Nominal wage rigidity prior to compulsory arbitration: evidence from the Victorian Railways, 1902–1921
Tóm tắt
Studies across a wide range of countries have shown that relatively few workers have received year-to-year wage cuts since the Second World War. However, there is very little micro-level evidence from earlier years, when lower inflation rates and a less regulated labour market may have led to stronger downwards pressure on wages. This paper examines wage adjustment at the Victorian Railways, Australia, between 1902 and 1921. It is shown that, despite strong downwards pressure on wages, nominal wages were rigid downwards and a high proportion of triennial wage changes were exactly zero. Even for workers with very long tenure and in years when the national price level declined, wage cuts were rare. We also show that the characteristics of workers whose wages were unchanged were very similar to those receiving wage cuts. Finally, we show that unlike the wages of incumbent staff, entry wages for new junior staff frequently declined from year to year.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Akerlof G, Yellen J (1990) The fair wage-effort hypothesis and unemployment. Q J Econ 105(2):255–283
Akerlof G, Dickens W, Perry G (1996) The macroeconomics of low inflation. Brookings Pap Econ Act 1(1):1–59
Allen R (1994) Real incomes in the english-speaking world, 1879–1913. In: Grantham G, MacKinnon M (eds) Labour market evolution: the economic history of market integration, wage flexibility and the employment relation. Routledge, London, pp 107–138
Altonji J, Devereux P (1999) The extent and consequences of downward nominal wage rigidity. National Bureau of Economic Research, Working Paper 7236, Cambridge
Baker G, Gibbs M, Holmstrom B (1994a) The internal economics of the firm: evidence from personnel data. Q J Econ 109(4):881–920
Baker G, Gibbs M, Holmstrom B (1994b) The wage policy of a firm. Q J Econ 109(4):921–955
Benham L, Rickard J (1973) Masters and servants: the Victorian railway strike of 1903. In: Iremonger J, Merritt J, Osborne G (eds) Strikes: studies in twentieth century Australian social history. Angus and Robertson, Sydney, pp 1–25
Bewley T (1999) Why wages don’t fall during a recession? Harvard University Press, Cambridge
Blanchard O, Summers L (1986) Hysteresis and European unemployment. In: Stanley F (ed) NBER Macroeconomics Annual, 1:15–77
Butler-Bowdon E (1991) In the service? A history of Victorian railway workers and their union. Hyland House, South Yarra
Butlin N (1962) Australian domestic product: investment and foreign borrowing 1861–1938/1939. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Chapple S (1996) Money wage rigidity in New Zealand. Labour Mark Bull 2:23–50
Churchward AR (1983) Inside the fence: unionism in the Victorian Railways 1903–1920. Unpublished MA Thesis, University of Melbourne
Dickens B, Groshen E, Holden S, Messina J, Schweitzer M, Turunen J, Ward-Warmedinger M (2007) How wages change: micro evidence from the international wage flexibility project. J Econ Perspect 21(2):195–214
Dwyer J, Leong K (2003) Nominal wage rigidity in Australia. Aust J Lab Econ 6(1):5–24
Elsby M (2004) Evaluating the economic significance of downward nominal wage rigidity. Mimeo
Fehr E, Goette L (2005) Robustness and real consequences of nominal wage rigidity. J Monet Econ 52(4):779–804
Gordon R (1982) Why US wage and employment behaviour differs from that in Britain and Japan. Econ J 92(365):13–44
Gregory RG, Borland J (1999) Recent developments in public sector labor markets. In: Ashenfelter O, Card D (eds) Handbook of labor economics, 1(3), chapter 53. Elsevier, Oxford, pp 3573–3630
Hall R (1980) Employment fluctuations and wage rigidity. In: George LP (ed) Brookings Papers on economic activity, 1(1):91–123
Hamilton B, MacKinnon M (1996) Quits and layoffs in early twentieth century labour markets. Explor Econ Hist 33(3):346–366
Hammond MB (1914) Wages boards in Australia: I. Victoria. Q J Econ 29(1):98–148
Hanes C (2000) Nominal wage rigidity and industry characteristics in the downturns of 1893, 1929 and 1981. Am Econ Rev 90(5):1432–1446
Hanes C, James J (2003) Wage adjustment under low inflation: evidence from US history. Am Econ Rev 93(4):1414–1424
Harrigan L (1962) Victorian railways to ‘62. Victorian Railways Public Relations and Betterment Board, Melbourne
Howlett P (2000) Evidence of the existence of an internal labour market in the great eastern railway company, 1875–1905. Bus Hist 42(1):21–40
Kahn S (1997) Evidence of nominal wage stickiness from microdata. Am Econ Rev 87(5):993–1008
Kahneman D, Tversky A (1979) Prospect theory: an analysis of decisions under risk. Econometrica 47(2):313–327
Kahneman D, Knetsch J, Thaler R (1986) Fairness as a constraint on profit seeking: entitlements in the market. Am Econ Rev 76(4):728–741
Keynes JM (1936) The general theory of employment, interest and money. Macmillan, London
Knoppik C, Beissinger T (2003) How rigid are nominal wages? Evidence and implications for Germany. Scand J Econ 105(4):619–641
Laybourne K (1992) A history of British trade unionism, 1770–1990. Alan Sutton Publishing Ltd, Bath
Leslie D (1985) The economics of cash limits as a method of pay determination. Econ J 95(379):662–678
Lindbeck A, Snower DJ (1988) Cooperation, harassment, and involuntary unemployment: an insider-outsider approach. Am Econ Rev 78(1):167–188
Maddock R, McLean I (1984) Supply-side shocks: the case of Australian gold. J Econ Hist 44(4):1047–1067
Marshall A (1887) A fair rate of wages. In: Pigou AG (ed) Memorials of Alfred Marshall, 1925th edn. MacMillan, London, pp 212–226
McCarthy PG (1970) Wages in Australia, 1891–1914. Aust Econ Hist Rev 5(1):56–76
Mitchell D (1985) Wage flexibility; then and now. Ind Relat 24(2):266–279
Morgan S (1995) Chinese railway lives, 1912–1937. Unpublished PhD Thesis, The Australian National University
Nickell S, Quintini G (2003) Nominal wage rigidity and the rate of inflation. Econ J 113(490):762–781
Pelling H (1987) A history of British trade unions, 4th edn. Macmillan, London
Pope D, Withers G (1994) Wage effects of immigration in late-nineteenth-century Australia. In: Hatton T, Williamson JG (eds) Migration and the international labor market, 1850–1939. Routledge, London
Portas JH (1971) Australian compulsory arbitration, 1900–1970. Hicks Smith & Sons, Sydney
Routh G (1954) Civil service pay, 1875 to 1950. Economica 21(83):201–223
Sammartino A (2002) Human resource management practices and labour market structures in the Victorian railways 1864–1921. PhD thesis, University of Melbourne
Seltzer A (2010) Did Firms cut nominal wages in a deflationary environment? micro-level evidence from the late 19th and early 20th century banking industry. Explor Econ Hist 47(1):112–125
Seltzer A, Merrett D (2000) Personnel practices at the union bank of Australia: panel evidence from the 1887–1900 entry cohorts. J Lab Econ 18(4):573–613
Sundstrom W (1990) Was there a golden age of flexible wages? Evidence from Ohio manufacturing, 1892–1910. J Econ Hist 50(2):309–320
Sutcliffe J (1921) A history of trade unionism in Australia. MacMillan & Co, Melbourne
Svenson S (1995) Industrial war, the great strikes, 1890–1894. Ram Press, Wollongong
The Victorian Railways Union (various years, commencing in 1912). The Railways Union Gazette. The Official Organ of the Victorian Railways Union
Turner I (1965) Industrial labour and politics: the dynamics of the labour movement in Eastern Australia 1900–1921. Hale & Ironmonger, Sydney
Vamplew W (ed) (1987) Australians: historical statistics. Fairfax, Syme & Weldon Associates, New South Wales
Victoria Parliament (1883a) The railways management bill (Act. No. 767). Parliamentary Papers, Melbourne
Victoria Parliament (1888–1889b) Victorian year-book. Sands & McDougall Limited, Melbourne
Victoria Parliament (1903c) Dismissed railway strikers. Victorian Parliamentary Debates, 106. Melbourne: 2332
Victoria Parliament (1902–21d) Report of the chief inspector of factories, work-rooms, and shops. Parliamentary Papers, Melbourne
Victoria Parliament (1902–21e) The Victorian government gazette, Melbourne
Victoria Parliament (1891–1903, 1905, 1921, 1922f) Victorian Railways annual reports. Parliamentary Papers, Melbourne
Williamson J (1995) The evolution of global labor markets since 1830: background evidence and hypotheses. Explor Econ Hist 32(2):141–196
Withers GA (1987) Labour. In: Maddock R, McLean I (eds) The Australian economy in the long run. Cambridge University Press, Melbourne, pp 248–288
Withers G, Endres T, Perry L (1985) Australian historical statistics: labour statistics. Source Papers in Economic History, No. 7