Recreational trampling negatively impacts vegetation structure of an Australian biodiversity hotspot
Tóm tắt
Recreational trampling damage of natural vegetation is an increasing problem in the global context and has the potential to impact on vegetation communities that are of high ecological and socio-economic interest. Wildflower tourism in the national parks of southwest Australia, a global biodiversity hotspot, has the potential to damage the flora on which it depends through trampling. Little research has been previously undertaken in these largely shrub-dominated communities to identify and quantify such impacts. This study is the first to do so, using observational studies of tourists, a descriptive study, and trampling experiments. The behaviours of independent tourists and tour groups were observed. Of the 213 independent visitors observed 41 visitors left trails to view flowers and in the process trampled vegetation. Vegetation height and cover were measured at three sites frequented by wildflower tourists. Vegetation height and cover declined in response to use by tourists. Trampling experiments, which relied on trampling treatments of 0, 30, 100, 200, 300/500 passes, where 0 passes represents the control, were applied at four sites. Trampling led to a significant reduction in vegetation height immediately post-treatment, for all treatments, with a non-significant recovery over time. Trampling also significantly reduced vegetation cover, with the resistance indices for these experimental sites ranging from 30 to 300 passes. Collectively these results illustrate the low resilience and resistance of these valued communities and the possible impacts of wildflower and other nature based tourism, through trampling. The paper concludes with suggested management strategies, which strongly emphasise the importance of education for the tourism industry and provide for international comparisons in regard to recreational trampling impacts on biodiverse shrub land communities.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Agafonoff A, Brown R, Thomson-Dans C, Marchant N (1998) Western Australia’s threatened flora. Department of Conservation and Land Management, Perth
Ballantyne M, Pickering CM (2012) Ecotourism as a threatening process for wild orchids. J Ecotour 11(1):34–47
Ballantyne M, Pickering CM (2013) Tourism and recreation: a common threat to IUCN red-listed vascular plants in Europe. Biodivers Conserv 22:3027–3044
Ballantyne M, Gudes O, Pickering CM (2014) Recreational trails are an important cause of fragmentation in endangered urban forests: a case-study from Australia. Landsc Urban Plan 130:112–124
Barrett S, Yates C (2014) Risks to a mountain flora ecosystem with endemic biota in southwestern Australia. Austral Ecol. doi:10.1111/aec.12199
Barros A, Pickering CM (2014) Impacts of experimental trampling by hikers and pack animals on a high-altitude alpine sedge meadow in the Andes. Plant Ecol Divers. doi:10.1080/17550874.2014.893592
Barros A, Gonnet J, Pickering CM (2013) Impacts of informal trails on vegetation and soils in the highest protected area in the Southern Hemisphere. J Environ Manag 127:50–60
Bayfield NG (1979) Recovery of four montane health communities on Cairngorm, Scotland, from disturbance by trampling. Biol Conserv 15:165–179
Beard JS (1990) Plant life of Western Australia. Kangaroo Press, Kenthurst
Bernhardt-Romermann M, Gray A, Vanbergen AJ, Berges L, Bohner A, Brooker RW, De Bruyn L, De Cinti B, Dirnbock T, Grandin U, Hester AJ, Kanka R, Klotz S, Loucougaray G, Lundin L, Matteucci G, Meszaros I, Olah V, Preda E, Prevosto B, Pykala J, Schmidt W, Taylor ME, Vadineanu A, Waldmann T, Stadler J (2011) Functional traits and local environment predict vegetation responses to disturbance: a pan-European multi-site experiment. J Ecol 99:777–787
Boon PI, Fluker M, Wilson N (2008) A ten-year study of the effectiveness of an educational programme in ensuring the ecological sustainability of recreational activities in the Brisbane Range National Park, South-Eastern Australia. J Sustain Tour 16(6):681–697
Buckley R (2005) Recreation ecology research effort: an international comparison. Tour Recreat Res 30:99–101
Buckley R, King K, Zubrinich T (2004) The role of tourism in spreading dieback disease in Australian vegetation. In: Buckley R (ed) The environmental impacts of tourism. CABI Publishing, Wallingford, pp 317–324
Burbidge A, Hopper S, van Leeuwen S (1990) Nature conservation, landscape and recreation values of the Lesueur area. Report to the Environmental Protection Authority from the Department of Conservation and Land Management. Bulletin 424. Environmental Protection Authority, Perth
Burgman MA, Keith DA, Hopper SD, Widyatmoko D, Drill C (2007) Threat syndromes and conservation of the Australian flora. Biol Conserv 134:73–82
CALM (1991) Fitzgerald River National Park management plan 1991–2001. Department of Conservation and Land Management, Perth
CALM (1995) Lesueur National Park and Coomallo Nature Reserve management plan 1995–2005. Department of Conservation and Land Management, Perth
CALM (1999) Stirling Range National Park and Porongurup National Park management plan 1999–2009. Department of Conservation and Land Management, Perth
Cole DN (1985) Recreational trampling effects on six habitat types in western Montana. USDA Forest Service Research Paper INT-350. Intermountain Research Station, Ogden
Cole DN (1987) Research on soil and vegetation in wilderness: a state of knowledge review. National wilderness research conference: issues, state of knowledge, future directions. U. F. Services. Ogden USA. Gen Tech Rep. INT 220:135–177
Cole DN (2004) Impacts of hiking and camping on soils and vegetation: a review. In: Buckley R (ed) Environmental impacts of ecotourism. CABI Publishing, Cambridge, pp 41–60
Cole DN, Bayfield NG (1993) Recreational trampling of vegetation: standard experimental procedures. Biol Conserv 63:209–215
Cole DN, Spildie DR (1998) Hiker, horse and Ilama trampling effects on native vegetation in Montana, USA. J Environ Manag 53:61–71
Cole DN, Hammond TP, McCool SF (1997) Information quantity and communication effectiveness: low-impact messages on wilderness trailside bulletin boards. Leis Sci 19(1):59–72
Cressie N (1993) Statistics for spatial data. Wiley, New York
Dai A (2013) Increasing drought under global warming in observations and models. Nat Clim Chang 3:52–58
Deifs J, Pate J, Bell D (1987) Northern Sandplain Kwongan: community biomass and selected species response to fire. J R Soc West Aust 69:133–138
Denscombe M (1998) The good research guide for small scale-social research problems. Open University Press, Buckingham
Gole C (2006) The southwest Australia ecoregion: jewel of the Australian continent. Southwest Australia Ecoregion Initiative, Perth
Griffin T, Hopkins A (1981) Short-term effects of brush harvesting on the Kwongan vegetation at Eneabba, Western Australia. Report No. 45. Department of Fisheries and Wildlife, Perth
Growcock AJ (2006) Impacts of camping and trampling on Australian alpine and subalpine vegetation and soils. Doctor of Philosophy, School of Environmental and Applied Sciences, Griffith University, Gold Coast
Guo T, Smith JW, Leung YF, Seekamp E, Moore RL (2015) Determinants of responsible hiking behavior: results from a stated choice experiment. Environ Manag. doi:10.1007//s00267-015-0513-1
Hamberg L, Malmivaara-Lamsa M, Lehvavirta S, O’Hara RB, Kotze DJ (2010) Quantifying the effects of trampling and habitat edges on forest understory vegetation—a field experiment. J Environ Manag 91:1811–1820
Hawes M, Dixon G (2014) A methodology for prioritising management tasks for an extensive recreational walking track system. J Outdoor Recreat Tour 5–6:11–16
Hill W, Pickering CM (2006) Vegetation associated with different walking track types in the Kosciuszko alpine area, Australia. J Environ Manag 78:24–34
Hill R, Pickering CM (2009) Differences in resistance of three subtropical vegetation types to experimental trampling. J Environ Manag 90:1305–1312
Hnatiuk R, Hopkins A (1981) An ecological analysis of Kwongan vegetation south of Eneabba, Western Australia. Aust J Ecol 6:423–438
Hopkins A, Keighery G, Marchant N (1983) Species rich uplands of south Western Australia. Proc Ecol Soc Aust 12:15–26
Hopper SD (1979) Biogeographical aspects of speciation in the southwest Australian flora. Annu Rev Ecol Syst 10:399–422
Hopper SD (2009) OCBIL theory: towards an intergrated understanding of the evolution, ecology and conservation of biodiversity on old, climatically buffered, infertile landscapes. Plant Soil 322:49–86
Hopper SD, Gioia P (2004) The Southwest Australian floristic region: evolution and conservation of the global hot spot of biodiversity. Annu Rev Ecol Syst 35:623–650
Jennings G (2010) Tourism research. Wiley, Milton
Kelly CL, Pickering CM, Buckley R (2003) Impacts of tourism on threatened plant taxa and communities in Australia. Ecol Manag Restor 4(1):37–44
Kent M, Coker P (1992) Vegetation description and analysis: a practical approach. Wiley, Chichester
Kim M, Daigle J (2012) Monitoring of vegetation impact due to trampling on Cadillac Mountain Summit using high spatial resolution remote sensing data sets. Environ Manag 50(5):956–968
Kuss FR, Hall CN (1991) Ground flora trampling studies: five years after closure. Environ Manag 15(5):715–727
Laliberte E, Lambers H, Burgess TI, Wright SJ (2014) Phosphorus limitation, soil-borne pathogens and the coexistence of plant species in hyperdiverse forests and shrublands. New Phytol. doi:10.1111/nph.13203
Lambers H, Brundrett M, Raven J, Hopper S (2010) Plant mineral nutrition in ancient landscapes: high plant species diversity on infertile soils is linked to functional diversity for nutritional strategies. Plant Soil 334:11–31
Leung Y, Marion JL (2000) Recreational impacts and management in wilderness: a state of knowledge review. Wilderness Science in a time of change conference, Proceedings RMPS-P15-Vol 5, vol 5: Wilderness visitors, experiences and visitor management. Rocky Mountain Research Station, USDA Forest Service, Missoula
Leung YF, Newburger T, Jones M, Kuhn B, Woiderski B (2011) Developing a monitoring protocol for visitor-created informal trails in Yosemite National Park, USA. Environ Manag 47(1):93–106
Liddle MJ (1975) A theoretical relationship between the primary productivity of vegetation and its ability to tolerate trampling. Biol Conserv 8:251–255
Liddle MJ (1997) Recreation ecology: the ecological impact of outdoor recreation and ecotourism. Chapman & Hill, London
Liddle MJ, Thyer NC (1986) Trampling and fire in a subtropical dry sclerophyll forest. Environ Conserv 13(1):33–39
Littlefair CJ (2004) Reducing impacts through interpretation, Lamington National Park. In: Buckley R (ed) Environmental impacts of ecotourism. CABI Publishing, Wallingford, pp 297–316
Malmivaara-Lamsa M, Hamberg L, Lofstrom I, Vanha-Majamaa I, Niemela J (2008) Trampling tolerance of understorey vegetation in different hemiboreal urban forest site types in Finland. Urban Ecosyst 11:1–16
Marion J, Leung Y (2004) Environmentally sustainable trail management. In: Buckley R (ed) The environmental impacts of ecotourism. CABI Publishing, Wallingford, pp 229–243
Marion J, Leung Y (2011) Indicators and protocols for monitoring impacts of formal and informal trails protected areas. J Tour Leis Stud 17(2):215–236
Marion J, Reid S (2007) Minimising visitor impacts to protected areas: the efficacy of low impact education programmes. J Sustain Tour 15:5–27
Marion J, Wimpey J, Park L (2011) The science of trail surveys: recreation ecology provides new tools for managing wilderness trails. Park Sci 28(3):60–65
McDougall KL, Wright GT (2004) The impact of trampling on feldmark vegetation in Kosciuszko National Park, Australia. Aust J Bot 52:315–320
Mende P, Newsome D (2006) The assessment, monitoring and management of hiking trails: a case study from the Stirling Range National Park, Western Australia. Conserv Sci West Aust 5(3):27–37
Monz CA (2002) The response of two Arctic Tundra plant communities to human trampling disturbance. J Environ Manag 64:207–217
Monz CA, Cole DN, Leung Y, Marion JL (2010a) Sustaining visitor use in protected areas: future opportunities in recreation ecology research based on the USA experience. Environ Manag 45:551–562
Monz CA, Marion JL, Goonan KA, Manning RE, Wimpey J, Carr C (2010b) Assessment and monitoring of recreation impacts and resource conditions on mountain summits: examples from the Northern Forest, USA. Mt Res Dev 30(4):332–343
Monz CA, Pickering CM, Hadwen WL (2013) Recent advances in recreation ecology and the implications of different relationships between recreational use and ecological impacts. Front Ecol Environ 11(8):441–446
Myers N, Mitterneier RA, Mittermeier G, da Fonseca GAB, Kent J (2000) Biodiversity hotspots for conservation priorities. Nature 403:853–858
Newbey KR (1995) A biological survey of Fitzgerald area, Western Australia. Part 4: Vegetation and flora. CALM Sci 3:29–46
Newsome D (2003) The role of an accidentally introduced fungus in degrading the health of the Stirling Range National Park ecosystem in South Western Australia: status and prognosis. In: Rapport DJ, Lasley WL, Rolston DE, Nielsen NO, Qualset CO, Damania AB (eds) Managing for healthy ecosystems. Lewis Publishers, Boca Raton
Newsome D, Milewski A, Phillips N, Annear R (2002) Effects of horse riding on national narks and other natural ecosystems in Australia: implications for management. J Ecotour 1(1):52–74
Newsome D, Moore SA, Dowling RK (2013) Natural area tourism: ecology, impacts and management, 2nd edn. Channel View Publications, Bristol
Paczkowska G, Chapman AR (2000) The Western Australian flora: a descriptive catalogue. Wildflower Society of Western Australia, Nedlands
Park LO, Manning RE, Marion JL, Lawson SR, Jacobi C (2008) Managing visitor impacts in parks: a multi-method study of the effectiveness of alternative management practices. J Park Recreat Adm 26(1):97–121
Parks and Wildlife (2015) Phytophthora dieback. Department of Parks and Wildlife, Western Australia. Accessed 23 Mar 2015. http://www.dpaw.wa.gov.au/management/pests-diseases/phytophthora-dieback
Pate J, Beard J (1984) Kwongan: plant life of the sandplain. University of Western Australia Press, Nedlands, Perth
Phillips N (2000) A field experiment to quantify the environmental impacts of horse riding in the D’Entrecasteaux National Park. Bachelor of Science (Honours), Environmental Science, Murdoch University, Perth
Phillips N, Newsome D (2002) Understanding the impacts of recreation in Australian protected areas: quantifying damage caused by horse riding in D’Entrecasteaux National Park, Western Australia. Pac Conserv Biol 7:256–273
Pickering CM (2010) Ten factors that affect the severity of environmental impact of visitors to protected areas. Ambio 39:70–77
Pickering CM, Growcock AJ (2009) Impacts of experimental trampling on tall alpine herbfields and subalpine grasslands in the Australian Alps. J Environ Manag 91:532–540
Pickering CM, Hill W (2007) Impacts of recreation and tourism on plant biodiversity and vegetation in protected areas in Australia. J Environ Manag 85:791–800
Pickering CM, Hill W, Newsome D, Leung Y (2010) Comparing hiking, mountain biking and horse riding impacts on vegetation and soils in Australia and the United States of America. J Environ Manag 91:551–562
Pickering CM, Rossi S, Barros A (2011) Assessing the impacts of mountain biking and hiking on subalpine grassland in Australia using an experimental protocol. J Environ Manag 92:3049–3057
Pinheiro J, Bates D, DebRoy S, Sarkar D, R Development Core Team (2013) nlme: linear and nonlinear mixed effects models, R package version 3.1-108. R Development Core Team, Vienna
Prescott O, Stewart G (2014) Assessing the impacts of human trampling on vegetation: a systematic review and meta-analysis of experimental evidence. PeerJ 2:e360. doi:10.7717/peerJ360
R Development Core Team (2013) R: a language and environment for statistical computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna. http://www.R-project.org/
Randall M, Newsome D (2008) Assessment, evaluation and a comparison of planned and unplanned walk trails in coastal south-western Australia. Conserv Sci West Aust 7(1):19–34
Roovers P, Verheyen K, Hermy M, Gulinck H (2004) Experimental trampling and vegetation recovery in some forest and healthland communities. Appl Veg Sci 7:111–118
Shearer BL, Crane C, Cochrane A (2004) Quantification of the susceptibility of the native flora of the Southwest Botanical Province, Western Australia, to Phytophthora cinnamomi. Aust J Bot 52:435–443
Sloan S, Jenkins CN, Joppa LN, Gaveau DL, Laurance WF (2014) Remaining natural vegetation in the global biodiversity hotspots. Biol Conserv 177:12–24
Smith A (2014) Personal communication: National Park visitor data. Parks and Visitor Science Coordinator, Department of Parks and Wildlife, Perth
Specht R, Specht A (1999) Australian plant communities: dynamics of structure, growth and biodiversity. Oxford University Press, Melbourne
Stott PA, Gillett NP, Hegerl GC, Karoly DJ, Stone DA, Zhang X, Zwiers F (2010) Detection and attribution of climate change: a regional perspective. Wiley Interdiscip Rev Clim Chang 1:192–211
Sun D, Liddle MJ (1991) Field occurrence, recovery and simulated trampling resistance and recovery of two grasses. Biol Conserv 57(2):187–203
Sun D, Liddle MJ (1993a) Plant morphological characteristics and resistance to simulated trampling. Environ Manag 17(4):511–521
Sun D, Liddle MJ (1993b) A survey of trampling effects on vegetation and soil in eight tropical and subtropical sites. Environ Manag 17(4):497–510
Sun D, Liddle MJ (1993c) Trampling resistance, stem flexibility and leaf strength in nine Australian grasses and herbs. Biol Conserv 65:35–41
Talbot LM, Turton SM, Graham AW (2003) Trampling resistance of Tropical rainforest soils and vegetation in the Wet Tropics North East Australia. J Environ Manag 69:63–69
Thomson C, Hall G, Friend G (1993) Mountains of mystery: a natural history of the Stirling Range. Department of Conservation and Land Management, Perth
Torn A, Tolvanen A, Norokorpi Y, Tervo R, Siikamaki P (2009) Comparing the impacts of hiking, skiing and horse riding on trail and vegetation in different types of forest. J Environ Manag 90:1427–1434
TWA (2005) Tourism Western Australia strategic plan 2005–2010. Tourism Western Australia, Perth
TWA (2011) Wildflower holiday e-guide. Accessed 26 Aug 2014. http://www.tourism.wa.gov.au
TWA, DEC (2010) Review of nature-based tourism. TWA, Perth
Walden-Schreiner C, Leung YF, Newburger T, Woiderski B (2012) Developing an accessible methodology for monitoring visitor use patterns in open landscapes of Yosemite National Park. Park Sci 29(1):53–61
Waltert B, Wiemken V, Rusterholz H, Boller T, Baur B (2002) Disturbance of forest by trampling: effects on mycorrhizal roots of seedlings and mature trees of Fagus sylatica. Plant Soil 243:143–154
Watson M, Iwamura T, Butt N (2013) Mapping vulnerability and conservation adaptation strategies under climate change. Nat Clim Chang 3:989–994
Whinam J, Chilcott N (1999) Impacts of trampling on alpine environments in central Tasmania. J Environ Manag 57:205–220
Whinam J, Chilcott N (2003) Impacts after four years of experimental trampling on alpine/sub-alpine environments in western Tasmania. J Environ Manag 67:339–351
Wimpey J, Marion JL (2011) A spatial exploration of informal trails networks within Great Falls Park, WA. J Environ Manag 92:1012–1022
Yorks TP, West NE, Mueller RJ, Warren SD (1997) Toleration of traffic by vegetation: life form conclusions and summary extracts from a comprehensive data base. Environ Manag 21(1):121–131