Operations as marketing: A competitive service strategy

Journal of Operations Management - Tập 10 - Trang 303-328 - 1991
Aleda V. Roth1
1Duke University, Durham, NC 27706, USA

Tóm tắt

AbstractThis paper presents a competitive service strategy paradigm which explicitly considers the strategic role of operations as a competitive weapon. This service strategy paradigm draws upon the prevailing manufacturing strategy literature in its definition of strategic operations choices and critical success factors. We show that to make a service delivery system a potential marketing tool, critical success factor criteria must be based upon the explicit service task or mission which coincides with a service operations strategy. We illustrate how critical success factors are the linchpin between operations and marketing in service organizations.Assessing critical success factors is the first step of a process which determines the strategic role that operations can play in a service firm. Using a sample of 117 retail banks, our paper explores industry critical success factors along two dimensions, one is market‐oriented and the other is competitor‐oriented. We derive a framework, which we label the Customer/Account Base (CAB) matrix, to serve as a decision‐aiding tool to evaluate the relative competitive positioning of a service firm. Our analyses show that quadrants on the CAB matrix coincide with four stages of capability development, similar to those found in manufacturing by Hayes and Wheelwright (1984), reflecting the strategic role a service delivery system design plays in meeting the competition.We go on to empirically link the competitive priorities of retail banks with operations strategy contents of structure, infrastructure and integration choices. Using our service strategy paradigm, we empirically show that the pattern of operations choices varies by competitive priority. As anticipated, the pattern of operations choices linked to relationship banking, one of the most difficult capabilities to achieve and one that requires a high degree of customer contact, is characterized by the most holistic and integrative operations strategy. In conclusion, our exploratory findings illustrate how the prevailing manufacturing strategy framework can be adopted in service strategy delivery system design and the moderating role that customer contact exerts in service strategy formation.

Tài liệu tham khảo

Adam E.E., 1981, Productivity and Quality, Measurement As a Basis for Improvement 10.1177/014920638901500204 Adler R., 1984, Harvard Business School Working Paper Series Albrecht K., 1988, What Every Customer Wants, Laventhol and Horwath, 13 Albrecht K., 1988, At America's Service This Bank Believes Quality Pays.ABA Banking JournalOctober1987;18. C.A.Amatos.Banks Focus on Service to Gain Competitive Edge.Columbus DispatchJune 19 1988;2. Eurobanks Head for One Market.American BankerMarch 17 1988. New Guarantee Programs Hone Better Financial Service Image.American BankerSeptember 8 1987;6. Service Earns ‘Good’ Consumer Rating.American BankerSeptember 29 1987. Action Center Smoothes Ruffled Customer Feathers.American Banker's Association JournalAugust1984;83. Action Center Smoothes Ruffled Customer Feathers.American Banker's Association JournalAugust1984;87. J.C.Anderson G.Cleveland R.G.Schroeder.Operations Strategy: A Literature Review.Journal of Operations Management1989. Bateson J.E.G., 1985, Self‐Service Consumer: An Exploratory Study, Journal of Retailing, 61 Berry L.L., 1981, The Employee As Customer, Journal of Retail Banking, 3, 33 Bowen D.E., 1990, Service Management Effectiveness: Balancing Strategy, Organization and Human Resources, Operations and Marketing Carlzon J., 1987, Moments of Truth R.B.Chase.Where Does the Customer Fit in a Service Operation?.Harvard Business ReviewNovember–December1978;137–142. 10.1287/opre.29.4.698 R.B.Chase D.Garvin.Service Factory.Harvard Business Review1989. R.B.Chase R.H.Hayes.Beefing Up Operations in Service Firms.Sloan Management ReviewFall1991;15–26. 10.1111/j.1540-5915.1984.tb01241.x R.Chase D.A.Tansik.The Customer Contact Model for Organization Design.Management ScienceSeptember1983. Collier D.A., 1987, Service Management—Operating Decisions Collier D.A., 1990, Service Management Effectiveness: Balancing Strategy, Organization and Human Resources, Operations and Marketing, 234 Shawmut Preview Electronic Branch.Computers in BankingSeptember 12 1986;14–16. John T.Cox.Service Guarantee Program at B of A Promotes Customer Satisfaction.Bank MarketingJanuary1987;30. Crosby P.B., 1979, Quality is Free Czepiel J.A., 1985, The Service Encounter Davis S., 1987, Future Perfect Donnelly J.H., 1985, Marketing Financial Services Donnelly J.H., 1985, Marketing Financial Services: A Strategic Vision 10.1016/0272-6963(90)90094-T Fitzsimmons J.A., 1982, Service Operations Management Gale B.T., 1988, The Interfaces of Marketing and Strategy C.Giffi A.V.Roth.Survey Shows Priorities Are Quality Workers and Mature Technologies.CIM ReviewFall1990;5–15. Giffi C., 1991, Competing in World Class Manufacturing: America's 21st Century Challenge M.B.Graham S.Rosenthal.Flexible Manufacturing Systems Require Flexible People.Human Systems Management1986. Green P.E., 1978, Analyzing Multivariate Data Greenberg B., 1987, Special Report No. 220, 1 C.W.L.Hart.The Power of Unconditional Service Guarantees.Harvard Business ReviewJuly–August1988;54–61. Hayes R.H., 1984, Restoring Our Competitive Edge Herzberg F.H., 1966, Work and the Nature of Man Heskett J.L., 1986, Managing in the Service Economy J.L.Heskett.Lessons in the Service Sector.Harvard Business ReviewMarch–April1987;118–126. Heskett J.L., 1990, Service Breakthroughs: Changing the Rules of the Game Hill T., 1989, Manufacturing Strategy: Text and Cases Huete L., 1988, The Industrialization and Span of Retail Banks' Delivery Systems, International Journal of Operations and Production Management, 8, 10.1108/eb054825 P.Kotler.Eurobanks Head for One Market.American BankerMarch 17 1988. Kotler P., 1984, Marketing Management: Analysis, Planning and Control 10.1016/0305-0483(90)90058-H Levitt R., 1972, Production Line Approach to Service, Harvard Business Review, 50, 41 10.2307/1251193 Lovelock C.H., 1984, Services Marketing Lovelock C.H., 1988, Managing Services: Marketing, Operations, and Human Resources Miller J.G., 1991, A Taxonomy of Manufacturing Strategy Miller J.G., 1988, Manufacturing Strategies, Operations Management Review, 6, 8 10.1002/smj.4250060306 Parasuraman A., 1988, SERVQUAL: A Multiple‐Item Scale for Measuring Consumer Perceptions of Service Quality, Journal of Retailing, 64, 12 Porter M., 1980, Competitive Strategy Porter M., 1985, Competitive Advantage: Creating and Sustaining Superior Performance F.F.Reichheld W.E.SasserJr..Zero Defections: Quality Comes to Services.Harvard Business ReviewSeptember–October1990;105–111. Riddle D.I., 1986, Service‐Led Growth, The Role of the Service Sector in World Development Rockart J.F., 1979, Chief Executives Define Their Own Data Needs, Harvard Business Review, 57, 81 Roth A.V., 1989, Managing International Manufacturing, 187 10.1007/978-94-009-2189-4_11 Roth A.V. and J.G. Miller. “Success Factors for Manufacturing.”Business Horizons to appear. Roth A.V., 1988, The Future of Retail Banking Delivery Systems Roth A.V., 1989, Investing in Retail Delivery System Technology, Journal of Retail Banking Roth A.V., 1990, Retail Banking Strategies: Opportunities for the 1990's A.V.Roth M.van derVelde.Customer‐Perceived Quality Drives Retail Banking in '90s.Bank ManagementNovember1991;29–35. Roth A.V., 1992, World Class Banking: Benchmarking the Strategies of the Retail Banking Leaders A.F.Ryan.Break the Wall between Operations and Business.The American BankerFebruary 5 1987. W.E.Sasser.Match Supply and Demand in Service Industries.Harvard Business ReviewNovember–December1976;133–140. Sasser W.E., 1978, Management of Service Operations 10.1016/0272-6963(86)90013-6 Skinner W., 1978, Manufacturing in the Corporate Strategy First Union's Service Guarantee.The Southern BankerDecember1987;28–29. 10.2307/1251131 10.1016/0272-6963(89)90028-4 10.1287/mnsc.33.4.509 Thomas D.R.E., 1978, Strategy Is Different in Service Business, Harvard Business Review, 56, 158 Watts J., 1987, The Financial Services Shockwave‐Survival Tactics for Wall Street and Main Street Wheelwright S.C., 1985, Competing through Manufacturing, Harvard Business Review, 63 10.1016/0007-6813(78)90032-0 10.2307/1251563 V.A.Zeithaml L.L.Berry A.Parasuraman.Communication and Control Processes in the Delivery of Service Quality.Marketing Science Institute Report No. 87–100June1987. Zemke R., 1989, The Service Edge: 101 Companies that Profit from Customer Care