Quasilegality and migrant smuggling in Northern Niger
Tóm tắt
Niger’s status as a ‘hub’ for West African migration is now cemented in the imaginaries of interveners and global observers. Even as the number of migrants transiting the country falls sharply from a peak in 2015, the policies and practices on the part of the Nigerien government, its local partners, and international actors, continue to coalesce around irregular migration as a major security priority. This mostly repressive approach to irregular migration has had knock-on effects on livelihoods in Northern Niger, where the bulk of the economy around transiting migration is rooted. While the story of criminalization and securitization in Niger is a well-worn one, there is less attention to some of the ways these processes are incremental, erratic, incomplete, ambiguous, and contested. This article argues that once we consider the voices of market insiders in the smuggling economy alongside those in the security and intervention sector, these narratives point to the fundamentally ambiguous status of the migration economy between the licit and illicit, the legal and the illegal. To capture this ambiguity, the article draws on the concept of quasilegality, which captures the in-between status of the flows in question, and in particular the conceptual space between the licit/illicit and legal/illegal binaries. Quasilegality points to three salient factors in contesting the straightforward narrative of criminalization in Niger: a gap between the social acceptability of smuggling and state legal frameworks, the ambiguity of the state legal framework and its application, as well as market insiders’ own understanding of their activities. The article’s attention to narratives around migration, crime, and (in)security in Niger is at once a means of complicating the smoothness of security and control as well as a broader critique of views of migration in Niger that would see it as a straightforward example of ‘transnational organized crime’ in West Africa.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Bøås M (2020) EU migration management in the Sahel: unintended consequences on the ground in Niger? Third World Quarterly 42(1):52–67
Boyer F, Mounkaila H (2018) Européanisation des politiques migratoires au Sahel. Le Niger dans l’imbroglio sécuritaire. In: Emmanuel Grégoire (ed.), L’État réhabilité en Afrique. Réinventer les politiques publiques à l’ère néolibérale Karthala, pp. 267–285
Boyer F (2019) Sécurité, développement, protection. Le triptyque de l’externalisation des politiques migratoires au Niger. Hérodote 172(1):171–191
Brachet J (2016) Policing the desert: the IOM in Libya beyond war and peace. Antipode 48(2):272–292
Brachet J (2018) Manufacturing smugglers: from irregular to clandestine mobility in the Sahara. Ann Am Acad Political Soc Sci 676(1):16–35
Brachet J, Choplin A, Pliez O (2011) Le Sahara entre espace de circulation et frontière migratoire de l’Europe. Hérodote (3): 163–182
Bredeloup S, Pliez O (2005) Migrations entre les deux rives du Sahara. Autrepart 36(4):3–20
Carrier N, Klantschnig G (2018) Quasilegality: khat, cannabis and Africa’s drug laws. Third World Quarterly 39(2):350–365
Cassanelli LV (1986) Qat: changes in the production and consumption of a quasilegal commodity in northeast Africa. In: Appadurai A (ed) The Social Life of Things: commodities in Cultural Perspective. Cambridge University Press
Dauchy A (2019) EU security enforcement in Niger: Immigration as a Trojan horse?. Conference paper presented at Walls and Wars. Identifying and questioning the military in contemporary border security policies
Düvell F (2011) Paths into irregularity: the legal and political construction of irregular migration. Eur J migration Law 13(3):275–295
Ellis S (2004) Briefing: the Pan-Sahel initiative. Afr Affairs 103(412):459–464
Frowd PM (2020) Producing the ‘transit’ migration state: international security intervention in Niger. Third World Quarterly 41(2):340–358
Grégoire E, Scholze (2012) Identité, imaginaire et tourisme en pays touareg au Niger. Via no. 2 (online)
Gutelius D (2007) Islam in northern Mali and the war on terror. J Contemp Afr Stud 25(1):59–76
IOM (2017) Flow Monitoring Report – Niger – Report # 2017-5 (May 2017). URL: https://dtm.iom.int/reports/niger-—-flow-monitoring-report-may-2017 (Accessed 29 July 2022)
IOM (2018) Population Flow Monitoring – Niger – Overview (January 2018). URL: https://dtm.iom.int/reports/niger-—-flow-monitoring-report-january-2018 (Accessed 29 July 2022)
Kohl I, Gaulier A (2013) Afrod, le business touareg avec la frontière: nouvelles conditions et nouveaux défis.Politique africaine(4):139–159
Larémont RR (2011) Al Qaeda in the islamic Maghreb: Terrorism and counterterrorism in the Sahel. Afr Secur 4(4):242–268
Maher S (2018) Out of West Africa: human smuggling as a social enterprise. The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 676(1):36–56
Mezzadra S (2011) The gaze of autonomy: capitalism, Migration and Social Struggles. In: Squire V (ed) The contested politics of mobility: Borderzones and irregularity. Routledge, Abingdon
Moretti S (2020) Transit Migration in Niger: stemming the Flows of Migrants, but at what cost? Migration and Society 3(1):80–88
Perrin D (2021) La Libye comme Terrain de Reconfiguration Géopolitique des Migrations. Herodote 182(3):93–108
Raineri L (2018) Human smuggling across Niger: state-sponsored protection rackets and contradictory security imperatives. J Mod Afr Stud 56(1):63–86
Richter L (2021) Moral Borderwork: Policies, Policing, and Practices of Migrant Smuggling at the EU-Morocco Border. Geopolitics [advance view]: 1–20
Raineri L (2021) ‘Migrant smuggling and the social organisation of cross-border mobility’ In: Gallien, M. and Weigand, F., 2022. The Routledge Handbook of Smuggling. Taylor & Francis, 313–325
Sanchez G, Natividad N (2017) ‘Reframing migrant smuggling as a form of knowledge: A view from the US-Mexico border’ In: Günay, C. and Witjes, N., 2017. Border Politics. Cham: Springer, 67–83
Scheele J (2012) Smugglers and saints of the Sahara: regional connectivity in the twentieth century. Cambridge University Press
Stambøl EM (2019) The rise of Crimefare Europe: fighting migrant smuggling in West Africa. Eur Foreign Affairs Rev 24(3):287–308
Van Dessel J (2019) International Delegation and Agency in the externalization process of EU Migration and Asylum Policy: the role of the IOM and the UNHCR in Niger. Eur J Migration Law 21(4):435–458
Van Schendel W, Abraham I (eds) (2005) Illicit flows and criminal things: States, borders, and the other side of globalization. Indiana University Press
Watson S (2015) The criminalization of human and humanitarian smuggling. Migration Mobil Displacement 1(1):39–53