Substantive or symbolic compliance with regulation, audit fees and audit quality
International Journal of Disclosure and Governance - Trang 1-20 - 2023
Tóm tắt
We examine whether Audit Fee Regulation (AFR) enhances auditors’ bargaining power in setting audit fees, consequently leading to superior quality audit services using the Iranian audit environment. We posit two hypotheses of “symbolic” and “substance” compliance. We find that neither audit fees nor audit quality has increased in the post-AFR era, supporting the symbolic hypothesis. The results are robust to several sensitivity tests, including difference-in-difference analysis. Contrary to the regulator’s expectation, our findings suggest that arbitrarily stimulating suppliers’ incentives without considering the priority and importance of demand-side incentives in a compliance-driven audit market and the flexibility to bypass the regulation result in symbolic (de jure) compliance with the regulation. We provide policy, practice, and research implications by suggesting that positive intended consequences of regulations in a compliance-driven audit market can be achieved when the regulation is robust with less latitude for discretion symbolic compliance.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Afsharipour, A. 2009. Corporate governance convergence: lessons from the Indian experience, Northwestern journal of international law and business 29, [Internet document] (Social Science Research Network) [created 29 June 2009], available from SSRN: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1413859.
Amani, A., & Davani, H. 2010. The services, fees and ranking of auditors. Donya-e-Eqtesad, 20 January, 18–19 (In Persian).
Anthony, J.H., and K. Ramesh. 1992. Association between accounting performance measures and stock prices: A test of the life cycle hypothesis. Journal of Accounting and Economics 15: 203–227.
Averhals L., Caneghem T. V., & Willekens M 2020 Mandatory audit fee disclosure and price competition in the private client segment of the Belgian audit market. Journal of International Accounting Auditing and Taxation, 40: 10037
Azami, Z., and T. Salehi. 2017. The relationship between audit report delay and investment opportunities. Eurasian Business Review 7: 437–449.
Bagherpour, M., G. Monroe, and G. Shailer. 2014. Government and managerial influence on auditor switching under partial privatization. Journal of Accounting and Public Policy 33 (4): 372–390.
Ball, R. 2006. International financial reporting standards (IFRS): Pros and cons for investors. Accounting and Business Research 36: 5–27.
Barnes, P., and M.A. Renart. 2013. Auditor independence and auditor bargaining power: Some Spanish evidence concerning audit error in the going concern decision. International Journal of Auditing 17 (3): 265–287.
Barth, M.E., W.R. Landsman, M. Lang, and C. Williams. 2012. Are IFRS-based and USGAAP-based accounting amounts comparable? Journal of Accounting and Economics 54 (1): 68–93.
Bedard, J.C., D. Falsetta, G. Krishnamoorthy, and T.C. Omer. 2010. Voluntary disclosure of auditor-provided tax service fees. The Journal of the American Taxation Association 32 (1): 59–77.
Bianchi, P., N. Carrera, and M. Trombetta. 2019. The Effects of auditor social and human capital on auditor compensation: Evidence from the Italian small audit firm market. European Accounting Review 29 (4): 693–721.
Bierstaker, J.L., and A. Wright. 2001. The effects of fee pressure and partner pressure on audit planning decision. Advances in Accounting 18 (1): 25–46.
Blankley, A.I., D.N. Hurtt, and J.E. MacGregor. 2012. Abnormal audit fees and restatements. Auditing A Journal of Practice & Theory 31 (1): 79–96.
Bozorg Asl, M. 2010. The audit quality and fees. Donya-e-Eqtesad, March 5, p. 17 (in Persian), available at: www.donya-e-eqtesad.com.
Casterella, J.R., J.R. Francis, B.L. Lewis, and P.L. Walker. 2004. Auditor industry specialization client bargaining power and audit pricing. Auditing A Journal of Practice and Theory 23 (1): 123–140.
Chan, K.H., K.Z. Lin, and P.L. Mo. 2006. A political-economic analysis of auditor reporting and auditor switches. Review of Accounting Studies 11: 21–48.
Chaney, P.K., D.C. Jeter, and P.E. Shaw. 2003. The impact on the market for audit services of aggressive competition by auditors. Journal of Accounting and Public Policy 22: 487–516.
Chen, C.J.P., X. Su, and X. Wu. 2007. Market competitiveness and Big 5 pricing: Evidence from China’s binary market. The International Journal of Accounting 42 (1): 1–24.
Cho, M., S.Y. Kwon, and G.V. Krishnan. 2021. Audit fee lowballing: Determinants, recovery, and future audit quality. Journal of Accounting and Public Policy 40 (4): 106787.
Cook, E., and T. Kelley. 1988. Auditor stress and time budgets. CPA Journal 57: 83–86.
Coram, P., J. Ng, and D.R. Woodliff. 2004. The effect of risk of misstatement on the propensity to commit reduced audit quality acts under time budget pressure. Auditing A Journal of Practice & Theory 23 (2): 161–169.
Craswell, A., and J. Francis. 1999. Pricing initial audit engagements: A test of competing theories. The Accounting Review 14 (2): 201–215.
Cunningham, L.M., C. Li, S.E. Stein, and N.S. Wright. 2019. What’s in a name? Initial evidence of U.S. audit partner identification using difference-in-differences analyses. The Accounting Review 94 (5): 139–163.
Danaifar, H., A. Azar, and A. Salehi. 2009. Lawlessness in Iran: explaining the role of political, economic, legal, managerial and socio-cultural factors. Journal of Research Police Science 11 (3): 7–65.
DeAngelo, L.E. 1981. Auditor size and audit quality. Journal of Accounting and Economics 3 (3): 183–199.
Dechow, P., and I. Dichev. 2002. The quality of accruals and earnings: The role of accrual estimation errors. The Accounting Review 77: 35–59.
DeFond, M., and J. Zhang. 2014. A review of archival auditing research. Journal of Accounting and Economics 58 (2–3): 275–326.
DeFond, M.L., T.J. Wong, and S.H. Li. 2000. The impact of improved auditor independence on audit market concentration in China. Journal of Accounting and Economics 28: 269–305.
Ding, Y., H. Zhang, and J. Zhang. 2007. Private vs. state ownership and earnings management: Evidence from Chinese listed companies. Corporate Governance: An International Review 15: 223–238.
Dunn, K., M. Kohlbeck, and B.W. Mayhew. 2011. The impact of the Big 4 consolidation on audit market share equality. Auditing A Journal of Practice 30 (1): 49–73.
Eierle, B., S. Hartlieb, D. Hay, L. Niemi, and H. Ojala. 2021. External environment and the pricing of audit services: A systematic review of archival literature. Auditing A Journal of Practice and Theory, Accepted Manuscript,. https://doi.org/10.2308/AJPT-2019-510.
Elder, R.J., and A. Yebba. 2020. The introduction of state regulation and auditor retendering in school districts: Local audit market structure, audit pricing, and internal controls reporting. Auditing A Journal of Practice & Theory 39 (2): 81–115.
Eshleman, J.D., and B.P. Lawson. 2017. Audit market structure and audit pricing. Accounting Horizons 31 (1): 57–81.
Ettredge, M., E.E. Fuerherm, and C. Li. 2014. Fee pressure and audit quality. Accounting, Organizations and Society 39 (4): 247–263.
Faraji, O., M. Kashanipour, F. MohammadRezaei, K. Ahmed, and N. Vatanparast. 2020. Political connections, political cycles and stock returns: Evidence from Iran. Emerging Markets Review 45: 100766.
Faraji, O., F. MohammadRezaei, H. Yazdifar, K. Ahmed, and Y. Najafi Gadikelaei. 2022. Audit qualification paragraphs and audit report lag: Evidence from Iran. Spanish Journal of Finance and Accounting, Accepted Manuscript,. https://doi.org/10.1080/02102412.2022.2086731.
Ferguson, A., P. Lam, and N. Ma. 2019. Further evidence on mandatory partner rotation and audit pricing: A supply-side perspective. Accounting & Finance 59: 1055–1100.
Field, A. 2013. Discovering Statistics Using IBM SPSS Statistics. Sage.
Francis, J.R. 2004. What do we know about accounting quality? The British Accounting Review 36 (4): 345–368.
Francis, J.R., P.N. Michas, and S.E. Seavey. 2013. Does audit market concentration harm the quality of audited earnings? Evidence from audit markets in 42 countries. Contemporary Accounting Research 30 (1): 325–355.
Ghosh, A., and S. Lustgarten. 2006. Pricing of initial audit engagements by large and small audit firms. Contemporary Accounting Research 23 (2): 333–368.
Gilson, R.J. 2001. Globalizing corporate governance: Convergence in form or function. The American Journal of Comparative Law 49: 329–357.
Golmohammadi Shuraki, M., Pourheidari, O. and Azizkhani, M. 2020. Accounting comparability, financial reporting quality and audit opinions: evidence from Iran. Asian Review of Accounting, ahead-of-print No. ahead-of-print. https://doi.org/10.1108/ARA-06-2020-0087.
Hay, D., and D. Jeter. 2011. The pricing of industry specialization by auditors in New Zealand. Accounting and Business Research 41 (2): 171–195.
Hay, D.C., W.R. Knechel, and N. Wong. 2006. Audit fees: A meta-analysis of the effect of supply and demand attributes. Contemporary Accounting Research 23 (1): 141–191.
Houston, R.W. 1999. The effect of fee pressure and client risk on audit seniors’ time budget decisions. Auditing A Journal of Practice and Theory 18 (2): 70–86.
Hovannisian Far, G. 2010. Forced auditing: Its quality and fees. Donya-e-Eqtesad, February 26, p. 12 (in Persian).
Huang, H., K. Raghunandan, and D. Rama. 2009. Audit fees for initial audit engagements before and after SOX. Auditing A Journal of Practice & Theory 28 (1): 171–190.
Huang, T.-C., H. Chang, and J.-R. Chiou. 2016. Audit market concentration, audit fees, and audit quality: Evidence from China. Auditing A Journal of Practice and Theory 35 (2): 121–145.
Ireland, J.C., and C.S. Lennox. 2002. The large audit firm fee premium: A case of selectivity bias? Journal of Accounting, Auditing and Finance 17 (1): 73–91.
Jain, P.K., and Z. Rezaee. 2006. The Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 and capital-market behavior: Early evidence. Contemporary Accounting Research 23 (3): 629–654.
Jing, Z. 2019. Two essays on auditing in China. PhD Dissertation. The Hong Kong Polytechnic University.
Johnson, L.E., S.P. Davies, and R.J. Freeman. 2002. The effect of seasonal variations in auditor workload on local government audit fees and audit delay. Journal of Accounting and Public Policy 21: 395–422.
Kasai, N., & T. Takada, 2012. How do regulation and deregulation on audit fees influence audit quality?: Empirical Evidence from Japan. Working paper
Kenchel, W.R. 2016. Audit quality and regulation. International Journal of Auditing 20 (3): 215–223.
Khanna, T., J. Kogan, and K. Palepu. 2006. Globalization and similarities in corporate governance: A cross-country analysis. The Review of Economics and Statistics 88: 69–90.
Killough, L., and C. Ho. 1985. The race is on: Has competition changed the accounting profession? The National Public Accountants 30 (12): 20–24.
Kothari, S., A. Leone, and C. Wasley. 2005. Performance matched discretionary accrual measures. Journal of Accounting and Economics 39: 163–197.
Krishnan, G., and J. Zhang. 2019. Do investors perceive a change in audit quality following the rotation of the engagement partner? Journal of Accounting and Public Policy 38 (2): 146–168.
Langli, J.C., and T. Svanström. 2014. Audits of private companies. In The Routledge Companion to Auditing, ed. D. Hay, W.R. Knechel, and M. Willekens. New York: Routledge.
Lennox, C.S. 1999. Non-audit fees, disclosure and audit quality. The European Accounting Review 8: 239–252.
Leuz, C. 2006. Cross listing, bonding and firms’ reporting incentives: A discussion of Lang, Raedy and Wilson. Journal of Accounting and Economics 42 (1): 285–299.
Mali, D., and H. Lim. 2021. Can audit effort (hours) reduce a firm’s cost of capital? Evidence from South Korea. Accounting Forum 45 (2): 171–199.
Moayedi, V., and M. Aminfard. 2012. Iran’s post-war financial system. International Journal of Islamic Middle Eastern Financing and Management 5: 264–281.
MohammadRezaei, F., and O. Faraji. 2019. The dilemma of audit quality measuring in archival studies: Critiques and suggestions for Iran’s research setting. Journal of Accounting and Auditing Review 26 (1): 87–122 ((In Persian)).
MohammadRezaei, F., and N. Mohd-Saleh. 2017. Auditor switching and audit fee discounting: The Iranian experience. Asian Review of Accounting 25 (3): 335–360.
MohammadRezaei, F., N. Mohd-Saleh, and M.J. Ali. 2015. Increased competition in an unfavourable audit market following audit privatisation: The Iranian experience. Asian Journal of Business and Accounting 8 (1): 115–149.
MohammadRezaei, F., N. Mohd-Saleh, R. Jaffar, and M.S. Sabri. 2016. The effects of audit market liberalisation and auditor type on audit opinions: The Iranian experience. International Journal of Auditing 20 (1): 87–100.
MohammadRezaei, F., N. Mohd-Saleh, and K. Ahmed. 2018. Audit firm ranking, audit quality and audit fees: Examining conflicting price discrimination views. The International Journal of Accounting 53 (4): 295–313.
MohammadRezaei, F., O. Faraji, and Z. Heidary. 2021. Audit partner quality, audit opinions and restatements: Evidence from Iran. International Journal of Disclosure and Governance 18 (2): 106–119.
Moore, D., P.E. Tetlock, L. Tanlu, and M. Bazerman. 2006. Conflicts of interest and the case of auditor independence: Moral seduction and strategic issue cycling. Academy of Management Review 31 (1): 10–29.
Niemi, L. 2004. Auditor size and audit pricing: Evidence from small audit firms. European Accounting Review 13 (3): 541–560.
Otley, D.T., and B.J. Pierce. 1996. Auditor time budget pressure: Consequences and antecedents. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal 9 (1): 31–58.
Palmrose, Z. 1986. Audit fees and auditor size: Further evidence. Journal of Accounting Research 24: 405–411.
Petersen, M.A. 2009. Estimating standard errors in finance panel data sets: Comparing approaches. Review of Financial Studies 22 (1): 435–480.
Raghunathan, B. 1991. Premature signing-off of audit procedures: An analysis. Accounting Horizons 5 (2): 71–79.
Rodriguez-Perez, G., and S.V. Hemmen. 2010. Debt, diversification and earnings management. Journal of Accounting and Public Policy 29: 138–159.
Roudaki, J. 2008. Accounting profession and evolution of standard setting in Iran. Journal of Accounting, Business & Management 15: 33–52.
Salehi, M., A. Jafarzadeh, and Z. Nourbakhshhosseiny. 2017. The effect of audit fees pressure on audit quality during the sanctions in Iran. International Journal of Law and Management 59 (1): 66–81.
Simon, D., and J. Francis. 1988. The effects of auditor change on audit fees: Test of price cutting and price recovery. The Accounting Review 63 (2): 255–269.
Simunic, D.A. 2014. The market for audit services. In The Routledge Companion to Auditing, ed. D. Hay, W.R. Knechel, and M. Willekens. New York: Routledge.
Soltes, E. 2014. Incorporating field data into archival research. Journal of Accounting Research 52 (2): 521–540.
Teoh, S.H., I. Welch, and T.J. Wong. 1998. Earnings management and the long run market performance of initial public offerings. Journal of Finance 53: 1935–1974.
Wong, R.M.K., M.A. Firth, and A.W.Y. Lo. 2018. The impact of litigation risk on the association between audit quality and auditor size: Evidence from China. Journal of International Financial Management and Accounting 29 (3): 280–311.
Xie, Z., C. Cai, and J. Ye. 2010. Abnormal audit fees and audit opinion – Further evidence from China’s capital market. China Journal of Accounting Research 3: 51–70.
Yaacob, N.M., and A. Che-Ahmad. 2012. Audit fees after IFRS adoption: Evidence from Malaysia. Eurasian Business Review 2: 31–46.
Zeghal, D., S. Chtourou, and Y.M. Sellami. 2011. An analysis of the effect of mandatory adoption of IAS/IFRS on earnings management. Journal of International Accounting, Auditing and Taxation 20 (1): 61–72.
Zhang, R., R.M.K. Wong, G. Tian, and M.M. Fonseka. 2021. Positive spillover effect and audit quality: A study of cancelling China’s dual audit system. Accounting & Finance. https://doi.org/10.1111/acfi.12563.