Moral Desirability and Rational Decision
Tóm tắt
Being a formal and general as well as the most widely accepted approach to practical rationality, rational decision theory should be crucial for justifying rational morals. In particular, acting morally should also (nearly always) be rational in decision theoretic terms. After defending this thesis, in the critical part of the paper two strategies to develop morals following this insight are criticized: game theoretical ethics of cooperation and ethical intuitionism. The central structural objections to ethics of cooperation are that they too directly aim at the rationality of moral action and that they to do not encompass moral values or a moral desirability function. The constructive half of the paper takes up these criticisms by developing a two-part strategy to bring rationality and morals in line. The first part is to define ‘moral desirability’. This is done, using multi-attribute utility theory, by equating several adequate components of an individual’s comprehensive (rational) utility function with the moral desirability function. The second part is to introduce mechanisms, institutions, in particular socially valid moral norms, that provide further motivation for acting in accordance with morals.
Tài liệu tham khảo
Arrow KJ (<1951>/1963) Social choice and individual values. Wiley, New York 1951, 2nd edn. Yale U.P., New Haven 21963
Axelrod R (1984) The evolution of cooperation. Basic Books, New York
Baliga S, Sjöström T (2008) Mechanism design. Recent developments. In: Blume LE, Durlauf SN (eds) The new Palgrave dictionary of economics, vol 5, 2nd edn. Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke
Batson DC, O’Quinn K, Fultz J, Vanderplas M, Isen AM (1983) Influence of self-reported distress and empathy on egoistic versus altruistic motivation to help. J Pers Soc Psychol 45:706–718
Binmore K (2005) Natural justice. Oxford U.P., Oxford
Camerer CF (1995) Individual decision making. In: Kagel JH, Roth AE (eds) The handbook of experimental economics. Princeton University Press, Princeton, pp 587–703
Clemen RT, Reilly T (2001) Making hard decisions with decision tools. Pacific Grove, Duxbury
Corchón LC (2007) The theory of implementation. What did we learn? Working Paper 08-12, Economic Series (07), December 2007. Madrid: Universidad Carlos III de Madrid, Departamento de Economía 2007. 40 pp. Web: <http://e-archivo.uc3m.es:8080/bitstream/10016/2172/1/we081207.pdf> (23.10.09.)
Edwards W (1977) How to use multiattribute utility measurement for social decision making. IEEE Trans Syst Man Cybern, SMC-7:326–340
Fehr E, Gächter S (2001) Fairness and retaliation. In: Gerard-Varet L, Kolm SC, Ythier JM (eds) The economics of reciprocity, giving and altruism. (International Economic Association (= Iea) Conference Volumes, vol 130). Macmillan, Basingstoke, pp 153–173
Figueira J, Greco S, Ehrgott M (eds) (2005) Multiple criteria decision analysis. State of the art surveys. Springer, New York
Fishburn PC (1967) Methods of estimating additive utilities. Manage Sci 13:435–453
Flügel JC (1925) A quantitative study of feeling and emotion in everyday life. Br J Psychol 15:318–355
French S (1986) Decision theory. An introduction to the Mathematics of Rationality. Ellis Harwood, Ltd, Chichester, Halsted Press, New York
Gauthier D (1986) Morals by agreement. Clarendon, Oxford
Gauthier D (1991) Why contractarianism? In: Vallentyne P (ed) Contractarianism and rational choice. Essays on David Gauthier’s morals by agreement. Cambridge U.P, New York, pp 15–30
Harsanyi JC (<1955>/1976) Cardinal welfare, individualistic ethics, and interpersonal comparisons of utility. J Polit Econ 63(1955):309–321. Reprinted in: Idem: Essays on Ethics, Social Behavior, and Scientific Explanation. Reidel, Dordrecht, Boston 1976, pp 6–23.
Harsanyi JC (1977) Rational behavior and bargaining equilibrium in games and social situations. Cambridge U.P, Cambridge
Hoerster N (2003) Ethik und Interesse. Reclam, Stuttgart
Izard CE (1991) The psychology of emotions. Plenum, New York, London
Kahneman D, Tversky A (1979) Prospect theory. An analysis of decision under risk. Econometrica 47:263–291
Keeney RL, Raiffa H (<1976>/1993) Decisions with multiple objectives. Preferences and value tradeoffs. Wiley, New York. 1976. Reprint: Cambridge U.P., Cambridge 1993
Koehler DJ, Harvey N (eds) (2004) Blackwell handbook of judgment and decision making. Blackwell, Oxford
Krantz DH, Luce RD, Suppes P, Tversky A (1971) Foundations of measurement. Vol. I: Additive and polynomial representations. Academic, New York
Lazarus RS (1991) Cognition and motivation in emotion. Am Psychol 46:352–367
Lazarus RS, Lazarus BN (1994) Passion and reason. Making sense of our emotions. Oxford U.P, Oxford
Lumer C (1997) The content of originally intrinsic desires and of intrinsic motivation. Acta Anal 18:107–121
Lumer C (1998) Which preferences shall be the basis of rational decision? In: Fehige C, Wessels U (eds) Preferences. de Gruyter, Berlin, pp 33–56
Lumer C (<2000>/2009) Rationaler Altruismus. Eine prudentielle Theorie der Rationalität und des Altruismus. Osnabrück: Universitätsverlag Rasch 2000. 2nd, complemented edition: Mentis: Paderborn 2009
Lumer C (2002) Motive zu moralischem Handeln. Analyse & Kritik 24:163–188
Lumer C (2002/03) Kantischer Externalismus und Motive zu moralischem Handeln. Conceptus 35:263–286
Mackie JL (1977) Ethics. Inventing right and wrong. Penguin, Harmondsworth
Margolis H (1982) Selfishness, altruism, and rationality. A theory of social choice. Cambridge U.P, Cambridge
Montada L (1993) Moralische Gefühle. In: Edelstein W, Nunner-Winkler G, Noam G (eds) Moral und Person. Suhrkamp, Frankfurt, Main, pp 259–277
Narveson J (<1988>/2001) The libertarian idea. Temple U.P., Philadelphia. 1988. Reprint: Broadview, Peterborough, Ont. 2001
Narveson J (2010) The relevance of rational decision theory for ethics. Ethical Theory Moral Pract. This issue
Nunner-Winkler G (<1993>/1999) Moralische Motivation und moralische Identität. Zur Kluft zwischen Urteil und Handeln (1993) In: Garz D, Oser F, Althof W (eds) Moralisches Urteil und Handeln. Suhrkamp: Frankfurt, Main 1999. Pp 314–339
Oliner SP, Oliner PM (1988) The Altruistic personality. Rescuers of Jews in Nazi Europe. Free, New York, Collier Macmillan: London
Raiffa H (1968) Decision analysis. Introductory lectures on choices under uncertainty. Addision-Wesley, Reading
Rawls JB (<1971>/1999) A theory of justice. The Belknap Press of Harvard U.P., Cambridge, Mass. 1971. Revised ed.: Oxford U.P., Oxford [etc.] 1999
Scheffler S (<1982>/1994) The rejection of consequentialism. A philosophical investigation of the considerations underlying rival moral conceptions. (1982.) Revised edition. Clarendon, Oxford. 21994
Sen AK (<1970>/1984) Collective choice and social welfare. Holden-Day, San Francisco. 1970. Reprint: North-Holland: Amsterdam; New York; Oxford 1984
Solomon RC (<1976>/1993) The passions. Emotions and the meaning of life. (1976.) Revised edition. Hackett, Indianapolis, Cambridge 1993
Stemmer P (2000) Handeln zugunsten anderer. Eine moralphilosophische Untersuchung. de Gruyter, Berlin
Taylor G (<1985>/1995) Shame, integrity, and self-respect. (1985.) In: RS Dillon (ed) Dignity, character, and self-respect. Routledge, New York. 1995. Pp 157–178
Trapp RW (1998) The potentialities and limits of a rational justification of ethical norms. Or: “What precisely is minimal morals?”. In: Fehige C, Wessels U (eds) Preferences. de Gruyter, Berlin, pp 327–360
Watson SR, Buede DM (1987) Decision synthesis. The principles and practice of decision analysis. Cambridge U.P, Cambridge
Weinreich-Haste H (1986) Moralisches Engagement. Die Funktion der Gefühle im Urteilen und Handeln. In: Edelstein W, Nunner-Winkler G (eds) Zur Bestimmung der Moral. Suhrkamp, Frankfurt, Main, pp 377–406
Williams B (1973) A critique of utilitarianism. In: Smart JJC, Williams B: Utilitarianism for and against. Cambridge U.P, Cambridge, pp 75–150
Zeelenberg M, Nelissen R, Pieters R (2008) Emotion, motivation, and decision making. A feeling-is-for-doing approach. In: Plessner H, Betsch C, Betsch T (eds) Intuition in judgment and decision making. Lawrence Erlbaum, New York, pp 173–189