Otto Neurath’s Scientific Utopianism Revisited-A Refined Model for Utopias in Thought Experiments
Tóm tắt
Otto Neurath’s empiricist methodology of economics and his contributions to political economy have gained increasing attention in recent years. We connect this research with contemporary debates regarding the epistemological status of thought experiments by reconstructing Neurath’s utopias as linchpins of thought experiments. In our three reconstructed examples of different uses of utopias/dystopias in thought experiments we employ a reformulation of Häggqvist’s model for thought experiments and we argue that: (1) Our reformulation of Häggqvist’s model more adequately complies with many uses of thought experiments, especially with the open-ended discussions of utopias and dystopias in thought experiments. (2) As a strict logical empiricist, Neurath is committed to a strictly empiricist account of thought experiments. John Norton’s empiricist argument view can indeed account for the justifications of empirical beliefs and genuine discoveries targeted by scientific utopianism in three distinct (yet connected) ways, all of which Neurath already contemplated: (2.I) Dealing with utopias and thought experiments on a regular basis increases creativity and inventiveness. (2.II) Particular ways of presenting knowledge facilitate scientific discovery and social progress. (2.III) The use of utopias in thought experiments can prompt conceptual change and allow access to new phenomena. We conclude by highlighting that, even though thought experiments support a positive attitude for exploring new social possibilities, Neurath points out that active decisions are unavoidable. The exploration of alternatives and the awareness of a need for decisions in policy discussion avert a technocratic outlook in social science.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Archard, D. 2017. The Methodology of Applied Philosophy. In A Companion to Applied Philosophy, ed. K. Lippert-Rasmussen, K. Brownlee, and D. Coady, 18–33. Chichester: Wiley Blackwell.
Arnswald, U. 2019. Die Verbindung des Utopismus von Morus über Mach bis zum Wiener Kreis: Ernst Machs ‘Gedankenexperiment als Utopie.’ In Der Wiener Kreis – Aktualität in Wissenschaft, Literatur, Architektur und Kunst, ed. U. Arnswald, F. Stadler, and P. Weibel, 11–31. Wien: LIT-Verlag.
Benacerraf, P. 1973. Mathematical Truth. The Journal of Philosophy 70 (19): 661–679.
Berneri, M.L. 1950/1971. A Journey through Utopia. New York: Schocken.
Bokulich, A., and M. Frappier. 2018. On the Identity of Thought Experiments: Thought Experiments Rethought. In The Routledge Companion to Thought Experiments, ed. M.T. Stuart, Y. Fehige, and J.R. Brown, 545–585. New York: Routledge.
Brendel, E. 2018. The Argument View: Are Thought Experiments Mere Picturesque Arguments? In The Routledge Companion to Thought Experiments, ed. M.T. Stuart, Y. Fehige, and J.R. Brown, 281–292. New York: Routledge.
Brown, J.R. 1992. Why Empiricism Won’t Work. Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association 1992 (2): 271–279.
Brown, J.R., and Y. Fehige 2017. Thought Experiments. In E.N. Zalta (Ed.), The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Summer 2017 Edition). https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/sum2017/entries/thought-experiment/. Accessed 13 September 2019
Brown, J.R. 1991/2011. The Laboratory of the Mind: Thought Experiments in the Natural Sciences. 2nd Edition. New York: Routledge.
Cartwright, N., J. Cat, L. Fleck, and T. Uebel. 1996. Otto Neurath: Philosophy Between Science and Politics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Carrier, M. 2022. What Does Good Science-Based Advice to Politics Look Like? Journal for General Philosophy of Science 53 (1): 5–21.
Cowen, T., and H. Fink. 1985. Inconsistent Equilibrium Constructs: The Evenly Rotating Economy of Mises and Rothbard. The American Economic Review 75 (4): 866–869.
Cunha, I.F. 2015. Utopias and Dystopias as Models of Social Technology. Principia 19 (3): 363–377.
Cunha, I.F. 2018. Constructing Dystopian Experience: A Neurath-Cartwrightian Approach to the Philosophy of Social Technology. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part A 72: 41–48.
Cunha, I.F. 2022. Experimentos de Pensamento na Crise das Ciências Humanas e Sociais: articulando duas ideias de Kuhn e o utopianismo de Neurath. Em Construção, forthcoming. https://doi.org/10.12957/emconstrucao.2022.65663
Davies, D. 2018. Art and Thought Experiments. In The Routledge Companion to Thought Experiments, ed. M.T. Stuart, Y. Fehige, and J.R. Brown, 512–525. New York: Routledge.
Duhem, P. 1906/2007. La théorie physique: son objet, sa structure. Paris: Vrin.
Elgin, C. 2014. Fiction as Thought Experiment. Perspectives on Science 22 (2): 221–241.
French, S., and A. Murphy. 2021. The Value of Surprise in Science. Erkenntnis. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10670-021-00410-z.
Gendler, T.S. 2000. Thought Experiment: On the Powers and Limits of Imaginary Cases. New York: Garland.
Grundmann, T. 2018. Platonism and the A Priori in Thought Experiments. In The Routledge Companion to Thought Experiments, ed. M.T. Stuart, Y. Fehige, and J.R. Brown, 293–308. New York: Routledge.
Häggqvist, S. 2009. A Model for Thought Experiments. Canadian Journal of Philosophy 39 (1): 55–76.
Häggqvist, S. 2019. Thought Experiments, Formalization, and Disagreement. Topoi 38: 801–810.
Hacking, I. 1992. Do Thought Experiments Have a Life of Their Own? Comments on James Brown, Nancy Nersessian and David Gooding. Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association 1992 (2): 302–308.
Hülsmann, J.G. 2000. A Realist Approach to Equilibrium Analysis. The Quarterly Journal of Austrian Economics 3 (4): 3–51.
Huxley, A. 1932/2006. Brave New World. New York: HarperCollins.
Huxley, A. 1958/2006. Brave New World Revisited. New York: HarperCollins.
Islas Mondragón, D. 2020. Experimentos Mentales en Ciencias Naturales. Mérida: UNAM.
Kuhn, T.S. 1964/1977. A Function for Thought Experiments. In The Essential Tension, 240–265. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
Leßmann, O. 2007. A Similar Line of Thought in Neurath and Sen: Interpersonal Comparison. In Otto Neurath’s Economics in Context, ed. E. Nemeth, S. Schmitz, and T. Uebel, 115–130. Wien: Springer.
Linsbichler, A. 2015. Otto Neurath and Ludwig von Mises – The Socialist Calculation Debates and Beyond. In Interactions in the History of Philosophy II, ed. B. Ercan, 311–324. Istanbul: Delta Publishing.
Linsbichler, A. 2021. Rationalities and their Limits: Reconstructing Neurath’s and Mises’s Prerequisites in the Early Socialist Calculation Debates. Research in the History of Economic Thought and Methodology 39B: 95–128.
Linsbichler, A. 2022a. Otto Neurath and Ludwig Mises: Philosophy, Politics, and Economics in Viennese Late Enlightenment. Erasmus Journal for Philosophy and Economics 14 (2): 202–208.
Linsbichler, A. 2022b. Jan Tinbergen and the Rise of Technocracy. In: F. Stadler (Ed.), Wittgenstein and the Vienna Circle. 100 Years After the 'Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus'. Vienna Circle Institute Yearbook 28. Wien: Springer Nature, forthcoming.
Mach, E. 1906/1917. Erkenntnis und Irrtum. Skizzen zur Psychologie der Forschung. Leipzig: Barth.
Mannheim, K. 1929/1936. Ideology and Utopia. Trans. L. Wirth & E. Shils. New York: Harcourt.
Miščević, N. 1992. Mental Models and Thought Experiments. International Studies in the Philosophy of Science 6: 215–226.
Miščević, N. 2018. Thought Experiments in Political Philosophy. In The Routledge Companion to Thought Experiments, ed. M.T. Stuart, Y. Fehige, and J.R. Brown, 153–170. New York: Routledge.
Mises, L. 1949/1998. Human Action: A Treatise on Economics. Auburn: Ludwig von Mises Institute.
Nemeth, E., and F. Stadler, eds. 1996. Encyclopedia and Utopia: The Life and Work of Otto Neurath. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
Nemeth, E. 1999. Auf dem Weg zur Wiedergewinnung eines wissenschaftlichen Gegenstands. In Otto Neurath: Rationalität, Planung, Vielfalt, ed. E. Nemeth and R. Heinrich, 146–166. Wien: R. Oldenbourg Verlag.
Nemeth, E. 2007. ‘Freeing up One’s Point of View’: Neurath’s Machian Heritage Compared with Schumpeter’s. In Otto Neurath’s Economics in Context, ed. E. Nemeth, S. Schmitz, and T. Uebel, 13–36. Wien: Springer.
Nemeth, E. 2013. The Philosophy of the ‘Other Austrian Economics.’ In New Challenges to Philosophy of Science, ed. H. Andersen, D. Dieks, W.J. Gonzalez, T. Uebel, and G. Wheeler, 339–350. Dordrecht: Springer.
Nemeth, E. 2019. Visualizing Relations in Society and Economics: Otto Neurath’s Isotype-Method Against the Background of his Economic Thought. In Neurath Reconsidered: New Sources and Perspectives, ed. J. Cat and A.T. Tuboly, 117–140. Cham: Springer.
Nemeth, E. 1982/1991. Otto Neurath’s Utopias: The Will to Hope. Trans. Thomas Uebel. In Rediscovering the Forgotten Vienna Circle, ed. T. Uebel, 285–292. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
Nersessian, N. 2018. Cognitive Science, Mental Modeling, and Thought Experiments. In The Routledge Companion to Thought Experiments, ed. M.T. Stuart, Y. Fehige, and J.R. Brown, 309–326. New York: Routledge.
Neurath, O. 1922. Vollsozialisierung und gemeinwirtschaftliche Anstalten. Der Kampf 15: 54–60.
Neurath, O. 1939. Modern Man in the Making. London: Secker & Warburg.
Neurath, O. 1996. Visual Education. In Encyclopedia and Utopia: The Life and Work of Otto Neurath, ed. E. Nemeth and F. Stadler, 245–355. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
Neurath, O. 1910/2004. On the Theory of Social Science. In Otto Neurath. Economic Writings: Selections 1904–1945, ed. T. Uebel and R. Cohen, 265–291. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
Neurath, O. 1911/1998. Nationalökonomie und Wertlehre. In Gesammelte ökonomische, soziologische und sozialpolitische Schriften, Band 1, ed. R. Haller and U. Höfer, 470–519. Wien: Hölder-Pichler-Tempsky.
Neurath, O. 1912/1973. The Problem of the Pleasure Maximum. In Empiricism and Sociology, ed. M. Neurath and R. S. Cohen, 113–122. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
Neurath, O. 1913/1983. The Lost Wanderers of Descartes and the Auxiliary Motive. In Otto Neurath. Philosophical Papers 1913–1946, ed. R. Cohen and M. Neurath, 1–12. Dordrecht: D. Reidel.
Neurath, O. 1917/2004. The Conceptual Structure of Economic Theory and its Foundations. In Otto Neurath. Economic Writings: Selections 1904–1945, ed. T. Uebel and R. Cohen, 312–341. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
Neurath, O. 1919/1979. Die Utopie als gesellschaftstechnische Konstruktion. In Wissenschaftliche Weltauffassung, Sozialismus und logischer Empirismus, ed. R. Hegselmann, 235–241. Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp.
Neurath, O. 1920/2004. Total Socialization: of the Two Stages of the Future to Come. In Otto Neurath. Economic Writings: Selections 1904–1945, ed. T. Uebel and R. Cohen, 371–404. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
Neurath, O. 1921/2004. A System of Socialisation. In Otto Neurath. Economic Writings: Selections 1904–1945, ed. T. Uebel and R. Cohen, 345–370. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
Neurath, O. 1925/2004. Economic Plan and Calculation in Kind. In Otto Neurath. Economic Writings: Selections 1904–1945, ed. T. Uebel and R. Cohen, 405–465. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
Neurath, O. 1930/1981. Bürgerlicher Marxismus. In Gesammelte philosophische und methodologische Schriften, Band 1, ed. R. Haller and H. Rutte, 349–356. Wien: Hölder Pichler Tempsky.
Neurath, O. 1931/1983. Sociology in the Framework of Physicalism. In Otto Neurath. Philosophical Papers 1913–1946, ed. R. Cohen and M. Neurath, 58–90. Dordrecht: D. Reidel.
Neurath, O. 1932/1983. Protocol Statements. In Otto Neurath. Philosophical Papers 1913–1946, ed. R. Cohen and M. Neurath, 91–99. Dordrecht: D. Reidel.
Neurath, O. 1935/1987. What is Meant by a Rational Economic Theory?. In Unified Science. The Vienna Circle Monograph Series originally edited by Otto Neurath, now in an English translation, ed. B. McGuiness,67–109. Dordrecht: D. Reidel.
Neurath, O. 1944/1970. Foundations of the Social Sciences. In Foundations of the Unity of Science: Towards an International Encyclopedia of Unified Science, Volume 2, ed. O. Neurath, R. Carnap, and C. Morris, 1–47. Chicago: Chicago University Press.
Neurath, O. 1945/2004. Alternatives to Market Competition. In Otto Neurath. Economic Writings: Selections 1904–1945, ed. T. Uebel and R. Cohen, 546–548. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
Norton, J. 1996. Are Thought Experiments Just What you Thought? Canadian Journal of Philosophy 26 (3): 333–366.
Norton, J. 2004a. Why Thought Experiments Do Not Transcend Empiricism. In Contemporary Debates in the Philosophy of Science, ed. C. Hitchcock, 44–66. Oxford: Blackwell.
Norton, J. 2004b. On Thought Experiments: Is There More to the Argument? Philosophy of Science 71: 1139–1151.
Norton, J. 2021. The Material Theory of Induction. Calgary: University of Calgary Press.
O’Neill, J. 2007. Markets, Deliberation and Environment. Oxon: Routledge.
Stadler, F., and O. Neurath. 2021. Otto Neurath und H.G. Wells. 20 Bildstatistiken von Otto Neurath in H.G. Wells, ‘Arbeit, Wohlstand und das Glück der Menschheit’ (1932). In Otto Neurath liest Stefan Zweigs ‘Die Welt von Gestern’, ed. A. Larcati and F. Stadler, 221–244. Wien: LIT.
Stuart, M.T. 2016. Norton and the Logic of Thought Experiments. Axiomathes 26: 451–466.
Tokumaru, N. 2016. Social Preference, Institution, and Distribution: An Experimental and Philosophical Approach. Singapore: Springer.
Uebel, T. 2008. Calculation in Kind and Marketless Socialism: On Otto Neurath’s Utopian Economics. European Journal of the History of Economic Thought 15 (3): 475–501.
Vieira, F. 2010. The Concept of Utopia. In The Cambridge Companion to Utopian Literature, ed. G. Claeys, 3–27. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Williamson, T. 2007. The Philosophy of Philosophy. Oxford: Blackwell.