Optimization of Wastewater Anaerobic Digestion Using Mechanistic and Meta-heuristic Methods: Current Limitations and Future Opportunities

Escudié R, Cresson R, Delgenès JP, Bernet N (2011) Control of start-up and operation of anaerobic biofilm reactors: an overview of 15 years of research. Water Res 45:1–10

Chen Y, Cheng JJ, Creamer KS (2008) Inhibition of anaerobic digestion process: a review. Bioresour Technol 99:4044–4064

Chin MJ, Poh PE, Tey BT, Chan ES, Chin KL (2013) Biogas from palm oil mill effluent (POME): opportunities and challenges from Malaysia’s perspective. Renew Sust Energ Rev 26:717–726

Seghezzo L, Zeeman G, van Lier JB, Hamelers HVM, Lettinga G (1998) A review: the anaerobic treatment of sewage in UASB and EGSB reactors. Bioresour Technol 65:175–190

Flores-Estrella R, Quiroz G, Mendez-Acosta HO, Femat RH (2013) Control of anaerobic digester for winery industry wastewater treatment. Ind Eng Chem Res 52:2625–2632

Jensen JK, Jensen AB (2000) Biogas and natural gas fuel mixture for the future. 1st World Conference and Exhibition on Biomass for Energy and Industry, Sevilla, Spain

Batstone DJ, Puyol D, Flores-Alsina X, Rodriguez J (2015) Mathematical modelling of anaerobic digestion processes: applications and future needs. Rev Environ Sci Biotechnol 14(4):595–613

Donoso-Bravo A, Mailier J, Martin C, Rodriguez J, Aceves-Lara CA, Wouwer AV (2011) Model selection, identification and validation in anaerobic digestion: a review. Water Res 45:5347–5364

Kythreotou N, Florides G, Tassou SA (2014) A review of simple to scientific models for anaerobic digestion. Renew Energy 71:701–714

Gerardi MH (2003) The microbiology of anaerobic digesters. Wiley-Interscience, New Jersey 51–57

Gerardi MH (2006) Wastewater bacteria. Wiley-Interscience, New Jersey 19–31

Poh PE, Chong MF (2009) Development of anaerobic digestion methods for palm oil mill effluent (POME) treatment. Bioresour Technol 100:1–9

van Haandel A, Kato MT, Cavalcanti PFF, Florencio L (2006) Anaerobic reactor design concepts for the treatment of domestic wastewater. Rev Environ Sci Biotechnol 5:21–38

Lettinga G et al (1984) High-rate anaerobic waste-water treatment using the UASB reactor under a wide range of temperature conditions. Biotechnol Genet Eng Rev 2:253–283

Kim W, Cho K, Lee S, Hwang S (2013) Comparison of methanogenic community structure and anaerobic process performance treating swine wastewater between pilot and optimized lab scale bioreactors. Bioresour Technol 145:48–56

Tong SL, Jaafar AB (2006) POME biogas capture, upgrading and utilization. Palm Oil Eng Bull 78:11–17

Ugoji EO (1997) Anaerobic digestion of palm oil mill effluent and its utilization as fertilizer for environmental protection. Renew Energy 10:291–294

Halalsheh M et al (2005) Effect of SRT and temperature on biological conversions and the related scum-forming potential. Water Res 39:2475–2482

Kalyuzhnyi SV et al (1996) Organic removal and microbiological features of UASB-reactor under various organic loading rates. Bioresour Technol 55:47–54

Lettinga G (1995) Anaerobic digestion and wastewater treatment systems. Antonie Van Leeuwenhoek 67:3–28

Giraldo-Gomez E and Duque M (1998) Automatic start-up of a high rate anaerobic reactor using a fuzzy logic control system. Fifth Latin American Workshop-Seminar Wastewater Anaerobic Treatment, 27th–30th, Vina del Mar, Chile

Ji JY, Xing YJ, Ma ZT, Zhang M, Zheng P (2013) Acute toxicity of pharmaceutical wastewaters containing antibiotics to anaerobic digestion treatment. Chemosphere 91:1094–1098

Sampaio MA, Gonçalves MF, Marques IP (2011) Anaerobic digestion challenge of raw olive mill wastewater. Bioresour Technol 102:10810–10818

Wang W, Ma W, Han H, Li H, Yuan M (2011) Thermophilic anaerobic digestion of Lurgi coal gasification wastewater in a UASB reactor. Bioresour Technol 102:2441–2447

Cao W, Mehrvar M (2011) Slaughterhouse wastewater treatment by combined anaerobic baffled reactor and UV/H2O2 processes. Chem Eng Res Des 89(7):1136–1143

Rajakumar R, Meenambal T, Rajesh Banu J, Yeom LT (2011) Treatment of poultry slaughterhouse wastewater in upflow anaerobic filter under low upflow velocity. Int J Environ Sci Technol 8(1):149–158

Mittal GS (2004) Characterization of the effluent wastewater from abattoirs for land application. Food Rev Int 20(3):229–256

Caldera Y, Madueno P, Griborio A, Fernandez N, Gutierrez E (2005) Effect of the organic load in the performance of the UASB reactor treating slaughterhouse effluent. Revista Tecnica de la Facultad de Ingenieria Universidad del Zulia 28(2):119–127

Lopez RJ, Higgins SR, Pagaling E, Yan T, Cooney MJ (2014) High rate anaerobic digestion of wastewater separated from grease trap waste. Renew Energy 62:234–242

Sànchez E, Borja R, Tavieso L, Martín A, Colmenarejo MF (2005) Effect of organic loading rate on the stability, operational parameters and performance of a secondary upflow anaerobic sludge bed reactor treating piggery waste. Bioresour Technol 96:335–344

Sreekanth D, Sivaramakrishna D, Himabindu V, Anjaneyulu Y (2009) Thermophilic treatment of bulk drug pharmaceutical industrial wastewaters by using hybrid up flow anaerobic sludge blanket reactor. Bioresour Technol 100:2534–2539

Alvarado-Lassman A et al (2008) Brewery wastewater treatment using anaerobic inverse fluidized bed reactors. Bioresour Technol 99:3009–3015

Raposo F, Borja R, Sanchez E, Martin MA, Martin A (2004) Performance and kinetic evaluation of the anaerobic digestion of two-phase olive mill effluents in reactors with suspended and immobilized biomass. Water Res 38(8):2017–2026

Poh PE, Chong MF (2014) Upflow anaerobic sludge blanket-hollow centered packed bed (UASB-HCPB) reactor for thermophilic palm oil mill effluent (POME) treatment. Biomass Bioenergy 67:231–242

Najafpour GD, Zinatizadeh AAL, Mohamed AL, Hasnain Isa M, Nasrollahzadeh H (2006) High-rate anaerobic digestion of palm oil mill effluent in an upflow anaerobic sludge-fixed film bioreactor. Process Biochem 41:370–379

Fang C, O-Thong S, Boe K, Angelidaki I (2011) Comparison of UASB and EGSB reactors performance, for treatment of raw and deoiled palm oil mill effluent (POME). J Hazard Mater 189:229–234

Long JH, Aziz TN, de los Reyes FL III, Ducoste JJ (2012) Anaerobic co-digestion of fat, oil, and grease (FOG): a review of gas production and process limitations. Process Saf Environ Prot 90:231–245

Ke S, Shi Z, Fang HHP (2005) Application of two-phase anaerobic degradation in industrial wastewater treatment. Int J Environ Pollut 23:65–80

Kim JK, Oh BR, Chun YN, Kim SW (2006) Effects of temperature and hydraulic retention time on anaerobic digestion of food waste. J Biosci Bioeng 102:328–332

Yilmaz T, Yuceer A, Basibuyuk M (2008) A comparison of the performance of mesophilic and thermophilic anaerobic filters treating papermill wastewater. Bioresour Technol 99:156–163

Yu HQ, Fang HHP, Gu GW (2002) Comparative performance of mesophilic and thermophilic acidogenic upflow reactors. Process Biochem 38:447–454

Muller A, Marsili-Libelli S, Aivasidis A, Lloyd T, Kroner S, Wandrey C (1997) Fuzzy control of disturbances in a wastewater treatment plant. Water Res 31(12):3157–3167

Lau I, Fang H (1997) Effect of temperature shock to thermophilic granules. Water Res 31:2626–2632

Parawira W, Murto M, Zvauya R, Mattiasson B (2006) Comparative performance of a UASB reactor and an anaerobic packed-bed reactor when treating potato waste leachate. Renew Energy 31:893–903

Altas L (2009) Inhibitory effect of heavy metals on methane-producing anaerobic granular sludge. J Hazard Mater 162:1551–1556

Leighton IR, Forster CF (1998) The effect of heavy metals on a thermophilic methanogenic upflow sludge blanket reactor. Bioresour Technol 63:131–137

Lin CY, Chen CC (1999) Effect of heavy metals on the methanogenic UASB granule. Water Res 33(2):409–416

Chen JL, Ortiz R, Steele TWJ, Stuckey DC (2014) Toxicants inhibiting anaerobic digestion: a review. Biotechnol Adv 32:1523–1534

Patel H, Madamwar D (2002) Effects of temperatures and organic loading rates on biomethanation of acidic petrochemical wastewater using an anaerobic upflow fixed-film reactor. Bioresour Technol 82:65–71

Bailey J, Ollis D (1986) On-line estimation of microbial specific growth rates. Automatica 22:705–709

Pavlostathis SG, Gosset JM (1986) A kinetic model for anaerobic digestion of biological sludge. Biotechnol Bioeng 28:1519–1530

Denac M, Miguel A, Dunn I (1988) Modelling dynamic experiments on the anaerobic degradation of the molasses wastewater. Biotechnol Bioeng 31:1–10

Bernard O, Polit M, Hadj-Sadok Z, Pengov M, Dochain D, Estaben M, Labat P (2001) Advanced monitoring and control of anaerobic wastewater treatment plants. Water Sci Technol 43(7):175–182

Batstone DJ, et al. (2002) Anaerobic Digestion Model No. 1 (ADM1). Report No. 13. London: IWA Publishing

Bastin G and Dochain D (1990) On-line estimation and adaptive control of bioreactors. Elsevier

Alcaraz-Gonzalez V et al (2005) Robust interval-based regulation for anaerobic digestion processes. Water Sci Technol 52(1–2):449–456

Dimitrova N, Krastanov M (2011) Nonlinear adaptive stabilizing control of an anaerobic digestion model with unknown kinetics. Int J Robust Nonlinear Control 22(15):1743–1752

Mendez-Acosta HO, Steyer JP, Femat R, Gonzalez-Alvarez V (2007) Robust nonlinear control of a pilot scale anaerobic digester. Lecture Notes Control Inform Sci 361:165–199

Rincon A, Angulo F, Olivar G (2009) Control of an anaerobic digester through normal form of fold bifurcation. J Process Control 19:1355–1367

Rincon A, Erazo C, Angulo F (2012) A robust adaptive controller for an anaerobic digester with saturated input: guarantees for the boundedness and convergence properties. J Process Control 22:1785–1792

Mendez-Acosta HO, Palacios-Ruiz B, Alcaraz-Gonzalez V, Gonzalez-Alvarez V, Garcia-Sandoval JP (2010) A robust control scheme to improve the stability of anaerobic digestion processes. J Process Control 20:375–383

Ward AJ, Hobbs PJ, Holliman PJ, Jones DL (2008) Optimisation of the anaerobic digestion of agricultural resources. Bioresour Technol 99:7928–7940

Batstone DJ, Styer JP (2007) Use of modeling to evaluate best control practice for winery-type wastewasters. Water Sci Technol 56:147–152

Mu SJ, Zeng Y, Tartakovsky B, Wu P (2007) Simulation and control of an upflow anaerobic sludge blanket (UASB) reactor using an ADM1-based distributed parameter model. Ind Eng Chem Res 46:1519–1526

Garcia C, Molina F, Roca E, Lema JM (2007) Fuzzy-based control of an anaerobic reactor treating wastewaters containing ethanol and carbohydrates. Ind Eng Chem Res 46:6707–6715

Gauthier JP, Kupka I (1994) Observability and observers for nonlinear systems. SIAM J Control Opt 34(4):975–994

Lauwers J et al (2013) Mathematical modeling of anaerobic digestion of biomass and waste: power and limitations. Prog Energy Combust Sci 39:383–402

García-Diéguez C, Bernard O, Roca E (2013) Reducing the Anaerobic Digestion Model No. 1 for its application to an industrial wastewater treatment plant treating winery effluent wastewater. Bioresour Technol 132:244–253

Garcia-Dieguez C, Molina F, Roca E (2011) Multi-objective cascade controller for an anaerobic digester. Process Biochem 46:900–909

Batstone DJ, Keller J (2003) Industrial applications of the IWA anaerobic digestion model no. 1 (ADM1). Water Sci Technol 47:199–206

Mairet F, Bernard O, Ras M, Lardon L, Steyer JP (2011) Modeling anaerobic digestion of microalgae using ADM1. Bioresour Technol 102:6823–6829

Paredes C, Cegarra J, Roig A, Sánchez-Monedero MA, Bernal MP (1999) Characterization of olive mill wastewater (alpechin) and its sludge for agricultural purposes. Bioresour Technol 67:111–115

Poh PE, Yong WJ, Chong MF (2010) Palm Oil Mill Effluent (POME) characteristic and the applicability of anaerobic systems for the treatment of POME. Ind Eng Chem Res 49:11732–11740

Punal A, Roca E, Lema JM (2002) An expert system for monitoring and diagnosis of anaerobic wastewater treatment plants. Water Res 36:2656–2666

Karakuzu C, Turker M, Ozturk S (2006) Modelling, on-line state estimation and fuzzy control of production scale fed-batch baker’s yeast fermentation. Control Eng Pract 14:959–974

Montiel-Escobar JL, Alcaraz-Gonzalez V, Mendez-Acosta HO, Gonzalez-Alvarez V (2012) ADM1-based robust interval observer for anaerobic digestion processes. Clean Soil Air Water 40(9):933–940

Boscolo A, Mangiavacchi C, Drius F, Rongione F, Pavan P, Cecchi F (1993) Fuzzy control of an anaerobic digester for the treatment of the organic fraction of municipal solid waste (MSW). Water Sci Technol 27(2):57–68

Mingzhi H, Ma Y, Jinquan W, Yan W (2009) Simulation of a paper mill wastewater treatment using a fuzzy neural network. Exp Syst Appl 36:5064–5070

Steyer J, Bernard O, Batstone D, Angelidaki I (2006) Lessons learnt from 15 years of ICA in anaerobic digesters. Water Sci Technol 53(4):25–33

Turkdogan-Aydinol FI, Yetilmezsoy K (2010) A fuzzy-logic-based model to predict biogas and methane production rates in a pilot-scale mesophilic UASB reactor treating molasses wastewater. J Hazard Mater 182:460–471

Varne AL, Macwan J (2012) Fuzzy rule based approach for modelling biogas production rate in a real scale UASB reactor treating distillery wastewater. J Environ Res Dev 6(3):788–800

Trelea IC (2003) The particle swarm optimization algorithm: convergence analysis and parameter selection. Inf Process Lett 85:317–325

Ruiz I, Veiga MC, de Santiago P, Blázquez R (1997) Treatment of slaughterhouse wastewater in a UASB reactor and an anaerobic filter. Bioresour Technol 60:251–258

Cai ZX (1997) Intelligent control: principles, techniques and applications. Series in Intelligent Control and Intelligent Automation: Volume 7:182–238

Wen CH, Vassiliadis CA (1998) Applying hybrid artificial intelligence techniques in wastewater treatment. Eng Appl Artif Intell 11(6):685–705

Holubar P, Zani L, Hager M, Froschl W, Radak Z, Braun R (2002) Advanced controlling of anaerobic digestion by means of hierarchical neural networks. Water Res 36:2582–2588

Rangasamy P, Iyer PVR, Ganesan S (2007) Anaerobic tapered fluidized bed reactor for starch wastewater treatment and modelling using multilayer perceptron neural network. J Environ Sci 19:1416–1423

Abbas N, Nasser Y, Ahmad KE (2015) Recent advances on artificial intelligence and learning techniques in cognitive radio networks. EURASIP J Wirel Commun Netw 174

Bai Q (2010) Analysis of particle swarm optimization algorithm. Comput Inform Sci 3(1)

Nguyen D, Gadhamshetty V, Nitayavardhana S, Khanal SK (2015) Automatic process control in anaerobic digestion technology: a critical review. Bioresour Technol 193:513–522

Juang CF (2004) A hybrid of genetic algorithm and particle swarm optimization for recurrent network design. IEEE Trans Syst Man Cybernet 34 (2)

Zhang Q, Li C, Liu Y, Kang L (2007) Fast multi-swarm optimization with Cauchy mutation and crossover operation. In: Advances in computation and intelligence. Springer: 344 – 352.

Manshad AK, Rostami H, Rezaei H and Hosseini SM (2015) Application of artificial neural network-particle swarm optimization algorithm for prediction of asphaltene precipitation during gas injection process and comparison with Gaussian process algorithm. J Energy Resour Technol 137

Smith SA (2009) Critical evaluation of the sugar degradation pathways of Anaerobic Digestion Model No. 1. Ph.D. thesis, Washington State University

Kruse R (2008) Fuzzy neural network. Scholarpedia 3 (11)

Vieira JAB, Dias FM, Mota AM (2004) Artificial neural networks and neuro-fuzzy systems for modelling and controlling real systems: a comparative study. Eng Appl Artif Intell 17(3):265–273

Tay J, Zhang X (2000) A fast predicting neural fuzzy model for high-rate anaerobic wastewater treatment systems. Water Res 34(11):2849–2860

Abu Qdais H, Bani Hani K, Shatnawi N (2010) Modelling and optimization of biogas production from a waste digester using artificial neural network and genetic algorithm. Resour Conserv Recycl 54:359–363

Rajagopal V, Radha V (2013) Selection of optimum features using PSO-SPG2 for predicting COD effluent level in wastewater. Int J Eng Technol 5:3318–3327

Heinzle E, Dunn IJ, Ryhiner GH (1993) Modeling and control of anaerobic wastewater treatment. Adv Biochem Eng Biotechnol 48:79–114

Monroy O, Ramirez J, Cuervo F, Ricardo F (1996) An adaptive strategy to control anaerobic digesters for wastewater treatment. Ind Eng Chem Res 35:3442–3446

Hilgert N, Harmand J, Steyer J, Vila P (2000) Nonparametric identification and adaptive control of an anaerobic fluidized bed digester. Control Eng Pract 8(4):367–376

Alcaraz-Gonzalez V, et al. (2000) Robust interval-based SISO and SIMO regulation for a class of highly uncertain bioreactors: application to the anaerobic digestion. Proceedings of the 39th IEEE Conference on Decision and Control 2000 (Vol. 5): 4532–4537

Alcaraz-Gonzalez V, et al. (2001) Robust interval-based siso regulation under maximum uncertainty conditions in an anaerobic digester. Proceedings of the 2001 I.E. International Symposium on Intelligent Control 2001: 240–245

Antonelli R, Harmand J, Steyer JP, Astolfi A (2003) Set-point regulation of an anaerobic digestion process with bounded output feedback. IEEE Trans Control Syst 11(4):495–504

Seok J (2003) Hybrid adaptive optimal control of anaerobic fluidized bed bioreactor for the de-icing waste treatment. JBiotechnol 102:165–175

Mailleret L, Bernard O, Steyer JP (2004) Nonlinear adaptive control for bioreactors with unknown kinetics. Automatica 40:1379–1385

Garcia-Sandoval JP, Gonzalez-Alvarez V, Castillo-Toledo B, Pelayo-Ortiz C (2008) Robust discrete control of nonlinear processes: application to chemical reactors. Comput Chem Eng 32:3246–3253

Mendez-Acosta HO, Garcia-Sandoval JP, Gonzalez-Alvarez V, Alcaraz-Gonzalez V, Jauregui-Jauregui JA (2011) Regulation of the organic pollution level in anaerobic digesters by using off-line COD measurements. Bioresour Technol 102:7666–7672

Petre E, Selisteanu D (2013) Adaptive and robust-adaptive control schemes for an anaerobic bioprocess with biogas production. 17th International Conference on System Theory, Control and Computing (ICSTCC), Sinaia 404–409

Harmand J, Manh AG, Steyer JP (2000) Identification and disturbance accommodating control of a fluidized bed anaerobic digester. Bioprocess Eng 23:177–185

Alvarez-Ramirez J, Meraz M, Monroy O, Velasco A (2002) Feedback control design for an anaerobic digestion process. J Chem Technol Biotechnol 77:725–734

Mendez-Acosta HO et al (2008) Robust control of volatile fatty acids in anaerobic digestion processes. Ind Eng Chem Res 47(20):7715–7720

Polit M, Estaben M, Labat P (2002) A fuzzy model for an anaerobic digester, comparison with experimental results. Eng Appl Artif Intell 15(5):385–390

Punal A, Rodriguez J, Franco A, Carrasco EF, Roca E, Lema JM (2003) Advanced monitoring and control of anaerobic wastewater treatment plants: diagnosis and supervision by a fuzzy-based expert system. Water Sci Technol 43(7):191–198

Yordanova ST (2004) Fuzzy two-level control for anaerobic wastewater treatment. Proc. 2nd IEEE International Conference on Intelligent Systems: 348–352

Mendez-Acosta HO, Campos-Delgado DU, Femat R, Gonzalez-Alvarez V (2005) A robust feedforward/feedback control for an anaerobic digester. Comput Chem Eng 29:1613–1623

Bastin G, Van Impe JF (1995) Nonlinear and adaptive control in biotechnology: a tutorial. Eur J Control 1(37):37–53

Renard P, Dochain D, Bastin G, Naveau H, Nyns EJ (1986) Adaptive control of anaerobic digestion processes: a pilot-scale approach. Biotechnol Bioeng 31:287–294

Theilliol D, Ponsart JC, Harmand J, Join C, Pascal G (2003) On-line estimation of unmeasured inputs for anaerobic wastewater treatment process. Control Eng Pract 11:1007–1019

Steyer J, Buffiere P, Rolland D, Moletta R (1999) Advanced control of anaerobic digestion processes through disturbances monitoring. Water Res 33(9):2059–2068

Gaida D, et al. (2011) Optimal control of biogas plants using nonlinear model predictive control. Irish Signals and Systems Conference 2011

Boger Z (1997) Experience in industrial plant model development using large-scale artificial neural networks. Inf Sci 101(3–4):203–216

Lindberg CF (1997) Control and estimation strategies applied to the activated sludge process. PhD thesis, Uppsala University, Finland

Alrawi RA, Ahmad A, Ismail NA, Kadir MO (2011) Anaerobic co-digestion of palm oil mill effluent with rumen fluid as co-substrate. Desalination 269:50–57

Demirer GN, Chen S (2005) Two-phased anaerobic digestion of unscreened dairy manure. Process Biochem 40:3542–3549