The impact of cost allocation errors on price and product-mix decisions
Tóm tắt
We use simulations to examine the impact of cost allocation errors on pricing and product-mix decisions. We compare the imperfect cost allocation of cost systems based on heuristics to the ideal cost allocation of a benchmark model. First, we find that more complex cost systems are associated with substantially lower profit errors. Second, we decompose the profit error and find that production quantity errors are larger than product portfolio errors indicating that reducing product portfolio errors is less critical in designing cost systems. We also document that overproduction errors are larger than underproduction errors and errors from keeping unprofitable products are larger than errors from dropping profitable products suggesting that cost systems tend to underestimate full costs. Third, we find that profit errors increase for more complex cost systems as resource sharing levels rise, which is an interesting counter intuitive result.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Ahmed MN, Scapens RW (2000) Cost allocation in Britain: towards an institutional analysis. Eur Acc Rev 9:159–204
Anand V, Balakrishnan R, Labro E (2013) On the profit performance of tidy cost systems: a numerical experiment. Working Paper, Emory University
Balachandran BV, Balakrishnan R, Sivaramakrishnan K (1997) On the efficiency of cost-based decision rules for capacity planning. Acc Rev 72:599–619
Balakrishnan R, Sivaramakrishnan K (2002) A critical overview of the use of full-cost data for planning and pricing. J Manag Acc Res 14:3–31
Balakrishnan R, Hansen S, Labro E (2011) Evaluating heuristics used when designing product costing systems. Manag Sci 57:520–541
Banker R, Hansen S (2002) The adequacy of full-cost-based pricing heuristics. J Manag Acc Res 14:33–58
Banker RD, Hughes JS (1994) Product costing and pricing. Acc Rev 69:479–494
Bjornenak T, Mitchell F (2002) The development of activity-based costing journal literature 1987–2000. Eur Acc Rev 11:481–508
Bordley RF (1993) Estimating Automotive Elasticities from Segment Elasticities and First Choice/Second Choice Data. Rev Econ Stat 75:455–462
Brierley J, Cowton J, Drury C (2001) Research into product costing practice: a European perspective. Eur Acc Rev 10:215–256
Bromwich M, Hong C (1999) Activity-based costing systems and incremental costs. Manag Acc Res 10:39–60
Charles SL, Hansen DR (2008) An evaluation of activity-based costing and functional-based costing: a game-theoretic approach. Int J Prod Econ 113:282–296
Cooper R, Kaplan RS (1988) How cost accounting distorts product costs. Acc Manag 69:20–27
Datar S, Gupta M (1994) Aggregation, specification and measurement errors in product costing. Acc Rev 69:567–591
Dearman DT, Shields MD (2001) Cost knowledge and cost-based judgment performance. J Manag Acc Res 13:1–18
Feldman D, Trzcinka C, Winer RS (2015) Pricing under noisy signaling. Rev Quant Financ Acc 45:435–454
Hansen S, Magee RP (1993) Capacity cost and capacity allocation. Contemp Acc Res 9:635–660
Homburg C (2001a) A note on optimal cost driver selection in ABC. Manag Acc Res 12:197–205
Homburg C (2001b) Using data envelopment analysis to benchmark activities. Int J Prod Econ 73:51–58
Homburg C (2004) Improving activity-based costing heuristics by higher-level cost drivers. Eur J Oper Res 157:332–343
Homburg C (2005) Using relative profits as an alternative to activity-based costing. Int J Prod Econ 95:387–397
Hwang Y, Evans III JH, Hegde VG (1993) Product cost bias and selection of an allocation base. J Manag Account Res 5:213–242
Innes J, Mitchel F, Sinclair D (2000) Activity-based costing in the U.K’.s larget companies: a comparison of 1994 and 1999 survey results. Manag Acc Res 11:349–362
Kee R, Schmidt C (2000) A comparative analysis of utilizing activity-based costing and the theory of constraints for making product-mix decisions. Int J Prod Econ 63:1–17
Kennedy T, Affleck-Graves J (2001) The impact of activity-based costing techniques on firm performance. J Manag Acc Res 13:19–45
Labro E, Vanhoucke M (2007) A simulation analysis of interactions among errors in costing systems. Acc Rev 82:939–962
Labro E, Vanhoucke M (2008) Diversity in resource consumption patterns and robustness of cost systems to errors. Manag Sci 54:1715–1730
Leitch RA, Chen Y (1999) Simulation of controlled financial statements. Rev Quant Financ Acc 13:189–207
Pfaff D (1994) On the allocation of overhead costs. Eur Acc Rev 1:49–70
Schilling M (2000) Toward a general modular systems theory and its application to interfirm product modularity. Acad Manag Rev 25:312–334
Schneeweiss C (1998) On the applicability of activity based costing as a planning instrument. Int J Prod Econ 54:277–284
Wouters MJF (1994) Decision orientation of activity-based costing. Int J Prod Econ 36:75–84