The Role of Ethical Leadership Versus Institutional Constraints: A Simulation Study of Financial Misreporting by CEOs

Journal of Business Ethics - Tập 93 - Trang 33-52 - 2010
Stephen Chen1
1Department of Business, Macquarie University, Sydney, Australia

Tóm tắt

This article examines the proposition that a major cause of the major financial accounting scandals that received much publicity around the world was unethical leadership in the companies and compares the role of unethical leaders in a variety of scenarios. Through the use of computer simulation models, it shows how a combination of CEO's narcissism, financial incentive, shareholders' expectations and subordinate silence as well as CEO's dishonesty can do much to explain some of the findings highlighted in recent high profile financial accounting scandals. Furthermore, it shows that the nature and impact of ethical leadership depends greatly on the institutional setting and can be expected to vary greatly by country and culture. In certain circumstances ethical leadership can have either a negligible or even opposite effect to that expected.

Tài liệu tham khảo

Aguilera, R. V. and G. Jackson: 2003, ‘The Cross-National Diversity of Corporate Governance: Dimensions and Determinants’, Academy of Management Review 28 (3), 447–465. Anderson, P.: 1999, ‘Complexity Theory and Organization Science’, Organization Science 10 (3), 216-232. Andvig, J.C. and K.O. Moene: 1990, ‘How Corruption May Corrupt’, Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 13, 63-76. Aschheim, S.E.: 1994, The Nietzsche Legacy in Germany 1890 – 1990 (University of California Press, Berkeley). Aycan, Z., R.N. Kanungo, M.Mendonca, K. Yu, J. Deller, G. Stahl and A. Kurshid: 2000, ‘Impact of Culture on Human Resource Management Practices: A 10-country Comparison’, Applied Psychology: An International Review 49 (1), 192-221. Bandura, A.: 1977, Social Learning Theory (Prentice-Hall: Englewood Cliffs, NJ). Becker, G.S.: 1968, ‘Crime and punishment: an economic approach’, Journal of Political Economy 76, 169–217. Blumstein, A., J. Cohen & D.P. Farrington: 2006, ‘Criminal career research: its value for criminology’, Criminology 26 (1), 1-35. Boyer, M.M. and H. Ortiz-Molina: 2008, ‘Career Concerns of Top Executives, Managerial Ownership and CEO's Succession’, Corporate Governance 16 (3), 178-193. Bragues, G.: 2008, ‘The Ancients against the Moderns: Focusing on the Character of Corporate Leaders’, Journal of Business Ethics 78, 373–387. Brown, M.E. and L.K. Treviño: 2006, ‘Ethical leadership: A review and future directions’, The Leadership Quarterly 17, 595–616. Brown, M. E., L.K. Treviño and D. Harrison: 2005, ‘Ethical leadership: A social learning perspective for construct development and testing’, Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 97, 117 − 134. Bruderer, E., & J.S. Singh: 1996, ‘Organizational evolution, learning, and selection: A genetic-algorithm-based model’, Academy of Management Journal 39, 1322–1349. Burns, J. M.: 1978, Leadership (Harper & Row: New York). Burns, N. and Kedia, S.: 2006, ‘The impact of performance-based compensation on misreporting’, Journal of Financial Economics 79, 35–67. Burton, R.M. and B. Obel: 1995, ‘The Validity of Computational Models in Organization Science: From Model Realism to Purpose of the Model’, Computational and Mathematical Organization Theory 1 (1), 57-71. Bushman, R.M and J.D. Piotroski: 2006, ‘Financial reporting incentives for conservative accounting: The influence of legal and political institutions’, Journal of Accounting and Economics 42, 107–148. Carson, T.L.: 2003, ‘Self–Interest and Business Ethics: Some Lessons of the Recent Corporate Scandals’, Journal of Business Ethics 43 (4), 389-394. Chen, S., Bouvain, P.: 2009, ‘Is Corporate Responsibility Converging? A Comparison of Corporate Responsibility Reporting in the USA, UK, Australia, and Germany’, Journal of Business Ethics 87, 299-317. Chen, J.C., D. Patten and R.W. Roberts: 2008, ‘Corporate Charitable Contributions: A Corporate Social Performance or Legitimacy Strategy’, Journal of Business Ethics 82, 131-144. Cohen, M. D., J.G. March & J.P. Olsen: 1972, ‘A garbage can model of organizational choice’, Administrative Science Quarterly 17, 1–25. Conger, J.: 1990, ‘The dark side of leadership’, Organizational Dynamics 19, 44-55. Conyon, M.J. and K.J. Murphy: 2000, ‘The Prince and the Pauper: CEO Pay in the United States and United Kingdom’, Economic Journal 110, 640-671. Davis, J.P., K.M. Eisenhardt and C.B. Bingham: 2007, ‘Developing Theory Through Simulation Methods’, Academy of Management Review 32 (2), 480–499. Davis, J.H. and J.A. Ruhe: 2003, ‘Perceptions of Country Corruption: Antecedents and Outcomes’, Journal of Business Ethics 43, 275–288. Den Niuewenboer, N.A. & M. Kaptein: 2007, ‘Spiraling Down into Corruption: A Dynamic Analysis of the Social Identity Processes that Cause Corruption in Organizations to Grow’, Journal of Business Ethics 83, 133-146. Doris, J: 2002, Lack of Character: Personality and Moral Behavior (New York: Cambridge University Press). Efendi, J., A. Srivastava and E.P. Swanson, E.P.: 2007, ‘Why do corporate managers misstate financial statements? The role of option compensation and other factors’, Journal of Financial Economics 85, 667–708. Ellis, H.: 1898, ‘Auto-Eroticism: A Psychological Study’, Alienist and Neurologist 19, 260–299 Emmons, R.: 1981. ‘Relationship between narcissism and sensation seeking’, Psychological Reports 48 (1), 247-250. Erev, I., T.S. Wallsten & D.V. Budescu: 1994, ‘Simultaneous over- and underconfidence: The role of error in judgment processes’, Psychological Review 101, 519–528. Fama, E.: 1980, ‘Agency problems and the theory of the firm’, Journal of Political Economy 88, 288-307. Farwell, L., and R. Wohlwend-Lloyd: 1998, ‘Narcissistic processes: optimistic expectations, favorable self-evaluations, and self-enhancing attribution’, Journal of Personality 66, 65–83. Feld, L.P. and B.S. Frey: 2007, ‘Tax Compliance as the Result of a Psychological Tax Contract: The Role of Incentives and Responsive Regulation’, Law & Policy 29 (1), 102-120. Fogarty, T., M.I. Magnan, G. Markarian and S. Bohdjalian, S.: 2009, ‘Inside Agency: The Rise and Fall of Nortel’, Journal of Business Ethics 84, 165–187. Forrester, J.: 1961, Industrial dynamics, (MIT Press Cambridge, MA). Freud, S.: 1957, ‘On Narcissism: An Introduction’, in J. Strachey (ed. & trans.), The Standard Edition of the Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud, Vol. 14 (Hogarth Press, London), pp. 67–104. Getz, K.A. and Volkema, R.J.: 2001, ‘Culture, Perceived Corruption and Economics: A Model of Predictors and Outcomes’, Business and Society 40, 7-30. Harman, G.: 2003, ‘No Character or Personality’, Business Ethics Quarterly 13 (1), 87-94. Harrison, J.R., Z. Lin, G.R. Carroll and K.M. Carley: 2007, ‘Simulation Modeling in Organizational and Management Research’, Academy Of Management Review 32 (4), 1229–1245. Hayward, M.L.A, V.P. Rindova and T.G. Pollock: 2004, ‘Believing One’s Own Press: The Causes and Consequences of CEO ego’, Strategic Management Journal 25, 637–653. Hodgson, G.M. and Jiang, S.: 2007, ‘The Economics of Corruption and the Corruption of Economics: An Institutionalist Perspective’, Journal of Economic Issues 61 (4), 1043-1061. Hofstede, G.: 1980, Culture’s Consequences: International Differences in Work Related Values (Sage Publications,Beverly Hills, CA). Jensen, M. and W. Meckling: 1976, ‘Theory of firm: managerial behavior, agency costs and ownership structure’, Journal of Financial Economics 3, 305–360. Kaplan, S. N.: 2008, ‘Are U.S. CEOs overpaid?’, Academy of Management Perspectives 22(2), 5–20. Kets de Vries, M.: 2003, Leaders, Fools and Impostors: Essays on the Psychology of Leadership (revised edition) (iUniverse, New York). Knights, D. & M. O’Leary: 2006, ‘Leadership, Ethics and Responsibility to the Other’, Journal of Business Ethics 67, 125-137. Koopman, P.L., D. N. Den Hartog, E. Konrad et al.: 1999, ‘National Culture and Leadership Profiles in Europe: Some Results From the GLOBE Study’, European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology 8 (4), 503–520. Kruger, J., & Dunning, D.: 1999, ‘Unskilled and unaware of it: How difficulties in recognizing one’s own incompetence lead to inflated self-assessments’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 77, 1121-1134. Larrick, R. P.: 1993, ‘Motivational factors in decision theories: The role of self-protection’, Psychological Bulletin 113, 440–450. Leuz, C., D. Nanda and P.D. Wysocki: 2003, ‘Investor Protection and Earnings Management: An International Comparison’, Journal of Financial Economics 69, 505-527. Levinthal, D.: 1991, ‘Random walks and organizational mortality’, Administrative Science Quarterly 36, 397–420. Li, J., J. Moy, K. Lam and W.L.C. Chu: 2008, ‘Institutional Pillars and Corruption at the Societal Level’, Journal of Business Ethics 83, 327-339. Lomi, A., & E.R. Larsen: 1996, ‘Interacting locally and evolving globally: A computational approach to the dynamics of organizational populations’, Academy of Management Journal 39, 1287–1321. Mac Intyre, A.: 1991, After Virtue (Duckworth: London). March, J. G.: 1991, ‘Exploration and exploitation in organizational learning’, Organization Science 2, 71–87. Matten, D. and Moon, J.: 2008, “Implicit” And “Explicit” CSR: A Conceptual Framework For A Comparative Understanding Of Corporate Social Responsibility’, Academy of Management Review 33 (2), 404–424. Milgram, S.: 1974, Obedience to Authority (Harper Collins: New York). Miller, H. and K.J. Engemann: 2004, ‘A Simulation Model of Intergroup Conflict’, Journal of Business Ethics 50, 355-367. Mocan, N.: 2008, ‘What determines corruption? International evidence from microdata’, Economic Inquiry 46(4), 493–510. Morrell, K.: 2004, ‘Socratic Dialogue as a Tool for Teaching Business Ethics’, Journal of Business Ethics 53, 383-392. Morris, J.A., C.M. Brotheridge and J.C. Urbanski: 2005, ‘Bringing humility to leadership: Antecedents and consequences of leader humility’, Human Relations 58, 1323-1350. Morrison, A.: 2001, ‘Integrity and Global Leadership’, Journal of Business Ethics 31, 65–76. Norberg, P.: 2009, ‘I don’t Care that People don’t Like What I Do – Business Codes Viewed as Invisible or Visible Restrictions’, Journal of Business Ethics 86, 211-225. Ono, H.: 2007, ‘Careers in Foreign-owned Firms in Japan’, American Sociological Review 72, 267-290. Park, H., M.T. Rehg and D. Lee: 2005, ‘The Influence of Confucian Ethics and Collectivism on Whistleblowing Intentions: A Study of South Korean Public Employees’, Journal of Business Ethics 58 (4), 387-403. Perel, M.: 2003, ‘An Ethical Perspective on CEO Compensation’, Journal of Business Ethics 48, 381-391. Pozner, J.E.: 2008, ‘Stigma and Settling Up: An Integrated Approach to the Consequences of Organizational Misconduct for Organizational Elites’, Journal of Business Ethics 80, 141–150. Reinstein, A., S.R. Moehrle and J. Reynolds-Moehrle, J.: 2006, ‘Crime and punishment in the marketplace: Accountants and business executives repeating history’, Managerial Auditing Journal 21 (4), 420-435. Resick, C.J., P.J. Hanges, M.W. Dickson and J.K. Mitchelson: 2006, ‘A Cross-Cultural Examination of the Endorsement of Ethical Leadership’, Journal of Business Ethics 63, 345–359. Robertson, D.C.: 1993, ‘Empiricism in Business Ethics: Suggested Research Directions’, Journal of Business Ethics 12 (8), 585-599. Rudolph, J. and N. Repenning: 2002, ‘Disaster dynamics: Understanding the role of quantity in organizational collapse’, Administrative Science Quarterly 47, 1–30. Schwartz, H.S: 1991, ‘Narcissism Project and Corporate Decay: The Case of General Motors’, Business Ethics Quarterly 1 (3), 249-268. Scott, W. R.: 1995, Institutions and Organizations (Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks, CA) Semadeni, M., A.A. Cannella, D.R. Fraser and D.S. Lee: 2008, ‘Fight or flight: managing stigma in executive careers’, Strategic Management Journal 29, 557–567. Sims, R.R. and J. Brinkmann: 2003, ‘Enron Ethics (Or: Culture Matters More than Codes)’, Journal of Business Ethics 45, 243–256. Soll, J. B.: 1996, ‘Determinants of overconfidence and miscalibration: The roles of random error and ecological structure’, Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 65, 117–137. Solomon, R.C.: 2003, ‘Victims of Circumstances? A Defense of Virtue Ethics in Business’, Business Ethics Quarterly 13 (1), 43-62. Sterman, J.: 2000, Business dynamics: Systems thinking and modeling for a complex world (Irwin McGraw-Hill: New York). Street, M.D., C. Robertson and S.W. Geiger: 1997, ‘Ethical Decision Making: The Effects of Escalating Commitment’, Journal of Business Ethics 16, 1153–1161. Suchman, M.C.: 1995, ‘Managing Legitimacy: Strategic and Institutional Approaches’, Academy of Management Review 20 (3), 571-610. Tavakoli, A.A., J.P. Keenan and B. Crnjak-Karanovic: 2003, ‘Culture and Whistleblowing: An Empirical Study of Croatian and United States Managers Utilizing Hofstede’s Cultural Dimensions’, Journal of Business Ethics 43, 49–64. Taylor, E. Z. and M. B. Curtis: 2010, ‘An Examination of the Layers of Workplace Influences in Ethical Judgments: Whistleblowing Likelihood and Perseverance in Public Accounting’, Journal of Business Ethics 93, 21–37. Treisman, D.: 2000, ‘The causes of corruption: a cross-national study’, Journal of Public Economics 76, 399–457. Trevor-Roberts, E., N. M. Ashkanasy and J. C. Kennedy: 2003, ‘The Egalitarian Leader: A Comparison of Leadership in Australia and New Zealand’, Asia Pacific Journal of Management 20, 517–540 Wagner-Tsukumoto, S.: 2005, ‘An Economic Approach to Business Ethics: Moral Agency of the Firm and the Enabling and Constraining Effects of Economic Institutions and Interactions in a Market Economy’, Journal of Business Ethics 60, 75-89. Waldman, D.A., M.S. de Luque, N. Washburn, R.J. House et al.: 2006, ‘Cultural and leadership predictors of corporate social responsibility values of top management: a GLOBE study of 15 countries’, Journal of International Business Studies 37, 823–837. Wallace, H. M., & R.F. Baumeister: 2002, ‘The performance of narcissists rises and falls with perceived opportunity for glory’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 82, 819–834. Watson, G.W., R.E. Freeman & B. Parmar: 2007,’Connected Moral Agency in Organizational Ethics’, Journal of Business Ethics 81, 323-341. Zhang, X., K.M. Bartol, K.G. Smith, M.D. Pfarrer and D.M. Khanin: 2008, ‘CEOs on the Edge: Earnings Manipulation and Stock-Based Incentive Misalignment’, Academy of Management Journal 51 (2), 241–258. Zyglidopoulos, S.C., P.J. Fleming and S. Rothenberg: 2009, ‘Rationalization, Overcompensation and the Escalation of Corruption in Organizations’, Journal of Business Ethics 84, 65–73.