Oil spill response capabilities and technologies for ice-covered Arctic marine waters: A review of recent developments and established practices

Abdelnour, R., and G. Comfort. 2001. Application of ice booms for oil-spill cleanup in ice-infested waters. Fleet Technology Limited, Final Report, 77 pp. Abdelnour, R., G. Comfort, and J. Mullin. 2001. The use of ice booms to facilitate the recovery of spilled oil in ice infested waters. In 16th international port and oceans engineering under Arctic conditions, Ottawa, Ontario, August 12–17, 2001. Allen, A.A., and W.G. Nelson. 1981. Oil spill countermeasures in land-fast sea ice. In Proceedings 1981 oil spill conference, API, Washington, D.C. Allshouse, M.R., G.N. Ivey, J. Xu, C.J. Beegle-Krause, R.J. Lowe, N.L. Jones, and T. Peacock. 2017. The impact of wind on the lagrangian structure of ocean surface transport. Environmental Fluid Dynamics 17: 473–483. Babiker, M., K. Kloster, S. Sandven, and R. Hall. 2010. The utilisation of satellite images for the oil in ice experiment in the Barents Sea, May 2009. SINTEF Oil in Ice – JIP, Report No. 29, 44 pp. Baschek, B. 2007. Multi-sensor oil spill surveillance program. International Oil & Ice Workshop, Anchorage, USA. Bejarano, A.C., W.W. Gardiner, M.G. Barron, and J.Q. Ward. 2017. Relative sensitivity of Arctic species to physically and chemically dispersed oil determined from three hydrocarbon measures of aquatic toxicity. Marine Pollution Bulletin 122: 316–322. Belore, R.C., K. Trudel, J.V. Mullin, and A. Guarino. 2009. Large-scale cold water dispersant effectiveness experiments with Alaskan crude oils and Corexit 9500 and 9527 dispersants. Marine Pollution Bulletin 58: 118–128. Bobra, A.M., and M.F. Fingas. 1986. The behavior and fate of Arctic oil spills. Water Science Technology 18: 13–23. BoHaSA. 2011. Behaviour of oil and other hazardous and noxious substances (HNS) spilled in Arctic waters (BoHaSA). Emergency Prevention, Preparedness and Response (EPPR) Working Group, March 2011. Bradford, J.H., D. Dickins, and L.M. Liberty. 2008. Locating oil spills under sea ice using ground-penetrating radar. The Leading Edge 27: 1424–1435. Bradford, J.H., D. Dickins, and P.J. Brandvik. 2010. Assessing the potential to detect snow covered oil spills on sea ice using airborne ground-penetrating radar. Geophysics 75: 1–12. Brakstad, O.G., I.K. Almås, and D.F. Krause. 2017. Biotransformation of natural gas and oil compounds of natural gas and oil compounds associated with marine oil discharges. Chemosphere 182: 555–558. Brakstad, O.G., T. Nortug, and M. Throne-Holst. 2015. Biodegradation of dispersed Macondo oil in seawater at low temperature and different oil droplet sizes. Marine Pollution Bulletin 93: 144–152. Brandvik, P.J., and T. Buvik. 2009. Using dogs to detect oil hidden in snow and ice. Results from Field Training on Svalbard April 2008, JIP—Report 14, 22 June 2009. Brandvik, P.J., J.L.M. Resby, P.S. Daling, F. Leirvik, and J. Fritt-Rasmussen. 2010b. Meso-scale weathering of oil as a function of ice conditions—Oil properties, dispersibility and in situ burnability of weathered oil as a function of time: SINTEF Materials and Chemistry, Oil in Ice—JIP Report No. 19, 116 pp. Brandvik, P.J., K.R. Sørheim, I. Singsaas, and M. Reed. 2006. Short state-of-the-art report on oil spills in ice-infested waters—Final: SINTEF Materials and Chemistry, Oil in Ice—JIP Report No. 1, 63 pp. Brekke, C., and A.H.S. Solberg. 2005. Oil spill detection by satellite remote sensing. Remote Sensing of Environment 95: 1–13. doi:10.1016/j.rse.2004.11.015. Brekke, C., B. Holt, C. Jones, and S. Skrunes. 2014. Discrimination of oil spills from newly formed sea ice by synthetic aperture radar. Remote Sensing of Environment 145: 1–14. Broström, G., A. Carrasco, and S. Berger. 2011. Oil drift modeling, the M/V Godafoss accident. In The proceedings of the sixth international conference on EuroGOOS, 274–282, 4–6 October 2011. Buist, I. 2010. Field testing of the USN oil herding agent on Heirdrun Crude in loose drift ice: SINTEF Materials and Chemistry, Oil in Ice—JIP Report no. 6. Buist, I., S. Potter, T. Nedwed, and J. Mullin. 2008a. Herding agents thicken oil spills in drift ice to facilitate in situ burning: A new trick for an old dog. In Proceedings of the international oil spill conference, 673–680, Savannah, Georgia, 4–8 May 2008. Buist, I., S. Potter, L. Zabilanksy, A. Guarino, and J. Mullin. 2008b. Recent mid-scale research on using oil herding surfactants to thicken oil slicks in ice pack for in situ burning. In Oil spill response—A Global perspective davidson, ed. W.F. Lee, and A. Cogswell, 41–62. Springer. Buist I.A, S.G. Potter, B.K. Trudel, S.R. Shelnutt, A. H. Walker, D.K. Scholz, P.J. Brandvik, J. Fritt-Rasmussen, et al. 2013. In situ burning in ice-affected waters: State of Knowledge Report Final Report 7.1.1 Report from Joint Industry Programme to present status of regulations related to in situ burning in Arctic and sub-Arctic countries, 294 pp. Cox, J. C., and I. A. Schultz. 1980. Proceedings of the third annual technical seminar, Arctic Marine Oil Spill Program, 45–61. CRRC. 2016. State-of-Science for Dispersant Use in Arctic Waters. D.F. Dickins Associates Ltd. 2004. Advancing oil-spill response in ice-covered waters: Report prepared for the Prince William Sound Oil Spill Recovery Institute and the U.S. Arctic Research Commission, 28 pp. Daling, P., and T. Strom. 1999. Weathering of oils at sea: Model/field data comparisons. Spill Science and Technology Bulletin 5: 63–74. Daling, P.S., F. Leirvik, I. Kjersti Almås, P.J. Brandvik, B.H. Hansen, A. Lewis, and M. Reed. 2014. Surface weathering and dispersibility of MC252 crude oil. Marine Pollution Bulletin 87: 300–310. doi:10.1016/j.marpolbul.2014.07.005. DeCola, E., T. Robertson, S. Fletcher, and S. Harvey. 2006. Offshore oil spill response in dynamic ice conditions—A report to WWF on considerations for the Sakhalin II Project: Nuka Research and Planning Group, LLC and Harvey Consulting, LLC, Alaska, 74 pp Dickens, D., and J.H.S. Andersen. 2009. Remote Sensing Technology Review and Screening. Oil in Ice—JIP, Report 22, 24 November 2009. Dickens, D., J.H.S. Andersen, P.J. Brandvik, I. Singsaas, T. Buvik, J. Bradford, R. Hall, M. Babiker, et al. 2010. Remote sensing for the oil in ice Joint Industry Program 2007–2009. Dickins, D. 2011. Behavior of oil spills in ice and implications for Arctic spill response. In Proceedings of the OTC Arctic Technology Conference, OTC 22126, 1–15. Houston, Texas, USA. Dickins, D., I.A. Buist, and W. M. Pistruzak. 1981. Dome’s petroleum study of oil and gas under sea ice. In The international oil spill conference proceedings, March 1981, 183–189. Dickins, D., J. Overall, and R. Brown. 1975. Beaufort Sea Project Tech. Rept. 27, Inst. of Ocean Sciences, Victoria B.C. Dickins, D.F., and I. Buist. 1999. Countermeasures for ice-covered waters. Journal of Pure and Applied Chemistry 71: 173–191. Environment Canada. 2013. Properties, Composition and Marine Spill Behavoir, Fate and Transport of Two Diluted Bitumen Products from the Canadian Oil Sands. Federal Government Technical Report, 87 pp. Faksness, L., and P. Brandvik. 2008. Distribution of water soluble compounds from Arctic marine oil spills A combined laboratory and field study. Cold Regions Science and Technology 54: 97–105. Fay, J.A. 1969. The spreading of oil slicks on a calm sea In Oil on the sea, ed. D. Hoult, 53–64. New York: Plenum. Fingas, M. 2008, A review of knowledge on water-in-oil emulsions. In Proceedings of international oil spill conference, 1269–1274, Savannah, Georgia, 4–8 May 2008. Fingas, M.F., and C.E. Brown. 1997. Review of oil spill remote sensing. Spill Science and Technology Bulletin 4: 199–208. doi:10.1016/S1353-2561(98)00023-1. Fingas, M.F., G. Halley, F. Ackerman, R. Nelson, M.C. Bissonnette, N. Laroche, Z. Wang, P. Lambert, et al. 1995. The Newfoundland offshore burn experiment— NOBE. In Proceedings of the international oil spill conference, 123–132. Washington, D.C.: American Petroleum Institute. Fingas, M.F., and B.P. Hollebone. 2003. Review of behaviour of oil in freezing environments. Marine Pollution Bullutin 47: 333–340. Firoozy, N., T. Neusitzer, D. S. Desmond, T. Tiede, M. J. Lemes, J. Landy, and D. G. Barber, 2017. An electromagnetic detection case study on crude oil injection in a young sea ice environment. IEEE Transactions on Geoscience and Remote Sensing. Garneau M.-È., C. Michel, G. Meisterhans, N. Fortin, T.L. King, C.W. Greer, and K. Lee. 2016. Hydrocarbon biodegradation by Arctic sea-ice and sub-ice microbial communities during microcosm experiments, Northwest Passage (Nunavut, Canada). FEMS Microbiology Ecology 92, fiw130. Glaeser, J.L., and G. Vance. 1971. A study of the behavior of oil spills in the arctic. Report Number 714/08/A/001,002, United States Coast Guard, Washington, DC, 53 pp. Holland-Bartels, L., and B. Pierce (ed). 2011. An evaluation of the science needs to inform decisions on Outer Continental Shelf energy development in the Chukchi and Beaufort Seas. Alaska: U.S. Geological Survey Circular 1370, 278 pp. Hoult, D.P., S. Wolfe, S. O’Dea, and J.P. Patureau. 1975. Oil in the arctic. Technical Report CG-D-96-75, Prepared for Dept. of Transportation, U.S. Coast Guard. Interagency Coordinating Committee on Oil Pollution Research (ICCOPR). 2009. Biennial report for fiscal years 2008 and 2009: Department of Homeland Security, U.S. Coast Guard, 60 pp. ITOF. 2014. The International Tanker Owners Pollution Federation Limited (ITOPF). Technical Information Paper (TIP), FATE OF MARINE OIL SPILLS. Izumiyama, K., A. Konno, and S. Sakai. 2002. Experimental study on spreading of oil under ice covers. In Proceedings of the twelfth (2002) international offshore and polar engineering conference, 821–826. Kitakyushu, Japan, 26–31 May 2002. Jensen, H.V., and J.V. Mullin. 2003. MORICE—New technology for mechanical oil recovery in ice infested waters. Marine Pollution Bulletin 47: 453–469. JIP. 2016. http://www.arcticresponsetechnology.org/publications-data. Johansen, Ø., B.A. Høverstad, K. Skognes, and K.-U. Evers. 2005. Simulation of oil drift and spreading and oil spill response analysis, ARCOP WP4. Environmental Protection and Management System for the Arctic, GROWTH Project GRD2-2000-30112 “ARCOP”. Johansen, Ø., P. Brandvik, and U. Farooq. 2013. Droplet breakup in subsea oil releases—Part 2. Predictions of droplet size distribution with and without injection of chemical dispersants. Marine Pollution Bulletin 73: 327–335. Juurmaa, K. 2006. Working Package 4 (WP4)—Environmental Protection and management system for the Arctic: in ARCOP Final Report. GROWTH Project GRD2- 2000-30112, Aker Finnyards Inc., 330 pp. Karlsson, J., C. Petrich, and H. Eicken. 2011. Oil entrainment and migration in laboratory–grown saltwater ice. In Proc. of the 21st international conference on port and ocean engineering under arctic conditions. Keevil, B.E., and R. Ramseier. 1975. In Proceedings of the 1975 Conference on Prevention and Control of Oil Pollution, 497–501. American Petroleum Institute, USA. Kovacs, A., and R.M. Morey. 1978. Radar anisotropy of sea ice due to preferred azimuthal orientation of the horizontal c axes of ice crystals. Journal of Geophysical Research 83: 6037–6046. doi:10.1029/JC083iC12p06037. Lee, J. 2016. Russia’s Arctic Oil Rush. Bloomberg. Lee, C.M., and J. Thomson. 2017. The Marginal Ice Zone and Arctic Sea State Teams. An autonomous approach to observing the seasonal ice zone in the western Arctic. Oceanography 30: 56–68, doi:10.5670/oceanog.2017.222. Lee, K., M. Boufadel, B. Chen, J. Foght, P. Hodson, S. Swanson, and A. Venosa. 2015. Expert panel report on the behaviour and environmental impacts of crude oil released into aqueous environments. Ottawa: Royal Society of Canada. ISBN 978-1-928140-02-3. Lessard, R.R., and G. DeMarco. 2000. The significance of oil spill dispersants. Spill Science and Technology Bulletin 6: 59–68. Lewis, A., and P.S. Daling. 2007. A review of studies of oil spill dispersant effectiveness in Arctic conditions (JIP Project 4, Act. 4.11): SINTEF Materials and Chemistry, Oil in Ice—JIP Report No. 11, 26 pp. Lewis, A., O. Johansen, I. Singsaas, and L. Solsberg. 2008. Ice Regimes for Oil Spill Response Planning: SINTEF Materials and Chemistry, Oil in Ice—JIP Report no. 15. Lewis, E.L. 1976. OIL IN SEA ICE Institute of Ocean Sciences, Patricia Bay, 1976, 26 pp. Malcolm, J.D. 1979. In Proceedings of a Workshop on Oil, Ice and Gas, 47–53. EE-14, Institute for Environmental Studies, Toronto, Ontario. Martin, S. 1979. A field study of brine drainage and oil entrainment in first-year sea ice. Journal of Glaciology 22: 473–502. Maus, S., S. Leisinger, M. Matzl, M. Schneebeli, and A. Wiegmann. 2013. Modelling oil entrapment in sea ice on the basis of microtomographic images. In Proceedings—Port and Ocean Engineering under Arctic Conditions, Espoo, Finland. POAC, 10 pp. Maus, S., J. Becker, S. Leisinger, M. Matzl, M. Schneebeli, and A. Wiegmann. 2015. Oil saturation of the sea ice pore space. In Proceedings—International conference on port and ocean engineering under arctic conditions. Milne, A.R., and R.H. Herlinveaux. 1977. Crude oil in cold water. Beaufort Sea Project, Summary Rep., Inst. Ocean Sci., Sidney (B.C.), 119 pp. Minerals Management Service. 2008. Arctic oil spill response research and development program: A decade of achievement: Minerals Management Service, 29 pp. Morey, R.M., A. Kovacs, and G.F.N. Cox. 1984. Electromagnetic properties of sea ice. Cold Regions Science and Technology 9: 53–75. doi:10.1016/0165-232X(84)90048-X. Mulac, B., R. Storvold, and E. Weatherhead. 2011. Remote sensing in the Arctic with unmanned aircraft: Helping scientists to achieve their goals. In International symposium on remote sensing of environment, international center on remote sensing of the environment (ICRSE), Sydney, Australia, 10–15 April, 2011. Mullin, J., R. Belore, and K. Trudel. 2008. Cold water dispersant effectiveness experiments conducted at Ohmsett with Alaskan crude oils using Corexit 9500 and 9527 dispersants. In Proceedings of the international oil spill conference, 817–822, Savannah, Georgia, 4–8 May 2008. NORCOR. 1975. Beaufort Sea Technical Report, No. 27. Beaufort Sea Project, Department of the Environment, Victoria, BC. 1975. 201. Nordam T., D.A.E. Dunnebier, CJ Beegle-Krause, M. Reed, and D. Slagstad. 2017. Impact of climate change and seasonal trends on the fate of Arctic oil spills. Ambio. doi:10.1007/s13280-017-0961-3. North Slope Spill Response. 2015. Mechanical recovery in ice. Summary Report for the Arctic Oil Spill Response Technology—Joint Industry Programme, 22 pp. NRC. 2014. Responding to Oil Spills in the U.S. Arctic Marine Environment. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press. doi: 10.17226/18625. Nuka Research and Planning Group, LCC. 2007. Oil spill response challenges in Arctic waters: Report to the World Wildlife Fund International Arctic, 30 pp. Nyland, D. 2004. Profiles of floating ice in Arctic regions using GPR. The Leading Edge 23: 665–668. doi:10.1190/1.1776738. Olascoaga, M.J., and G. Haller. 2012. Forecasting sudden changes in environmental pollution patterns. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 109: 4738–4743. Olason, E., S. Bouillion, and P. Rampal. 2016. Sea ice model developments in view of oil spill forecasting. Final Report for the Arctic Oil Spill Response Technology—Joint Industry Programme. Owens, E.H., H.A. Parker Hall, G.S. Mauseth, A. Graham, T. Allard, J.W. Engles, S. Penland, P.D. Reimer, et al. 2005. Shoreline and surveillance surveys on the M/V Selendang Ayu spill response, Unalaska Island, Alaska. In Proceedings of the 28th Arctic and Marine Oilspill Program (AMOP) Technical seminar. Pegau, W. S., J. Garron, and L. Zabilansky. 2016. Detection of Oil in and Under Ice, Final Report 5.1 for the Arctic Oil Spill Response Technology—Joint Industry Programme, 411 pp. Petrich, C. 2017. MOSIDEO/CIRFA Experiments on Behavior and Detection of Oil in Ice. In EGU General Assembly Conference Abstracts 19: 18268. Petrich, C., J. Karlsson, and H. Eicken. 2013. Porosity of growing sea ice and potential for oil entrainment. Cold Regions Science and Technology 87: 27–32. Pew Charitable Trust. 2013. Arctic Standards: Recommendations on Oil Spill Prevention, Response, and Safety in the U.S. Arctic Ocean. Pew Environment Group. 2010. Policy recommendations: Oil spill prevention and response in the U.S. Arctic Ocean: Pew Environment Group, 19 pp. Potter, S., and I. Buist. 2008. In situ burning for oil spills in Arctic waters—State-of-the-art and future research needs. In Oil spill response—A global perspective, eds. W.F. Davidson, K. Lee, and A. Cogswell, 23–39. Springer Prince, R.C., K.M. McFarlin, J.D. Butler, E.J. Febbo, F.C.Y. Wang, and T.J. Nedwed 2013. The primary biodegradation of the dispersed crude oil in the sea. Chemosphere 90: 521–526. doi:10.1016/j.chemosphere.2012.08.020. Puestow, T., L. Parsons, I. Zakharov, N. Cater, P. Bobby, M. Fuglem, G.,Parr, A. Jayasiri, et al. 2013. Oil Spill Detection and Mapping in Low Visibility and Ice: Surface Remote Sensing, Arctic Oil Spill Response Technology Joint Industry Programme (JIP), 84 pp. S.L. Ross Environmental Research Ltd. 2010. A two-year research program on employing chemical herders to improve marine oil spill response operations: Bureau of Ocean Energy Management, Regulation and Enforcement Final Report, Contract Number M08PC20015, 125 pp. S.L. Ross Environmental Research, Ltd., D.F. Dickins and Associates, Ltd., and Vaudrey and Associates, Inc. 1998. Evaluation of cleanup capabilities for large blowout spills in the Alaskan Beaufort Sea during periods of broken ice: Report to Alaska Clean Seas and Minerals Management Service on behalf of the North Slope Spill Response Project Team, 222 pp. S.L. Ross Environmental Research Ltd and Danish Centre for Energy and the Environment. Research. 2015. Summary: Herding surfactants to contract and thicken oil spills for in situ burning in Arctic waters. Report for the Arctic Oil Spill Response Technology—Joint Industry Programme, 62 pp. Sagers, M.J. 1994. Oil spill in the Russian Arctic. Polar Geography and Geology 18: 95–102. Skognes, K., and Ø. Johansen. 2004. Statmap-a 3-dimensional model for oil spill risk assessment. Environmental Modelling and Software 19: 727–737. Solsberg, L. 2008. Countermeasures for the Beaufort transition season. In Oil spill response—A global perspective, eds. W.F. Davidson, K. Lee, and A. Cogswell, 91–109. Springer Spring, W., T. Nedwed, and R. Belore. 2006. Icebreaker enhanced chemical dispersion of oil spills. In Proceedings of the 29 Arctic and Marine Oil spill Program (AMOP) Technical Seminar. Canada: Environment Canada. Sørstrøm, S.E., P.J. Brandvik, I. Buist, P. Daling, D. Dickin, L.G. Faksness, S. Potter, J.F. Rasmussen, et al. 2010. Joint industry program on oil spill contingency for Arctic and ice-covered waters—Summary report: SINTEF Materials and Chemistry, Oil in Ice—JIP Report, no. 32, 40 pp. Transportation Research Board and National Research Council. 2014. Responding to Oil Spills in the U.S. Arctic Marine Environment. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press. doi: 10.17226/18625. U.S. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. 2013. Transporting Alberta oil sands products: Defining the issues and assessing the risks. NOAA Technical Report 44, 152 pp. Valentine, D., J.D. Kessler, M.C. Redmond, S.D. Mendes, M.B. Heintz, C. Farwell, L. Hu, F.S. Kinnaman, et al. 2010. Propane respiration jump-starts microbial response to a deep oil spill. Science 330: 208–211. Venkatesh, S., H. El-Tahan, G. Comfort, and R. Abdelnour. 1990. Modelling the behavior of oil spills in ice- infested water. Atmosphere-Ocean 28: 303–329. Wadhams, P. 1976a. Oil and ice in the Beaufort Sea. Polar Record 18: 237–250. Wadhams, P. 1976b. Sea ice topography in the Beaufort Sea and its effect on oil containment. AIDJEX Bulletin 33: 1–52. Wadhams, P. 1980. Oil and ice in the Beaufort Sea—the physical effects of a hypothetical blowout. In Petromar 80; Petroleum & the Marine Environment. Proc. 1st Intl. Conf., 299–318, Monaco, 27–30 May 1980, Graham and Trotman. Wadhams, P. 1989. Environmental problems of Arctic oil and gas development. Petroleum Review 43: 524–526. Wadhams, P. 2012. The environmental threat of oil spills in the ice-covered Arctic Ocean. Hansard, 21 Feb 2012. Testimony to Environmental Audit Committee, UK House of Commons. Wang, K., M. Leppäranta, M. Gästgifvars, and J. Vainio. 2008. The drift and spreading of Runner-4 oil spill and the ice conditions in the Gulf of Finland, winter 2006. Journal of Earth Science 57: 181–191. Wang, S.D., Y.M. Shen, and Y.H. Zheng. 2005. Two dimensional numerical simulation for transport and fate of oil spill in seas. Ocean Engineering 32: 1556–1571. Wilkinson, J.P., P. Wadhams, and N.E. Hughes. 2007. Modelling the spread of oil under fast sea ice using three-dimensional multibeam sonar data. Geophysical Research Letters 34: L22506. doi:10.1029/2007GL031754. Wilkinson, J., T. Maksym, and H. Singh. 2013. Capabilities for detection of oil spills under sea ice from autonomous underwater vehicles, Arctic Oil Spill Response Technology Joint Industry Programme FINAL REPORT 5.2 Report from Joint Industry Programme. on oil spill detection and mapping in low visibility and ice: focus on undersea remote sensing, 103 pp. Wilkinson, J.P., P. Wadhams, and N.E. Hughes. 2006. A review of the use of sonar on underwater vehicles to obatin information on sea ice draft. In Arctic sea ice thickness: past, present and future, ed. P. Wadhams, and G. Amanatidis. World Wildlife Fund. 2009. Not so fast: Some progress in spill response, but U.S. still ill-prepared for Arctic offshore development—A review of U.S. Department of the Interior: Minerals Management Service’s (MMS) “Arctic Oil Spill response research and development program—a decade of achievement”, 16 pp. Yapa, P.D., and S.A. Weerasuriya. 1997. Spreading of oil spilled under floating broken ice. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering 123: 676–683.