The ISPS Code and The Cost of Port Compliance: An Initial Logistics and Supply Chain Framework for Port Security Assessment and Management
Tóm tắt
Following a description of ISPS and non-ISPS security initiatives, the main risk factors and security threats to ports are identified and analysed, with a focus on the risks stemming from non-tangible assets, flows and processes. Similarly, the various economic approaches to risk management and cost control in shipping are reviewed, and their shortcomings highlighted from the perspective of port logistics and supply chain security. By adopting a channel orientation to ports, the paper suggests that the subject of port security must shift from the current agenda of port-facility security to the wider context of port supply chain security, with a view to ensuring superior security standards and practices in ports and across their supply chain networks. Based on the rationale of logistics integration and supply chain partnership, a conceptual framework to port security is proposed through integrating and optimising three initial models relating, respectively, to channel design and process mapping, risk assessment and management, and cost control and performance monitoring.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Alderton, PM . (2002): The maritime economics of security. Maritime Policy and Management 29: 105–106.
American Association of Port Authorities On-line (AAPA). (2004) http://www.apaa_ports.org. visited on 15 March 2004.
Anderson, PL . (2002): Lost earnings due to the west-coast port shutdown: Preliminary estimate. Anderson Economic Group LLC. working paper 2002-10, October 2002.
Bichou, K and Gray, R . (2004): A logistics and supply chain management approach to port performance measurement. Maritime Policy and Management 31: 47–67.
Billington, CJ . (2001): Managing risks in ports. In: (ed). Managing Risks in Shipping: A Practical Guide. The Nautical Institute: London. pp. 57–69.
Booz Allen Hamilton port security war game (BAH). (2002) Available on-line on: http://www.boozallen.com. Visited on the 1st of April 2004.
Boscke, LB and Cuttino, JC . (2003): Measuring the economic and transportation impacts of maritime-related activities. Maritime Economics and Logistics 5: 133–157.
Bowersox, DJ and Closs, DJ . (2002): Supply chain sustainability and cost in the new war economy. Traffic World April 1, 2002.
Christy, DP and Grout, JR . (1994): Safeguarding supply chain relationships. International Journal of Production Economics 36: 233–242.
Cohen, MA and Lee, HL . (1989): Resource deployment analysis of global manufacturing and distribution networks. Journal of Manufacturing and Operations Management 2: 81–104.
Containerisation International. (2003a): Security versus supply chain. April 2003, pp. 49–53.
Containerisation International. (2003b): Cost of port security begins to show. December 2003: p. 29.
Cremers, P and Chawla, P . (1999): Shipboard management and safety standards. BIMCO Review, 7th Edition, 234–237.
Cullinane, K . (1991): The utility analysis of risk attitudes in shipping. Maritime Policy and Management 18: 157–169.
Dekker, HC . (2003): Value chain analysis in inter-firm relationship: A field of study. Management Accounting Research 14: 1–23.
Dorfman, R . (1993): An introduction to benefit–cost analysis. In: Stavins, RN (ed). Economics of the Environment 4th Edition, Norton & Co: New York, NY. pp. 297–322.
Drewry Shipping Consultants. (1998): Cost of quality shipping: The financial implications of the current regulatory environment. London, November 1998.
Evers, PT and Johnson, CJ . (2000): Performance perceptions, satisfaction, and intention: The intermodal shipper's perspective. Transportation Journal 40: 27–39.
Freeman, RE . (1984): Strategic management: A stakeholder approach. Pitman: Boston.
Fung, MK, Cheng, LK and Qiu, LD . (2003): The impact of terminal handling charges on overall shipping charges: An empirical study. Transportation Research Part A 37: 703–716.
Gong, HT, Firth, M, Cullinane, K and Wang, TF . (2002): A high risk -low beta business? Beta estimation in the international transport industry. In (ed). IAME 2002 Panama Conference Proceedings. International Association of Maritime Economists Conference, Panama, 13–15 November 2002.
Haralambides, HE, Verbeke, A, Musso, E and Benacchio, M . (2001): Port financing and pricing in the European Union: Theory, politics and reality. International Journal of Maritime Economics 3: 368–386.
Haralambides, HE . (2002): Competition, excess capacity and the pricing of port infrastructure. International Journal of Maritime Economics 4: 323–347.
International Maritime Organisation. (1997): Interim guidelines for the application of formal safety assessment (FSA) to the IMO rule making process. MSC/Cir.829 and MPEC/Circ. 355, IMO: London.
IMO. (2002): ISPS code Conference of Contracting Governments to the International Convention for the SOLAS 1974: SOLAS/ CONF.5/34. IMO: London, 17 December 2002.
Johnston, VR . (2004): Transportation security and terrorism: Resetting the model and equations-epilogue. Review of Policy Research 21: 379–402.
Kaplan, RS and Cooper, R . (1998): Cost and effect using integrated cost systems to drive profitability and performance. Harvard Business School Press: Boston, MA.
Kaplan, RS and Norton, DP . (1996): Balance scorecard: Translating strategy into action. Harvard Business School Press: Boston, MA.
Kavussanos, MG and Marcoulis, S . (2001): Risk and return in transportation and other U.S. and global industries. Kluwer Academic Publishers: Boston.
Lambert, DM, Stock, JR and Ellram, LM . (1998): Fundamentals of logistics management. McGraw-Hill: Boston, MA.
Lee, HL, Billington, C and Carter, B . (1993): Hewlett-Packard gains control of inventory and service through design for localization. Interfaces 23: 1–11.
Li, XK and Cullinane, K . (2003): An economic approach to maritime risk management and safety regulation. Maritime Economics and Logistics 5: 268–284.
Lloyd's List. (2003a): US pushes on with next round in CSI bout Lloyd's list: 24/06/2003.
Lloyd's List. (2003b): Lines take on extra staff to cope with US cargo clamp Lloyd's list: 5/3/2003.
Lloyd's List. (2004): Caribbean fears US trade link loss Lloyd's list: 30/01/2004.
Ma, S . (2002): Economics of maritime safety and environment regulations. In: Grammenos, CT (ed). The Handbook of Maritime Economics and Business. LLP: London. pp. 399–426.
Mourits, M and Evers, JJ . (1995): Distribution network design. International Journal of Physical Distribution & Logistics Management 25: 43–57.
Organisation for Economic and Co-operation Development. (1996): Competitive advantages obtained by some shipowners as a result of non-observance of applicable international rules and standards. OECD/GD 96: 1–31.
OECD. (2003): Security in maritime transport: Risk factors and economic impact. Maritime Transport Committee. OECD: Paris.
Peachey, JH . (2001): Managing risk through legislation. In: The Nautical Institute (ed). Managing Risks in Shipping: A Practical Guide. The Nautical Institute: London. pp. 92–105.
Sanchez, RJ, Hoffmann, J, Micco, A, Pizzolitto, G, Sgut, M and Wilmsmeir, G . (2003): Port efficiency and international trade: Port efficiency as a determinant of maritime transport costs. Maritime Economics and Logistics 5: 199–218.
Sheffi, S . (2001): Supply chain management under the threat of international terrorism. International Journal of Logistics Management 12: 1–11.
Slack, B, Comtois, C and McCalla, R . (2002): Strategic alliances in the container shipping industry: A global perspective. Maritime Policy and Management 29: 65–76.
Stank, TP, Keller, SB and Daugherty, PJ . (2001): Supply chain collaboration and logistics service performance. Journal of Business Logistics 22: 29–47.
Tietenberg, TH . (2000): Economics instruments for environmental regulations. In: Stavins, RN (ed). Economics of the Environment 4th Edition, Norton & Co: New York NY. pp. 378–393.
Tongzon, JL . (1995): Systematizing international benchmarking for ports. Maritime Policy and Management 22: 171–177.
Towill, DR . (1991): Supply chain dynamics. International Journal of Computer Integrated Manufacturing 4: 197–208.
The Financial Times. (2004): Bespoke delays follow 24-hour rule. Financial Times: 24 February.
The UK Maritime and Coastguard Agency. (1996): A methodology for formal safety assessment in shipping, deliverable D1.4: Full methodology report. MCA research project 383. London, UK.
The US Bureau of Customs and Border Protection (CBP). (2004): On-line. http://www.cbp.gov visited on the 1st of March 2004.
The US General Accounting Office (GAO). (2003): Container security: Expansion of key customs programs will require greater attention to crucial success factors. GAO-03-770, Washington DC, July 2003.
UNCTAD. (2004a): Container security: Major initiatives and related international developments. Report by the UCTAD Secretariat: Geneva. 26 February 2004.
UNCTAD. (2004b): Transport newsletter 23: First quarter 2004. Geneva. April 2004.
US Department of Homeland Security (DHS). (2003): Protecting America's ports: Maritime Transportation Act of 2002. Office of the press secretary: Washington DC, July 2003.
World Bank. (2001): Stakeholder analysis Available on-line under social development/ social assessment. http://www.worldbank.org/social.