The Routes of Moral Development and the Impact of Exposure to the Milgram Obedience Study

Journal of Business Ethics - Tập 75 - Trang 315-333 - 2007
Jerry Paul Sheppard1, Marnie Young2
1Faculty of Business Administration, Simon Fraser University, Burnaby, Canada
2Adler School of Professional Psychology,, Vancouver, Canada

Tóm tắt

This article examines how business students route themselves through the process of cognitive moral development (CMD) to arrive at a more autonomous level of CMD when there is an impetus to do so. In this study, two groups were given Rest’s Defining Issues Test; half the test 1 week and half three weeks later. In between, one group viewed a film of Milgram’s obedience study as a stimulus towards a more autonomous level of CMD. The results of the analysis indicate that viewing the Milgram study produced a positive response regarding subjects’ level of autonomous CMD. However, the response was not uniform across the subject pool. Females showed a greater consistent significant positive response to viewing Milgram while male subjects varied their response contingent upon their functional area of study. While subjects’ functional area of study alone made little difference in the results, when taken in conjunction with gender, significant differences were found between groups. Thus, researchers should take care when investigating differences between subjects’ area of study since gender differences may be present even within an apparently homogenous population-like business students.

Tài liệu tham khảo

Akaah I. (1996) The Influence of Organizational Rank and Role on Marketing Professionals’ Ethical Judgments. Journal of Business Ethics 15:605–613 Beard P. N. (1983) The Effect of Moral Intervention on Different Student Population Groups. Humanitas: Journal for Research in the Human Sciences 9(3):355–363 Bebeau M. J. (2002) The Defining Issues Test and the Four Component Model: Contributions to Professional Education. Journal of Moral Education 31(3):271–295 Behr P., Witt A. (2005) Visionary’s Dream Led to Risky Business. In: Gini A. (eds), Case Studies in Business Ethics, 5th Edition. Pearson Prentice/Hall, Upper Saddle River NJ, pp. 385–394 Beltramini R. F., Peterson R. A., Kozmetsky G. (1984) Concerns of College Students Regarding Business Ethics. Journal of Business Ethics 3:195–200 Bernardi R. A., Arnold D. F. Sr. (1997) An Examination of Moral Development within Public Accounting by Gender, Staff level, and Firm. Contemporary Accounting Research 14(4):653–668 Borkowski S. C., Ugras Y. J. (1998) Business Students and Ethics: A Meta-analysis. Journal of Business Ethics17(11):1117–1127 Boss J. A. (1994) The Effect of Community Service Work on the Moral Development of College Ethics Students. Journal of Moral Education 23:183–198 Carpendale J. I., Krebs D. L. (1992) Situational Variation in Moral Judgment: In a Stage or on a Stage?. Journal of Youth and Adolesence 21(2):203–225 Cherry, S.: 2000, Course Notes 12: Inferences for factor level means. Analysis of Variance & Experimental Design, http://www.math.montana.edu/∼cherry/st412/notes/Ho9/Ho9.html (accessed Oct. 10, 2002). Colby A., Kohlberg L. (1987) The Measurement of Moral Judgment: Standard Issue Scoring Manual. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge Derry R. (1987) Moral Reasoning in Work-related Conflicts. In: Frederick W. C. (eds), Research in Corporate Social Performance and Policy, Vol 9. JAI, Greenwich Conn, pp. 25–50 Derry R. (1989) An Empirical Study of Moral Reasoning among Managers. Journal of Business Ethics 8:855–862 Elm D., Weber J. (1994) Measuring Moral Judgment: The Moral Judgment Interview or the Defining Issues Test? Journal of Business Ethics 13(5): 341–355 Fiske S. T., Taylor S. E. (1984) Social Cognition. Addison-Wesley, Reading, Mass Gautschi F. H., Jones T. M. (1998) Enhancing the Ability of Business Students to Recognize Ethical Issues. Journal of Business Ethics 16:205–216 Gibbs J. C., Widaman K. F., Colby A. (1982) Social Intelligence: Measuring the Development of Sociomoral Reflection. Prentice-Hall, Inc., Englewood Cliffs, N. J. Gilligan C. (1977) In a Different Choice: Women’s Conceptions of the Self and of Morality. Harvard Educational Review 47:481–517 Gilligan C. (1982) Adult Development and Women’s Development: Arrangements for a Marriage. In Giele J. (eds), Women in the Middle Years. John Wiley & Sons, New York, pp. 57–83 Gilligan C., Attanucci J. (1988) Two Moral Orientations: Gender Differences and Similarities. Merrill-Palmer Quarterly 34(3): 223–237 Gilligan C., Ward J., Taylor J., Bardige B. (1988) Mapping the Moral Domain. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass Greising, D.: 1989, Chicago’s B-School Goes Touchy-Feely. Business Week, Nov. 27, 140. Guthrie K. H. (2001) Locus of Control and Field Independence-dependence as Factors in the Development of Moral Judgment. Journal of Genetic Psychology 146(1): 13–18 Hambrick D. C., Cho T. S., Chen M. J. (1996) The Influence of Top Management Team Heterogeneity on Firms’ Competitive Moves. Administrative Science Quarterly 41: 659–684 Hiltebeitel K. M., Jones S. K. (1991) Initial Evidence on the Impact of Integrating Ethics into Accounting Education. Issues in Accounting Education 6(2):262–275 Hilebeitel K. M., Jones S. K. (1992) An Assessment of Ethics Instruction in Accounting Education. Journal of Business Ethics 11:37–46 Hobel J. (2002) The Two Sides of HR. Canadian HR Reporter 15(2):4–8 Holstein C. B. (1976) Irreversible, Stepwise Sequence in the Development of Moral Judgment: A Longitudinal Study of Males and Females. Child Development 47:51–61 Janis I. L. (1983) Groupthink: Psychological Studies of Policy Decisions and Fiascoes, 2nd Ed. Houghton Mifflin, Boston Jeffrey C. (1993) Ethical Development of Accounting Students, Non-accounting Business Students, and Liberal Arts Students. Issues in Accounting Education 8(1): 86–98 Jones T. M. (1991) Ethical Decision Making by Individuals in Organizations: An Issue-contingent Model. Academy of Management Review 16:366–395 Jones T., Gautschi F. (1988) Will the Ethics of Business Change?: A Survey of Future Executives. Journal of Business Ethics 7:231–248 Jones T. M., Quinn D. P. (1995) An Agent Morality View of Business Policy. Academy of Management Review 20:22–42 Kennedy, E. J. and L. Lawton: 1998, `Religiousness and Business Ethics', Journal of Business Ethics, 17(2): 163-175 Kidwell J., Stevens R. I., Bethke A. (1987) Differences in Ethical Perceptions between Male and Female Managers: Myth or Reality?. Journal of Business Ethics 6:489–93 King P. M., Mayhew M. J. (2002) Moral Judgement Development in Higher Education: Insights from the Defining Issues Test. Journal of Moral Education 31(3):247–271 Kohlberg L. (1969) Stage and Sequence: The Cognitive-Developmental Approach to Socialization. In: Goslin D. (eds), Handbook of Socialization Theory and Research. Rand McNalley, Chicago, pp 347–480 Kohlberg L. (1981) The Philosophy of Moral Development, Essays in Moral Development. Harper & Row, New York Kohlberg L. (1984) Essays in Moral Development, the Psychology of Moral Development, Vol. II. Harper & Row, New York Kohlberg, L., C. Levine and A. Hewer: 1983, Moral Stages: A Current Formulation and a Response to Critics. Contributions to Human Development, 10. Basel: S Karger. Reprinted in Kohlberg, 1984. Lincoln D. J., Pressley M. M., Little T. (1982) Ethical Beliefs and Personal Values of Top Level Executives. Journal of Business Research 10:475–487 Lord A. T., DeZoort F. T. (2001) The Impact of Commitment and Moral Reasoning on Auditors’ Responses to Social Influence Pressure. Accounting, Organizations and Society 26(3): 215–235 Mason E. S., Mudrack P. E. (1997) Do Complex Moral Reasoners Experience Greater Ethical Work Conflict?. Journal of Business Ethics 16:1311–1318 Miceli N. S. (1996) Deviant Managerial Behavior: Costs, Outcomes and Prevention. Journal of Business Ethics 15(6):703–710 Milgram S. (1974) Obedience to Authority. Harper & Row, New York Milgram S. (1965) Obedience to Authority. New York University Film Library, New York Moberg D., Romar A. E. (2005) The Good Old Boys at WorldCom. In: Gini A. (eds), Case Studies in Business Ethics, 5th Edition. Pearson Prentice/Hall, Upper Saddle River NJ, pp 205–213 Mudrack, P. E.: 2003, The Untapped Relevance of Moral Development Theory in the Study of Business Ethics. Journal of Business Ethics, 42(3): 225–238. Nelson D. (2000) Multiple Methods for Analyzing Moral Judgment Development Using the Defining Issues Test. In: Burwell Ron (eds), Research on Christian Higher Education, Vol. 7. Council for Christian Colleges & Universities, Washington, D.C. Neter J., Kutner M. H., Wasserman W., Nachtsheim C. J. (1996) Applied Statistical Models, 4th Edition. McGraw-Hill, New York Nicholson N. (1998) How Hardwired is Human Behavior? Harvard Business Review 76(4): 134–147 Nichols M. L., Day V. E. (1982) A Comparison of Moral Reasoning of Groups and Individuals on the ‚Defining Issues Test’. Academy of Management Journal 25:201–208 Nisbett R. E., Ross L. D. (1980) Human Inference: Strategies and Shortcomings of Social Judgment. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs NJ Nisan M. (1984) Social Norms and Moral Judgment. In: Kurtines W., Gewirtz J. (eds), Morality and Moral Development. Wiley, New York, pp. 208–224 Nocera J. (2002) System Failure, Corporate America has Lost Its Way. Here’s a Road Map for Restoring Confidence. Fortune 145(13): 62–74 Nucci L. P. (1982) Children’s Responses to Moral and Social Conceptional Transgressions in Free-Play Settings. Child Development 53: 1337–1342 Peterson R. A., Beltramini R. F., Kozmetsky G. (1991) Concerns of College Students Regarding Business Ethics: A Replication. Journal of Business Ethics 10: 733–739 Ponemon L. A., Gabhart D. (1994) Ethical Reasoning Research in the Accounting and Auditing Professions. In Rest J. R., Narvaez D. (eds), Moral Development in the Professions: Psychology and Applied Ethics. Laurence Erlbaum Associates, Hilsdale, N.J., pp. 101–119 Pritchard R. E., Potter G. C., Saccucci M. (2004) The Selection of a Business Major: Elements Influencing Student Choice. Journal of Education for Business 79(3): 152–156 Reall M. J., Bailey J. J., Stoll S. K. (1998) Moral Reasoning on Hold during a Competitive Game. Journal of Business Ethics 17:1205–1210 Reed D. R. C. (1997) Following Kohlberg: Liberalism and the Practice of Democratic Community. University of Notre Dame Press, Notre Dame, Indiana Rest J. R. (1979) Development in Judging Moral Issues. University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis Rest J. R. (1986) Moral Development: Advances in Research and Theory. Praeger, New York Rest J. R. (1994) Revised Manual for the Defining Issues Test. Univ. of Minn. Press, Minneapolis Rest J., Narvaez D., Bebeau M. J., Thoma S. J. (1999) Postconventional Moral Thinking: A Neo-Kohlbergian Approach. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, NJ Rifkin G. (1996) One Man’s Search for Leadership. Forbes, April 8:110–115 Schlaefli A., Rest J., Thoma S. (1985) Does Moral Education Improve Moral Judgment? A Meta-Analysis of Intervention Studies Using the Defining Issues Test. Review of Educational Research 55: 319–352 Self D. J., Baldwin D. C. Jr., Olivarez M. (1993) Teaching Medical Ethics to First-year Students by Using Film Discussion to Develop their Moral Reasoning. Academic Medicine 68:383–385 Sikula A., Costa A. (1994) Are Women More Ethical Than Men? Journal of Business Ethics 13:859–871 Smith H. R., Carroll A. B. (1984) Organizational Ethics: A Stacked Deck. Journal of Business Ethics 3:95–100 Sneed J., Morgan D. A. (1999) Evaluating the Verbal, Quantitative, and Problem-Solving Skills of Students Entering the Accounting Curriculum. Management Research News 22(4): 22–28 St. Pierre K., Nelson E., Gabbin A. (1990)A Study of the Ethical Development of Accounting Majors in Relation to other Business and Nonbusiness Disciplines. Accounting Educators Journal 8:23–25 Stanga K. G., Turpen R. C. A. (1991) Ethical Judgments on Selected Accounting Issues: An Empirical Study. Journal of Business Ethics 10:739–747 Thoma S. J., Rest J. R., Davison M. L. (1991) Describing and Testing a Moderator of the Moral Judgment and Action Relationship. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 61(4):659–669 Trevino L. K. (1986) Ethical Decision Making in Organizations: A Person-Situation Interactionist Model. The Academy of Management Review 11(3): 601–617 Uddin N., Gillett P. R. (2002) The Effects of Moral Reasoning and Self-monitoring on CFO Intentions to Report Fraudulently on Financial Statements. Journal of Business Ethics 40(1): 15–21 Walker L. (1984) Sex Differences in the Development of Moral Reasoning: A Critical Review. Child Development 55:677–691 Weber J. (1990a) Managers’ Moral Reasoning: Assessing Their Responses to Three Moral Dilemmas. Human Relations 43(7): 687–702 Weber J. (1990b) Measuring the Impact of Teaching Ethics to Future Managers: A Review, Assessment and Recommendations. Journal of Business Ethics 9(3): 183–190 Weber J. (1991) Adapting Kohlberg to Enhance the Assessment of Managers’ Moral Reasoning. Business Ethics Quarterly 1(3):293–318 Weber J. (1992) Scenarios in Business Ethics Research: Review, Critical Assessment, and Recommendations. Business Ethics Quarterly 2(2): 137–160 Weber J., Wasieleski D. (2001) Investigating Influences on Managers’ Moral Reasoning. Business and Society 40(1): 79–111 White R. D. (2002) Do Employees Act like They Think? Exploring the Dichotomy between Moral Judgment and Ethical Behavior. Public Administration Quarterly 25(4): 391–412 Wimalasiri J. S. (2001) Moral Reasoning Capacity of Management Students and Practitioners: An Empirical Study in Australia. Journal of Managerial Psychology 16: 614–634 Wimalasiri J. S., Pavri F., Abdul A. K. (1996) An Empirical Study of Moral Reasoning among Managers in Singapore. Journal of Business Ethics 15(12): 1331–1341