Negotiation of a cross-border natural gas pipeline: An analytical contribution to the discussions on Turkish Stream

Abdelal, R., Tarontsi, S., 2011a. Energy Security in Europe (B): The Southern Corridor, Harvard Business School BGIE Unit Case No. 711-033, posted: 14 Mar 2012. Abdelal, R., Tarontsi, S., 2011b. Energy Security in Europe (A): Nord Stream, Energy Security in Europe (A): Nord Stream, Harvard Business School BGIE Unit Case No. 711-026, posted: 14 Mar 2012. Abdelal, 2013, The profits of power: commerce and realpolitik in Eurasia, Rev. Int. Political Econ., 20, 421, 10.1080/09692290.2012.666214 ACER, 2015a. European Gas Target Model Review and Update, available online at 〈http://www.acer.europa.eu/events/presentation-of-acer-gas-target-model-/documents/european%20gas%20target%20model%20review%20and%20update.pdf〉 (Accessed 24 July 2017). ACER, 2015b. On Unıt Investment Cost Indicators and Corresponding Reference Values for Electricity And Gas Infrastructure, 〈http://www.acer.europa.eu/official_documents/acts_of_the_agency/publication/uic%20report%20-%20gas%20infrastructure.pdf〉, (Accessed 10 November 2017). Jazeera, Al, 2014. Rusya’dan yeni boru hattı: 〈http://www.aljazeera.com.tr/haber/rusyadan-yeni-boru-hatti〉 (Accessed 22. July 2017). Bacik, 2006, Turkey and pipeline politics, Turk. Stud., 7, 293, 10.1080/14683840600714657 BBC, 2014. Putin’den Türkiye’ye doğal gaz indirimi, 〈http://www.bbc.com/turkce/haberler/2014/12/141201_putin_dogalgaz_indirim〉, (Accessed 8 November 2017). BOTAS, 2015. Annual Report, available online at: 〈http://botas.gov.tr/docs/raporlar/faalrap_2015.pdf〉 (Accessed 01 July 2017). Bruce, 1986 Chamberlain, 1951 Chyong, C.K., Hobbs, B.F., 2011. Strategic Eurasian natural gas model for energy security and policy analysis, CWPE 1134 & EPRG 1115. University of Cambridge, Faculty of Economics. Cohen, A., 1996. The new Great Game: pipeline politics in Eurasia. Caspian Crossroads, 2(1). Dastan, 2016, Review of the security of supply in Turkish energy markets: lessons from the winter shortages, Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev., 59, 958, 10.1016/j.rser.2016.01.015 Dickel, R., Hassanzadeh, E., Henderson, J., Honoré, A., El-Katiri, L., Pirani, S., Rogers, H., Stern, J., Yafimava, K., 2014. Reducing European dependence on Russian gas. OIES Paper NG92. Djankov, S., 2015. Russia’s economy under Putin: From crony capitalism to state capitalism. Policy Brief PB15-18. Washington, DC: Peterson Institute. EC, 2009. Common Rules for the Internal Market in Natural Gas Directive (2009/73/EC), available online at: 〈https://ec.europa.eu/energy/en/topics/markets-and-consumers/market-legislation〉 (Accessed 22 July 2017). EC, 2010. Regulation (EU) No 994/2010 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 20 October 2010 Concerning Measures to Safeguard Security of Gas Supply and Repealing Council Directive 2004/67/EC available online at: 〈http://eurlex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?Uri=OJ:L:2010:295:0001:0022:EN:PDF〉 (Accessed 22 July 2017). EC, 2016. Fact Sheet, Security of gas supply regulation, Brussels, 16 February 2016, online available at: 〈http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_MEMO-16-308_en.htm〉 (Accessed 22 July 2017). Eni, 2014. Blue Stream, available online at: 〈https://www.eni.com/en_RU/eni-russia/partners-projects/gazprom/bluestream/bluestream.shtml〉 (Accessed 22 July 2017). EMRA, 2017. Energy Market Regulatory Authority of Turkey, 2016 Yılı Sektör Raporu, available online at: 〈http://www.epdk.org.tr/TR/Dokumanlar/Dogalgaz/YayinlarRaporlar/Yillik〉 (Accessed 22 July 2017). Energy Charter, 2006. Gas Transit Tariffs in selected Energy Charter Treaty Countries, Energy Charter Secretariat, 〈http://www.energycharter.org/fileadmin/DocumentsMedia/Thematic/Gas_Transit_Tariffs_2006_en.pdf〉 (Accessed 07 November 2017). ENTSOG, Transparency. 〈https://transparency.entsog.eu/#/points/data?From=2014-11-01&periodize=1&points=BG-TSO-0001ITP-00041exit%2CTR-TSO-0001ITP-00041entry&to=2014-12-31〉 (Accessed 01 July 2017). Erdogdu, 2010, Bypassing Russia: nabucco project and its implications for the European gas security, Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev., 14, 2936, 10.1016/j.rser.2010.07.028 ETSAP, 2011. Oil and Gas Logistics, Technology Brief P03 – August 2011, 〈https://iea-etsap.org/E-TechDS/PDF/P03_oilgaslogistics_PS_revised_GSOK2.pdf〉, (Accessed 14 November 2014). EurAsia Daily, 2017. What will Russia lose refusing from gas pipelines bypassing Ukraine? 〈https://eadaily.com/en/news/2017/08/04/what-will-russia-lose-refusing-from-gas-pipelines-bypassing-ukraine〉, (Accessed 14 November 2017). EEAS, 2017. Antitrust: Commission invites comments on Gazprom commitments concerning Central and Eastern European gas markets, European External Action Service, Brussels, 〈https://eeas.europa.eu/headquarters/headquarters-homepage/22577/antitrust-commission-invites-comments-gazprom-commitments-concerning-central-and-eastern_en〉 (Accessed 19 November 2017). Finon, 2011, The EU foreign gas policy of transit corridors: autopsy of the stillborn Nabucco project, PEC Energy Rev., 35, 47, 10.1111/j.1753-0237.2010.00185.x Gazprom, 2016. Gazprom, DEPA, and Edison in talks on optimal route of Russian gas exports to the south of Europe, available online at: 〈http://www.gazprom.com/press/news/2016/december/article295952/〉 (Accessed 22 July 2017). 〈http://www.gazpromexport.ru/en/statistics/〉, (Accessed 29 November 2017). GWPF, 2012. Global Warming Policy Plaform, Turkey’s Bold Move Shakes Up EU Energy Security, available online at: 〈https://www.thegwpf.com/turkeys-bold-move-shakes-up-eu-energy-security/〉 (Accessed online 22 July 2017). Hafner, M., Tagliapietra, S., 2015. Turkish Stream: What Strategy for Europe? FEEM Working Paper No. 050.2015, posted: 28 May 2015. Honoré, A., 2014. The outlook for natural gas demand in Europe. Oxford Institute for Energy Studies. Oxford Institute for Energy Studies. Hansen, S., 2003. Pipeline Politics The struggle for control of the Eurasian energy resources (CIEP--02-2003). Netherlands. Henderson, J., 2016. Gazprom–Is 2016 the Year for a Change of Pricing Strategy in Europe? OIES Oxford Energy Comment. Henderson, 2015, The political and commercial dynamics of Russia’s gas export strategy, Oxf. Inst. Energy Stud., 1 IEA, 2013, World Energy Outlook, 2013 Interfax, 2015a. Russia’s Turkish Stream threat is a ‘political bluff’ – Naftogaz: 〈http://interfaxenergy.com/gasdaily/article/15030/russias-turkish-stream-threat-is-a-political-bluff-naftogaz〉 (Accessed 22 July 2017). Interfax, 2015b. Gazprom agrees on 180-km land section of Turkish Stream gas pipeline between Kiyikoy, Epsila: 〈http://www.interfax.com/newsinf.asp?Y=2010&m=2&d=10&pg=8&id=570227〉 (Accessed 22 July 2017). Kleveman, 2004, 288 Kremlin, 2014. News conference following state visit to Turkey, 〈http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/47126〉 (Accessed 21 Noovember 2017). Larsson, R.L., 2007. Nord Stream, Sweden and Baltic Sea Security. Defense Analysis, Swedish Defence Research Agency (FOI). Lee, 2014, Opportunities and risks in Turkmenistan’s quest for diversification of its gas export routes, Energy Policy, 74, 330, 10.1016/j.enpol.2014.08.003 MEDREG, 2015. Interconnection Infrastructures in the Mediterranean: A Challenging Environment for Investments, July, available online at: 〈http://www.medreg-regulators.org/Publications/Gas.aspx〉 (Accessed 22 July 2017). Menegaki, 2011, Bourgas–Alexandroupolis oil pipeline; will matching institutional and regulatory contexts lead to an effective bargaining and eventual consensus?, Energy Policy, 39, 1277, 10.1016/j.enpol.2010.11.056 Milov, V., 2015. Russia’s New Energy Alliances: Mythology versus Reality. Russie Nei. Visions N, 86. Mironova, I., 2015. Turkish Stream: Another geopolitical bluff from the Kremlin? Russia-Direct, online available at: http://www.russia-direct.org/opinion/turkish-stream-another-geopolitical-bluffing-kremlin〉 (Accessed 22 July 2017). Munteanu, 2016, South stream and Nord stream 2–implications for the European energy security, Análise Europeia-Revista da Associação Portuguesa de Estudos Europeus, 1, 60 Muthoo, 2000, A non-technical introduction to bargaining theory, World Econ. – Henley On Thames, 1, 145 Nash, 1953, Two person cooperative games, Econometrica, 21, 128, 10.2307/1906951 Neweurope, 2015. Russia Pushes Tesla Pipeline Through Balkans 〈https://www.neweurope.eu/article/russia-pushes-tesla-pipeline-through-balkans/〉 (Accessed 22 July 2017). New York Times, 2015. Russia Pr esses Ahead With Plan for Gas Pipeline to Turkey, 〈https://www.nytimes.com/2015/01/22/business/international/russia-presses-ahead-with-plan-for-gas-pipeline-to-turkey.html〉 (Accessed 22 July 2017). Omonbude, 2007, The transit oil and gas pipeline and the role of bargaining: a non-technical discussion, Energy Policy, 35, 6188, 10.1016/j.enpol.2007.06.001 Özdemir V., 2016. The EU-Russia-Turkey Energy Triangle, European Centre for Energy and Resource Security, Reflections, Working Paper Series Volume 2, Spring 2016. Pen, 1952, General theory of bargaining, Am. Econ. Rev., 42 Pirani, 2014, What the Ukraine crisis means for gas markets, Oxf. Inst. Energy Stud. Pirani, S., Yafimava, K., 2016. Russian Gas Transit Across Ukraine Post-2019: pipeline scenarios, gas flow consequences, and regulatory constraints. OIES PAPER: NG 105. Pourzitakis, S., 2015. The Energy Security Dilemma of Turkish Stream, Carnegie Europe, online available at: 〈http://carnegieeurope.eu/strategiceurope/?Fa=60861〉 (Accessed 22 July 2017). Reuters, 2015. EU chiefs launch biggest energy shake-up in half century, 〈https://www.reuters.com/article/eu-energy-grid/update-1-eu-chiefs-launch-biggest-energy-shake-up-in-half-century-idUSL5N0VZ3HZ20150225〉 (Accessed 19 November 2017). Reuters, 2017. Russia’s Gazprom sees Turkish Stream pipeline cost at $6 bln, 〈https://af.reuters.com/article/commoditiesNews/idAFR4N1G7057〉, (Accessed 10 November 2017). RT, 2015a. Russia, Greece sign €2bn deal in Turkish Stream gas pipeline, online available at: 〈https://www.rt.com/business/268279-russia-greece-turkish-stream/〉 (Accessed 22 July 2017). RT, 2015b. Moscow and Ankara agree 10.25% gas discount for Turkey, 〈https://www.rt.com/business/241949-russia-turkey-gas-discount/〉, (Accessed 18.14.2017). Schelling, 1960 Selei, A., B. Takácsné Tóth, B., 2015. A top-down approach to identify the most important natural gas cross-border infrastructure projects, Working Paper. DIW Berlin, available online at 〈http://unipub.lib.uni-corvinus.hu/2761/〉 (Accessed 24 July 2017). Skalamera, 2016, Revisiting the Nabucco Debacle: Myths and Realities, Probl. Post-Communism, 1 Skalamera, M., Goldthau, A., 2016. Russia: Playing Hardball or Bidding Farewell to Europe? Debunking the myths of Eurasia’s new geopolitics of gas. Belfer Center Geopolitics of Energy Project Discussion Paper (2016-03). Sputniknews, 2016. 〈https://sputniknews.com/business/201601191033383643-gas-dispute-russia-ukraine/〉. Sputniknews, 2017. Kiev Thinks Up Clever Way to Preserve Ukraine’s Gas Transit-Country Status, Available online at: 〈https://sputniknews.com/politics/201701051049302524-naftogaz-invites-european-partners/〉 (Accessed 22 July 2017). Stern, 2006, The Russian-Ukrainian gas crisis of January 2006, Oxf. Inst. Energy Stud., 16, 5 Stern, 2014, International gas pricing in Europe and Asia: a crisis of fundamentals, Energy Policy, 64, 43, 10.1016/j.enpol.2013.05.127 Stern, 2015, Does the cancellation of South stream signal a fundamental reorientation of Russian gas export policy?, J. Self-Gov. Manag. Econ., 3, 30 Stevens, 2006, Cross-border oil and gas pipelines: problems and prospects, Oil Gas. Energy Law J. (OGEL), 4 Stulberg, 2012, Strategic bargaining and pipeline politics: confronting the credible commitment problem in Eurasian energy transit, Rev. Int. Polit. Econ., 19, 808, 10.1080/09692290.2011.603662 Socor, V., 2012. Turkey plays paltry hand, Asian Times, available online at: 〈http://www.atimes.com/atimes/Central_Asia/NA13Ag01.html〉 (Accessed 22 July 2017). TANAP, 2012. Intergovernmental Agreement available online at: 〈http://www.tanap.com/corporate/agreements/〉 (Accessed 22 July 2017). TASS, 2017. Russia does not intend to negotiate with EU on Nord Stream 2 — envoy, 〈http://tass.com/economy/972969http://tass.com/economy/972969〉 (Accessed 19 November 2017). TENVA, 2014. Turkish Energy Foundation, BOTAS made a loss of around TRY 2 billion; any discount, will be used to compensate for this loss: 〈http://www.tenva.org/en/botas-2-milyar-tl-civarinda-zarar-ediyor-alacagimiz-her-indirim-bu-zararin-telafi-edilmesi-icin-kullanilacak/〉 (Accessed 22 July 2017). Tymoshenko, 2007, Containing Russia, Foreign Aff., 86, 69 Ulchenko, 2015, From South stream to Turkish stream: underlying reason and consequences ofTransformation, Russ. Anal. Dig., 163, 7 Whist, 2007, Nord stream: not just a pipeline, Fridtjof Nansen Inst., 30, 79 Wiśniewski, J., 2015. Virtual Pipelines, New EasternEurope, online available at: 〈http://www.neweasterneurope.eu/interviews/1645-virtual-pipelines〉 (Accessed 22 July 2017). World Bank, 2016. Press Release: online available at : 〈http://www.worldbank.org/en/news/press-release/2016/12/20/world-bank-group-supports-diversification-of-azerbaijans-gas-export-markets-and-security-of-energy-supply-for-turkey-and-europe〉, (Accessed 22 July 2017). Yafimava, K., 2013. EU Third Package for Gas and the Gas Target Model: Major Contentious Issues Inside and Outside the EU, Oxford Institute for Energy Studies, NG 75. Yafimava, 2015, Evolution of gas pipeline regulation in Russia-third Party access, capacity allocation and transportation tariffs, Oil, Gas. Energy Law J. (OGEL), 13 Yafimava, K., 2017. The Council Legal Service’s assessment of the European Commission’s negotiating mandate and what it means for Nord Stream 2, Energy Insight: 19, The Oxford Institute for Energy Studies. Yergin, 2011