The Challenges of Managing Legacy Phosphorus Losses from Manure-Impacted Agricultural Soils

Sharpley AN, Kleinman PJA, Flaten DN, Buda AR. Critical source area management of agricultural phosphorus: experiences, challenges and opportunities. Water Sci Technol. 2011;64(4):945–52. Daroub SH, Lang TA, Diaz OA, Grunwald S. Long-term water quality trends after implementing best management practices in South Florida. J Environ Qual. 2009;38(4):1683–93. Sharpley AN, Daniel T, Sims T, Lemunyon J, Stevens R, Parry R. Agricultural phosphorus and eutrophication—2nd edition. U.S. Department of agriculture agricultural research service ARS-129; 2003. Mulla DJ, Birr AS, Kitchen NR, David MB. Limitations of evaluating the effectiveness of agricultural management practices at reducing nutrient losses to surface waters. In: Liang G, editor. Final report: gulf hypoxia and local water quality concerns workshop. St Joseph: American Society of Agricultural and Biological Engineers; 2005. Sharpley AN. Global issues of phosphorus in terrestrial ecosystems. In: Reddy KR, O’Connor GA, Schelske CL, editors. Phosphorus biogeochemistry in subtropical ecosystems. Boca Raton, FL: Lewis Publishers; 1999. p. 15–46. Meals DW, Dressing SA, Davenport TE. Lag time in water quality response to best management practices: a review. J Environ Qual. 2010;39(1):85–96. McDowell RW, Sharpley AN, Chalmers AT. Land use and flow regime effects on phosphorus chemical dynamics in the fluvial sediment of the Winooski River, Vermont. Ecol Eng. 2002;18(4):477–87. Kleinman PJA, Sharpley AN, Buda AR, McDowell RW, Allen AL. Soil controls of phosphorus in runoff: management barriers and opportunities. Can J Soil Sci. 2011;91(3):329–38. Sharpley A, Jarvie HP, Buda A, May L, Spears B, Kleinman P. Phosphorus legacy: overcoming the effects of past management practices to mitigate future water quality impairment. J Environ Qual. 2013;42(5):1308–26. Kleinman PJA, Church C, Saporito LS, McGrath JM, Reiter MS, Allen AL, et al. Phosphorus leaching from agricultural soils of the Delmarva Peninsula, USA. J Environ Qual. 2015;44(2):524–34. Vadas PA, Sims JT. Predicting phosphorus desorption from mid-Atlantic coastal plain soils. Soil Sci Soc Am J. 2002;66(2):623–31. Delmarva Poultry Industry, Inc. Delmarva meat chickens, soybeans, and corn production and use 2015; http://www.dpichicken.org/facts/docs/Delmarva%20meat%20chicken%20production%20and%20corn%20and%20soybean%20use.pdf. Accessed 24 Apr 2018. Chesapeake Bay Program. Recommendations to estimate poultry nutrient production in the phase 6 watershed model. 2015; http://www.chesapeakebay.net/channel_files/22429/recommendations_to_estimate_poultry_nutrients_for_phase_6_model_03062015.pdf. Accessed 24 Apr 2018. Delaware Department of Agriculture. Delaware nutrient management commission annual report 2016. 2016; https://agriculture.delaware.gov/wp-content/uploads/sites/108/2017/12/2016-DNM-AR.pdf. Accessed 24 Apr 2018. Shober AL, Riggi S. Defining high phosphorus soils in Delaware. 2013; http://extension.udel.edu/factsheets/defining-high-p-soils-in-delaware/. Accessed 24 Apr 2018. Sims JT. Phosphorus soil testing: innovations for water quality protection. Commun Soil Sci Plant Anal. 1998;29(11–14):1471–89. Sims JT, Edwards AC, Schoumans OF, Simard RR. Integrating soil phosphorus testing into environmentally based agricultural management practices. J Environ Qual 2000;29(1):60–71. Maryland Department of Agriculture. Preliminary phosphorous soil test results. 2016; http://www.mda.maryland.gov/documents/Preliminary-P-Data_03.2016.pdf. Accessed 24 Apr 2018. Scheckel KG, Diamond GL, Burgess MF, Klotzbach JM, Maddaloni M, Miller BW, et al. Amending soils with phosphate as means to mitigate soil lead hazard: a critical review of the state of the science. J Toxicol Environ Health B Crit Rev. 2013;16(6):337–80. Busman L, Lamb J, Randall G, Rehm G, Schmitt M. The nature of phosphorus in soils. 2002; http://www.extension.umn.edu/agriculture/nutrient-management/phosphorus/the-nature-of-phosphorus/. Accessed 24 Apr 2018. Sample EC, Soper RJ, Racz GJ. Reactions of phosphate fertilizers in soils. In: Khasawneh FE, Sample EC, Kamprath EJ, editors. The role of phosphorus in agriculture. Madison: ASA and SSSA; 1980. p. 263–310. Sims JT, Simard RR, Joern BC. Phosphorus loss in agricultural drainage: historical perspective and current research. J Environ Qual. 1998;27(2):277–93. Zhang TQ, MacKenzie AF, Liang BC, Drury CF. Soil test phosphorus and phosphorus fractions with long-term phosphorus addition and depletion. Soil Sci Soc Am J. 2004;68(2):519–28. Iyamuremye F, Dick RP. Organic amendments and phosphorus sorption by soils. Adv Agron. 1996;56:139–85. Kumaragamage D, Akinremi OO, Flaten D, Heard J. Agronomic and environmental soil test phosphorus in manured and non-manured Manitoba soils. Can J Soil Sci. 2007;87(1):73–83. Pote DH, Daniel TC, Sharpley AN, Moore PA, Edwards DR, Nichols DJ. Relating extractable soil phosphorus to phosphorus losses in runoff. Soil Sci Soc Am J. 1996;60(3):855–9. Sims JT. The role of soil testing in environmental risk assessment for phosphorus. In: Sharpley AN, editor. Agriculture and phosphorus management: the Chesapeake Bay. Washington, DC: Lewis Publishers; 2000. p. 57–81. Gartley KL, Sims JT. Phosphorus soil testing-environmental uses and implications. Commun Soil Sci Plant Anal. 1994;25(9–10):1565–82. Pierzynski GM. Methods of phosphorus analysis for soils, sediments, residuals, and waters. Southern Cooperative Series Bulletin 396; U.S. Department of Agriculture and North Carolina State University, Raleigh; 2000. Gartley KL, Sims JT, Olsen CT, Chu P. Comparison of soil test extractants used in Mid-Atlantic United States. Commun Soil Sci Plant Anal. 2002;33(5–6):873–95. Bhattacharyya P, Nayak AK, Shahid M, Tripathi R, Mohanty S, Kumar A, et al. Effects of 42-year long-term fertilizer management on soil phosphorus availability, fractionation, adsorption-desorption isotherm and plant uptake in flooded tropical rice. Crop J. 2015;3(5):387–95. Dhillon NS, Dhesi TS, Brar BS. Phosphate sorption-desorption characteristics of some Ustifluvents of Punjab. J Indian Soc Soil Sci. 2004;52(1):17–22. Zhang W, Faulkner JW, Giri SK, Geohring LD, Steenhuis TS. Evaluation of two langmuir models for phosphorus sorption of phosphorus-enriched soils in New York for environmental applications. Soil Sci. 2009;174(10):523–30. Dou ZX, Ramberg CF, Toth JD, Wang Y, Sharpley AN, Boyd SE, et al. Phosphorus speciation and sorption-desorption characteristics in heavily manured soils. Soil Sci Soc Am J. 2009;73(1):93–101. Graetz DA, Nair VD. Phosphorus sorption isotherm determination. In: Pierzynski GM, editor. Methods of phosphorus analysis for soils, sediments, residuals, and waters. Southern Cooperative Series Bulletin 396; U.S. Raleigh: Department of Agriculture and North Carolina State University; 2000. Villapando RR, Graetz DA. Phosphorus sorption and desorption properties of the spodic horizon from selected Florida Spodosols. Soil Sci Soc Am J. 2001;65(2):331–9. Barrow NJ. The description of sorption curves. Eur J Soil Sci. 2008;59(5):900–10. Limousin G, Gaudet JP, Charlet L, Szenknect S, Barthes V, Krimissa M. Sorption isotherms: a review on physical bases, modeling and measurement. Appl Geochem. 2007;22(2):249–75. • Kleinman PJA. The persistent environmental relevance of soil phosphorus sorption saturation. Curr Pollut Rep. 2017;3(2):141–50 This paper provides a detailed review on soil P sorption saturation, a commonly used parameter to describe soil P dynamics and estimate the potential of soil to release non-point P pollution. Schoumans OF, Groenendijk P. Modeling soil phosphorus levels and phosphorus leaching from agricultural land in the Netherlands. J Environ Qual. 2000;29(1):111–6. Nair VD, Graetz DA. Phosphorus saturation in spodosols impacted by manure. J Environ Qual. 2002;31(4):1279–85. Sims JT, Maguire RO, Leytem AB, Gartley KL, Pautler MC. Evaluation of Mehlich 3 as an agri-environmental soil phosphorus test for the Mid-Atlantic United States of America. Soil Sci Soc Am J. 2002;66(6):2016–32. Breeuwsma A, Reijerink JGA, Schoumans OF. Impact of manure on accumulation and leaching of phosphate in areas of intensive livestock farming. In: Steele K, editor. Animal waste and the land-water interface. Boca Raton: Lewis Publishers; 1995. p. 239–49. Beauchemin S, Simard RR. Soil phosphorus saturation degree: review of some indices and their suitability for P management in Quebec, Canada. Can J Soil Sci. 1999;79(4):615–25. Chang SC, Jackson ML. Fractionation of soil phosphorus. Soil Sci. 1957;84:133–44. Hedley MJ, Stewart JWB, Chauhan BS. Changes in inorganic and organic soil-phosphorus fractionations induced by cultivation practices and by laboratory incubations. Soil Sci Soc Am J. 1982;46(5):970–6. Kuo S. Phosphorus. In: Sparks DL, editor. Methods of soil analysis, part 3, chemical methods. SSSA book series no. 5. Soil science of America. Madison: SSSA; 1996. p. 869–919. Shafqat MN, Pierzynski GM. Long-term effects of tillage and manure applications on soil phosphorus fractions. Commun Soil Sci Plant Anal. 2010;41(9):1084–97. Levy ET, Schlesinger WH. A comparison of fractionation methods for forms of phosphorus in soils. Biogeochemistry. 1999;47(1):25–38. Pierzynski GM, McDowell RW, Sims JT. Chemistry cycling, and potential movement of inorganic phosphorus in soils. In: Sims JT, Sharpley AS, editors. Phosphorus: agriculture and the environment. Monograph No. 46. Madison: Soil Science Society of America; 2005. p. 53–86. Cross AF, Schlesinger WH. A literature review and evaluation of the Hedley fractionation: applications to the biogeochemical cycle of soil phosphorus in natural ecosystems. Geoderma. 1995;64(3–4):197–214. Kizewski F, Liu YT, Morris A, Hesterberg D. Spectroscopic approaches for phosphorus speciation in soils and other environmental systems. J Environ Qual. 2011;40(3):751–66. • Kruse J, Abraham M, Amelung W, Baum C, Bol R, Kuhn O, et al. Innovative methods in soil phosphorus research: a review. J Plant Nutr Soil Sci. 2015;178(1):43–88 This paper provides a detailed review on advanced methods that are currently in use for soil P research. Sharpley AN, McDowell RW, Kleinman PJA. Amounts, forms, and solubility of phosphorus in soils receiving manure. Soil Sci Soc Am J. 2004;68(6):2048–57. Buda AR, Kleinman PJA, Bryant R, Allen A. Impact of legacy phosphorus sources on diffuse pollution from agriculture: lessons from the Chesapeake Bay watershed. In: van Bochove E, et al., editors. Diffuse pollution and eutrophication: 14th international water association conference of the diffuse pollution specialist group. Beaupré, QC, Canada. London: IWA Publ; 2010. p. 63. Motavalli PP, Miles RJ. Soil phosphorus fractions after 111 years of animal manure and fertilizer applications. Biol Fertil Soils. 2002;36(1):35–42. Singh V, Dhillon N, Brar B. Influence of long-term use of fertilizers and farmyard manure on the adsorption-desorption behavior and bioavailability of phosphorus in soils. Nutr Cycl Agroecosyst. 2006;75(1–3):67–78. Jiao Y, Whalen JK, Hendershot WH. Phosphate sorption and release in a sandy-loam soil as influenced by fertilizer sources. Soil Sci Soc Am J. 2007;71(1):118–24. Butler JS, Coale FJ. Phosphorus leaching in manure-amended Atlantic coastal plain soils. J Environ Qual. 2005;34(1):370–81. DeSmet J, Hofman G, Vanderdeelen J, VanMeirvenne M, Baert L. Phosphate enrichment in the sandy loam soils of West-Flanders, Belgium. Fert Res. 1996;43(1–3):209–15. Nair VD, Portier KM, Graetz DA, Walker ML. An environmental threshold for degree of phosphorus saturation in sandy soils. J Environ Qual. 2004;33(1):107–13. Waldrip HM, Pagliari PH, He ZQ, Harmel RD, Cole NA, Zhang MC. Legacy phosphorus in calcareous soils: effects of long-term poultry litter application. Soil Sci Soc Am J. 2015;79(6):1601–14. • Dodd RJ, Sharpley AN. Recognizing the role of soil organic phosphorus in soil fertility and water quality. Resour Conserv Recycl. 2015;105:282–93 This paper provides a detailed review on soil organic P and its role in soil fertility and water quality, which is valuable to fully understand the dynamics of soil P (also legacy P). McCollum RE. Buildup and decline in soil phosphorus: 30-year trends on a Typic Umprabuult. Agron J. 1991;83(1):77–85. •• Fiorellino N, Kratochvil R, Coale F. Long-term agronomic drawdown of soil phosphorus in Mid-Atlantic coastal plain soils. Agron J. 2017;109(2):455–61 This study monitored the long-term drawdown of soil test P on Delmarva with grain or forage cropping, which provides valuable information about how long it will take to drawdown excessive soil test P levels to optimum condition. Penn C, McGrath J, Bowen J, Wilson S. Phosphorus removal structures: a management option for legacy phosphorus. J Soil Water Conserv. 2014;69(2):51A–6A. Shelton JE, Coleman NT. Inorganic phosphorus fractions and their relationship to residual value of large applications of phosphorus on high phosphorus fixing soils. Soil Sci Soc Am Proc. 1968;32(1):91–4. Linquist BA, Singleton PW, Yost RS, Cassman KG. Aggregate size effects on the sorption and release of phosphorus in an Ultisol. Soil Sci Soc Am J. 1997;61(1):160–6. Buda AR, Kleinman PJA, Srinivasan MS, Bryant RB, Feyereisen GW. Effects of hydrology and field management on phosphorus transport in surface runoff. J Environ Qual. 2009;38(6):2273–84. Leader JW, Dunne EJ, Reddy KR. Phosphorus sorbing materials: sorption dynamics and physicochemical characteristics. J Environ Qual. 2008;37(1):174–81. Lyngsie G, Penn CJ, Hansen HCB, Borggaard OK. Phosphate sorption by three potential filter materials as assessed by isothermal titration calorimetry. J Environ Manag. 2014;143:26–33. Penn CJ, Bryant RB, Kleinman PJA, Allen AL. Removing dissolved phosphorus from drainage ditch water with phosphorus sorbing materials. J Soil Water Conserv. 2007;62(4):269–76. Stoner D, Penn C, McGrath J, Warren J. Phosphorus removal with by-products in a flow-through setting. J Environ Qual. 2012;41(3):654–63. Dayton EA, Basta NT. Use of drinking water treatment residuals as a potential best management practice to reduce phosphorus risk index scores. J Environ Qual. 2005;34(6):2112–7. Silveira ML, Miyittah MK, O’Connor GA. Phosphorus release from a manure-impacted spodosol: effects of a water treatment residual. J Environ Qual. 2006;35(2):529–41. Staats KE, Arai Y, Sparks DL. Alum amendment effects on phosphorus release and distribution in poultry litter-amended sandy soils. J Environ Qual. 2004;33(5):1904–11. Stout WL, Sharpley AN, Pionke HB. Reducing soil phosphorus solubility with coal combustion by-products. J Environ Qual. 1998;27(1):111–8. Penn CJ, Bryant RB. Application of phosphorus sorbing materials to streamside cattle loafing areas. J Soil Water Conserv. 2006;61(5):303–10. DeLaune PB, Moore PA, Carman DK, Sharpley AN, Haggard BE, Daniel TC. Development of a phosphorus index for pastures fertilized with poultry litter-factors affecting phosphorus runoff. J Environ Qual. 2004;33(6):2183–91. Penn CJ, Bryant RB, Callahan MP, McGrath JM. Use of industrial by-products to sorb and retain phosphorus. Commun Soil Sci Plant Anal. 2011;42(6):633–44. Penn C, Bowen J, McGrath J, Nairn R, Fox G, Brown G, et al. Evaluation of a universal flow-through model for predicting and designing phosphorus removal structures. Chemosphere. 2016;151:345–55. •• Penn C, Chagas I, Klimeski A, Lyngsie G. A review of phosphorus removal structures: how to assess and compare their performance. Water. 2017;9(8):583. https://doi.org/10.3390/w9080583 This paper compiled over 40 studies on P removal structure and compared their performances, which provides insight in how to evaluate and select P removal structure with different types and sorbing material compositions. Bryant RB, Buda AR, Kleinman PJA, Church CD, Saporito LS, Folmar GJ, et al. Using flue gas desulfurization gypsum to remove dissolved phosphorus from agricultural drainage waters. J Environ Qual. 2012;41(3):664–71. Penn CJ, McGrath JM, Bryant RB. Ditch drainage management for water quality improvement. In: Moore MT, Kroger R, editors. Agricultural drainage ditches: mitigation wetlands for the 21st century. Kerala: Research Signpost; 2010. p. 151–73. Lyngsie G, Borggaard OK, Hansen HCB. A three-step test of phosphate sorption efficiency of potential agricultural drainage filter materials. Water Res. 2014;51:256–65. Penn CJ, McGrath JM. Predicting phosphorus sorption onto steel slag using a flow-through approach with application to a pilot scale system. J Water Resour Prot. 2011;3:235–44. •• Penn CJ, Bowen JM. Reducing phosphorus transport: an overview of best management practices. In: Penn CJ, Bowen JM, editors. Design and construction of phosphorus removal structures for improving water quality. Berlin: Springer; 2017. p. 13–33. This paper provides a detailed review on P removal structure, an innovative best management practice that currently works well to control dissolved P losses from legacy P impacted soils. Guppy CN, Menzies NW, Moody PW, Blamey FPC. Competitive sorption reactions between phosphorus and organic matter in soil: a review. Aust J Soil Res. 2005;43(2):189–202. Haynes RJ, Mokolobate MS. Amelioration of Al toxicity and P deficiency in acid soils by additions of organic residues: a critical review of the phenomenon and the mechanisms involved. Nutr Cycl Agroecosyst. 2001;59(1):47–63. Koski-Vahala J, Hartikainen H, Tallberg P. Phosphorus mobilization from various sediment pools in response to increased pH and silicate concentration. J Environ Qual. 2001;30(2):546–52. Ma JF, Takahashi E. Effect of silicate on phosphate availability for rice in a P-deficient soil. Plant Soil. 1991;133(2):151–5. Owino-Gerroh C, Gascho GJ. Effect of silicon on low pH soil phosphorus sorption and on uptake and growth of maize. Commun Soil Sci Plant Anal. 2005;35(15–16):2369–78. Lee YB, Hoon C, Hwang JY, Lee IB, Kim PJ. Enhancement of phosphate desorption by silicate in soils with salt accumulation. Soil Sci Plant Nutr. 2004;50(4):493–9. Pettit RE. Organic matter, humus, humate, humic acid, fulvic acid and humin: their importance in soil fertility and plant health. 2004; https://static1.squarespace.com/static/55c8cff5e4b0af53827c3795/t/56084ddbe4b0da24d92b6e73/1443384795781/Texas+A%26M+Study.pdf. Accessed 24 Apr 2018. Grant CA, Flaten DN, Tomasiewicz DJ, Sheppard SC. The importance of early season phosphorus nutrition. Can J Plant Sci. 2001;81(2):211–24. •• Tubaña BS, Heckman JR. Silicon in soils and plants. In: Rodrigues FA, Datnoff LE, editors. Silicon and plant diseases. Berlin: Springer; 2015. p. 7–51. This paper provides a detailed review on the use of Si fertilization for crop production, which provides insight in the potential adoption of Si fertilization to address early season P deficiency and accelerate the drawdown of soil test P with crop removal in legacy P impacted agricultural soils. Heckman JR, Johnston S, Cowgill W. Pumpkin yield and disease response to amending soil with silicon. Hortscience. 2003;38(4):552–4. Provance-Bowley MC, Heckman JR, Durner EF. Calcium silicate suppresses powdery mildew and increases yield of field grown wheat. Soil Sci Soc Am J. 2010;74(5):1652–61. Fisher RA. A preliminary note on the effect of sodium silicate in increasing the yield of barley. J Agric Sci. 1929;19:132–9. Eneji AE, Inanaga S, Muranaka S, Li J, Hattori T, An P, et al. Growth and nutrient use in four grasses under drought stress as mediated by silicon fertilizers. J Plant Nutr. 2008;31(2):355–65.