More harm than good? The questionable ethics of medical volunteering and international student placements

Schweitzer A. Selbstzeugnisse. CH Beck: Munich; 1959. Bishop R, Litch J. Medical tourism can do harm. BMJ. 2000;320(7240):1017. Bezruchka S. Medical tourism as medical harm to the third world: why? For whom? Wild Environ Med. 2000;11:77–8. Dupuis C. Humanitarian missions in the third world: a polite dissent. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2004;113:433–5. Welling D, Ryan J, Burris D, Rich N. Seven sins of humanitarian medicine. World J Surg. 2010;34:466–70. Roberts M. Duffle bag medicine. JAMA. 2006;295(13):1491–2. Loiseau B, Sibbald R, Raman S, Benedict D, Dimaras H, Loh L. ‘Don’t make my people beggars’: a developing world house of cards. Community Dev J. 2015; doi:10.1093/cdj/bsv047. Montgomery L. Short-term medical missions: enhancing or eroding health? Missiology. 1993;21(3):333–41. Bauer I. The health impact of tourism on local and indigenous populations in resource-poor countries. Travel Med Infect Dis. 2008;6(5):276–91. Bauer I. The myth of empowering the poor through tourism – time to fess up? Glob Health Persp. 2014. doi:10.5645/ghp2014.02.002. Bauer I. Improving global health – Is tourism’s role in poverty elimination perpetuating poverty, powerlessness and ‘ill-being’? Glob Public Health. 2015. doi:10.1080/17441692.2015.1094109. Simpson K. “Doing development”: the gap year, volunteer-tourists and a popular practice of development. J Int Dev. 2004;16(5):681–92. Sin H. Volunteer tourism – “involve me and I will learn”. Ann Tour Res. 2009;36(3):480–501. Benson A, Wearing S. Volunteer tourism: commodified trend or new phenomenon? In: Moufakkir O, Burns P, editors. Controversies in tourism. Wallingford: CABI; 2012. p. 242–54. Guttentag D. The possible negative impact of volunteer tourism. Int J Tour Res. 2009;11:537–51. Guttentag D. Volunteer tourism: as good as it seems? Tour Recreat Res. 2011;36(1):69–74. Guiney T, Mostafanezhad, M. The political economy of orphanage tourism in Cambodia. Tourist Stud. 2014; doi: 10.1177/1468797614563387. Bar-On E, Lebel E, Kreiss Y, Merin O, Benedict S, Gill A, Lee E, et al. Orthopaedic management in a mega mass casualty situation. The Israel defence forces field hospital in Haiti following the january 2010 earthquake. Injury. 2011;42:1053–9. Burnweit C, Stylianos S. Disaster response in a pediatric field hospital: lessons learned in Haiti. J Pediatr Surg. 2011;46:1131–9. Cranmer H. Volunteer work – logistics first. N Engl J Med. 2005;353(15):1541–4. De Ville de Goyet C. Health lessons learned from the recent earthquakes and tsunami in Asia. Prehosp Disaster Med. 2007;22(1):15–21. Rajpura A, Boutros I, Khan T, Khan S. Pakistan earthquake: experiences of a multidisciplinary surgical team. Prehosp Disaster Med. 2010;25(4):361–7. Vanholder R, Borniche D, Claus S, Correa-Rotter R, Crestani R, Ferir M, Gibney N, Hurtado A, et al. When the earth trembles in the Americas: the experience of Haiti and Chile 2010. Nephron Clin Pract. 2011;117:c184–97. Jobe K. Disaster relief in post-earthquake Haiti: unintended consequences of humanitarian volunteerism. Travel Med Infect Dis. 2011;9:1–5. Archer N, Moschovis P, Le P, Farmer P. Post-earthquake Haiti renews the call for global health training in medical education. Acad Med. 2011;86(7):889–91. Merchant R, Leigh J, Lurie N. Health care volunteers and disaster response – first, be prepared. N Engl J Med. 2010;362(10):872–3. Hays K, Prepas R. The professionalization of international disaster response: it is time for midwives to get ready. J Midwifery Womens Health. 2015;60:348–59. Lal S, Spence D. Humanitarian nursing in developing countries: a phenomenological analysis. J Transcultural Nurs. 2014; doi: 10.1177/1043659614536585. Hearns A, Deeny P. The value of support for aid workers in complex emergencies: a phenomenological study. Disaster Manag Response. 2007;5(2):28–35. Malone J. Nursing in the world’s war zones. Nurs Manag. 2012;19(3):26–8. Cole D, Plugge E, Jackson S. Placements in global health masters’ programmes: what is the student experience? J Public Health. 2012. doi:10.1093/pubmed/fds086. Button L, Green B, Tengnah C, Johansson I, Baker C. The impact of international placements on nurses’ personal and professional lives: literature review. J Adv Nurs. 2005;50(3):315–24. Jarman B, Cogbill T, Kitowski N. Development of an international elective in a general surgery residency. J Surg. 2009;66(4):222–4. Matar W, Trottier D, Balaa F, Fairful-Smith R, Moroz P. Surgical residency training and international volunteerism: a national survey of residents from 2 surgical specialties. Can J Surg. 2012;55(4 Supp 2):S191–9. Powell A, Mueller C, Kingham P, Berman R, Pachter H, Hopkins M. International experiences, electives, and volunteerism in surgical training: a survey of resident interest. J Am Coll Surg. 2007;205(1):162–8. Powell A, Casey K, Liewehr D, Hayanga A, James T, Cherr G. Results of a national survey of surgical resident interest in international experience, electives and volunteerism. J Am Coll Surg. 2009;208(2):304–12. Butler M, Krishnaswami S, Rothstein D, Cusick R. Interest in international surgical volunteerism: results of a survey of members of the American Pediatric Surgical Association. J Pediatr Surg. 2011;46:2244–9. Sha S, Wu T. The medical student global health experience: professionalism and ethical implications. J Med Ethics. 2008;34:375–8. Crump J, Sugarman J. Ethical considerations for short-term experiences by trainees in global health. JAMA. 2008;300(12):1456–8. White M, Cauley K. Op-ed. A caution against medical student tourism. Virtual Mentor. 2006;8(12):851–4. Dowell J, Blacklock C, Liao C, Merrylees N. Boost or burden? Issues posed by short placements in resource-poor settings. Br J Gen Pract. 2014;64(623):272–3. Miranda J, Yudkin J, Willott C. International health electives: four years of experience. Travel Med Infect Dis. 2005;3(3):133–41. McCall D, Iltis A. Health care voluntourism: addressing ethical concerns of undergraduate student participation in global health volunteer work. HEC Forum. 2014;26(4):285–97. Wallace L. Does pre-medical ‘voluntourism’ improve the health of communities abroad? J Global Health Perspectives. 2012, August 1, http://jglobalhealth.org/article/does-pre-medical-voluntourism-improve-the-health-of-communities-abroad-3/ DeCamp M. Ethical review of global short-term medical volunteerism. HEC Forum. 2011;23:1–103. Dolnicar S, Randle M. The international volunteering market: market segments and competitive relations. Int J Nonprofit Volun Sect Mark. 2007;12(4):350–70. Coghlan A, Noakes S. Towards an understanding of the drivers of commercialization in the volunteer tourism sector. Tour Recreat Res. 2012;37(2):123–31. Berry N. Did we do good? NGOs, conflicts of interest and the evaluation of short-term medical missions in Sololá. Guatemala Soc Sci Med. 2014;120:344–51. RCDP International. Homepage. 2016. http://www.rcdpinternationalvolunteer.org/ Accessed 6 July 2016. Langowski M, Iltis A. Global health needs and the short-term medical volunteer: ethical considerations. HEC Forum. 2011;23:71–8. McLennan S. Medical voluntourism in Honduras: ‘helping’ the poor? Prog Dev Stud. 2014;14(2):163–79. Wall A. The context of ethical problems in medical volunteer work. HEC Forum. 2011;23:79–90. Green T, Green H, Scandlyn J, Kestler A. Perceptions of short-term medical volunteer work: a qualitative study in Guatemala. Glob Health. 2009;5(4):1–13. Sykes K. Short-term medical service trips: a systematic review of the evidence. Am J Public Health. 2014;104(7):e38–e348. Martiniuk A, Manouchehrian M, Negin J, Zwi A. Brain gains: a literature review of medical missions to low and middle-income countries. BMC Health Serv Res. 2012;12:134. Dickson M, Dickson G. Volunteering: beyond an act of charity. J Can Dent Assoc. 2005;71(11):865–9. Montgomery L. Reinventing short-term medical missions to Latin America. Lat Am Theol. 2006;2(2):84–103. Laleman G, Kegels G, Marchal B, Van der Roost D, Bogaert I, Van Damme W. The contribution of international health volunteers to the health workforce in sub-Saharan Africa. Hum Resour Health. 2007;5:9. Bodnar B. So you think you want to save the world. Yale J Biol Med. 2011;84:227–36. Muula A. Is there any solution to the ‘brain drain’ of health professionals and knowledge from Africa? Croat Med J. 2005;46(1):21–9. Maki J, Qualls M, White B, Kleefield S, Crone R. Health impact assessment and short-term medical missions: a methods study to evaluate quality of care. BMC Health Serv Res. 2008;8:121. doi:10.1186/1472-6963-8-121. Elnawawy O, Lee A, Pohl G. Making short-term international medical volunteer placements work: a qualitative study. Br J Gen Pract. 2014;64(623):e329–35. DeCamp M. Scrutinizing global short-term medical outreach. Hastings Center Report. 2007;37(6):21–3. Wall L. Ethical concerns regarding operations by volunteer surgeons on vulnerable patient groups: the case of women with obstetric fistulas. HEC Forum. 2011;23:115–7. Richter L, Norman A. AIDS orphan tourism: a threat to young children in residential care. Vulnerable Child Youth Stud. 2010;5(3):217–29. Wolfberg A. Volunteering overseas – lessons from surgical brigades. N Engl J Med. 2006;54(5):443–5. Pyott A. Short-term visits by eye care professionals: ensuring greater benefit to the host community. Community Eye Health. 2008;21(8):62–3. Kleinman A, Benson P. Anthropology in the clinic: the problem of cultural competency and how to fix it. PLoS Med. 2006;3(10):1673–6. Carruth L. Camel milk, amoxicillin, and a prayer: medical pluralism and medical humanitarian aid in the Somali Region of Ethiopia. Soc Sci Med. 2014;120:405–12. Tourism Research and Marketing (TRAM). Volunteer tourism: a global analysis. Wagingen: Atlas; 2008. Coghlan A, Fennell D. Myth or substance: an examination of altruism as the basis of volunteer tourism. Ann Leis Res. 2009;12(3-4):377–402. Kane L. How to feel really good after a vacation. Med Econ. 1998;75(19):58–65. Souers C. A Bolivian medical mission experience. AORN. 2007;86(5):759–66. McBride A, Lough B, Sherraden M. International service and the perceived impacts on volunteers. Nonprof Volunt Sec Q. 2012;41:969–90. Thompson K, Boore J, Deeny P. A comparison of an international experience for nursing students in developed and developing countries. Int J Nurs Stud. 2000;37:481–92. Lough B. International volunteers’ perceptions of intercultural competence. Int J Intercult Rel. 2011;35:452–64. Godfrey J, Wearing S, Schulenlorf N. Motivations of medical volunteer tourists and a discussion of the underlying ethics. A qualitative case study from Cusco, Peru. In: Slocum S, Kline C, Holden A, editors. Scientific tourism. Researchers as travellers. London: Routledge; 2015. p. 131–47. Bjerneld M, Lindmark G, McSpadden L, Garrett M. Motivations, concerns, and expectations of Scandinavian health professionals volunteering for humanitarian assignments. Disaster Manag Response. 2006;4(2):49–58. Bjerneld M, Lindmark G, Diskett P, Garrett M. Perceptions of work in humanitarian assistance: interviews with returning Swedish health professionals. Disaster Manag Response. 2004;2(4):101–8. Scheyvens R. Tourism and poverty. New York: Routledge; 2011. Snyder J, Dharamsi S, Crooks V. Fly-by medical care: conceptualizing the global and local social responsibilities of medical tourism and physician voluntourists. Global Health. 2011;7(6):1–14. Ott B, Olson R. Ethical issues of medical missions: the clinicians’ view. HEC Forum. 2011;23:105–13. Anderson M, Brown D, Jean I. Time to listen. In: Hearing people on the receiving end of international aid. Cambridge, Mass: CDA; 2012. Oken E, Martinez E, Stern L. Use of volunteer medical brigades to assess growth in Honduras. J Trop Pediatr. 2004;50(4):203–8. Van Dijk D, Dinant G-J, Jacobs J. Inappropriate drug donations: what has happened since the 1999 WHO guidelines? Educ Health. 2011;24(2):1–12. Wood C. Travel, roads, risks and volunteers. J Tour Cult Change. 2016;14(1):1–9. Küpper T, Rieke B, Neppach K, Morrison A, Martin J. Health hazards and medical treatment of volunteers aged 18-30 years working in international social projects of non-governmental organizations (NGO). Travel Med Infect Dis. 2014;12:385–95. Costa M, Oberholzer-Riss, Hatz C, Steffen R, Puhan M, Schlagenhauf P. Pre-travel health advice guidelines for humanitarian workers: a systematic review. Travel Med Infect Dis. 2015;13:449–65. Callahan M, Hamer D. On the medical edge: preparations of expatriates, refugee and disaster relief workers, and Peace Corps volunteers. Infect Dis Clin Am. 2005;19(1):85–101. Thomson C, English J. Premature return of peace corps volunteers. Public Health Rep. 1964;79(12):1065–73. Lopes Cardozo B, Gotway Crawford C, Eriksson C, Zhu J, Sabin M, Ager A, et al. Psychological distress, depression, anxiety, and burnout among international humanitarian aid workers: a longitudinal study. PLoS One. 2012;7(9):e44948. Anderson F, Wansom T. AMA J Ethics. 2009;11(7):506–10. Levi A. The ethics of nursing student international clinical experiences. JOGNN. 2009;38(1):94–9. Crump J, Sugarman J. Working group on ethics guidelines for global health training. Global health training. Ethics and best practice guidelines for training experience in global health. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2010;83(6):1178–82. DeCamp M, Rodriguez J, Hecht S, Barry M, Sugarman J. An ethics curriculum for short-term global health trainees. Glob Health. 2013;9(5):1–10. Seymour B, Benzian H, Kalenderian E. Voluntourism and global health: preparing dental students for responsible engagement in international programs. J Dent Educ. 2013;77(10):1252–7. Caldron P, Impens A, Pavlova M, Groot W. A systematic review of social, economic and diplomatic aspects of short-term medical missions. BMC Health Serv Res. 2015;15(380):1012. DeCamp M, Enumah S, O’Neill D, Sugarman J. Perceptions of a short-term medical programme in the Dominican Republic: voices of care recipients. Glob Public Health. 2014;9(4):411–25. Lough B, McBride A, Sherraden M. Measuring volunteer outcomes. In: Development of the International Volunteer Impacts Survey, CSD Working Papers, vol. No.09-31. St Louis: Center for Social Development, Washington University in St Louis; 2009. Bauer I, Thomas K. An evaluation of community and corporate bias in impact assessment tools. Int Soc Sci J. 2006;58(189):501–14. Bauer I. Bridging the conceptual gap between researcher and respondent by using simple rank ordering: an example from the Peruvian Andes. Int J Interdiscipl Soc Sci. 2007;2(4):157–67. Sharp H, Canady J, Ligot F, Hague R, Guiterrez J, Guiterrez J. Caregiver and patient reported outcomes after repair of cleft lip and/or palate in the Philippines. Cleft Palate Craniofacial J. 2008;45(2):163–71. Loh L, Cherniak W, Dreifuss B, Dacso M, Lion H, Evert J. Short term global health experiences and local partnership models: a framework. Glob Health. 2015;11:50.