making in problems relevant to investment practice. J Pension Econ Finance 5(1):91–110 Coate S, Besley T (2003) Elected versus appointed regulators: theory and evidence. J Eur Econ Assoc 1(5):1176–1206 Cocco JF, Volpin PF (2007) Corporate governance of pension plans: the U.K. evidence. Financ Anal J 63(1):70–83 Coggburn JD, Kearney RC (2010) Trouble keeping promises? An analysis of underfunding in state retiree benefits. Public Adm Rev 70(1):97–108 Coronoado JL, Engen EM, Knight B (2003) Public funds and private capital markets: the investment practice and performance of state and local pension funds. Natl Tax J 53(3):579–594 Dalton DR, Daily CM, Ellstrand AE, Johnson JL (1998) Meta—analytic reviews of board composition, leadership structure, and financial performance. Strateg Manag J 19:269–290 Dawson AB (2015) Pensioners, bondholders, and unfair discrimination in municipal bankruptcy. Univ Pa J Bus aw 17(1):1–46 Depken CA, LaFountain C (2006) Fiscal consequences of public corruption: empirical evidence from state bond ratings. Publ Choice 126(1):75–85 Easterday KE, Eaton TV (2012) Double (accounting) standards: a comparison of public and private sector defined benefit pension plans. J Public Budg Acc Financ Manag 24(2):278–312 Eaton TV, Nofsinger JR (2004) The effect of financial constraints and political pressure on the management of public pension plans. J Acc Public Policy 23(3):161–189 Ferris SP, Jagannathan M, Pritchard AC (2003) Too busy to mind the business? Monitoring by directors with multiple board appointments. J Finance 58(3):1087–1112 Fich EM, Shivdasani A (2006) Are busy boards effective monitors? J Finance 61(2):689–724 Finegold D, Benson GS, Hecht D (2007) Corporate boards and company performance: review of research in light of recent reforms. Corp Gov Int Rev 15(5):865–878 Fitch Ratings (2005) The Not So Golden Years: Credit Implications of GASB 45 Public Finance Fitch Ratings (2011) Enhancing the analysis of U.S. state and local government pension obligations. Public Finance. http://www.ncpers.org/Files/2011_enhancing_the_analysis_of_state_local_government_pension_obligations.pdf. Accessed 14 June 2016 Fitch Ratings (2017). Revised pension risk measurements. Public Finance. http://www.nasra.org//Files/Topical%20Reports/Credit%20Effects/Fitch1706.pdf. Accessed September 20 2017 Gold J, Latter G (2009) The case for marking public plan liabilities to market. In: Mitchell OS, Anderson’s G (eds) The future of public retirement systems. Oxford University Press, New York, pp 29–57 Gopalakrishnan V (1994) The effect of recognition vs. disclosure on investor valuation: the case of pension accounting. Rev Quant Financ Acc 4(4):383–396 Groseclose T, Snyder JM Jr (1996) Buying supermajorities. Am Polit Sci Rev 90(2):303–315 Hanif Farooq, Millard Charles, Bass Erik J, Curmi Elizabeth, Deans Sarah, Lam Darwin, Maekawa Hiroyuki, Pittaway Nigel (2016) The coming pension crisis. Global Perspectives & Solutions, Citi. http://www.apapr.ro/images/BIBLIOTECA/reformageneralitati/2016%20citi.pdf. 17 June 2016 Harper Joel T (2008) Board of trustee composition and investment performance of US public pension plans. Rotman international centre for pension management working paper. http://www.rijpm.com/admin/article_files/Joel_Harper_Board_of_Trustee_Composition_and_Investment_Performance_of_US_Public_Pension_Plans_February_2008.pdf. Accessed 20 June 2016 Harper RM, Mister WG, Strawser J (1991) The effect of recognition versus disclosure of unfunded postretirement benefits on lenders. Percept Debt Acc Horizons 5(3):50–56 Harris EE (2014) The impact of board diversity and expertise on nonprofit performance. Nonprofit Manag Leadersh 25(2):113–30 Helland E, Sykuta M (2005) Who’s monitoring the monitor? Do outside directors protect shareholders’ interests? Financ Rev 40(2):155–172 Hermalin BE, Weisbach MS (1988) The determinants of board composition. Rand J Econ 19(4):589–606 Hermalin BE, Weisbach MS (2003) Boards of directors as an endogenously determined institution: a survey of the economic literature. Econ Policy Rev 9(1):7–26 Hess D (2005) Protecting and politicizing public pension fund assets: empirical evidence on the effects of governance structures and practices. Univ Calif Davis Law Rev 39:187–227 Hess D, Impavido G (2003) Lessons from corporate governance and international evidence. In: Musalem AR, Palacios RJ (eds) Public pension fund management: governance, accountability, and investment policies. World Bank, Washington, pp 49–89. http://www-wds.worldbank.org/external/default/WDSContentServer/WDSP/IB/2004/10/20/000160016_20041020130739/Rendered/PDF/302250PAPER0public0pension.pdf. Accessed 21 June 2016 Iglesias A, Palacios RJ (2000) Managing public pension reserves part I: evidence from the international experience. World Bank Social protection discussion paper no. 0003. http://www-wds.worldbank.org/servlet/WDSContentServer/WDSP/IB/2000/12/15/000094946_00111805312189/Rendered/PDF/multi_page.pdf. Accessed 17 June 2016 Keating EK, Berman ES (2007) Unfunded public employee health care benefits and GASB No. 45. Acc Horiz 21(3):245–263 Kelley DG (2014) The political economy of unfunded public pension liabilities. Public Choice 158:21–38 Kiewiet DR, McCubbins MD (2014) State and local government finance: the new fiscal ice age. Annu Rev Polit Sci 17:105–122 Klein A (1999) An empirical analysis of the relation between board of directors’ composition, firm performance, and the degree of CEO domination over the board of directors. Working paper. New York University, Stern School of Business Lim CSH (2013) Preferences and incentives of appointed and elected public officials: evidence from state trial court judges. Am Econ Rev 103(4):1360–1397 Liu P, Thakor AV (1984) Interest yields, credit ratings, and economic characteristics of state bonds: an empirical analysis: note. J Money Credit Bank 16(3):344–351 Lucas DJ, Zeldes SP (2009) How should public pension plans invest? Am Econ Rev Pap Proc 99(2):527–532 Maher JJ (1996) Perceptions of postretirement benefit obligations by bond rating analysts. Rev Quant Financ Acc 6(1):79–94 Martell CR, Kioko SN, Moldogaziev T (2013) Impact of underfunded pension obligations on credit quality of state governments. Public Budg Finance 33(3):24–54 Martin LJ, Henderson GV Jr (1983) On bond ratings and pension obligations: a note. J Financ Quant Anal 18(4):463–470 Maskin E, Tirole J (2004) The politician and the judge: accountability in the government. Am Econ Rev 94(4):1034–1054 McDaniel L, Martin RD, Maines LA (2002) Evaluating financial reporting quality: the effects of financial expertise vs. financial literacy. Acc Rev 77:139–167 Mitchell Olivia S, Hsin P-L (1997) Public sector pension governance and performance. In: Valdes Prieto S (ed) The economics of pensions: principles, policies, and international experience. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 92–126 Mitchell OS (1993) Public pension governance and performance: lessons for developing countries. The World Bank policy research working paper 1199. http://www-wds.worldbank.org/external/default/WDSContentServer/WDSP/IB/1993/10/01/000009265_3961005101002/Rendered/PDF/multi0page.pdf. Accessed 21 June 2016 Mitchell OS (1988) Worker knowledge of pension provisions. J Labor Econ 6(1):21–39 Mitchell OS, Smith RS (1994) Pension funding in the public sector. Rev Econ Stat 76(2):278–290 Mitchell OS, McCarthy D, Wisniewski SC, Zorn P (2001) Developments in State and Local Pension Plans. In: Mitchell OS, Hustead’s EC (eds) Pensions in the Public Sector. University of Pennsylvania Press, Philadelphia, PA, pp 11–40 Monahan A (2010) Public pension plan reform: the legal framework. Educ Finance Policy 5(4):617–646 Moody’s (2013). Moody’s announces new approach to analyzing state, local government pensions, Moody’s Investor Services. https://www.moodys.com/research/Moodys-announces-new-approach-to-analyzing-state-local-government-pensions--PR_271186. Accessed 17 June 2016 Moody’s (2014). Moody’s US public pension analysis largely unchanged by New GASB 67/68 standards. Special Comment. Available online: https://www.gfoatspringinstitute.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/Moodys-US-Public-Pension-Analysis-Largely-Unchanged-By-New-GASB-67-68-Standards.pdf. Accessed 20 Sept 2017 Moody’s (2016) Enhanced pension disclosures under GASB 68 improve credit analysis but leave underlying credit risks unchanged. https://www.moodys.com/research/Moodys-Enhanced-pension-disclosures-under-GASB-68-improve-credit-analysis--PR_347261. Retrieved 20 Sept 2017 Munnell AH, Aubry JP, Quinby L (2016) How big a burden are state and local OPEB benefits?. Issue brief. Center for State and Local Government Excellence. http://slge.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/16-03-SLGE-OPEBweb.pdf. Accessed 19 Sept 2017 Munnell AH, Sunden A (2001) Investment practices of state and local pension funds: Implications for social security reform. In: Mitchell OS, Hustead’s EC (eds) Pensions in the public sector. University of Pennsylvania Press, Philadelphia, pp 153–194 Munnell AH, Aubry J-P, Quinby L (2011) Public pension funding in practice. J Pension Econ Finance 10(2):247–268 Naughton J, Petacchi R, Weber J (2015) Public pension accounting rules and economic outcomes. J Account Econ 59(2):221–241 Novy-Marx R, Rauh J (2011) Public pension promises: How big are they and what are they worth? J Finance 66(4):1211–1249 Peecher ME (2002) Evaluating financial reporting quality: the effects of financial expertise vs. financial literacy: discussion. Account Rev 77:169–173 Peng J, Wang Q (2017) Affordability of public pension benefit: a historical and empirical analysis of the US state and local government pension contributions. J Pension Econ Financ 16(1):21–42 Perry T, Shivdasani A (2005) Do boards affect performance? Evidence from corporate restructuring. J Bus 78(4):1403–1432 Petra ST (2005) Do outside independent directors strengthen corporate boards? Corp Gov 5(1):55–64 Picconi M (2006) The perils of pensions: Does pension accounting lead investors and analysts astray? Account Rev 81(4):925–955 Prunty RL, Sugden JA (2015) Six years into the recovery, pensions, are a big divider of U.S. state credit. Standard & Poor’s Rating Services. http://files.ctctcdn.com/701ae45c001/d34862bb-09ac-4c16-83e6-cf3026085196.pdf. Accessed 14 June 2016 Public Plans Database (2001–2010). Center for retirement research at Boston College and Center for State and Local Government Excellence. http://crr.bc.edu/data/. Accessed 21 June 2016 Rauh, JD (2016) Hidden debt, hidden deficits. A hoover institution essay. http://www.hoover.org/research/public-pension-crisis. Accessed 17 June 2016 Ricketts LR, Walker CJ (2012) State and local debt: growing liabilities jeopardize fiscal health. Reg Econ. https://www.stlouisfed.org/~/media/Files/PDFs/publications/pub_assets/pdf/re/2012/d/debt_crisis.pdf. Accessed 21 June 2016 Romano R (1993) Public pension fund activism in corporate governance reconsidered. Columbia Law Rev 93(4):795–853 Romano R (1995) The politics of public pension funds. Public Interest 119:42–53 Rubinfeld D (1973) Credit ratings and the market for general obligation municipal bonds. Natl Tax J 26(1):17–27 Russek F (2011) The underfunding of state and local pension plans. CBO economic and budget issue brief. https://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/cbofiles/ftpdocs/120xx/doc12084/05-04-pensions.pdf. Accessed 17 June 2016 Ryan RJ, Fabozzi FJ (2002) Rethinking pension liabilities and asset allocation. J Portf Manag 28(4):7–15 Schelker M (2012a) The influence of auditor term length and term limits on US state general obligation bond ratings. Public Choice 150(1):27–49 Schelker M (2012b) Auditor expertise: evidence from the public sector. Econ Lett 116(3):432–435 Schneider M, Damanpour F (2002) Public choice economics and public pension plan funding. Adm Soc 34(1):57–86 Shafroth F (2015) Municipal Bondholders Beware. Governing: the state and localities. http://www.governing.com/columns/public-money/goc-bondholders-beware.html. Accessed 17 June 2016 Stalebrink OJ (2014) Public pension funds and assumed rates of return: an empirical examination of public sector defined benefit pension plans. Am Rev Public Adm 44(1):92–111 Staman J (2011) State and local pension plans and fiscal distress: a legal overview. Congressional research service. https://infolinx.aon.com/infolinx/rts/rtsdbln.nsf/0455ef6bb6300d3185256a40005a1065/00e00680bb364a898625786a005020dc/$FILE/4-6-11%20CRS%20S%20L%20Pension.pdf. Accessed 21 June 2016 Standard & Poor’s (2006) OPEB liabilities pose minimal near-term rating risk for public finance credits. Public Finance. http://www.iaff.org/Gasb/Presenters/Geoffrey%20E.%20Buswick/OPEB%20Liabilities%20Pose%20Minimal%20Near-Term%20Rating%20Risk%20For%20Pu.pdf Starr-McCluer M, Sunden A(1999) Workers’ knowledge of their pension coverage: a reevaluation. Federal reserve. https://www.federalreserve.gov/econresdata/scf/files/penknow.pdf. Accessed 21 June 2016 Sunstein CR (2003) Why societies need dissent. Harvard University Press, Cambridge Thom M (2015) The drivers of public sector pension reform across the U.S. states. Am Rev Public Adm 47(4):1–15 Useem M, Hess D (2001) Governance and investments of public pensions. In: Mitchell OS, Hustead’s EC (eds) Pensions in the public sector. University of Pennsylvania Press, Philadelphia, PA, pp 132–152 Useem M, Mitchell OS (2000) Holders of the purse strings: governance and performance of public retirement systems. Pension research council working paper. http://fic.wharton.upenn.edu/fic/papers/00/0008.pdf. Accessed 20 June 2016 Walsh MW (2016). Treasury plan for puerto rico favors pensions over bondholders. The New York Times. http://www.nytimes.com/2016/02/25/business/dealbook/treasury-plan-for-puerto-rico-prioritizes-pensions-over-bondholders.html. Accessed 17 June 2016 Wang Q, Peng J (2016) An empirical analysis of state and local public pension plan funded ratio change, 2001–2009. Am Rev Public Adm 46(1):75–91 Weisbach MS (1988) Outside directors and CEO turnover. J Financ Econ 20:431–460 Wisniewski SC (2005) Potential state government practices impact of the new GASB accounting standard for retiree health benefits. Public Budg Finance 25(1):104–118 Yang T, Mitchell OS (2005) Public pension governance, funding, and performance: a longitudinal appraisal. In: Evans J, Orsxag M, Piggott’s J (eds) Pension fund governance: a global perspective on financial regulation. Edward Elgar Publishing, Cheltenham, pp 179–199 Zorn P (1997) Public pensions. Public Adm Rev 57(4):361–362